One statement that really stuck out to me was her response to her self-asked question, "What social conditions help to form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed?" (16) Meghann interpreted that responsibility arose from the individual based on their environment. Part of me agrees with that, especially with the things I have posted previously commenting on other articles. But the statement that really stuck out to me went a little deeper than that. She says, "We are at once acted upon and acting, and our 'responsibility' lies in the juncture between the two." (16) I thought this was such a great insight that we've been talking about all year!
This statement is so significant because it implies that there is a reciprocal responsibility within each situation - whether it be between man-and-man, man-and-environment, man-and-himself, whatever it is, there is a responsibility we hold to the other, and there is a responsibility that is held for us. To further her idea, Butler evidences a common occurance in our society - violence. She poses the idea that violence stems from response from violent injury because it "may well seem 'justified'". (16) This is true. But then she challenges us, asking if this is the kind of responsibility we want to be holding as we participate in "social transformation" that is "non-violent" and cooperative". (17) I love the idea she brings up about the double standard - about how we WANT to do it the non-violent, peaceful way, but in our own lives we act out violently and defensively, almost the complete opposite of the "guiding ideal". (17)
This ties into another one of her points, "who counts as human?" (20) I believe our negative reactions to negative situations would definitely define us as human, just as the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, and mourning also make us human. Because we have all experienced loss, vulnerability, and grief - whether through a family member dying as Danielle mentioned, or a break up with a boyfriend/girlfriend, or a special pet dying, or a brother/sister going away to college - this ties us together as a race. We are defined and differentiated from other animals and living things on Earth because of our ability to feel intense emotion and our ability to speak out, act out, or try to change it. The connection we automatically have with another when we realize they are experiencing or have experienced the same feelings overtaking us, counts us all as human.
The idea of shared anger, pain, and vulnerability ties back to my work at MCCS. The kids are definitely one of a kind and heavily guarded. But talking to one student has been such a great experience at school. He is very quick to talk about his frustrations and problems with me. I didn't expect to be affected so much by his situations, but I found myself relating to him by thinking about times in my life when I felt just as frustrated and angry. In this way, we have this connectedness and bond that I'm so grateful for. Butler sums up my thoughts very nicely in her last paragraph, "You are what I gain through this disorientation and loss. This is how the human comes into being, again, and again, as that which we have yet to know." (49) Even though I don't know the exact reasons why he and I have such a great bond, that is how the human life works. We all experience the same feelings and the feeling of connectedness it brings us is something that brings us peace.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.