Thursday, October 6, 2011

Prompt for the "Moral Mind" and the "Brain is an Argument" from How We Decide

Please bring in elements from both chapters in your response (both are important and I want you to read both, not just focus on the brain and behavior of the sociopath. I know this is intriguing but as I have noted in past classes that everyone gets carried away with this, I would suggest not making this the focus of your reflection as it is not the most important part of this week's reading!)

In "The Moral Mind," Lehrer illustrates some of the ways in which our brains are wired for empathy: "These innate emotions are so powerful that they keep people moral even in the most amoral situations" (179). What situations/contexts are most apt to elicit our moral emotions and corresponding actions? He offers a series of examples of this inherent sympathy/morality--which are most interesting to you? Can you relate to your service experience in any way?
and
In the next chapter, "The Brain is an Argument." Lehrer talks about the importance of doubt and the inner dialogue in making decisions and judgments. He writes that although confidence is comforting, the "desire to always be right is a dangerous side-effect of having competing regions inside one's head" (210). As Lehrer illuminates through a variety of stories, feeling sure and acting on certain assumptions can create a dangerous sense of false security. Again, what interests you most here? Why? Can you link to your service experience?

1 comment:

  1. The author of The Moral Mind makes a distinction between personal and impersonal moral decisions (177). Personal moral decisions directly involve another person, while impersonal moral decisions don’t directly involve others. As humans we have an easier time making impersonal moral decisions because if another human gets hurt in the process, our brain processes the situation differently than if we had made a decision to directly hurt someone else. Our minds have evolved to distinguish slight differences between situations and decisions.

    As humans we seem to just know the difference between right and wrong. In other words, when presented with a moral decision, an answer comes to mind right away, even though we might not be able to justify why or how we came to that conclusion. Emotions play into our decision making as well as what we have learned. This is true. Everyday people make decisions, but when asked to explain them or justify them, they hesitate. There isn’t one clear answer.

    For instance, in The Brain Is an Argument article, the author states that “each [set of] distinct claims will trigger a particular set of emotions and associations, all of which them compete for [our] conscious attention” (199). Based on the data that we have access to, our minds make decision, but our decisions are also dependent on our emotions. Like it or not, human emotions are easily influenced by adds and self-image. We can’t exist within society without experiencing some sort of outside influence. Everyone is a mix of facts and emotions that work together to define us and the decisions we make.

    Personally, I know I try to completely separate emotions and decisions. In reality, the two are connected and intertwined in every aspect of life. As Lewer says “we like to believe that our decisions reflect a clear cortical consensus, that the entire mind agrees on what we should do” (203), but when you are faced with a challenge, it becomes difficult to separate emotions and logic. Our heart and mind work together to make us who we are.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.