Saturday, December 10, 2011

Curiosity Leads to Evolution

I think it is very important for cultures to share with each other. Just like biology, cultures evolve too. They have to change in order to fit with the current times. I don’t think that by sharing new traditions we destroy a “unique” culture. Suk Cha and Appiah both agree that there is no “pure” culture. Suk Cha states “It is difficult to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another” (5). While Appiah writes that, “…people in each place make their own uses from even the most famous global commodities” (113).

How can we ever grow and learn from each other if we do not share? And who is to say that tribal cultures are better off untouched? “Are all these pockets of homogeneity less distinctive than they were a century ago? Well, yes, but mostly in good ways. More of them have access to medicines that work. More of them have access to clean drinking water. More of them have schools. Where, as is still too common, they don’t have the things, this is not something to celebrate but to deplore. And whenever loss of difference there has been, they’re constantly inventing new forms of difference: new hairstyles, new slang, even from time to time, new religions. No one could say that the world’s villages are-or are about to become-anything like the same”(103).

Trapping a culture is not the same as preserving it. No two cultures are ever going to be exactly alike because traditions change people’s actions, beliefs, and moral standings. Counter cosmopolitans are afraid of change. They are afraid of the things that they do not know or understand. Perhaps they are even afraid that a new way of thinking could completely change their way of life. I can understand their fear, but again, each culture can make something unique out of “contamination.” No tribe, city, or country can change overnight because something new was introduced, and if they do change, it is usually for the better, like access to new clothes, technologies, medicines, and food. Curiosity about the unknown is the key to change.


~C. Standridge-Folsom

Global Interaction and Ethics

Our last reading assignment included the final four chapters of Kwame Anthony Appiah’s Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers as well as an article by In-Suk Cha titled “Toward a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World.” Both pieces of writing take an in-depth look at the global interaction of cultures. As a result, the main topics of In-Suk Cha’s article can be easily supported with Appiah’s writings.

One of Cha’s first points is that, although conflict does break out, various groups of people manage to coexist with each other most of the time. He partly attributes this to his belief that societies have much in common with each other as a result of cultural exchange (4-5). Appiah tackles the same topic in his seventh chapter, where he discusses the homogeneity and “contamination” of cultures. One exemplar he presents is a comparison between Kumasi, the capital of Asante, and villages around twenty miles out from the capital. Although the villages have much less diversity than Asante, they still feel the external influences from things such as “…the World Cup in soccer, Muhammad Ali, Mike Tyson, and hip-hop” (102).

Another major discussion of Cha’s is in regards to global ethics leading towards peace. Cha suggests that progress is already being made in this direction, but that to this end it is important for people to understand the cultural impact of interaction between societies (6). Appiah talks about a similar concept in his eighth chapter, although his discussion consists of specific ethnic issues in regards to the ownership of cultural objects. Toward the beginning of the chapter, for example, Appiah tells the story of how the Djenné-Jeno terra-cottas were dug up and exported despite specific laws in Mali to help prevent such occurrences (117). Appiah goes on to argue that the issue should not be so much about keeping high quality Mali art in the country as making sure Mali has a diverse collection of high quality art from around the world (124).

Cha’s concluding main topic is that although human interaction can be oppositional, there is no such thing as humanity without it (11). This can be comparably seen with Appiah’s concluding chapter, where he attempts to analyze the morality of enduring a cost to help strangers. He brings up the specific scenario of donating money to charity organizations such as UNICEF, and then contrasts philosophical principles that would relate to such a situation (159). Appiah ends by explaining that helping less fortunate strangers is a “demand of simple morality” (173).

- Christopher Galbick

Friday, December 2, 2011

From Julia Hyry: Are Globally Accepted Ethics Possible?

Our prompt for todays reading featured a quote by Suk Cha that stated, “One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies.” (Cha 5). Cha then goes on to ask if an ethics for peace that spans across all cultures can actually exist. Although a world filled with peace and ethics that apply to all cultures is slowly coming about and is worth attempting to reach, I don’t believe that it will ever completely occur due to the presence of counter-cosmopolitans.

Cosmopolitanism is essentially the movement towards a more accepting world that makes judgment based only on basic morals that are found globally. As Kwame Appiah states in his book, Cosmopolitanism, “Cosmopolitans think that there are many values worth living by and that you cannot live by all of them,” (Appiah 144). In other words, different cultures embody different values that are neither better nor worse then another, just different. Today many people struggle because some cultures are losing certain practices, causing them to become more universal and less distinct, but Appiah tells readers that “the identity of a society can survive through these changes.” (107).While this new character who is expected to accept various societies, religions, and cultural practices develops, another character with equally opposite ideas also exists, the counter-cosmopolitan.

Counter-cosmopolitanism is an ideology that involves absolutism to the extreme, that is the idea that their beliefs and culture are correct while all others are wrong. According to Appiah, “For the counter-cosmopolitans, universalism issues in uniformity.” (145). They want people of every other culture to end their practices and beliefs in order to join theres. What makes it counter-cosmopolitanism is that they do not care wether those in other cultures want to change, their belief is that they should change because what they are doing is wrong. This lack of acceptance or even toleration can lead to violent conflicts such as those committed by what Appiah describes as neofundamentalists.

As long as counter-cosmopolitanism exists, the world will not be able to accept a common moral code because their will be an unending attempt to move towards one uniform culture. This movement is bound to become violent when radical people get involved, therefore keeping the world from reaching a peaceful resolution.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

from Noelle

The ideas illustrated in Appiah's final chapters go hand in hand with the points made by Suk Cha in "Toward Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World," especially the first two points. Suk Cha states that humanity cannot use fear of difference as an excuse for violence and conflict because our societies share too much in common with each other. We are all connected in many unique ways, even if we stem from different backgrounds and cultures. Appiah purports this same idea in his "Cosmopolitanism." He writes that one connection we all share with each other "...is the connection not through identity but despite difference" (135). He uses the example that all human beings can respond to art, even if the art is not our own art or art from our specific culture. Despite the differences of humanity, the commonalities which all humans share; such as the urge for love, compassion, and family create much stronger bonds. Suk Cha's second point includes "...We have obligations though, as we never need have if we choose to believe that we are not responsible for decisions we make and the actions we take. Our obligations include examining the nature of societies in terms of their differences and similarities and in terms of how they change upon interaction" (6). Appiah illustrates this point in his writings; in fact he believes that all humans have obligations to each other. He is not saying that we should treat all strangers with the same love and care that we would treat a close friend or relative; "...our obligation is not to carry the whole burden alone. Each of us should do our fair share; but we cannot be required to do more" (164). We have the obligation to treat each other with dignity and respect, and to do our part in benefiting the lives of those less fortunate than us. But we are only expected to do what we can, no more and no less.

In everyday language, contamination is perceived as a negative thing, however Appiah does not see cosmopolitan contamination as such. People feel as if their identities are being threatened by globalization and the meshing of different cultures. Many do not like the changes which are resulting from the ever expanding world. Appiah writes, "In the era of globalization...people make pockets of homogeneity. Are these pockets of homogeneity less distinctive than they were a century ago? Well, yes, but mostly in good ways. More of them have access to medicines that work. More of them have access to clean drinking water. More of them have schools " (103). It is true that the world is changing, and along with it, the cultures of the people who live in this world. There is a difference in preserving cultural artifacts and cultures. Cultural artifacts can be saved, restored, and used to tell the story of the particular culture it originates from. Cultures themselves, however, are susceptible to the changing times and the people who embrace them.

In order to understand counter-cosmopolitans, we must be able to fully define cosmopolitans. Cosmopolitans embrace the belief that there are countless values to live by, and no one person can live by them all. This is why they hope and expect that these values will be embodied by the different people and societies around the world. Cosmopolitans also understand that their knowledge is not bullet-proof; but constantly subject to change. On the other hand, counter-cosmopolitans believe that there is one right way for everyone to live. "For counter-cosmopolitans, then, universalism issues in uniformity. The cosmopolitan may be happy to abide by the Golden Rule about doing unto others...But cosmopolitans care if those others don't want to be done unto as I would be done unto" (145). Counter-cosmopolitans, on the other hand, tend to embrace their own ideology and do what they themselves believe the correct action is, regardless of the beliefs held by those they are helping. Counter-cosmopolitans are part of all different cultures across the world, including fundamentalist Christians in the West and fundamentalist Muslims in the Middle East. MCCS consists of a mix of students from various cultures and backgrounds. They are more likely to hold a counter-cosmopolitan mindset, simply because they are usually set in their views and are least likely to be open to other ways of thought. This is because most of them have grown up in harsh environments, and the only way survived is by living by their own rules. It would not make sense to open up to different ways of viewing things because these students relate uncertainty and fear to what they do not know.

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Tolerance -Whitney Myers

Human beings are social by nature. Community is an inevitable aspect of life, and necessary for the human traits we enjoy. “That human nature is conflicted and oppositional, there can be no doubt. That is surely one thing that every society has discovered, just as every society discovers that whatever is decent, beautiful and just exists only because of societal living. Civil union can bring out the best and likely the worst in human beings, but without civil union, there is no humanity” (Cha, 10). Though community and social relationships between peoples are a necessary part of living as a human, these relationships may lead to disputes. In order to solve these disputes, it is necessary to determine a method by which we can communicate across societies about the controversy we experience.

In order to communicate about the conflicts that might arise between people or groups, an understanding of the other groups’ values and core beliefs is helpful. Cha puts forth that a universal system of values, that all situations might be evaluated by, might be even more helpful. Humans are responsible for creating and agreeing upon this universal code of ethics, as it will not simply come to be without active attempts to assist its development. “Can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures? I stand with those who contend that we are already moving toward such an ethics and it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency” (Cha, 6). Individuals and groups must deliberately work toward a method by which to understand and evaluate the conflict between themselves and other individuals or groups.

Appiah’s discussion of counter-cosmopolitanism hinges on the difference between counter-cosmopolitan universalism and cosmopolitan universalism, two proposed methods by which to bridge the gaps between different groups. Counter-cosmopolitans promote universalism, but without the tolerance that cosmopolitans find necessary in dealing peacefully with the world. “What distinguishes the neofundamentalists, violent or not, is that they exemplify the possibility of a kind of universal ethics that inverts the picture of cosmopolitanism I’ve been elaborating. Universalism without toleration, it’s clear, turns easily to murder” (Appiah, 140). When universalism is promoted without the acknowledgement that some will not fit easily into the promoter’s idea of universalism, that intolerance can cause violent attempts to force the ‘other’ to conform or concede. This is not to say that cosmopolitan tolerance is unlimited. “…There are limits to cosmopolitan tolerance. We will sometimes want to intervene in other places, because what is going on there violates our fundamental principles so deeply. We, too, can see moral error… Toleration requires a concept of the intolerable” (Appiah, 144). Complete tolerance is not realistic in my view, as it would require the acceptance of all kinds of appalling brutality and violence.

In Appiah’s earlier image of the relativist many shattered mirrors and the universalist single shattered mirror, Appiah describes his cosmopolitanism as a form of the single shattered mirror, but the counter-cosmopolitan view he later describes is also a version of the single shattered mirror. Both views acknowledge that there should be a universal understanding of some code or system, and that there are unacceptable breaches of that code, but the cosmopolitan system differs in the acknowledgment of the incomplete picture they might possess. “…Cosmopolitans believe in universal truth, too, though we are less certain that we have it all already… One truth we hold to, however, is that every human being has obligations to every other. Everybody matters: that is our central idea. And it sharply limits the scope of our tolerance” (Appiah, 144). Though cosmopolitans’ do have a limited tolerance, that tolerance, and their acceptance of new additions to their incomplete universal truth, allow them to peacefully converse with other groups and cultures. They do so by working to find the universal basis on which they can relate to others, and find common ground on which to build conversation.

Everybody Matters- Jessica D.

Children’s openness and the ability to easily forgive always fascinate me. As the topic of the ethics of peace arises, I think a child’s mentality is the answer. I remember when I was in kindergarten I had a very diverse group of friends: Caucasian, Hindus, Buddhist, Christians, African-American, and Hispanic. Despite the differences in our races, cultures, and religions, we all got along well. No discrimination, no divisions, but all united in innocent friendship. Appiah says, “We do not need…a homogenous system of values, in order to have a home” (113). I could not agree more. He also goes on to say, “Cultures can die without physical extinction” (114). This idea struck me because I realized the importance of it. When Appiah explained the different and vast journeys cultural artifacts went through in time and space, I realized the beauty in knowing that those artifacts are evidence of the great diversities in our human race. Furthermore, although some people may deny being bound to others because of their differences in space, time, and beliefs, they are essentially bound in some point in the past by the innumerable exchanges in their cultures. It’s symbolic of the impossibility of “cultural/racial purity”, and the beauty of “contamination.” Essentially, it’s not about the differences in cultures and people, it’s about the “contribution to the civilization of the universal” (118). How does this relate to the ethics of peace? I compare it back to children. As children grow up and are more exposed to society, I find that some become hardened and corrupted as adults. Likewise, some radical groups of people resort to violence to “uphold their beliefs.” But this is corrupted. For example, the core beliefs of Islam, Buddhism, and Christianity all involve peace. In the numerous century-strive to uphold these beliefs, one is bound to deter from it eventually. We are all human and imperfect after all.

“As one truth we hold on to is that every human being has obligations to every other. Everybody matters” (143). I relate this back to the students at MCCS. It’s not about how they might be involved in gang-related activities or dealing drugs or sometimes outrageously rude. The fact is that they are all human beings who were once innocent children, unfortunately hardened and mislead by the life they were raised in, and maybe made just one significantly bad choice that landed them in their current situation. All the more reason to care and help them.

The Final Chapters

I enjoy Appiah on the chapter on cosmopolitan contamination. Although humans tend to indulge in other cultures...they do not always necessarily buy into them. On page 110 there was a mini story about a man named Sipho and how his culture differs from that of the Western culture and that he does not have to embrace this culture proving "cultural consumers are not dupes." Even with commonality with others people can still retain their own ways. On page 111 "talk of cultural imperialism structuring the consciousness of those in the periphery treats Sipho and people like him as tabulae rasae on which global capitalism's moving finger writes its message, leaving behind another homogenized consumer as it moves on. It is deeply condescending. And it isn't true." But he also finds what he calls the golden rule of cosmopolitanism in contamination: "Homo sum: human nil a me alienum puto. I am human: nothing human is alien to me." Suk Cha writes "It is difficult to find some sort of cultural exchange with another." People like Sipho who do not necessarily embrace the ways of Western culture are still exposed and practice some form of cultural exchange. "People in each place make their own uses of the most famous global commodities" (113). I mean I know he was talking about marketing but I feel like people do exchange cultures even if it is an economic thing. I feel like having a diverse multicultural food court in a mall counts even. Anyway my point is that people are connected by their commonality in being human and that's how they can peacefully exist in this world although their cultures might differ, it shapes a rounder world.

In terms of counter-cosmpolitanism Appiah states "For the counter-cosmopolitanisms, then, universalism issues in uniformity. The cosmopolitanism may be happy to abide by the Golden Rule about doing onto others (putting aside, for the moment, the conceptual problems of "universalizability" I discussed earlier). But cosmopolitans care if those others don't want to be done unto as I would be done unto to" (145). My interpretation here of what Appiah is saying is that for counter-cosmpolitanism is that you maintain the same attitude towards everyone with uniformity. However, cosmopolitanisms understand that you want and how you want to be treated may not be the same for others. --I find I can apply this to my service. I would have to be a cosmopolitanism. In a situation where I am growing and blind to what is in the future. However, the kids do not necessarily want to be helped. And not all of them need help or need someone looking over their shoulder. Some kids need more attention than others and I think it is good that some kids do not want to be help. I can think of one girl who hates the attention and hates the help because she motivates herself and challenges herself to succeed on her own. Even if she is considered somewhat below par, considering the circumstances that she comes from a family who does not speak english, she is an impressive student. And in a situation where one might think she needs help, she might be better off on her own and I think this shapes who she will become. (She does get help every now and then and that's why she is in the program.)
America, often acknowledged for its diverse population of people, is wildly referred to as a great “melting pot” of various cultures, races, and creeds. Every day we are contstantly and unconsciously influenced by the many cultures that inhabit this country, from the clothes we wear and the products we use to people we encounter on a daily basis. Appiah states, “Cosmopolitans think that human variety matters because people are entitled to the options they need to shave their live in partnership with others.” While reading Cosmopolitanism, I wondered how an individual’s culture was to be maintained and preserved in a globalized society. It seems as if there is an underlying fear of one’s cultural practices, beliefs, traditions, and objects will eventually become mainstream and their origins/background eventually lost to history. However, if one invokes an attitude of cultural imperialism (the domination of one culture over another), it prevents one from truly exploring their world and hinders their pursuit of knowledge. Appiah states, “Cultural preservations often make their case by invoking the evil of “cultural imperialism.”” I believe that one should always remain true to their roots, but should explore other cultures to form their own opinion of the world that surrounds them. They might be surprised that some of their cultural practices are rooted and interwoven into cultures they have no knowledge even existed.

Ethics and Cultures

Suk Cha says asks “can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures?” (6). My response to her question lies in part with Appiah, when he states that “‘culture’ is whatever people make and invest with significance through the exercise of their human creativity” (118). I for one believe that cultures and religions merely come from the imagination. In the case of Indian culture and religion, there are many Gods but one supreme God and there are tons of stories associated with each God. To me, I treat these stories as stories with morals that I can walk away with, a “guide to life”. But other than that, I don’t entirely think that the characters and the situations were present at any certain time in life. Also, I think that culture plays a role in the ethics of a person. At least for me, as I stated earlier, I often view stories about the Gods as a guide to life. By this I mean that I use the mistakes of the demons and the valor of the Gods to decide how to go about situations in my own life.

To delve deeper, as John Stuart Mill states, “different persons also require different conditions for their spiritual development; and can no more exist healthily in the same moral...” (104). This bring me back to MCCS. I noticed that these students although similar are quite different from each other in a variety of ways. In some ways, their similarities bring them together and in other ways, their differences bring them together. Just as Appiah states, "one connection - the one neglected in talk of cultural patrimony - is the connection not through identity but despite difference." (135). By these similarities and differences, I approach each student differently. If I did, however, approach these students similarly, their differences wouldn’t matter and I also would not be helping certain students in the areas where they need it. I feel that the one-on-one tutoring helps focus on the students’ difficulties. For example, when I worked with this one student on the High School Exit Exam Math portion. I could pinpoint his main trouble and I helped him get through it as well as stay focused on the subject. This seemed more beneficial than helping a full class of students out all at different levels.

These final chapters helped to reel in all the topics discussed in this book and helped me to connect them to my service learning project.

Again with the interdependence! But this concept is truly the core of what we are learning in this course. As much as we all want to be independent of each other, as much as we want to say that we as Americans are different from the Chinese because of said reasons, we still share some of the same values such as peace. 'Despite the history of longing for peace, it is fair to say that there is no ready-made set of ideas as to how the human race can live together in harmony' (4). We could simply say that we are all human and that in it of itself could be what connects us all together regardless of our color or location. However as humans, we don't want to be jumbled up into just one category. It's as if we don't want to come to terms with the facts that we are dependent on someone else because that would mean that we don't have a solid foundation to stand on our own. 'One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies' (5). What we need to realize is that our 'solid foundation' has been built on the cosmopolitan foundation of our histories. Each culture has been affected in some way by many other cultures, regardless of whether or not they want to admit it.In the United States, I know that I have been exposed to hundreds of different cultures, some I am aware of and some I am not. Yet there are times when we need to individually step back and look at how our lives are flowing as well as the kinds of things we value. Parents want their children to be healthy in order to survive, intelligent in order to make a living and loved for their own emotional well being. This may be true in many many cultures that we overlook as being 'the other culture.' Appiah talks about the obligations we have towards strangers and says that these obligations '..entail, as Adam Smith saw, clearheadedness, not heroism' (173). I feel that our obligation to strangers is to be understanding. We are going to know our values, our morals, and our culture inside and out because that is what we have been forming our entire lives. First, we must accept that there are other cultures and that 'othering' benefits no one. Further, we must step back from our own lives and try to see the world in the shoes of another. While we may not agree, our efforts are appreciated and we gain a better knowledge of our cosmopolitan world. Our visions are clouded with perspective, negativity, bias, and sometimes ignorance. It's a difficult thing to understand a different culture which is why it is so easy to succumb to 'othering' and bias. What they don't realize is that we are able to see the bigger picture with the beauty of every culture, every family and every individual human being by trying just a little bit harder.

I thought that I'd have a few things in common with the girls at YMM but in the first few meetings, I felt that there was nothing. Yet as the weeks went on, we became just a group of girls talking about world news, make up tutorials and baby updates. We all wanted the same thing, to succeed, we just had different pathways in getting to where we wanted to be. These mothers were still teenagers who wanted to look good when they went out, have a stable family and get an education. At first I could only see our differences because what could we realistically have in common other than the fact that we were teenage girls? I guess in my own way I was 'othering' this group of girls which my perspective. Now, it seems silly of me to even think of us as a separate group because we all need and crave the same things. 'We solve problems using the schemata of the new world with the same ease with which we once solved problems in our homeworlds. We are able to do this because, despite the differences, there are some transcultural, common elements' (7). My world was once a place that knew very little about teenage pregnancy but my experience with YMM has given me more perspective on how to handle certain situations yet has not thrown me off balance. Why should there be othering, when maybe we're just some teenage girls looking for love or girls looking to be empowered. If anything, we're all connected within humanity.

Acceptance - Kiefer

Suk Cha’s question of “Can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures?” (6, Suk Cha) incites a strong response in my mind. My opinion, sharing some ideas with Appiah’s concept of cosmopolitanism, is a combination of values embedded in curious acceptance and a relative point of view. Human variety and difference is a natural part of life and comes as a natural product of how spread out and wide spread humanity is on this planet. With the variety of people and places across the globe, divergence among those groups is only natural. As speciation drives huge differences in animals over millions of years, so does humanity’s cultures specialize, albeit in relative microcosm, over hundreds. I really enjoyed the quotation Appiah used from John Stuart Mill, it writes that “If it were only that people have diversities of taste, that is reason enough for not attempting to shape them all after one model. But different persons also require different conditions for their spiritual development; and can no more exist healthily in the same moral, than all the variety of plants can exist in the same physical, atmosphere and climate” (104, Appiah). We, as humans from whatever culture we hail from, can only exist, thrive, and truly understand our own side of the coin. Of course, we can study and integrate ourselves into other societies, but ultimately I feel we are inexorably linked to what is our own. I feel an understanding of this concept would go far in helping society. For example, I need to use this view in my service learning experiences in order to overcome difficulties in evaluating my service group. I would be failing the kids at Coleman if I treated them all as eggs from the same basket. They are not identical, they are as varied and as full of depth as all the world’s cultures. That’s why I feel society and the educational system fails these children. With their intense individuality, both in personality and situation, how is it fair that each child be evaluated by the same standardized exam? That’s like evaluating the “quality” of a culture through the material gain of its subscribers. Materialism is a western invention, and one that not all cultures have an understanding of or care for.

Appiah writes that “Cosmopolitans think that there are many values worth living by and that you cannot live by all of them. So we hope and expect that different people and different societies will embody different values” (144), I say that there are some values that certain people can only live by, but that does not make them any better or worse than anybody else. Sun Cha writes “That human nature is conflicted and oppositional, there can be no doubt. That is surely one thing that every society has discovered, just as every society discovers that whatever is decent, beautiful and just exists only because of societal living” (10, Sun Cha). The environment you grew up in, in combination with your personality, is everything. I believe if we are to come to up with an ethics for peace across cultures it will be one based on accepting differences and embracing new beliefs, even if we do not have the tools to wholly understand them.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

Insideoutproject.net

Hello! I think that this project is really cool, and wanted to share it.



Friday, November 25, 2011

From Camille: Potential

(sorry, Camille, I deleted this by mistake and now am re-posting!)
One point that strikes me again and again is the idea that we are all connected. I like the way Appiah describes it in chapters 8 (Whose Culture Is It Anyway?) and 9 (The Counter Cosmopolitans). At the end of chapter 8, Appiah talked about the connections we share with each other - across cultures and across time. "One connection - the one neglected in talk of cultural patrimony - is the connection not through identity but despite difference." (135) I found this idea very significant because we are so quick to look at the things we have in common. We're very quick to divide things into two categories: likes and differences. In reality, those are not the only two categories. Similarities aren't the only things that enable us to draw connections. Differences can do this for us, just as much. We do this every day, without even knowing. For example, one of my best friends and I have been friends for 9 years now; she likes to party, drink, and doesn't believe in a higher being while I like to stay home, watch movies, and go to church. We are different; we have different personalities, habits, and beliefs. But there are imaginary connections (134) that bind us together. We have been through everything together - transferring schools, experiencing heartbreak, etc. Experience and emotion has brought us together.

This example, although on a small scale, is relatable to the human society as a whole. Although on a larger scale, it is easier to stereotype a culture or group and seperate groups based on beliefs, each group is fundamentally connected, and this is because each person is fundamentally connected to another. Appiah writes, "My people - human beings - made the Great Wall of China ,the Chrysler Building, the Sistine Chapel: these things were made by creatures like me, through the exercise of skill and imagination. I do not have those skills, and my imagination spins different dreams. Nevertheless, that potential is also in me. The connection through a local identity is as imaginary as the connection through humanity. ... [The] connection [is] made in the imagination; but to say this isn't to pronounce either of them unreal. They are among the realest connections that we have." (135)

I think this idea that we can be connected, even if it is by something as large as basic creativity or potential, is an important idea, not just for Cosmopolitanism, but for everyday life. We're so quick to start fights, on a local and global level because of differences. Look at the Wall Street protests: WE are the 99% and THEY are the 1%. Again, it's differences that we use to fuel our fight. I feel like this is just an excuse though. Or at least, I feel like this isn't the real reason for our anger or protest. On a fundamental level I think we fight because we feel we have been wronged, not because we find difference with someone else. I think Suk Cha validates that idea when she says, "One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of differences as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another." (5)

I can see the similarities vs. differences idea at work in my service-learning opportunity at MCCS. The kids are quick to define themselves and the people around them by similarities or differences. Even I, as a mentor, are quick to look for differences and similarities between myself and the students. In reality, this isn't how it should be. Like Suk Cha said, differences aren't a valid basis for an argument because there are too many things that connect us together. Appiah defines those connections on a basic level when he says we all have imagination and potential.

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Cosmopolitanism and "Toward Transcultual Ethics" (This article is posted on moodle--I forgot to mention but it is important!)

(The Dangers of a Single Story and the Gratitude Video are posted below the prompt for your Thanksgiving viewing pleasure!)

In "Toward Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World," In Suk Cha writes,
"One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial
fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share
too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group
or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another." (5)
and:
Can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures? I stand with those who contend that we are already moving toward such an ethics and it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency. We have obligations though, as we never need have if we choose to believe that we are not responsible for decisions we make and the actions we take. Our obligations include examining the nature of societies in terms of their differences and similarities and in terms of how theychange upon interaction. (6)

That human nature is conflicted and oppositional, there can be no doubt. That is
surely one thing that every society has discovered, just as every society discovers
that whatever is decent, beautiful and just exists only because of societal living. Civil
union can bring out the best and likely the worst in human beings, but without civil
union, there is no humanity. (10)
How does Appiah, support and illustrate these points in these last chapters? Why does Appiah support what he calls cultural "contamination" and what does he mean by the conceptual challenge inherent in his discussion of "counter-cosmopolitans," of "how to distinguish benign and malign forms of universalism?" (143). Can you relate these points to or illuminate them through your service-learning experience?

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Identities -Whitney Myers

People seem to hold the logical idea that there is safety in groups. In order to create a stable group, the group identity can be established in competition with those considered “outsiders.” Appiah’s cosmopolitan perspective of this issue is that people must learn to depend on ties to humanity in addition to the smaller groups to which they may hold allegiance. Issues occur when “…we care only about people with whom we share an identity- national, familial, religious, or the like” (98). People create groups based on sub-identities, and lose sight of their more substantial identity as human beings. In order to achieve this larger loyalty, humans must find common ground on which to join.

As an option in finding a common base for human interaction, Appiah describes the “thin” moral concepts that seem to permeate humanity, despite cultural differences. “Thin concepts seem to be universal; we aren’t the only people who have the concepts of right and wrong, good and bad; every society, it seems, has terms that correspond to these thin concepts” (47). These thin concepts might provide commonality useful in communication between people of different groups. In finding joint values between groups, the “other” can begin to be seen as human. “The problem of cross-cultural communication can seem immensely difficult in theory, when we are trying to imagine making sense of a stranger in the abstract. But the great lesson of anthropology is that when the stranger is no longer imaginary, but real and present, sharing a human social life,… you can make sense of each other in the end” (99). Once a stranger’s life can be viewed as human, like one’s own, it creates common ground and opportunity for communication. Once this communication can be established, conversation between groups can take place.

Appiah’s discussion of the human tendency to create a sense of group identity by designating an “other” is interesting, especially in light of the many collective identities that one person might feel themselves to be part of. They might consider themselves to be part of an ethnic group, or a socio-economic group, or a regional/geographical group, or even a smaller social group, like a gang. A group like a gang uses the concept of the “other” to create group definition, but the process of creating strength this way can cause violence, as can ethnic conflict or geographical conflict. Appiah’s position allows people to maintain their ties to many groups, as long as the overarching loyalty to humanity is present to prevent violent conflicts. Sub-groups seem to play a large part in the social interactions at MCCS, and, similarly to humanity as a whole, MCCS might benefit from unification under one extensive identity.

Another option to counter the group-forming aspect of human nature might be to find an “other” against which to create solidarity in the human race as a whole. As possibilities, I nominate the zombie population, or, alternatively, the inevitable Borg invading force.

Commonality In Others

I find I relate more with the second prompt. After gaining a perspective on some of the kids I have this story of them that I cannot erase. My impressions of the kids have matured but I also have impressions of the places that they come from and the people who mold their lives. I don't intend to sound critical or even judgmental however i feel like it is inevitable upon my exposure to someone is different than me, more the judgement than the criticizing. However, I see that the parents and whoever raises these kids at Coleman do not allow for their kids to grow up in a less than perfect environment because that is what they want. I guess I have my own idea of an ideal way these kids could be raised even under less than fortunate circumstances. And I feel my ideas are more closely associable to the universal ways than some of these people. However, I guess we both have something in common, we hope to improve the lives of these Coleman students. They are enrolled in the Coleman program because the parents take the time to apply and make arrangements around conflicting schedules and babysitters and all other kinds of factors to keep them in the program. I just can't help but wonder how some of the kids get exposed to some of the inappropriate things that they do under their parents care. For instance, their humor is sometimes overly mature and highly dirty. On page 94, the big question is...do we need universals? I guess need is the key word and no, no one needs a universal way to raise their kid but i guess it serves as a good template. It's the fallback for someone who has no other way to do something. I like how Appiah states it on page 97 "They do not need to be universal; all they need to be is what these particular people have in common." I guess our interests in these kids do not have to necessarily agree in terms of practice but we have the same intentions of making sure they get the help that they need. This goes for the supervisors too. Even if I don't necessarily agree with the methods of the program, they are pressed under circumstances that makes this the only available way to potentially help the kids and therefore make a difference in any way.

There is no Othering

I feel most compelled by Appiah’s “othering.” At the beginning of my service-learning, I felt a strong distinction between myself and the MCCS kids. I’m sure they probably felt the same way too. I wondered if I would be able to relate to these strangers who I knew nothing about, and I thought probably didn’t want me butting into their personal lives. “Cosmopolitans suppose that all cultures have enough overlap in their vocabulary to begin a conversation. (57)” I didn’t want awkward silences when I was tutoring someone while I mentally argued in my mind whether or not I should ask a personal question like, “Are you close with your parents?” or “How’s your love life?” At the same time, I wanted to be more than just a person who comes on a weekly basis and tells them which math problems to solve. But as my time at MCCS went on, I grew more comfortable talking with them, and I realized that I don’t have to know a whole lot about their background to be able to develop a relationship. I found out that some seem tired during class because they have to work, some like to spend time with family, and others like to party on the weekends (although not in the way I would have a “good time”). The little conversations we have painted a more wholesome image of them as a person. They are no longer just a blur of strangers with a big label that says Juvenile Delinquent. This is the beauty of being united as humans in this life.

Although Appiah explores some interesting perspectives on the “Golden Rule,” for me it is the very root of why I want to connect with others deeply. It’s not just, “Do not do unto others what you do not want done unto you.” For me, this implies living with a big sense of focusing on the self. A deeper belief that springs from the Golden Rule that I live by is, “Love one another, as I have loved you (John 13:34). The “I” is referring to God. It erases the self and puts God’s infinite and selfless love as the standard. This way, I don’t worry about my own fears about how to interact with strangers. I imagine looking through God’s eyes and seeing each person as a beloved precious brother, sister, or parent; my own flesh and bone, someone I would give up my life for because Jesus deemed them worthy of dying for. In this way, there is no “othering” for me. Sometimes in my human nature I can’t help but make that distinction in my mind. But my heart always reminds me not to lose touch of that core belief that drives my very life.

Cosmopolitanism Continued

This week’s reading consisted of three additional chapters from Kwame Anthony Appiah’s Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers. Chapters four, five, and six take a closer look at disagreements, justifications, and the organization of people into groups.

The fourth chapter of Cosmopolitanism opens with Appiah introducing moral discussions as a form of conversation across cultures (46). He goes on to define “thin” and “thick” concepts, where thin concepts are broad notions that tend to be universal while thicker concepts are more specific ideas that tend to have ties to a particular culture (46-47). Appiah uses taboos as an example of a local value, while noting that this thick concept does not interfere with people’s recognition of thinner and more universal concepts (56). Later in the chapter, the Golden Rule is brought up as a representative case of how the same value can have more than one interpretation (62). Appiah also uses the death penalty to show that the same value can be weighted differently (65). He sums up the chapter by indicating that people can disagree about three things: what values should be applied to a situation, how those values should be interpreted, and what significance those values should be given (66).

In the fifth chapter, Appiah starts out by looking at situations where people have different justifications but end up with the same result. He argues that people can readily live together and agree with most results without using the same reasoning (71). Appiah continues along this line of thought, proposing that most of the time people’s choices are based on experiences and intuition. The only time people use reasoning is when changing their normal habits, and even that is less about arguing values and more about seeing things from a different perspective (72-73). One of the examples Appiah uses to support these claims is with females wanting to have more specialized careers such as being doctors and lawyers. He argues that if the disagreement was about logic, the women’s movement could have happened very quickly. Instead, the movement was a long process of changing people’s perspectives on female roles (76-77).

The first part of Appiah’s sixth chapter is spent introducing and then explaining one of the customs in Ghana. Appiah uses this to lead into questioning how universal human characteristics are (94). His ultimate point in this vein of reasoning is that people’s ability to connect is not necessarily limited to what values they share. He notes that normally two individuals get to know each other because they share a number of the same values, but then end up enjoying the discovery of values they did not previously share (97). Appiah’s final thought references cosmopolitan opponents who argue that for a group to be made there must be another set of people left out. His rebuttal for this is that any given individual is going to fit in with a variety of different groups. This implies both that no individual will be left out from everything and that the groups lead to everyone being interconnected.

I think some of Appiah’s ideas, particular in chapter six, can be applied to my experiences with students at Coleman Elementary. In some ways, I can be seen as part of a culture separate from the children. The children share a similar age and have been growing up together for a number of years, while I share a closer attachment with the “Dominican tutor” culture. Nonetheless, during the last time I served at Coleman I ended up playing soccer with several of the students. During the game, we were able to better learn each other’s names and personalities. Our mutual love of soccer essentially allowed us to get to know each other better and expand our connections beyond the value of soccer itself.

- Christopher Galbick

Understanding Perceptions

The fourth chapter of Appiah's "Cosmopolitanism" entitles Moral Disagreement introduces the concept of "thin" and "thick" values.  The morality of the world consists of a mixture of both types of values; "Once you understand the system, you'll be likely to agree: and it won't be because you've given up any of your basic moral commitments.  There are thin, universal values here...but their expression is highly particular, thickly enmeshed with local customs and expectations and the facts of social arrangements" (49).  In every society, there are the same thin universal values, such as pride and respect for elders, however these values coexist with the thick values of each specific society.  Because all individuals come from different societies, each with distinct traditions, beliefs, and values, that disagreements are created.  According to Appiah, "...the most fundamental level of disagreement occurs when one party to a discussion invokes a concept that the other simply doesn't have.  This is the kind of disagreement where the struggle is not to agree but just to understand" (47).  It is difficult for us to understand the views of others, even if we share similar thin values, because our thick values are unique to each individual.  This idea can especially be related back to my experience with service learning at MCCS.  While the students and I can see eye to eye on certain subjects, we fail to view other matters, such as prioritizing school work, in the same way.  This is due to the different thick values we accept.  While I grew up in a setting where education and respect were top priorities, many of the students were raised in a completely different setting.
The main concept which stood out to me the most in the fifth chapter, The Primacy of Practice, was that individuals can value the same thing, but because of different reasons.  Appiah uses the example, "If my interest is in discouraging theft, I needn't worry that one person might refrain from theft because she believes in the Golden Rule; another because of her conception of personal integrity; a third because she thinks God frowns on it" (69).  The thing that matters is that all three people are refraining from committing and theft; and as a result their justifications are not as significant.  Without this ideal, society would not be able to function as it is today; "indeed, our political coexistence, as subjects or citizens, depends on being able to agree about practices while disagreeing about their justification" (70).  
The chapter Imaginary Strangers introduces an especially powerful concept, which is often overlooked during times of distress and disagreement.  Cross cultural conversations do not require universals in order to be successful.  Appiah writes "...the points of entry to cross cultural conversations are things that are shared by those who are in the conversation.  They do not need to be universal; all they need to be is what these particular people have in common.  Once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to enjoy discovering things we do not yet share" (97).  This concept can also be related to my experience at MCCS.  I do not relate to all the students because of specific universals which are always true; i relate to them individually, starting from the things we have in common.  From there a relationship is formed, and then other issues which we may not agree upon can be discussed without fear of reproach.

"Why?" The Most Important Question

I think the greatest differences in cultures can make for the best conversations. Appiah points out that it’s not the agreement that’s important, but the understanding of each other’s perspectives that we should focus on. I think asking “why?” is the best way to understand one another. Appiah calls this “Cosmopolitan curiosity” and says that through our curiosity, “We can learn from one another; or we can simply be intrigued by alternative ways of thinking, feeling, and acting” (97). We do not have to agree with one’s practices to be able to understand why they are done. A cosmopolite may not agree with an action of a different culture, but (s)he makes an effort to understand and therefore respect the culture for its actions. Coleman Academy has kids from every type of background. These kids have different traditions, especially for the holidays and by talking about them in class and after school, they learn something new about their fellow student and about a different culture. I think it’s great that the kids accept each other’s differences. They may be too young to completely understand now, but having these experiences early in life, will hopefully make them more curious about others in the future.

My favorite point Appiah has made thus far is “I don’t say that we can’t change minds, but the reasons we exchange in our conversations will seldom do much to persuade others who do not share our fundamental evaluative judgments already” (72). Several pages later he goes on to say, “I am urging that we should learn about people in other places, take an interest in their civilizations, their arguments, their errors, their achievements, not because that will bring us to agreement, but because it will help us get used to one another” (78). His point is that we will encounter opinions and practices different from our own, and we can argue our sides until we are blue in the face and chances are, each of us will still believe that our own beliefs and practices are the right ones. However, it is important to be able to see a different view from our own. That is the ultimate reason that we exchange conversation, whether in the form of discussion or argument. We should always be able to take something valuable from our conversations and to learn and grow from other points of view.

~C.Standridge-Folsom

Pointless conversation

"Conversation for the sake of conversation." Have you ever heard someone say that? I used to think that it just meant, "let's talk to fill the silence." But here in Cosmopolitanism, Appiah gives his own definition of conversation that changes my mind about the former phrase.

Appiah says two important things about conversation in the end of chapter 5. One, "Conversation is hardly guaranteed to lead to agreement about what to think and feel." (84) and two, "Conversation doesn't have to lead to consensus about anything, especially not values; it's enough that it helps people get used to one another." (85) In my own interpretation, conversation is not just a space or time filler, it is yet another way to connect with one another. What I like about this piece is that it again ties with the idea that there is not rule book of things, even in conversation. The point of conversation is not to get the other to believe in what you believe, but to realize that it is possible to live with others who don't have the exact same moral code as your own.

I love what Appiah's message in chapter 6, Imaginary Strangers, that "when the stranger is no longer imaginary, but real and present, sharing a human social life, you may like or dislike him, you may agree or disagree; but, if it is what you both want, you can make sense of each other in the end." (99) This ties back into chapter five, because how do we agree or disagree on ideas without first conversating about them?

This reminds me of my first day at MCCS, where I tutored two boys that asked me if I drank or smoked, to which I said I did not. They were so shocked by my answers because they just assumed that, because of my age and circumstance, I would have been the type to. I'm not surprised by their shock because honestly, that's the response most people give me when they first learn I don't participate in those activities. So I guess for my entire life, I've been dealing with the process Appiah is talking about: living in a world with different opinions, just as the world has done with me. What I found interesting about these MCCS boys, were that they didn't just blow me off like some other of my peers do. They actually accepted me and respected me for my choices, perfectly exemplifying Appiah's final statements in chapters 5 and 6: conversation is a route to get used to one another and a way to make sense of each other in the end.

Appiah states that “[they] each have a pattern of life that they are used to; and neighbors who are, by and large, used to them…” (71). This relates to my service experience as I have noticed that these students are grown up in a certain way, influenced by media, friends and family, that they live life in only one way. Through this one experience, they experience much more. By this I mean that, their attitude towards one person in their life is carried through to the rest. If they are used to swearing at home to express their emotions and not getting in trouble, they are most likely going to swear in school to express their emotions and hopefully, not get in trouble. Also by this I mean that, if they grew up being tough, that one experience that made them tough will make them tough and ready for any other situation. It’s like siblings almost. If one sibling hurts another, then the other sibling will retaliate. And later when that sibling is in danger, he knows what to do from experience of retaliating before. In other instances, when the teachers ask the students to write for a bit, they immediately jump back and start to curse. This is in contrast to the fact that when the students are allowed to speak out, they tend to lower their cursing. Their skills are held in their speech as they have been taught, like any other being, to use their voice, hence being “street-smart”. This leads me into looking into conversations. Appiah states that “I don’t say that we can’t change minds, but the reason we exchange in our conversations will seldom do much to persuade others who do not share our fundamental evaluative judgments already” (72). In other words, he says that conversations are in part to persuade people to think differently about an issue. Appiah later states that “…a good deal of what we intuitively take to be right….is what we are used to…” (72). This again connects back to the fact that how a person lives their life is the only way they know how to live their life. What humans learn from living their life is what they translate into words to converse and perhaps persuade others with. However, this way of life can be changed if one has a reason for the change. For example, I listen to the students conversing about their activities outside of class and sometimes talk to them about those activities. One of the students was telling me, during the “My Hero” project, that she babysits her niece. She mentioned that prior to babysitting her niece, she would always be either smoking or drinking or etc but when she is around the newborn baby, she doesn’t engage in these activities. This shows that with reason, changes can be made but regardless of these temporary changes, the way of life this student is used to will exist. While this shows the students values set, Appiah’s response is that “conversation doesn’t…lead to…values; it’s enough that it helps people get used to one another” (85). In other words, Appiah says that through conversing people learn about one another and how to handle each person in a situation. This, to me, is a mature concept. At County, I noticed that the students like to irritate one another, a sort of childish thing to do. When you know something is going to get someone angry, you continue to do it until the other person cracks. This has gotten some students in a lot of trouble. I agree with Appiah that conversation does lead to a way of knowing how man should live with one another but at the same time, I do believe that it does show a set of values and morals just as long as man follows them.