I found Butler’s discussion of the intentional use of political rhetoric by the government and the media to influence the public extremely intriguing. She writes about the use of specific, politically controlled rhetoric to influence domestic perception of events, and about the larger implications of certain rhetoric in distorting human perception of the value of lives. I do not mean to say that all media or all government literature employ a deceptive rhetoric like the one Butler describes, but rather I mean to examine the method by which words can be used to damage public perception of a people or institution.
Butler’s primary example, the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, works to demonstrate the devastating effects political rhetoric can have on the operation of democratic society.
She begins by describing the conditions that invalidated public anti-war sentiment, which she refers to as ‘anti-intellectualist.’ “…Moralistic anti-intellectual trends coupled with a distrust of the Left… has produced a situation in which our very capacity to think about the grounds and causes of the current global conflict is considered impermissible” (Butler, 3). When it is impermissible to disagree with the government, democratic society cannot function, as democracy’s success hinges on the ability of the people to influence government action.
Butler then describes how dissent became impermissible. “The raw public mockery of the peace movement, and the characterization of anti-war demonstrations as anachronistic or nostalgic, work to produce a consensus of public opinion that profoundly marginalizes anti-war sentiment and analysis, putting into question in a very strong way the very value of dissent as part of contemporary U.S. democratic culture” (Butler, 3-4). By creating public hostility toward anti-war sentiment, a view opposing the government, the American public is no longer able to dissent without seeming anti-American and anti-democratic. This is in complete conflict with democratic ideals, but effective in minimizing public refusal to accept the publicized reasoning behind the war.
She finally explains that the United States government retains their appearance of hegemonic standing by dictating a specific vocabulary, both in terms of definition and usage, and therefore limiting the language allowed to express dissent. “The articulation of this hegemony takes place in part through producing a consensus on what certain terms will mean, how they can be used, and what lines of solidarity are implicitly drawn through this use” (Butler, 4). By restricting usage and controlling definition, the government creates a climate in which certain terms will be interpreted as it desires, specifically in order to equate anti-war sentiment and anti-Americanism.
When Butler comes to her discussion of dehumanization, and whom the government and media allow to be portrayed as human, she suggests that rather than controlling for meaning and usage of certain terms, the government and media simply omit all language pertaining to those they seek to dehumanize. “There is less a dehumanizing discourse at work here than a refusal of discourse that produces dehumanization as a result” (Butler, 36). By excluding all mention of tragedy when the victim is considered an enemy, and focusing attention on domestic tragedy at the hands of that enemy, writers can construct a distorted public view of that subject. “If there is a ‘discourse,’ it is a silent and melancholic one in which there have been no lives, and no losses; there has been no common bodily condition. No vulnerability that serves as the basis for an apprehension of our commonality; there has been no sundering of the event” (Butler, 36). The government and media can eliminate the perception of human aspects, such as grief and suffering by refusing to report those aspects, resulting in prejudice against an enemy as inhuman.
The use of words to influence perception of a population is not limited to political objectives, and can manifest additionally in social situations. Many minorities fall victim to rhetoric, even unintentional biased language, which creates stigma and prejudice at every social level, from national politics to school yard bullying. When this dehumanizing rhetoric becomes absorbed into mainstream speech, it can be highly detrimental to the mindset of the targeted group, as well as perception of their human aspects. We must be aware of such rhetoric and work to prevent further absorption of distortive language into our everyday speech.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.