Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Morality: Emotion rather than Reason

The two chapters that I have read of Lehrer's book,  "The Moral Mind" and "The Brain is an Argument" are, in my opinion, the most interesting readings required by this class thus far.  These chapters discuss morality in how it relates to it's source: the minds of human beings.  Lehrer informs us, not only of the emotional sources of morality (our conscious and unconscious), but also explains the biological sources as well (the amygdala).  According to him, "morality can be a squishy, vague concept, and yet, at its simplest level, it's nothing but a series of choices about how we treat other people" (169).
Through the course of history morality has, for the most part, been attributed directly to one's ability to reason.  In other words, morality was thought to be fueled by our own logical, objective, and rational thoughts.  However in recent years it has been discovered that morality is not rational, as was previously believed.  It is emotional.  Lehrer cites a study in "The Moral Mind" chapter which informed a randomly selected group of people about a story in which a brother and sister decided to have sex with each other.  They were asked whether or not this action was right or wrong and the response was that the deed was wrong.  When asked to provide reasoning for this belief people came up with excuses, but as each excuse was justified then the people were more likely to just say that sex between siblings is wrong.  This provides evidence that supports the assertion that morality is determined first by our emotions, and then explained by our reasoning.  "The emotional brain generates the verdict.  It determines what is right and what is wrong...The rational brain, on the other hand, explains the verdict.  It provides reasons, but those reasons all come after the fact" (175).
This idea flows into the subsequent chapter, "The Brain is an Argument" which discusses the fact that for every decision human beings make, there is an argument in our minds about what the best decision is.  Although most would like to believe that all the decisions one makes are the most logical and reasonable decisions possible, the truth is that our emotions often over through our rationality.  We make decisions we believe to be right in order to comply with our previous dispositions.  An example of this concerns voters and party loyalty.  Republicans, even when provided with facts which devalue their party, almost always come up with reasons to stay loyal to their political party; and the same goes for Democrats as well.  According to a study performed involving partisanship, "Western realized that voters weren't using their reasoning faculties to analyze the facts; they were using reason to preserve their partisan certainty" (205).
The most interesting and beneficial thought that I acquired from this reading is the knowledge that morality is determined by our emotions.  Our decisions are made by our emotions and then validated by our reasoning.  This information helps me better understand some of the situations I have experienced while mentoring at MCCS.  Last Wednesday when I came to mentor, I participated in a class discussion which revolved around moral decisions.  One of the questions was, "If you found a wallet on the ground with money in it, but no identification, what would you do?"  All of the MCCS students responded that they would take the money for themselves, which shocked me.  When it was my turn to express my opinion, I said that I would turn in the wallet, which shocked the MCCS students.  I explained that if I was the one who had lost my wallet I would want the person to find it to turn it in, and most of the kids had not thought of the situation in that way.  They began to understand my point of view, and I began to understand theirs.   The students would be happy to have extra money, and justified taking the money by saying that there was no identification and that the person whose wallet it was shouldn't have lost it.  I would have felt guilty taking the money for myself, and justified returning the money by thinking about how I would feel if the shoe was on the other foot.  The fact is that both myself, and the MCCS students made our decisions based on our emotions, and justified those decisions with our reason.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.