Tuesday, October 25, 2011

The Chaos of Humanity

Butler asks, “What social conditions help to form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed? . . .” (16) Explore her discussion around these questions.

The argument that these questions pose is that, “our acts are not self-generated, but conditioned” (16). Responsibility is therefore put on the individual and the conditions that the person is in. Butler then ties in her argument of violence into this question. It takes a person’s experience with violence to compel them to take action. According to Butler, “(Only) Once we have suffered violence are we compelled, ethically, to ask how we will respond to violent injury” (16). Take for instance, the women suffrage movement. Because women were subjected to violence, their view of the violence that is occurring in the world today is affected. The same goes for other minorities that have had violent histories. Experiencing violence definitely gives you a different point of view when you hear about violence occurring which is why the use of violence is an unethical way to solve a dispute.

(What really caught my eye in Butler’s argument was the emphasis given by president Bush put on the mentality of “us or them.” If you spoke out against what he was doing you were considered a terrorist yourself. What was down during 9/11 was a terrible thing but responding with just as much violence is not the answer. I found it very appalling as a modern that a mentality even existed. Disagreeing with the government should not automatically make you a terrorist.)

“Who counts as human?” (20). Why are the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, mourning integral to Butler’s thesis? Do I agree that these are universal human experiences that might be a source of moral response?

One of Butler’s main themes is that man is vulnerable and in that vulnerability we must accept things about ourselves. When a person experiences a loss, he or she will feel like, “we have lost some ties by which we are constituted” (22) because of that we feel like, “we don’t know who we are or what to do” (22). In a way, loss leaves us to open to vulnerability and in that place we question who we are. Personally, I agree with this concept. It is important to accept how truly vulnerable we are and accept that loss and grief is an integral part of life. In my previous question, I quoted Butler saying that in order to understand violence you must undergo violence yourself. The same can be applied to grief. In order to be able to support a grieving person and support them you must have experienced grief yourself. Grief and loss add to our knowledge and experience of life and in turn shape what we think is morally sound or not. Without the experience of loss, you will not fully grasp the hollow emptiness that a person is feeling when they have lost someone. In short, I do agree that loss, vulnerability, etc. are a source of moral responses because they shape the way a person thinks and reacts to everyday life.

“Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something (23).” Do you have a significant moment from service that illustrates this?

My understanding of the quote is that humanity in itself is chaos and we do have a self-destructive nature. If we were all operating together peacefully something is wrong. If we all agreed to everything then we would be a brain washed society that doesn’t have the ability to think. This can be shown in both of my service projects. One kid I worked with at County Community (I will not state his name) told me when I was tutoring him that he thought I would automatically think he was an awful person because of where he is. Of course, I quickly replied with a no because I believe that just because you are in County doesn’t make you a bad person. He then proceeded to tell me that he wants to strive to do better and he knows that what he did to get into County was bad but he has a hard time doing what is instructed because he doesn’t want to be told what to do. To link this with the previous quote, he is the perfect example of human nature and its need to be against. We all have been in situations where we wanted to skip an assignment a teacher wants us to do or defy an authority but in order to survive we have learned to obey. The kids at county community are products of not wanting to work in the system. That is not only in the county community kids but in all of us. What makes us different from the county community kids is we have learned to keep the feelings of defiance controlled.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.