I have previously heard of the terms "collective responsibility" and "collective guilt," however I have never thought thought about the terms deeply. Arendt states in "Responsibility and Judgement" that there is no such thing as collective guilt. This is because "guilt, unlike responsibility, always singles out; it is strictly personal" (147). A group cannot collectively feel guilty because the group dynamic and the individual dynamic are distinctly different. It is strictly metaphorical because "we can say we feel guilty for the sins of our fathers or our people or mankind, in short, for deeds we have not done..." but we are not responsible for them (147). This conjecture makes perfect sense when it is analyzed. A German person may feel guilty for the actions of his or her ancestors during World War II, but because that person was not directly involved in the actions, the guilt is not placed upon them. However, if one has knowledge of an immoral act performed by another and does nothing to stop it, then one is just as guilty as the person who performed the act. One may feel compassion for another who is suffering, however if one did not directly or indirectly cause that suffering then it is impossible for that person to feel true guilt.
In the following chapter, Arendt discusses the concept of the "banality of evil" and "the absence of thinking." According to her, the "banality of evil" is "...the phenomenon of evil deeds, committed on a gigantic scale, which could not be traced to any particularity of wickedness, pathology, or ideological conviction in the doer..." and "However monstrous the deeds were, the doer was neither monstrous nor demonic"(159). This conjecture leads to the idea that people are not innately evil. Although human beings are capable of performing horrible deeds, the motive to perform said deeds does not stem from evil within us. Arendt continues her discussion and explains that the root cause of evil actions is the absence of thought. Blatant evidence which supports this view can be drawn from the actions of Nazi soldiers who ran the death camps during the Holocaust. When the war was ended and they were asked to explain their actions, the excuse which was repeatedly offered was that they were simply following orders. Nazi soldiers murdered, starved, and mutilated millions of innocent people because they were following orders, and not thinking about their actions. Although this seems like a ridiculous excuse, if analyzed it makes sense . The Nazi soldiers did not think about their monstrous deeds; but if they did then they would never have been able to commit the crimes that they did. They were not evil people to the core, they simply performed evil deeds. Arendt states, "the most conspicuous and most dangerous fallacy in the proposition, as old as Plato, 'Nobody does evil voluntarily,' is the implied conclusion, 'Everybody wants to do good.' The sad truth of the matter is that most evil is done by people who never made up their mind to be either bad or good" (180). This fact is often overlooked, and can be related to my experience at MCCS. I believe that many of the students who go there believe that there is something inherently wrong with themselves which causes them to go down the wrong path. If they understood that they, as individuals, are not "bad" or "stupid" and that it is simply their absence of thinking which leads to their bad decisions, they would be more motivated to be successful in life.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.