Saturday, February 26, 2011
Prompt: The Moral Mind and The Brain is an Argument
and/or
In the next chapter, "The Brain is an Argument." Lehrer talks about the importance of doubt and the inner dialogue in making decisions and judgments. He writes that although confidence is comforting, the "desire to always be right is a dangerous side-effect of having competing regions inside one's head" (210). As Lehrer illuminates through a variety of stories, feeling sure and acting on certain assumptions can create a dangerous sense of false security. Again, what interests you most here? Why? Can you link to your service experience?
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Canada in America!
Whatever It Takes
The life changing work Geoffrey Canada has begun in Harlem is ambitious, daunting, and extremely powerful. In my last blog post I asked the question, “Why don't more people with money give back to those less fortunate?” and Canada is my answer. Here is a man who grew up in the streets of Harlem, and saw first hand the problems associated with a life of poverty: increased addiction to drugs and alcohol, theft, domestic abuse and child neglect, gang violence and the ever-present reality of death. “It really is getting worse. Too many guns, too much crack, too few jobs, so little hope” (1). Canada is an exception to the norm. He made it out of that lifestyle and now wants to show the way for others. By creating the Promise Academy Charter School within a protected 'safe' zone called the Harlem Children's Zone, Canada takes those from low income families chosen by lottery under his wing. He stays with each child/family from Kindergarden through high school. “The support system he provided would need to be comprehensive, a continuous linked series of programs. It wasn't enough to help out in just one part of a child's life: the project would need to combine educational, social, and medical services” (Tough, 4). And the most extraordinary thing is his guarantee that all students will attend college. If this isn't ambitious enough, he foots the bill for their education. In addition to the children benefitting from the program, the parents are educated as well. They are taught parenting skills which range from diapers to finances. The ultimate goal is to help raise a community out of the depths of poverty, drugs, and violence, and into a community of hope and possibility.
However you measure parenting, middle-class parents tend to do it very differently from poor parents – and the path they follow, in turn, tends to give their children an array of advantages, both cognitive and non-cognitive: a bigger vocabulary, better brain chemistry, a more assertive attitude. As Lareau pointed out, kids from poor families might be nicer, they might be happier, they might be more polite – but in countless ways, the manner in which they are raised puts them at a disadvantage in the measures that count in contemporary American society (16).
Canada's 60 Minutes interview was enthralling. His passion was evident, as was his ultimate dream. Communities across the nation would change dramatically if there were more Promise Academies. Statistics showed that the cost of student education was less than the cost of housing them in jail. Getting adolescents and teenagers off the streets and away from crime and violence will strengthen not hurt our economy. Canada's methods are different, but effective. One in particular is his love for bribing students. If students maintain a certain GPA then at the end of the semester they are given a check. This has caused students to become more committed, time efficient, responsible, and excited about their education. The personal vision of one man has changed the lives of many. This acknowledgement helps me to see that America's future might be a little brighter. We are capable of so many things: exploring the depths of the ocean and sending someone to the moon, landing rovers on Mars, crashing satellites into asteroids, nano-technologies, medical breakthroughs... all this is being accomplished by a small fraction of our society, the middle and upper-class. But as Canada has proved, the neglected or 'counted out' if given the same educational opportunities can perform and contribute just as much to society. Geoffrey Canada is a modern day messiah, and his message is the most fundamental – give everyone a chance to live, dream, and succeed by ending the “decades – generations – of discrimination, isolation, and cultural decay” (6).
Whatever it Takes: Geoffrey Canada's Quest to Change Harlem and America is addition to my knowledge of Canada’s successful change to education in Harlem. When reading about Canada a smile always appears on my face because he is so driven to see his plan unfold to its fullest capacity, and make sure each individual child was prepared for college. Another aspect that I like about Canada is he never stops believing in a child after high school, he continues to help motivate them even during college. For many people they view Canada as an egotistic man who is ill preparing the students and is only doing this for himself. If you look at his situation realistically, he is going beyond what local public schools should be doing. We as people cannot fault him because a select few can attend his school. The fingers should be pointed and the government for not given children their rights to a better education. I appreciate Canada for selecting “a single geographical area and devote all of his energies to that one place.”
Comparing the reading to my service learning is simple. MAP is a community of its own that makes sure that everyone that walks through their doors is helped to the best of their ability. No one at MAP gets turned away, but similar to Promise Academy, MAP’s services are not for everyone. As I mentioned before MAP helps everyone, if they cannot service someone they recommend other facilities that will better suit the client. Promise Academy is not like any other charter school and I can compare it to MAP because it is not like your local Planned Parenthood.
Recently MAP opened my eyes and showed me how they truly care for every client. As mentioned in the reading Canada intervened in children’s lives and MAP follows suit. MAP tries their best to be every step of the way with clients’ everyday life. A client in particular mentioned to me how much MAP helped him even when he strayed away for the straight and narrow path. To watch the relationship that case workers had with this one client express this was not just a facility that catered to those who have AIDS/HIV, they are also a family oriented project. Once he walked in everyone knew he and did not ask what was wrong, but more of what could they do help the solution.
A line/ question that I like and kept me thinking and I felt screams students in low – income areas as well as those who are suffering from deadly diseases need more than a few donations and fancy ideas. “For me [Canada] the big question in America is: Are we going to try to make this country a true meritocracy? Or will we forever have a class of people in America who essentially won’t be able to compete because the game is fixed against them?”
From Louise:
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Whatever it Takes
“You grow up in America and you are told from day one that this is the land of opportunity. That everyone has an equal chance to make it in this country and then you look at places like Harlem and you stand there and say, that is absolutely a lie” These were the first words that Canada said in his 60 minute interview with Anderson Cooper. Canada’s motivations are the children who have the odds stacked up against them. Who, through no fault of their own, have been born to an inferior class and are expected to fail and remain that way. He is committed to “save kids by the tens of thousands, because that’s how we are losing them.” I found this article very inspiring. To him, he may not be doing enough to help the community but the way that I see is that he is not only helping the child but future generations as well.
There was a piece of argument that I would have to agree with Canada in regards to public schools. “He believed that the only way to successfully educate poor children in significant numbers was to improve not replace, the public school system.” I am not opposed to charter schools but I am disappointed that the government is not being active enough to improve the public school system. Instead we have to resort to charter schools where only a few students can take advantage of the opportunity.
I found the research on chapter 2 to be very interesting. When I read this article it took me back to the nature vs nurture argument. Is it possible that genes are the only factors that play a major role in a child’s intelligence/behavior? Or can we change that through proper nurturing and education? I think it’s the latter. I am sure there are exceptions like Einstein or Beethoven who may have been born with a certain gift, but for the most part, a person’s IQ can change depending on their surroundings. The proof is in the research. Nutrition, socioeconomic, parental involvement, and many other factors have proven to be huge factors at an early age. To assume that genes are responsible for their failure is absurd and ignorant.
From Dayna: Geoffrey Canada
What a powerful story, Geoffrey Canada’s quest to change Harlem and American really touched close with me. This is a powerful movement that he has begun, reaching out to help these communities that are really struggling is going to put a new face on America. Canada is giving all children a chance to succeed before they are automatically expected to fail. I feel this relates very closely with my service learning experience. These girls who I look at, are of these same children in Harlem. They weren’t given many opportunities to strive and prosper. They weren’t given as many chances to succeed as other children were. In result, they have bigger struggles of not only not finishing their education but also raising children at such a young age. Related with the quote Canada said, "The people who run prisons in this country are looking at our third-graders. They look at their test scores each year to begin to predict how many prison cells will be needed twenty years from now." (p.15). As Denise researched and found, the reasoning behind this is that “until third grade, children are learning to read. After third grade, they are reading to learn.” If these children fall back on their reading after third grade, they are put at an extreme disadvantage for all the years to come. This then causes these children to drop out of school and thus creating this cycle which pours more children into prisons, indicated John Morgan, a child psychologist and Executive Director at Voices for Virginia’s Children. To me, not knowing how or why the teenagers that I work with at the Teen Mom Center, are in their situations, its easy to think that as young children perhaps they were not striving through school and were only getting farther and farther behind, resulting in majority of them attending Oracle School and some striving for their GEDs. They could have used a school like Harlem’s Children Zone. Of course I’m not saying these girls are headed for prison, I’m just stating that closer attention needs to be paid to these early years of education. Children need to be encouraged and guided. I feel a school like the one Geoffrey Canada has created is the answer that we need, across America.
Dayna Reilly
You Will Not Have Our Children
Tuesday, February 22, 2011
Our Time
Saturday, February 19, 2011
Prompt for Whatever it Takes: Geoffrey Canada's Quest to Change Harlem and America
What motivates Canada?
What are some of his personal ethical challenges/inner debates?
Can you relate to anyone you have met in your service-learning or to your own experience, thus far?
The second chapter, "Unequal Childhoods," chronicles some of the history of the debate surrounding the causes of generational poverty: "Canada had come up against one of the most nettlesome questions in all of social science: Why are poor people poor?" (23). It is interesting to note how non-objective science can actually be, depending on who is designing the tool of measurement, deciding what should be measured, and how this data should be interpreted--on top of all of this, politics also enters the picture. Paul Tough does a good job of laying out some of the different approaches and attitudes to the issue. What most surprises you? What appears finally to be fair and less biased accounts of some of the root causes of poverty? Can you relate any of these findings to your service-learning or why your community partner organization exists?
Watch Canada on 60 Minutes
Thursday, February 17, 2011
I found the readings to be very insightful about moral and social responsibility. In their own way, each philosopher states that there are many things wrong with society today, and the reason being is that society as a whole has forgotten what it means to be socially responsible and actively participate in helping further develop society as a whole as a pose to the individual.
In “The Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society” by Cornel West, West believes it is crucial that one realize that American democracy has a tradition of struggle; the struggle for “decency and dignity, the struggle for freedom and democracy” (West 5). According to Cornel West, struggle has become an American tradition and the only way to overcome it is by accepting it, and although the end to struggle is not near, we should take action in trying to stop it because it is our moral responsibility.
Societies are not perfect, nor are people. Everyone faces challenges and struggles, but what West is saying is that the struggle is not as important as what one chooses to do with it. Everyone suffers, and the moral responsibility of individuals is to see how they can actively participate and be part of the change in making a difference in the lives of those who are suffering rather than being the cause as to why people suffer.
Today all people think about is “me, me, me!” When does one stop to think about others? Living in a society means that one should work with others for the greater of the people and not for the greater of oneself. However, West is saying that this is not happening because we are living in a “hotel civilization,” in a “market culture” where achieving wealth and success is more important than “nonmarket values.”
If people were to focus more on the “nonmarket values” such as justice, care, and love society would be much better off because then the individual would allow others to see what they are really made of and focus on the true importance of life which consists of helping and working together with others.
As William James stated “Every claim creates an obligation…the obligation is to listen and devise or suggest means of relief.” In my service learning site the claim has been made distinctly clear; help educate those who have not been educate. Through tutoring at MCCS I am helping to provide student with the power of knowledge that they did not previously posses.
“We ask why we are here, what is the meaning of it all?” –Jane Goodall
The answer to me is simple, I am here to help and give back to my community by passing down the knowledge that has been passed down to me by my parents and teachers. I am at MCCS because it is my responsibility as an active citizen to acknowledge the struggle, take part in the struggle and do something about it.
At this point in time society is at a very crucial moment when traditions about responsibility have almost completely diminished and it seems impossible to reinstate society to what it used to be. However, it is not impossible, as Jane Goodall said, “I strongly believe that we have the power to change the state of things on our planet. The environment can never be as it was- but we can save a good deal of what is left.”
From Dayna: We're All in the Same Boat
I found Cornel West’s piece to be both extremely intense and very eye opening for me. Although I may not agree with everything he states, I do agree that, “we are living in one of the most terrifying moments in the history of our nation (211).” I found the power portrayed from his quote, “We are all in the same boat, on the same turbulent sea. The boat has a huge leak in it and in the end, we go up and down together (211),” to be both completely accurate and true. The meaning of this being, the American society is on rocky grounds so we need to pull together and unite to come up with a resolution. As the saying goes, “two heads are better than one,” then imagine what we could do. As West then states, “democracy is also about giving each person a dignified voice in the decision-making processes in those institutions that guide and regulate their lives (212).” This is extremely important because all Americans should have a “say” in their society. If the boat is going down anyways, wouldn’t the corporations want to do what they could to save it? Otherwise what is the purpose? What is the purpose of your power if you can’t use it anyway? As a corporate executive responded to West stated, “We are not in the same boat. We’re global.” My response to this is then are you not apart of the American society, because that’s what it sounds like to me, the attitude of not wanting to deal with it so acting as if you are above it all. Corporations contributions to this decline in wages and jobs are to simply downsize more, to lay off more working middle class people, because what’s it to them, they have some of the highest profits in America (211). I love how West goes on to say, “There must be prescribed forms of public accountability for institutions that have a disproportionate amount of wealth, power and influence, This is not a matter of demonizing corporations, but an issue of democratic survival (211).”
TERRIBLE TIMES
Ashley Ferguson
In Cornell West’s The Moral Obligation of Living in a Democratic Society discusses how a nation that is for the people is truly for the individual. West mentions that the state of America’s democracy “is one of the most terrifying moments in the nation” (211). I agree with West, our nation is terrifying because more than half of people in America are both struggling and suffering. One of the student’s blogs mentioned Hurricane Katrina, a tragedy that is still “mind boggling” to me. “Think about the victims and the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina for a moment. Members of our own country desperately waiting for assistance, but it does not come immediately. Yet when another country is devastated, like the Indonesian tsunami victims, the US pledges millions of dollars in aid,” (Jason’s blog). I always argue that America should stop involving itself in other nations affairs and be more concerned about the issues that it’s nation is facing. West mentions “nurturing spirituality is so difficult today because we are bombarded by a market that evolves buying and selling, promoting and advertising,” (212-213). This statement is true the world is more concerned about the latest gadget and who has the best web plan instead of worrying about their child’s schooling or the effect of their voting power.
West discusses the wealthy being a low percent and owning a high percentage of the wealth; meanwhile they watch the poor suffer. Learning that prevention clinics are declining because the elite “forgot” about those who are in fact really suffering explains that our nation believes in a cast system. Being a nonprofit is just one of the many conflicts that my service learning project MAP is facing. Connecting this reading to MAP I realize that many of the clients like W.E.B Du Bois “understood what it meant to be cast as a part of a problem people rather that people with problems,”(210). Many people are ignorant to the diseases (HIV, AIDS Hepatitis A and B) and exile those who suffer from them. If we are a country who are for the people we shouldn’t stand back and watch as an epidemic kills more the half of the country. A line that I believe is best for my service learning project is “empathy is not simply a matter of trying to imagine what others are going through, but have the will to muster enough courage to do something about it.
From Tom: Are you a 20 percenter?
Traditions aren't simply automatic, they're maintained by those that feel they are worthy of maintaining -- or at least you hope others are maintaining them because they are worth maintaining. I think that's one of the salient points in West's narrative, that if a culture grows apathetic and loses its bottom to fight for a better tomorrow, then the culture atrophies like so many grapes on a withered vine.
Is America losing its bottom to fight for better conditions, or a bigger piece of the pie? I think I need a picture to wrap my head around it.
Not quite the statistic quoted by West(top 20 percent owns 94 percent of the wealth), but it's close. It is not hard to figure out why there is such a disparity, after all most of history consisted of tiny groups of elites on one side and hordes of plebs on the other. Naturally, the elites held most of the wealth.
I believe that in America's history it has been one of the few places where you could become an elite through wealth accumulation. Entrepreneurs, inventors & patent holders, and those that just worked hard and served a need well. This wasn't really a choice for many of the new immigrants, however. Blacks, Hispanics, and just about anyone who couldn't readily assimilate into American culture couldn't just hang out a shingle anywhere they wanted.
It has changed over time, but large shares of people find themselves struggling to stay afloat day after day while others seem to afford luxuries like botox and shopping addiction. This is a recipe for disaster according to Dr. West; harbingers of cultural decay and decadence leading to a callousness to the bottom 80 percent by the 20 percent above. Eventually, the 80 percent will get angry.
I can't say for sure if there has ever been a time in human history where this wasn't the case. In fact, I would guess the wealth disparity was worse in the past. But I do think we can't rest on our laurels, and the 80 percenter's need to realize there is a workable path to something better, something they can be involved in.
West states, "The ultimate logic of a market is...I want power now."(Pg 213). Market culture and non-market culture should be separate entities, but one is in danger of being capsized by the other for venal drives. That is the root of the problem, or it might be more correct to say the rootlessness of the problem. That man becomes a solely economic creature unable to emote values, such as honor, justice, and compassion. How one does this, yet maintains personal freedom to individuals I'm not quite certain.
Interconnectedness Begins With "I"
We have become a culture that is satified by words, and words alone. We no longer probe, fact find. We take rhetoric to be fact. Fear has permeated our thinking as if it was needed like air and water. This isolates us into individuals and no longer fosters community which increases the divide. Goodall states (p. 5), that we can make a difference when "we talk to each other, teach, give of our time or moneyto improve the quality of life..." We must see this societal deficiency as hurting everyone, not just. We are, as West points out, destroying our community. He states (p.212) that "the roots of democracy are fundamentally grounded in mutual respect, personal responsibility, and social accountability....is also about giving each person a dignified voice in the decision-making process". I feel that the middle class is suffering but also bears some of the responsibility that we find ourselves in today in Modern day America. As Barzun states, "At first the loosening of rules looks like liberation, but it is illusory....A permissive society acts liberal....youth turns cynic. Now we are faced with generations, and not just certain groups of people that are angry. Goodall says that when community is not an opportunity, it will affect the individual's behavior. "A young chimpanzee (who shares 98.4% of the same DNA as its closest relative, the human) who has a disturbed upbringing, a harsh, non-supportive mother or caretaker, no opportunity to to form close bonds...is likely to be insecure and to find it difficult to form meaningful relationships with others in adult life". I feel that a culture can be one of these "primary caregivers" modeling the behavior of what is truly important or valued in that given society. With 94% of human communication being non-verbal, I wonder what our citizens have seen modeled over the past decade. Extreme Consumerism Leading To Prozac Nation! More is NOT better. Spiritual values are the answer and not in an organized religion type of way. Martin Luther was on to something when he believed there was no middle person needed. My hope is that every individual can take a moment away from their iPAD or 65" plasma TV to hug their children and realize that, (West, p. 212) "Spirituality requires an experience of something bigger than ourselves that binds us to community". Maslow calls this "Love and Belongingness"! Marx called Relifgion the "opiate of the masses". Today, he might use the term "consumerism" to identify the tool by the elite to put us to sleep...
It is not only the spelling of the word but yet it is the practicing of the concept "interconnectedness" that starts with "I"....
CHOOSING WHICH NEIGHBORS' TROUBLES TO ATTEND TO
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Moral Obligations
Cornell West's Moral Obligations poses interesting ideas about “...the struggle for decency and dignity, the struggle for freedom and democracy” (first paragraph). The idea that common, ordinary people were once viewed as “weeds and rain drops” (2, bottom paragraph) nothing more than a collective mass, is I think, a viewpoint from elite society. The divide between the haves and the have-nots continues to expand. “One percent of the population owns 48 percent of the total net financial wealth” (3, second paragraph) this statistic supplied by West demonstrates why even though we are one of the richest nations in the world, we still have people living without food or shelter. I find it remarkable that those in the position to make real change (the Bill Gate's and Steve Job's of the multi millionaires club) don't do more to help those less fortunate. West describes a human history of “elites, of kings, queens, princes... all of whom subordinated and exploited everyday people” (3, first paragraph). Think about the victims and the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina for a moment. Members of our own country desperately waiting for assistance, but it does not come immediately. Yet when another country is devastated, like the Indonesian tsunami victims, the US pledges millions of dollars in aid. This is wonderful and something our nation should do to help others, but why is it so difficult to help those in our own country? As West puts it “These sets of conditions are immoral” (3, third paragraph).
West also mentions the need for “public discourse” when it comes to the “civic responsibilities of corporations” (3, fifth paragraph). Why are corporations growing and CEO's getting richer while local school districts are laying off teachers or closing schools because of a lack of money? Might this be an opportunity for corporations who have “a disproportionate amount of wealth, power, and influence” (3, fifth paragraph) to make a decent and necessary contribution to the betterment of local society?
West's description of 'non-market values' is poignant. “Mercy, justice; they are non-market. Care, service; non-market. Solidarity, fidelity; non-market. Sweetness and kindness and gentleness. All non-market” (5, sixth paragraph). This made me think of my Service Learning client and the difficulty we face - trying to convince administrators, principals, teachers and parents with strong religious or social beliefs to see another side of an issue. “It is hard to convince people that there are alternative options...” (5, seventh paragraph).
As West puts it in his final paragraphs that “there is no overnight solution” (6, second paragraph) to our problems, he does suggest that we look to our past to find 'empathy.' If we can put ourselves in the shoes of those less fortunate, those who faced prejudice and remember their struggles, “...the struggle for decency and dignity, the struggle for freedom and democracy” (first paragraph), than we will as West believes, find hope for a better future. These words remind me of something Du Bois wrote in his book The Souls of Black Folk, where he brings up the famous words upon which our nation was built:
“By every civilized and peaceful method we must strive for the rights which the world accords to men, clinging unwaveringly to those great words which the sons of the Fathers would fain forget: 'We hold these truths to be self-evident: That all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness'” (DuBois, 50).
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
From Teresa: Responsibilities in a Democracy
People with problems can be lumped together and seen as the same problem over and over again. Persons working in public service, such as the DMV, Social Security Office, police departments could use this thought process as a means of dealing with an overwhelming amount of issues and to protect their own sensitivities. I do not think that one person’s thoughts and concerns are the same for an entire race. I do think we should re-examine power and money distribution with 20% of the people maintaining 80% of the wealth by significantly changing the funding and more wide spread support of education.
DeBois and Barzun also wove a theme of responsibility into their text. DeBois noted,“The roots of democracy are fundamentally grounded in mutual respect, personal responsibility; and social accountability.” Barzun explained that our rights imply reciprocity. Indicating that we need to actively participate in the democratic process. We can do so by regularly making ethical choices and not practicing with an attitude of “if we can get away with it, it is ok”. This thought process may provide an immediate gain, but is detrimental to us in the long run. As Barzun stated, “the habit of grabbing, cheating, and evading reciprocity is the best way to degrade a civilization.” DeBois and Barzun are calling for all of us to act in a respectful, accountable manner that will multiply into society.
Barzun acknowledges that events should be analyzed for personal perspective. He states that understanding “things come and go-also protects against the worst among machines: the band-wagon. To keep from climbing on...the other machine, the media.” The band-wagon offers the masses an easy out, the convenience of not questioning. He goes on to challenge this thought process by asking,“what is the role of the most disadvantaged in relation to the public interest?” Surely it is for them to speak out so that we do not ignore the problems that ultimately effect all of us.
Goodall warns against society’s neglect, “Any civilization that is unable to sustain its networks of caring and nurturing will generate enough anger and aggression to make communication near impossible”. Supporting our youth and teaching them to respect nature will help them to make good choices and interact with others in a healthy manner.
Monday, February 14, 2011
Road to a better democracy
All three articles raise good questions of the American democracy of today. Our role as Americans is to keep the meaning of democracy what it should be. To be part of a larger democratic community we must take charge and become active participants, clear our mind from prejudices or negative thoughts, and move forward without forgetting what history has taught us.
It is true that we are “living in one of the most terrifying moments in the history of this nation”(Cornel 211). There is so much wealth in this country and yet less than 20 percent have most of it. In order to live in a democracy we must first ask ourselves, “What is the role of the most disadvantaged in relation to the public interest”(Cornal 212). At this point, the common people are not being heard because we are not as involved as we should be. We do not have to impact the world in a huge way to make a difference. The smallest gesture of kindness goes a long way, “ It is impossible to overemphasize the power of the individual in the shaping of the values of a society”(Goodall n.p.). Barzun brings about a special point on what it is to be man/woman of honor; “’Honor’ here means knowing how little one brings and how much one has received and feeling impelled to discharge the debt”(Barzun n.p.). It is not only our duty to give back to the less fortunate but we are in “debt” with them.
In order to move forward we must leave racism and prejudices behind. Barzun writes about how our minds can become mechanical if we allow ourselves to be lethargic. “So does race thinking-a verdict passed mechanically at a color-coded signal”(n.p.). Cornel makes the exact same point in his article, “Problem people become indistinguishable and interchangeable, which means that only one of them has to be asked to find out what all the rest of them think”(210). We must reevaluate the way we think to prevent us from getting stuck.
Lastly, history has the greatest lessons, but most of us are either ignorant or forget it quickly. “History is concrete and complex; everything in it is individual and entangled”(Barzun n.p.). We will never progress as a country if we keep making the same mistakes over and over again.
Julia
Saturday, February 12, 2011
Prompt for West, Barzun, and Goodall reading
(The prompt simply provides some ideas for your reflection. Responding directly to the prompt is not required! You are completely free to engage other ideas and to make connections between readings and with service in whatever way makes sense to you.)
Cornell West starts his piece "The Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society" by stating the inherent complexity and irrationality of tough social issues, especially those related to race. He restates W.E.B. DeBois’s analysis that “Being Black in America is to be a problem . . . Problem people become indistinguishable and interchangeable, which means that only one of them has to be asked to find out what the rest of them think” (5). He connects this issue to the idea that democratic sensibility “cuts against the grain of history” in which the ruling class exerted its power over the underclass, effectively dehumanizing the “ordinary” individual. Thus, West asserts, if we are to live justly and democratically, we must critically engage and examine issues of race and power: “No democracy can survive with a middle class so insecure that it is willing to accept any authoritarian option in order to provide some sense of normalcy and security in their lives. It also opens the door for significant segments of that middle class to scapegoat those who are most vulnerable” (10).
Think about what this means and if you can relate to anything related to your service or community partner. Also, see if you can connect to similar ideas conveyed by Barzun and Goodall:
What does Barzun mean by his struggle against the “mechanical.” He writes that “any ossified [fossilized] institution . . . manifests the mechanical. So does race-thinking—a verdict passed mechanically at a color-coded signal. Ideology is likewise an idea machine, designed to spare the buyer all further thought” (pg. 3 of pdf, right hand side).
Jane Goodall writes that it is “impossible to overemphasize the power of the individual in the shaping of the values of a society. . . In human society, the legacies of a Hitler or a Jesus, a Gandhi or an Ayatollah Khomeini, are testimonies to the impact they made during their brief years on earth. . . Every single one of has, I believe, a significant part to play in the scheme of things” (pg. 9 of pdf, right hand side).
What does it mean to be part of a larger, democratic community. What happens if we don't struggle/question/strive as individuals but wait, instead for someone else to do it for us?