Thursday, October 13, 2011

"The Moral Mind"

Inevitably, I found The Moral Mind to be much more interesting than The Brain is an Argument so I will probably write more about the former. It opens with the tale of a psychopath and initially, I am skeptical. Although I did think about notorious psychopaths such as Ted Bundy or the Craigslist Killer, I wanted compelling statistics or more scientific substance to support the claims proposed on how a psycopath thinks. The skewed morality of a psychopath was claimed to be the result of broken amygdala, an almond shape mass of nuclei said to be located in the temporal lobe of the brain. The temporal lobe is the home for mechanisms of language, memory, meaning, and hearing. I guess it would make some sense why a broken amydala would be responsible for an alternate morality. I was happy to read on in The Brain is an Argument and see that a lot of the information in both readings were complementary. I feel like I only know about the arguments discussed on a minimal level but am perplexed by the arguments proposed. When Lehrer suggests that the desire to always be right is a side effect of an arguing brain, it makes me contemplate whether or not I am that way. I wonder whether or not it is my own brain that I am fighting or the other parties involved. Even though it is hypothesized that we are highly interconnected emotionally, and with our ability to empathize with other people I wonder if that is only because we are open to it. When someone wants walls up and wants to set up a barrier, isolated from any kind of affection to other people, are we still able to empathize with others? Does our brain send inhibitory neurons for empathy or even sympathy? I want to know if someone can block emotion to or from other people. It is proposed that emotion drives most of our decisions and logic is actually the support that backs up our choices. For some reason, I want so bad to disagree with this and say that I am rational and logical. And to some extents, of course I am. But the truth of the matter is, my choices have always been based off of emotions, especially my impulses. Upon reading the two scenarios about the runaway trolley and the maintinence workers, I decided that in the first story I would definitely pull the lever and kill one maintinence worker over five. However, In the second study I reluctantly decided I would let the five die. I know this sounds bad, but I thought it over multiple times and realized I devised an argument and justification that is rooted at my own emotions and feelings and sympathy for the overweight man that I would be killing. The way I justified it is in the first situation, I would be saving five people rather than killing one because those maintinence workers were already in harm's way. But in the second scenario, I would be going out of my way to kill someone. Also, I could not commit to just shoving someone off a bridge. What if that didn't work and the man just died in vain? And if he wanted to be a savior and sacrifice for the lives of the maintinence workers, he would have just fallen over or jumped himself. Lehrer argues that people are more likely to make the choices I did because the second scenario is more personal. I guess, he is right. The arguments I was making with myself were because of all my own emotions and feelings. And the funny thing is, I was making an argument with myself. Trying to prove myself right. But I wasn't arguing with anyone in particular, just me and my own arguing brain...I almost feel mind blown.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.