Josie Stipe
From “The Moral Mind” I really got a kick out of the primate examples that Lehrer used-
mostly because I have done extensive volunteer work with primates. From page 178, I can relate
to this particular quote, “’This basic primate morality doesn’t understand things like tax evasion,
but it does understand things like pushing your buddy off a cliff.’ As Greene puts it, a moral
violation can be roughly defined as ‘me hurts you,’ a concept simple enough for a primate to
understand.” At the primate sanctuary, I work with some particularly smart macaques named
Simon, Cecil, Dallas, Toby, and Oscar. Cecil and Dallas live together next to Simon, and I have
caught them fighting occasionally. After the fights, the three of them engage in behaviours that
demonstrate an acknowledgment that they hurt each other- they tend each others’ wounds,
groom each other, and share food. Toby seems to understand the concept of “You scratch my
back and I’ll scratch yours” (albeit very literally, ha-ha). He allows me to groom his arms and
reciprocates the favor, thus playing off the “advice of Luke: ‘and as ye would that men [or
monkey] should do to you, do ye also to them likewise.’” (180). Applying this to humans, it is
akin to teaching a young child the concepts of right and wrong. From an early age, we are told
things like “Don’t hit people because it hurts them.” As we grow older, we hear such
admonitions as “No cheating on exams” and “Don’t lie.” The miracle of the human brain over
the more primitive brain of our monkey relatives is that we are able to understand the reasoning
behind why we shouldn’t lie (People won’t trust us, and our society seems to be built on a
foundation of trust). In humans, my example of Toby scratching my arms after I scratched his
would be like teaching a child the Golden Rule “Do unto others as you would have them do unto
you.”
Oscar is definitely my special monkey friend at the sanctuary. I worked very hard to gain
his trust over the past eleven months while volunteering with him. As a defence mechanism
developed over the years, I have become very good at disguising my feelings outwardly- I show
no emotion when I am extremely sad or act perfectly normal when I could be in a black
depression. After spending so much time with Oscar, he has become attuned to my inward
emotions. If I’m feeling particularly depressed or in a bad mood, he comes down and sits next to
me with a pleading look on his face, then he reaches out to attempt to make contact with me as if
I were sitting next to a small child trying to comfort him or her. Oscar used to be a research
animal, and was subjected to the torment of other monkeys in the lab as well as the pain of the
tests he was forced to undergo. He is my example that fits with the quote, “At its core, moral
decision-making is about sympathy. We abhor violence because violence hurts. We treat others
fairly because we know what it feels like to be treated unfairly. We reject suffering because we
can imagine what it’s like to suffer” (180). He appears to be sympathetic because he
understands what it’s like to be in pain. He knows that being picked on hurts, so he does
everything under his monkey-sized locus of control to make sure that Toby doesn’t pick on me
and that I am feeling comforted.
From my life experiences, I feel it is true that the "desire to always be right is a
dangerous side-effect of having competing regions inside one's head" (210). As someone who is
very much a scientist with a bit of a perfectionist’s streak when it comes to finding the right
answers, I often wrestle with this during my time spent on my research project. If I make a
mistake while following my laboratory protocol, I find myself getting frustrated with what
happens and wanting to start over, even if my mentor feels that the mistake won’t seriously
affect the outcome. I have also been a firm believer in the old saying, “If you want something
done right, do it yourself!” I have trouble delegating tasks to people when working in groups,
and this occasionally causes me to feel like I can take on the entire project entirely on my own.
If I have managed to get an entire project to do on my own, I often feel like I have to try to
be “superwoman” or as Meghann called it “Superhuman” and do it all on my own, without
outside assistance. This gets me into trouble because it nags on my conscience that I asked for
help on something that I should have been able to do on my own.
In my service learning through Young Moms of Marin, I do see a sense of what Meghann
referred to as the “Superhuman complex” and the “It’s not going to happen to me” fallacy.
Some of the moms feel like they have to be the sole caretaker of their children when they are
clearly overwhelmed. They need help, but won’t accept it for fear of not being seen as a good
mother to their kids because they accepted help from an organization or a person. I heard Teresa
talk about an example of the “It’s not going to happen to me” fallacy- from what I recall, a
young woman came in with one of the young moms whom Teresa was helping. The visiting
teenager told Teresa, “I’m not going to become a young mother like these girls have become!”
Sure enough, she made the mistake of thinking she was “superwoman” and became pregnant. I
also see evidence of the scarring from the young mom’s childhoods as they deal with their
children. The teen moms struggle to be emotionally connected to their children on occasion.
The mothers mean well, but sometimes, the children are ignored when they misbehave or cry. I
can kind of understand that feeling- when I was younger, my dad did not know what to do with
me when he and I were alone in the house together. If I would cry, he would tell me to shut up
or ignore me until I stopped crying. As I got older, he tried to be “superdad” by getting involved
with every activity that I was a part of. I will never fully understand the situation unless I end up
there myself, but gaining this perspective will help me better figure out what the young mothers
are going through and talking about.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.