Saturday, October 30, 2010

In All Things, Moderation...

Individuals in modern times are grappling with finally obtaining the long fought for and flourishing independence in their relationship with society. No longer are our actions pre-judged based off of our ranking. I was not born a baker, nor would society ever judge me only in that role were it to be my profession. I am free to determine and pursue my own interests to the best of my abilities. Questions start arising quickly though, including how to judge our wants, pursue our wants, and what affect do ethics have on the answers to these questions. The independence of thought and action can force us to questions what is good and bad. Further, with the secularization seen in modern philosophy, we must decide what motivating and determining forces on which to rely. Both Guignon and Calhoun discuss the focus inward in authenticity and integrity.
                 Even with the independence and freedom of thought, the world around us greatly affects our thoughts. One of the major faults seen in the philosophy of integrity is “this understanding of integrity as a personal virtue, guarding one's integrity must be largely self-protective” (Calhoun 253).  Authenticity as well seeks to “[pull] back from your entanglements in social game-playing and going with the flow so that you can get in touch with your real, innermost self” (Guignon 146).   Modern philosophy unhealthy and inaccurately wants us all to cut the connections and separate the world form ourselves.
However, we are not in a closed system nor are we passive. Yet, removing the self creates the impression that by being authentic or having integrity, we have finally achieved a different sphere from the world. In this different sphere, striving for results does not involve the “outside” world. Calhoun presents counter examples from our judgments of other’s integrities noting in one case, “integrity here seems tightly connected to viewing oneself as a member of an evaluating community and to caring about what that community endorses” (Calhoun 254). Integrity can mean being true to the outside world in many forms including a direct community, an extended nation, the human species, or even for some all the living creatures man is interconnected with on planet Earth. If integrity can be based on these outside factors, the self is also based on all these surroundings. Even this is to passive an approach, Guignon continues by declaring that “to be fully authentic is to recognize the need to be constantly vigilant in one’s society, to be engaged in political action aimed at preserving and reinforcing a way of life that allows for such worthy personal life projects as that of authenticity” (Guignon 162). Upon our shoulders is not only the weight of defining ourselves but also defining the world around us, especially given man’s prominence on the planet.
For better or for worse, individuals are not alone. Working at Marin AIDS Project, I have seen run ups against the system. If the populations attempt to support the poor through medical aid and food stamps, it is seen as socially responsible. However, leaving post-pubescent young-adults with abstinence only education feeds our citizens into these special programs and is morally irresponsible. Using AIDS as an example of immoral based actions which are sounds from the “self” view but not the “non-self” view, one can see many donors who contribute to AIDS organizations across the world but vote for legislation which often foils the very efforts of the organizations they claim to support, major examples for HIV/AIDS include the cutting of public health services of those with the disease, the underfunding or elimination of testing programs, foreign policies which lead to further instability in HIV prevalent areas, and the move to abstinence only education which increases high risk behaviors as well as the social stigma.
Yet, I do not want to say that not caring deeply enough and following issues closely is the only  error in expressing authenticity. One individual recounted a story of his ex-wife trying to but a ranch in Nevada to serve as a wild horse refuge. (Wild horses in Nevada are sterilized in a state program to try to reduce or eliminate the population. Wild horses effect both ranching and native wildlife, some of which has been further endangered by increasing human presence in the state.) Yet, this man was on government aid programs with multiple health problems, and the ex-wife would sell the home they owned in the state to pay for her work in Nevada. Is it moral to confront these skewed priorities, to ask the downtrodden to abandon convictions and get their lives together first? It certainly is accepted to tell middle-class Americans to do just that from changing education plans when college comes during a recession or judge a mother who does not vaccinate her child. Is it condescension or guilt which discourages our judgment of these people in the same fashion? Rather than feeling the actions of the ex-wife authentic or socially progressive, I felt them selfish, misguided, and leeching. This type of blind dedication to a cause without taking in social or practical concerns, “non-self” aspects, even when seen as efforts towards a helpful cause, illustrated to me the dangers of a disconnect between personal wants and true, ethical authenticity and integrity.
We want to feel part of the solution, but both common modern ideals of authenticity and integrity promote ideas of uncompromised, “right answer” pursuits in a multifaceted world in which sometime the most ethical, authentic solutions are ones in which the self is left behind. 

Friday, October 29, 2010

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Social Virtue

As the final chapters of Charles Guignon's book On Being Authentic unfold we are faced with the final verdict on authenticity. What does it mean to really be authentic? Though Guignon has thus far only given us a historical and factual understanding to the meaning of authenticity, here he finally gives his own opinion of what theories and ideas he thinks make up the true self.

In a nutshell, he believes that we are "self-making or self-fashioning beings"(127) and that "we have the ability to organize our lives into a relatively cohesive story"(130) which we shape by our experiences, interactions, and feelings; these creative, unique configurations make us into self-made people. Though he mentions death, responsibility, and the concept of time, his overpowering concept that he is trying to express deals with the role society plays in forming an authentic self. In previous chapters Guignon has given various accounts on the way society has been viewed in the past in relation to finding the self. What he now proposes is that the best way to look at authenticity is as a "social virtue"(156), not as only a personal one. He argues that we are "shaped and defined by society"(155) and that we find our identity and integrity by being conscious of what the issues of the world are and by enacting our own selves accordingly; "becoming authentic involves becoming more clear-sighted and reflective about the issues that face us in our current situation"(161).

In her essay "Standing for Something", Cheshire Calhoun focuses on the integrity of being. She offers that integrity is a social virtue that is expressed by people who "stand for something". Having something that you are wholeheartedly committed to does not necessarily make you authentic; for example being dedicated to money or power is not usually considered a virtue. It can be considered a virtue if it is being sought after not only for personal gain but for social precedent. She also states that the personal virtues that we do hold help us to conduct ourselves properly with others and allows for relationships of mutual respect to form.

In the service-learning experience I have had so far I have learned more about myself then I thought I would. With this statement I do not want to imply that my rewards have only been to realize my "personal identity", just that I have seen that humans as a whole, which also includes myself, are ever changing and that the encounters and experiences that we have shape us into people who can interact with society and who can develop the virtues that are crucial to living with others. I have visited a few families in the Marin Parents of Multiple's Club outreach program and have seen the dedication that Jana has put in to helping out the struggling parents. I have also personally experienced how my identity has shifted since I have been interacting with mothers, who identify themselves with a different group than I do. Also, I have realized that since I am living in society, I should also be an active member of it not just a self-centered being who focuses inward to find authenticity. By reaching out in my community I have been able to commit to something that will improve the well being of society.


-Ilaria Guerra

Monday, October 25, 2010

Prompt for 11/2: On Being Authentic and "Standing for Something":

Guignon has described the historical movements in intellectual thought that brought us to our present crux that he illuminates in the final chapers: we have the liberty to value the development of our individual being and at the same time we must also take responsibility for the condition of others if we wish to survive and thrive in community, especially in a democratic society.Chesire Calhoun, in “Standing for Something” reinforces Guignon’s final point that authenticity can be most fruitful understood as a “social virtue” (156) in which the personal undertaking o of seeking to be and act authentically is “made possible by a social world in which certain democratic ideals have emerged.”

Both argue for the ways in which our "authentic" identity hinges on our participation with others in the world.
Guignon states this concisely when he summarizes the philosophical views of Bernard Williams:

“It is only through the our social interactions that we become selves whose inner episodes are given enough steadiness and cohesiveness so that our relations to others can be built on cooperation and trust” (155)
And again, later:

“when the ideal of authenticity is understood in terms of its social embodiment [the ways in which we engage with the world] it is clear that being authentic is not just a matter of concentrating on one’s own self, but also involves deliberation about how one’s commitments make contribution to the good of the public world in which one is a participant” (163).

Calhoun similarly argues that “integrity” can and should be seen as a social virtue:
Integrity calls us simultaneously to stand behind our convictions and to take seriously others' doubts about them. Thus, neither ambivalence nor compromise seem inevitably to betoken lack of integrity. If we are not pulled as far as uncertainty or compromise, integrity would at least demand exercising due care in how we go about dissenting. (260)
Please think about one or more of these statements in relation to your service-learning experience, and discuss making connections with other textual quotes/ideas and specifics from your work with the community.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

On being Authentic


I like this book because it talked about our worldview. One of the quotes I liked was “the modern understanding of self and world was newly emerging sense of society as something man-made, as a product of human decision and contractual arrangements rather than as something natural or preordained.” I liked this quote because it acknowledges that we are responsible for the state of our world. It means to me that we are directly responsible for all the negative aspects of our society and that we are responsible for the negative state of our environment. It also means that we can choose to make our world better. We have the power to make the world better, despite the powerless feeling many people have about their government, society, and environment. This quote reminded me of Freire in that way. Freire discouraged that feeling of helplessness in his works.

Another quote I liked was “Though functioning in the modern world requires we be able to perform standardized routines and enact roles, we need something more in life to be really alive at all.” To me this means we have to find something outside of our society, something very personal, to feel alive. I think this is something we have a passion for. It could be religion, a social life, family, a job, or some sort of hobby. We have to work and do things we don’t like to function in society, but we want more out of life than to just function in society. What drives people to want to function in society could be the thing they need to get the feeling that they are alive. Many people search for a very long time to find this. This reminded me of the start of the book where the author talked about self-help and finding ones self.

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Constantly Changing

In the second section of On Being Authentic, Guignon discusses the three major events that shifted humans into a modern worldview in the 16th century: the broadening of Christian sects, the advancement of science and the idea that society’s are not natural, but are instead human made. All of these events led to an increase of a sense of dualism, or “outer self “ and “inner-self,” which was also discussed in more detail in Peterson’s book. One thing that really stuck out to me that Guignon said regarding the changes of the 16th century that led to the evolution of moderns was; “ The primary task of humans is seen as gaining knowledge of the external world” (42). As moderns, we are constantly being filled with knowledge and our job is to decide what information we choose to shape us as ethical human beings and change our sense of self.

In chapter four, Guignon discusses philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau who’s contrubitions to self identity are numerous. Rousseau said most things that upset us are caused by “our own making” or due to things that happen in society. To relate to this idea, Guignon says, “Constant reflection and calculative reason distort our nature and tear us away from the simple understanding of right and wrong we have from birth” (56). In other words, due to social conditioning, humans create their own problems. I see this often in society today. For example, the use of ADD medication has more than doubled since the 1960’s. Society allows us to have problems and says that we have problems and why would we not agree with it?

And to conclude my mismatch of ideas, I will end with something Guignon said in chapter three of his book; “If the social realm is inherently inhuman, the way to humanize it is to be sincere in our dealings with others” (35). Society shapes us and we in turn shape it, but in our personal and private dealings with others we must be sincere in order to maintain a “humanness” quality in society.

Uniting the Self

In the 21st Century, our modern understanding of the Self is fragmented; this split in our identity, according to Charles Guignon, is the product of a series of historical events that destroyed the perspective of human beings as subservient to the authority of a Creator. The Protestant Reformation brought God out of the hands of the clergy and into the heart of each believer, using Biblical principles to affirm that every individual is responsible for their relationship with God and by extension, their eternal salvation through individual faith. In this atmosphere of rebellion against the cultural hierarchy of self understanding, the Scientific Revolution was born. Early scientists like Galileo began to view a non-theistic world, a "homogeneous aggregate of material objects in contingent casual interactions" (p. 30). In a universe of natural order and continuous construction, there is no need for a Creator God and "a divine plan no longer makes any sense" (p. 31). Enlightenment thinkers took scientific reasoning to perpetuate this understanding of society and humans as children of circumstance and chance evolutionary creation, giving rise to Romanticism's counter argument: the deification of the mind and human ingenuity as the height of creation and individual identity as an abstract notion.

In place of a collective ideology entered a new, modern conception of being human in the world: the "mind itself as the ultimate source and nature turns out to be its product" (p. 62). We are now, following this reasoning, the gods of our understanding and the chiefs of all knowledge. I do find, however, that the danger Guignon points out in Chapter of On Being Authenitic is very real: "a conception of authentic existence as not merely out of sync with society, but as necessarily anti-social, as something outrageous, even monstrous" (p. 76). Romantic thinkers such as Jean-Jacques Rousseau were so intent on proving how we should identify ourselves as humans that they placed greater emphasis on the self than is warranted. Today we live in a society where our identity is split between a public face and a private life; authenticity is a goal, not a reality, and has become a campaign for self discovery instead of self awareness.

In my view of the self, there is a God, and He says "I am who I am" (Exodus 3:14, NIV); given that He has created me in His image, I feel it is safe to say that I am who I am as well. I am my public and private life; my dreams and aspirations are my identity as much as my everyday actions. In having split identities, I feel that we as human beings loose our relational understanding. Whether or not society is a mental construct is irrelevant: it is here, and we are a part of it simply by being in community with other humans. Our role, as members of our community, is to embrace our entire self, public and private, and to present ourselves as whole people with understanding of our humanity in relation to others and in the innermost workings of our souls. As honors students and as students who serve in our community, the people we work with and work for deserve nothing less than our full and united selves.

Science and Detachment

In chapter 3 of Charles Guignon's "On Being Authentic", he discusses three pivotal historical events that brought focus upon the individual. One of these events was the advancement of modern science in Europe. Previously, nature and the cosmos were seen as creation of God, instilling them with an innate purpose and importance to humankind as fellow creations. However, as knowledge of the world around humans increased it was realized that the structures of nature act independently of humankind, "...with no mysterious or supernatural principles at work anywhere" (31). This idea greatly diminished the importance of emotional and spiritual interaction with nature, and emphasized the individual's ability to view the world objectively.
In order to view the world as a mechanized process, separate from the human experience, one must, "...suspend all the those beliefs, commitments, and concerns that traditionally were seen as definitive of the self" (32). The world must be viewed through scientific abstraction to rightly know your true self. People become "subjects" that experience life against a backdrop of objects and structures of nature that can be fully understood and manipulated. The human is the center of the universe. Instead of emphasizing our roles in nature, our new goal, "...is seen as attaining power and mastery over nature" (33). The ability to gain and utilize knowledge of our surroundings separates us from nature and makes the individual all-important, not his or her place in the world.

In chapter 4, Guignon discusses the criticism of this separation from nature. He says, "There is the feeling that, with the coming of the disenchanted outlook of modernity, a primal unity and wholeness in life has been lost" (50). How can it be the natural state of humans to exist as separate entities from their own home? What has been seen as the underlying importance of life is stripped away by the cold, objective views of science. The true self is not wholly made up of the individual.

Monday, October 18, 2010

The Artistry of Life

What is it to really be "authentic" when society tells us to be one thing as we feel and experience something entirely different? Is authenticity defined by what society deems to be the norm, or by what we as unique individuals live out on a daily basis? To be authentic, Guignon suggests, is to "be true to ourselves in order thereby to be true to others; there is no suggestion that being true to oneself is valuable in its own right" (Guignon 27). So does that mean that the ultimate, the meaning, the authenticity of human existence is to provide this real-ness to others in spite of ourselves?

In a word so filled with mixed messages, and an ever-increasingly manipulative and suggestive media, it is a not so far-fetched reality that authenticity and avant-garde-ness have been slurred and lost in the flashy window displays, commercials, and advertisements polluting our world today. Our modern interpretation of authenticity as a "realization [of] a split between the Real Me - the true inner self - and the persona (from the Greek word for "mask") that one puts on for the external world" (35) is somewhat perturbing to me. We externalize ourselves to the degree that we want to publicize. We put forward a face that we think society will like, and thereby acknowledge and admit that we are clearly divided creatures. What we really are or intrinsically know to be true about ourselves is kept hidden, seemingly as a guilty token of what we are afraid to share with society.

So why does this divide have to exist? We talked about it in Peterson's "Everyday Ethics and Social Change;" the bridging of internal and external self, the private and public spheres. It is clear that we have collectively decided to separate the two to such a large degree that our authenticity is thrown into question. Guignon states "if you are true to yourself, you cannot then be false to any man" (35). But then, in being divided individuals, are we not lying to ourselves in only bringing half of ourselves to our lives each day? What we put forward in public life is only one limited and limiting facet of who we completely are as modern humans. I don't think we can truly be true to ourselves, and thereby true to others, and thereby authentic, until the divide between internal and external is reconciled. Until we as individuals begin to place our own self-fulfillment above the approval of society, "the chatter of the public world" (37), we cannot hope to attain genuine authenticity.

Guignon's discussion of what it means to be an artist really spoke to me, and actually embodies the ideal of authenticity and being a true and self-loving individual. "To be an artist, one must become authentic," he states. "The artist learns to let the unconscious creative process work itself our in its own way within him, without imposing the assumptions derived from social expectations and reinforced by the intellect" (74). As an artist, this resonated strongly within me, particularly in relation to what we are taught as dancers. We must overcome what society narrowly defines as beautiful, and bring to the stage what we have experienced and believe as individuals, for that is where the true beauty and discovery lies. We are not robots, nor are we instruments of society's doctrines; "that alone is living the artist's life: in understanding and creating" (75).


Phillipa Armes

Saturday, October 16, 2010

Society and the Individual

For the past few readings we have been discussing the role society plays in our search to be the human. In Everyday Ethics we discussed the separation of the private and public spheres, and in Pedagogy of Freedom the differences between teaching to and teaching with and its role in the greater scheme of society. Now in this second section of Charles Guignon's book On Being Authentic we are confronted with the evolution of the philosophy of individualism in relation to “the formation of the modern worldview”(28). He states that three shifts occurred in the mentality of authenticity the first being the Protestant Reformation, the second being the Scientific Revolution and the third was the concept that society is "man-made" and "anti-natural"(33). All three of these periods in time mark a different understanding of how one should relate the self to society. Guignon attempts to give such understanding in his text, and I will try to relate it to life today.

With the first thinking came the the assumption that “we should never let the affairs of this world concern us too much, for the only issue that really matters for us is our immortal soul and its eternal life”(30). This thinking reenforces the slight detachment from society or rather thinking of “society” as a greater religious family but that the goal of life is to find “personal salvation or the religious individualism”(29). In today's society there is still a large majority of people that believe that the ultimate path to authenticity is the spiritual one that is connected with God. This path however is confronted with the obstacles of living in a modern and technology filled life of instant gratification.

This brings us to the second shift that Guignon discusses which is the Scientific Revolution. This brought on a philosophy that the world should really be defined in the terms of a universe which is a “homogeneous aggregate of material objects in contingent causal interactions”(30). The anthropocentric thinking thus followed as well as the outlook that “there are no boundaries to human mastery over nature”(33). Scientific progress is not achievable without the help of a demanding society, and in addition the split between man and nature decreased the possibility of seclusion of the individual since man was brought together from the absence of nature.

The third shift is an interesting one. It is an extension of the scientific revolution thinking but goes farther to say that not only is society man made but it is anti-natural. This shift actually had the opposite effect of its predecessor; it pushed the people looking for the authentic inner soul away from the unnatural synthetic society. As Guignon puts it “if the social realm is inherently inhuman, the way to humanize it is to be sincere in our dealings with others: we need to say what we mean and mean what we say”(35). Guignon also uses the poetic example of Faustus to explain that though ultimate knowledge and power are tempting pleasures, “what benefits the man to gain the world and lose his soul?”(41). You could say that in this moment in time, many of us are skeptical of the corruptness of society and that we are looking inward to find the better way of life.

In chapter four, Guignon moves on to explore the philosophy of individualism found in the Romantic era. He claims that there are a few factors that were present then that are still present in our contemporary world: the sense that we must recover a sense of wholeness, the conviction that truth is found through listening to ones feelings, and that the self is the the most “real” of them all. It is hard to say how these ideas have affected me or how they have shaped the world I live in because in truth I have not experience the world or myself enough to the point where a retreat inward was necessary. However I can see that some of the ideas that Guignon is talking about have a very real presence in this modern society. Like he stated in the earlier section, the distancing from the natural and “primordial” constitutes in the missing of an essential par to of the human self that is connected with nature, which is the point of recovering the wholeness of being. He states that “we need to listen not to society, but to the voice of nature”(57). In the Romantic mindset, society was keeping us from being whole and nature was the ultimate cure. The environmental movement can be described as a move away from the harmful effects of society to the healthier preservation of our natural world.

Another problem with society, which is a point that Peterson touches on in Everyday Ethics, is that personal feeling are not cultivated nor expressed in the public sphere of society. The creativity that spurs form the feeling that we all posses, is a quality that makes us human and makes up our individual self. Restricting these feelings in the presence of the public to make way for pure research and facts, has brought our society to a cold and detached place. “Your creative activity of self-making is the ultimate source of you own being”(70); return to feelings is a return to the self.

The last concept that Guignon unpacks is the Romantic vision that the self is the “real”. This is a very abstract concept, which I personally have not fully grasped yet, but essentially suggesting that “the authentic self is the individual who can stand alone, shedding all status relations and social entanglements, in order to immerse him- or herself in 'sheer life'”(72). This to me has a very Buddhist ring to it and thus is probably not a philosophy that is adapted by the majority of people. However, realizing that the real is within oneself and should not be sought elsewhere is the core of the argument. These few chapters in the book have been dense with insight and information and the next few indicate further exploration of the role society plays, and has played, in the realm of authenticity.

Service, Self, and Community Through "Radical Enlightenment"

Jean Rostand stated, "science has made us gods even before we are worthy of being men" (Wikiquote.org). With the capacity to understand the world around us, it becomes harder to passively accept a role in the universe as something which continues naturally to form out of chaos. We do not want to be ants and deer, in organized groups only from evolution. Humans are creators, inventors, changers, and the closest thing to gods on this planet.  This outlook “begins to see society as something anti-natural, as a fortuitous product of human agreements” (33). Society is no longer an aspect of our species, a core of humanity, but rather a “gentleman’s agreement” made logically to help us advance. Society is a tool manipulated by choice rather than an inherent aspect of being man. If society is only a tool, there is no deeper connection or role to play in its advancement beyond the point where it provides us benefit. Service learning would be valuable only in addressing problems where solutions potentially could raise the standard of leaving of the group and inherently oneself as a member of that society.
A break between the natural world and the created world, meaning human society and infrastructure, mirrors a break in our self view between our natural selves and our created selves. When this split occurs, “values are found not ‘out there’ in the world of living beings, but rather ‘in here,’ in the minds of humans” (50).  If the world is a completely rational and logical set up which can be remade “according to a rational plan,” then answers come only in the form of greater understanding of cause and effect of events in the world (33).  Existence and the universe defined as the interaction of matter does not lend itself to replace the role of religion as it fades out. Matter and science emphasizes that we are not unique or chosen. Spiritual transcendence is not possible since disconnecting and looking beyond factual evidence is a marker of denial and delusion. There is nothing more than the interactions of matter. Even our empathy can be looked at as an evolutionary development to try to strengthen our responses and care to others of a group, to keep us all together and thus better protect our species if not immediately benefitting the individual. With this perspective, we must not become philosophers, ethicists, and humanists; we must become behaviorists and evolutionary biologists.
 If “the universe is cold, heartless, mute,” then there is no humanity in it, only reality (42). To bring humanity back into our lives, there must be some “core” to get back to and bring to the front. While “the scientific worldview brings with it a powerful sense of human progress and emancipation,” the sense of connectedness and purpose is removed often leaving individual grasping for reasons “when choice is seen as having no basis other than momentary preference or feeling” (49,44).  So, if there is no deep meaning in the world, “the goal of life is to increase pleasure and avoid pain” (50).
This philosophy provides few answers on close inspection since it can be interpreted on multiple levels. One of the major problems with viewing increasing pleasure as a selfish and destructive force is that increasing pleasure long term for the individual almost always involves increasing pleasure for the community as well. To increase the pleasure of discovery, advancement, and thought, other members of the community must be educated, employed, and consulted. Pain as well can be endured reaching far beyond the “momentary preference.” One clear example is that choice of take care of one’s health through daily care, such as good hygiene and exercise, as well as more intense medical treatments such as surgery or physical therapy. Many of the arguments against the scientific line miss the idea that our pleasures and pains are placed within complex contexts over long life spans and treasured social networks. If we do not want to be ants and deer, the ability to reason and use logic to advance ourselves and our communities long term is the important aspect, not the need to control, dominate, and separate our works from those of nature and, in modern movements, those of society.
A reactionist may seek out an authentic life that “is organic, mysterious, dark, and bound up with some greater reality” (75). A gut reaction to finding that complete logic is too hard, too abstract, and too blunt to be the truth. If one cannot find the answers in the physical world, turning in provides a potential respite from having to live under the modern perspectives. This approach leads people to blindly search for answers outside of every fact seen. If there answers “are beyond on the reach of one’s own intelligence,” we can stop fretting about having to break apart and accept facts in the world the way “radical Enlightenment” requires (75).  

Circe McDonald

Prompt for Oct. 19, On Being Authentic 26-77

Guignon continues in his critique of the modern ideal of authenticity in "The Modern Worldview" with an overview of 3 historical events/shifts that led to the formation of the this distinct worldview and self-understanding (27). The events that he describes as having been crucial to the formation of this worldview are: 1) The Protestant Reformation, 2) the rise of modern science that we know as the Scientific Revolution that then led into the Enlightenment that provided the base for 3) the idea of social contract, that society is "man-made" and "anti-natural"(33)and put more emphasis on the concept of the individual. Guignon captures this notion well by citing Hannah Arendt's thinking that this new idea, "led people to abandon the old belief that one if fully human only in interactions of public life and to adopt the modern belief that one is truly oneself only when ensconced in private life" (34).
We will discuss these events more in class so focus here on the ways in which these events and new relationship to religion/God, to society, to ourselves reinforced the rise of myth of the individual that, in a sense has been "fundamentalized"--believing that a metaphor or abstract concept is literal. As I said in class, the concept of each individual as deserving of autonomy, of having rights and responsibilities and the power to choose--is a beautiful concept (I believe). Yet, this individual is always embedded in a larger context.
Guignon is not defending or promoting any ideas about authenticity and will ultimately make his own case only in the last chapters. His goal is to give us a fuller understanding of the forces that have shaped our collective unconscious and given us such a binary understanding of our lives as split between the personal and the public etc. Peterson in Everyday Ethics also touched on this.
In Chapter 4, Guignon describes the ways in which the Romantic rejection of the Enlightenment's embrace of scientific truth has an ongoing impact on this schism/collective identity crisis that has fed the self-help and many New Age movements to help people "find" that inner, natural core self that societal pressures forces into hiding.
Although, you as individuals may not feel this schism in your own life--lucky you!--it is evident that as a society we are very affected by this dualistic self-understanding and the different messages we receive at every phase of our lives. Use the text to reflect on how you see some of these concepts manifest, not only in your own life, but in the issues that we face today.

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

The Importance of Authenticity

This may not directly address the prompt for this reading, but as it is, I find some serious fault in this whole idea of authenticity. Mainly, does authenticity exist? And, if it does, what importance can it really hold?
Humans are innately nothing. We are born relatively empty. People are born with natural, basic human desires and the ability to express these needs for simple survival. It is other people, society as a whole, the media, and every other aspect of the world that can be experienced that fills a person with the superfluous aspects of humans we call personality and character. So, what is authenticity. If I were to dispense of every characteristic of my being that is a result of outside influence, I would be nothing, a caveman. What difference does it make if I receive my influence from Dr. Phil or God? There is no defining factor that can separate sources into authentic and inauthentic. Anyone who says otherwise is only speaking from a subjective standpoint.
It is possible that Guignon will address this issue later in his book, but for now I find his argument biased. I was not aware that, "The idea that becoming authentic is our highest goal in life might seem so self-evident as to be not worth discussing" (Guignon 6). You are who you are. If you buy into Oprah or Dr.Phil it does not make you less authentic than someone who seeks to better themselves from the inside. Everyone is inevitably made up of a million different influences that cannot be traced or labeled. It is absurd to me to imagine an original, authentic being, separate from society.
Guignon suggests two ways of finding the authentic self. Both encounter the same problems. If someone looks to utilize the "...resources and potentialities..." (7) that are already within them, then they are only looking towards things that have been instilled in them by past outside influences. If someone else seeks to engage themselves in society to find authenticity then they do not fit a proper definition of authentic. They are defined by the whole.
As it stands, I see no merit in authenticity, because I don't believe in it. Maybe my mind will change by the end of this book.

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

A Whole Self: Outside and Inside

Why are we here? Is there a meaning to this life? Who am I and what is my relationship to the outside world? These meaningful questions have perplexed thinkers and philosophers since the beginning of time. In Charles Guignon’s book On being Authentic, he places great focus on the question of self. He discusses two ideals to work with in the quest to be authentic. The first ideal is that of deep self-discovery coming from within, or “Identity resides within the house of intellect” (Porter 7). It is a sort of Buddhist ideal requiring one to see past their everyday thoughts and worries to get to their core of being, through intense reflection. The second ideal is finding authenticity and true self by giving “your life over to something greater than yourself” (Guignon 7). Investment of self in the community, with peers and other people in the outside world will give you a greater sense of self, because it teaches you what your inner values are.

Guignon argues “The Constant preoccupation with self cuts you off from others, breeding competition, aggressiveness, envy, alienation, and ultimately despair” (Guignon 7). Though self reflection is an important part of identity, if you are constantly consumed with “thy self” you become unethical. In Flesh in The Age of Reason, Porter briefly discusses the evolution of psychology and the idea it produced that “nothing should be concealed or rationalized away” (Porter 12). By alienating ourselves, we are not admitting to things that affect us and our “true self suffers.”

“The ideal of authenticity is a project of becoming the person you are” (Guignon 3). You forever have been and always will be yourself, but you are constantly growing and evolving due to your experiences with the outside world. It is human connected-ness that shapes our authenticity as individuals.

Just Be Yourself

"Just be yourself"; these are the words that most of us hear when we ask for advice about a stressful or intimidating situation. This assertion that if one shows the true colors of the "inner self" (Porter, 1) everything in life will be better is an age old belief that is explored in Charles Guignon's book On Being Authentic and Roy Porter's introduction excerpt from his book Flesh in the Age of Reason. Though Guignon gives his critique of some of popular culture's definition on what it means to be authentic and Porter gives a historical narrative of the various stages the philosophy of authenticity has gone through, in both readings two main concepts are being addressed to answer the question "What is the most meaningful and worthwhile life possible for humans"(Guignon, 6-7). The first concept being "enownment" and the other being "self-emptying and self-abnegation" (Guignon, 7). These two ideas on authenticity give insight on the way people and cultures see themselves as authentic beings.

The ideal of enownment focuses on the achievement of self-ownership and works with the assumption that "each individual already contains resources and potentialities"(Guignon, 7) to be the best that one can be. In relation to this ideal Guignon tells us to take it with a grain of salt; he is skeptical about the teachings of modern self help gurus like Dr. Phil and Oprah because though they teach people how to bring out qualities that have always been in them but the motivation has no substance behind it. Porter similarly states that the enownment theory didn’t come to be until later in history with Freud's belief that "there was indeed an inner core truth of the self"(Porter, 14) and also with John Locke's assertion that the mind, self, "begins as white paper, or wax, to be molded and fashioned as one pleases"(Porter 8). The enownment idea in summary relies on individual discovery and is essentially a "superficial and self-serving"(Porter, 15) concept.

On the other hand, the self-emptying idea gives one's quest for authenticity "over to something greater than yourself"(Guignon, 7). It is a more all encompassing theory that puts humans as "parts of a wider cosmic totality"(Guignon, 13) and stresses the right way to be humans, or be authentic, is to direct our orientation to that which is bigger than us like God or a larger life force like Dharma. Porter claimed that during the Romantic era one of the beliefs was that "communing with nature was the way to restore harmony with one's true inner self"(Porter, 10) and that in order to reach autonomy one must "fuse personal development with spiritual destiny"(Porter, 10).

Through history there have been many phases of thinkers and philosophers that have come and put forth their interpretations on what it means to be not only human but a fulfilled human. The inner self is a mysterious and obscure place that human kind has tried to shed light on for years and though countless methods have been discussed, there may never be a right answer to the question "Who are we?".

-Ilaria Guerra

Authenticity is Singular and Plural

Through service, education, and the experience of life itself I know that there is no greater way to connect with "the deepest and most eternal part of thy soul" than living in connection to others (p. xi). Though it may seem contradictory to the notion that who we are on the inside shapes our outward appearances and actions, I believe that our environments and culture shape our internal self and ultimately share a dual relationship in determining our authentic self; following this reasoning, authenticity of self and personal growth are dependent on a community which invests in the growth of its members.
Having lived in Marin County for over half a decade and watched classmates and friends fall victim to bullying, depression, drugs, suicide, overdoses, and life-threatening illnesses, I can say that my fight to give children in America a sense of belonging and community through relationship is extremely close to my heart. When I look back on my junior year in high school, the message that I wish I could tell those teenagers who have fallen victim to life's ills and those who did not make it to this day is that they were a part of our collective identity, and they were loved. When I represent Big Brothers Big Sisters at a pageant or an event, I have a vested interest in seeing that children of circumstance have at least one positive, strong relationship in their lives, one that will leave an impression on their personal sense of self and give them a foundation on which to have a positive self image. It is amazing to see what an empowering mentoring relationship can do for a child's self esteem and the effect it can have on their future.
I say this because unlike Charles Guignon and Roy Porter, I do not believe that there are only two ideal focuses for a meaningful life. We, as communal creatures, have goals of "achieving self possession" and "a conception of being part of a wider flow of life" (p. 7). Freud and Plato being at extreme ends of the spectrum, we live in St. Augustine's world whether we like it or not. We all seek a state of moving "inward and upward", understanding ourselves so our lives and positionally in relation to others are fulfilling and meaningful (p. 17). I do not view sacred or cyclical time as a notion of the past, left in Biblical history or precolonial Africa, but as a reflection of the eternal need of humankind for authenticity in their singular and pluralistic identities, and because I honor both I am able to derive meaning from every moment as a deepening of my personal roundedness and authenticity, within this world and within my soul.

Wherefore art thou, self?

Both writers bring up major trends in the definitions of our true selves in relation to the outside world.  Starting from “all thought-processes being collective” then transitioning to the defiance of the gods seen in ancient Greek philosophies and myths to eventually landing at modern movements seeking answers “not with an understanding of [an individual’s] relation to God, but with his relation to himself,” the trend seen is to move further and further inward as our understanding of the outside world increases (Porter 4, Guignon 2). The trend hints that as the understanding of our surrounds increase, all outside ourselves appear less spiritual, mystical, and important. Further, with our ever greater ability to manipulate our surroundings, people are placed as the central force in the universe.  Once approaching the outside world with a position of power and an increasingly engrained and rigid dedication to logic, one must be moved into the position of an observer and manipulator. Upon finding no inherent god, purpose, or connection with surroundings though, looking inward remains the only respite and hope to find deeper meaning. Given the extreme knowledge base, modern individuals are comfortable with the “heroic vision of man making himself.”
Yet, self-creation and limitless freedom bring up new challenges. Without a template off of which to grow, how can one measure success? If success is only an inner state, can one not think his or herself into a feeling of accomplishment without taking any physical action in the world? To be able to self create, separation from all non-self influences would have to be maintained for fear of simply incorporating engrained aspects of society rather than the “true self”. If we do possess “some real and essential ‘inner self,’” it either must be stagnant or developing (Porter 3). If the self is stagnant, than “enownment” would ultimately lead to some conclusion or result about yourself and an answer to finding individual happiness. If the self is developing however, there is no inherent kernel of truth which to authentic or dedicated too. There is no nub of the person buried but rather a complex perspectives, personalities, and ideas which each can manifest different aspects of ourselves without really resulting in inauthentic existence.
A developing self holds the potential “of becoming something you were not yet-becoming a person who is more than or better than what he or she had been before” (Guignon 3). While religion and professions can and have created the meaning of becoming better than or more than the self, there is no reason in a more secular and independent modern perspective this idea could not be created from the self. An interesting difference between this idea and finding answers in the true self is that from this perspective improvement and achievement does not relate to self-discovery. The path of being better relates to being better in the interaction with the world rather than being more honest or ever being happier. “The highest goal of living, on this view, is to become a new person by becoming responsive to the call of something greater than yourself” (Guignon 8).
Our self-hood leads back to how we define our self-hood. If self-hood is the most poignant and constant driving emotions unique to our personalities, only through the acknowledgment and satisfaction of these drives can happiness and contentment be found. If self-hood is our chosen role in society, perfecting and embodying that role to the fullest and best extent would be the ultimate authenticity. If self-hood is defined by the nature of our interactions, by controlling the world around us can we truly control ourselves and be authentic. There is no definitive answer to what self-hood is since it is an intangible idea under the constraints of language; I wonder if self-hood can only be expressed or defined through action. Authenticity seems to create disconnect between self-hood and physical actions which creates another path away from facing the realities of the world. Self-hood to me is my actions, thoughts, and expressions. There can be no “deeper” me which is hidden from the world and from myself. Seeking it out may only create a false perception of a hidden self. 

Circe McDonald

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Who is What? What is We? Who am I?

Guignon suggests two very different and very distinct ways of defining our purposes in life, posing the "age-old question": "What is the most meaningful and worthwhile life possible for humans?" (Guignon 6-7). The first method, as identified by the author, is "owning oneself, of achieving self-possession" (6). In this psyche, we as humans must have pre-determined and acknowledged that all we need to fully advance in and make the most out of our lives already resides within ourselves; all we need to do is tap into those "resources" (6).

The second idea that Guignon poses is that of "self-loss or releasement" (6). The antithesis of the first approach, the author states that this methodology calls for the total ignorance of the self, and the complete devotion to the greater good. In theory, this approach should bring around a feeling and ideal of "'belongingness' or 'togetherness,' a conception of being part of a wider flow of life rather than being in contention with everyone else in a struggle for self-enhancement" (6).

His two very discernible approaches aside, Guignon brings up a good point in reproducing the human dilemma: "What exactly is this 'inner self' we are supposed to be true to? What does it include and what does it exclude? What if it turns our that this true self includes some fairly nasty - or, even worse, banal - characteristics, traits we would prefer not to think of as really us?" (9). What exactly is it to be human? What is the meaning of life? To what higher purpose do we aspire that validates our existence? What is it to actually know ourselves? According to Guignon, it is "to know above all what your place is in the scheme of things" (13).

Porter's evaluation of our seemingly endless human craving for purpose closely mirrors Guignon's, attributing Guignon's "self-loss" to premodern ideals and his "self-possession" to postmodern ones. Porter reports that it was not until the golden age of Greece that "the first stirrings of true individual consciousness" (Porter 4) came about, a result of thinkers questioning the divine order that had until then ruled all aspects of life. Before these revolutionary thoughts came into fruition, the truths that "self-denial was the supreme good" and "the whole was greater than the part" (5) reigned true, both characteristic of premodern thought.

It is now commonly accepted that Renaissance Italy marked the dawn of man's free-thinking break from "conformity and the Church, taking fearless leaps forward into self-discovery and self-fulfillment" (5). This new way of thinking largely comprised of a leaning towards introspection and the scrutiny of one's own psyche, viewing "salvation [as] a personal pilgrimage" (6) rather than one governed and spelled out by church and state.

These great Renaissance thinkers began to create within the realm of postmodern thinking, different "sects" and varying degrees of individualistic thinking in everyday life, stretching from a "compuls[ive] [] self exposure" (8) to "sensibility" (9) to "self-love" (10) to "sexuality" (12). What all these branches share in common however, is their beginning in the roots of discord towards an all-ruling and powerful ideal of conformity. And though we as a race, and as unique individuals, still struggle with the "'I am that I am'" (16) complex, we have collectively determined that only through self initiated and fueled introspection can we each discover our meaning and purpose.


Phillipa Armes

Saturday, October 9, 2010

Prompt for: Oct 12 reading: "Know Yourself" and On Being Authentic, vii-25

Both of these readings call into question the notion of "self-hood" and the dual messages that exist about the nature of our "authentic" being and the path to "achieving" that idealized state. Both authors challenge some of the assumptions that we, as moderns, have about what it means to be a unique, autonomous individual.

Porter gives a fascinating historical overview of some of the shifts in our conceptions of self, and the Western presupposition of "some real and essential 'inner self'" ("Know Yourself", 1). He, as does Guignon, notes that "there is no shortage of publicity for a galaxy of styles of self-fulfillment. . . but such nostrum-mongering is set against a backdrop of the erosion of established identities, associated with the disintegration of traditional family patterns, employment, gender roles, education and other social institutions"(16).

Guignon will build the case more slowly throughout the book, while Porter in these few pages gives the historical overview and asks questions to which Guignon will speak in the last chapters of his book.

So, we will be talking more about the broader issues in following weeks, for now, use both texts to unpack what Guignon calls the two ideals, two quite divergent concepts about how we "might answer the age-old question, What is the most meaningful and worthwhile life possible for humans"(On Being Authentic, 6-7). He describes the two ideals--one of "enownment" and the other of "self-emptying and self-abnegation" (7).

Both he and Porter describe some of the historical and intellectual developments that have been the catalysts for these views. What are some of the influences that they note and how do they describe the differences between these different ways of thinking about our self-hood?

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Teaching is The most Important thing We all Do

The debate of whether it is nature or nurture that shapes us as humans has been constantly contemplated amongst psychologists and philosophers for a long time. For the most part, I think who we are as humans (ethical humans at that) is primarily based on what we are taught, which makes education extremely important. Teachers can choose to teach whatever they want, and if they so choose they can teach others their own set of ethics. This teaching of ethics may be a way to shape others ethical codes, and will therefore shape and change social views and the way we live as ethical or non ethical human beings. In Pedagogy of Freedom, Friere says, “Education as a specifically human action has a ‘directive’ vocation, that is, it addresses itself to dreams, ideals, utopias, objectives” (100). Through education we learn what our dreams, ideals etc. are and are therefore becoming “human” and hopefully “human” and “ethical.”

Later on in his book, Friere says; “It is an error to separate practice and theory, thought and action, language and ideology. It is as erroneous as separating the teaching of contents from the participation in the student’s own process of becoming a subject in the learning of such contents” (112). This is an interesting idea because it highlights the fact that a math teacher is not teaching just math or a dance teacher is not just teaching dance. Teaching of subjects cannot be separated from teaching of life ideals. I relate this idea very much to dance, because though my teachers were teaching me the difficult technique of ballet, they were also, although maybe not consciously teaching me a set of ethics that I now live by, including but not limited to hard work, dedication and sacrifice. Teaching is a human act, because we always, sometimes perhaps involuntarily place our views and things we have learned on those surrounding us, which can definitely be true in my service learning. Just by listening to others stories and hearing what they have to say, my thoughts and life views change.

Neutrality of Teaching and Education to immobilize the classes

Should education be neutral? Should society be trying to keep education objective? Freire says that education shouldn't be neutral. "I could never treat education as something cold, mental, merely technical, and without soul, where feelings, sensibility, desires, and dreams had no place, as if repressed by some kind of reactionary dictatorship(p.129)" Freire wants education to encourage curiosity and critical thinking. For him neutrality would be wrong for education. I think our society wants education to be the transfer of knowledge where neutrality would be the ideal learning environment. I would prefer Freire's type of education that encourages thinking rather than knowledge. It is easier to have a student memorize knowledge than to have them think about why or how that knowledge came about, or go a step further and challenge the student to create their own knowledge. Freire's teaching creates students that will seek to change the world rather than accept it how it is.
Our Society may want education to be neutral to keep the dominant group in charge. Freire said, "From the perspective of the dominant classes, there is no doubt of course that educational practice ought to cover up the truth and immoblize the classes(p.91)." The dominant classes control the education of the marginalized classes and that is how they stay in power. Our society needs a ideology change to focus on the poor. Education should be something that encourages people to push themselves for the better. Our education system is failing if we are producing students that are content with the world how it is.

Being Human

In part four of Paulo Freire's Pedagogy of Freedom, he emphasizes the importance of teachers to act as compassionate, interactive, searching human beings instead of methodological robots. Extending Feire's point to a larger social context, I can see the need for more humane thinking and action in many different workplaces and in everyday life. To help put an end to this generation's global plights and encourage a new generation to embrace their human nature, it must be made a priority to increase human dialogue and interaction now.
Freire says, "The open-minded teacher can not afford to ignore anything that concerns the human person" (Freire 127). To disregard the fact that both the student and the teacher are indeed human, containing emotions, desires, tendencies, disabilities and other human features is a mistake. Education can be made as strictly formulated, structured, and impersonal as possible, but this can not stop either the teacher or the student from bringing their humanity into the classroom. It is not something that can simply be turned off. It would be best for both parties if human nature became an integral part of the learning process, using the extra baggage we carry as humans, as opposed to robots, in the most effective way possible. Freire states, "Education as a specifically human action has a "directive" vocation, that is, it addresses itself to dreams, ideals, utopias, objectives..." (100). Neutrality is an impossibility in education. The politics of a lesson plan do not have to be voiced, but they will be personally felt by every student. It is better, then, to create a dialogue that involves the students and their beliefs and experiences into the curriculum. This will help students to engage in critical thinking and inspire a desire or curiosity for knowledge that doesn't have to be forced.
In a larger context than the classroom, Freire's ideas can be used effectively to inspire everyone to allow their humanity to exist socially in action and dialogue instead of only personally. Freire points out, "It is in the context of the work situation that the worker needs to engage in the process of becoming a citizen, something that does not happen as a consequence of 'technical efficiency'" (94). Being a citizen includes taking stake in society actively seeking the greater good for fellow humans. This goal in incompatible with striving for maximum efficiency in any particular occupation. People need to work to become engaged members of society instead of focusing on technical success. This shift in public emphasis would greatly reduce many problems that the world is facing today, as many of these problems came about because of moral neglect in pursuit of success and efficiency. In this way, Freire's ideals can easily be applied to all occupations, not just that of the student.
To become a human again, a citizen, is essential to making a better, more ethical, world to live in. The goals of the education system as well as most other companies needs to shift from efficiency to concern for the lives and well being of others. This is a monumental change that Freire recognizes is idealistic, but the foundation of his beliefs could lead the next generation to become a part of the solution and not a continuation of the problems we face today.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Ideas Noticeably Absent

If “I cannot teach without exposing who I am,” I cannot learn without exposing long held beliefs and motivations to scrutiny, criticism, and revision if not complete rejection (87). In this way, any new experience is both frightening and filled with great opportunity. Most of our beliefs are veiled in what is socially acceptable. Last week during our class, I noticed how we approached presenting our ideas to each other in our race discussion. All of us, scared to be considered racist or ignorant for our interpretations of the situation, declared some sort of relation to a minority group, either through a family’s immigration or ethnicity, before making a statement.  In any circumstance, it would have been a strain in our society to state a belief about race as a white individual, even the impact of race on a white person, without claiming status outside the dominant paradigm. This only serves to continue the idea that the “true” white members of our society are still bias and inherently out of touch with race in America. By hiding behind these acceptable approaches, this misconception seemed to me to be adopted unintentionally from the beginning. In the exposing ourselves, we are easily open for attack. Yet, even noticing these uses of language and patterns brought me a deeper understanding of one aspect of race and how standards in the approaches we take towards race have been deeply engrained.  In placing statements out in the world, they are more easily revised and scrutinized compared to those notions entertained in ones inner thoughts.
“Practice and theory, authority and freedom, ignorance and knowledge…none of these terms can be mechanically separated one from another” (88). If the action and the meaning behind it cannot be separated, the only way to gain and enhance this meaning is to go through the action. The opposite would hold true as well, an action without meaning would be transitory and ineffective without true impact. By acknowledging and reinforcing this bond between experience and conviction, service learning builds a foundation which can be spread and hopefully built upon to create ethical questioning and better citizens. Yet, it is difficult to take time to experience every issue. I would end up with a checklist running around the community. Poverty, hunger, AIDS, health care, education inequality, etc. would add up rapidly. Looking through the practice ballot for the upcoming election, I had to assess support for community issues I have never experienced and am not directly impacted by. While experience is an important strengthener, it is not practical to try to apply this idea to changing minds about every blight in society. The most I hope to take from service learning is that issues are very complex. While I seek to be informed and proactive, I am not a devoted revolutionary or reformer. Yet, I believe my small steps create an attainable change.
Freire's rage against “fatalism, with its flighty postmodern pragmatism” is misplaced (26). Pragmatism is an important part of any approach to change. The difficulty is separating perceived boundaries and restraints, the perceived unchangeables, the perceived inevitability, from the actual, inherent problems. While this route is much more difficult, it is also much more sustainable. To say freedom and equality are not inherently impossible is true. However, even Freire makes concessions about the role of authority, which by definition places a thought, group, or person above others, is necessary to maintain freedom. So, the pragmatism of agreeing to boundaries and rules, creating an authority, is pessimistic in its perception of humanity as in need of guidance and control to overcome evil which will almost inevitably occur between people. Yet, it finds hope in that we can make our freedoms, understandings, and goals stronger, communal, and more obtainable through changing our system of authority, and most importantly, questioning the system at all opportunities.

Circe McDonald

Sunday, October 3, 2010

The Oblivion of Opinion

Friere puts teaching on a pedestal above most things we as a generalized society place within the realm of priority. He holds the positive teacher-student (and reciprocal and omnipresent student-teacher) relationship so highly that he believes it is able to produce such drastic and profound outcomes as instilling within students "a sense of [their] own self-confidence" (85), which seems a rather BIG proposition to me, as a student and artist who has long struggled with my own confidence. Friere suggests that if students are able to see within their teacher a firm and unabashed self confident, opinionated openness, then the students too will feel encouraged to find the same traits within themselves. "Monkey see, monkey do," but with REAL, experienced, and lasting results.

I saw this idea as the seed which Friere then went on raise into his discussion on human "becoming." He states, "the perception the student has of my teaching is not exclusively the result of how I act but also of how the student understands my action." Through observing and actively learning, we come to recognize the same truths within ourselves, until this deep recognition of internalized self perception "becomes a way of life" (90). Learning, in essence, exists "because we are constantly in the process of becoming and, therefore, are capable of observing, comparing, evaluating, choosing, deciding, intervening, breaking with, and making options, we are ethical beings..." (92). To become, therefore, is to be in a constant state of learning, and to learn is to be in a constant movement of becoming. The two are one and the same.

I thoroughly enjoyed Friere's argument of the necessity of teaching children independence and self-confidence in their thoughts and decisions at a young age. Too often we see young adults who are entirely dependent upon their parents and grandparents and other adults in their lives to supply for them the "key" to life. With every decision faced and obstacle met, the adolescent turns to the elders to do the work, make the choices, and pick up the pieces... And we allow this to happen - even applaud it! Friere's view on education is one that I similarly hold: "... emphasize the children's freedom to decide, even if they run the risk of making a mistake, than to simply follow the decision of the parents. It's in making decisions that we learn to decide. I can never learn to be who I am if I never decide anything because I always have the good sense and the wisdom of my mother and father to fall back on" (97).

We learn through experience and exposure. We need teachers and mentors who bring their own lives to the classroom, and who foster environments in which the students can too. We need lasting changes to how we approach education - more doing and less telling. The fostering of creativity must be esteemed, and the masterpieces and failures of each individual and the collective whole must be equally celebrated. "The child has, at the very least, the right to prove the craziness of his or her idea" (97).


Phillipa Armes

When Self Confidence Holds Hands With Respect

The first week's reading of The Pedagogy of Freedom left me unsure as to the ethic of the educator in Paulo Freire's teacher-student relationship. In the chapter "Teaching is a Human Act", Freire outlines the teacher's ethical foundation and gives powerful arguments for a respectful self confidence and "its ability to discuss its own positions, and its openness to reviewing both itself and its previously held positions" (p. 85). If a teacher is confident in their beliefs yet shows kindness and empathy towards their students, their relationship will be based on mutual respect and allow for an educational environment in which knowledge "becomes a kind of passion" (p. 123).

I have been in many situations where being self confident is a bridge between strength in my moral understandings and understanding of the morality of others. As a mentor in the Big Brothers Big Sisters organization as well as a born again believer who is increasingly becoming more confident in my faith, I feel that I can talk to other young adults and community members from the perspective of an unfinished human being. I am constantly growing and evolving, and my experiences and relationships have given me a strong sense of self and an excitement for the future. My faith has given me a renewed vigor for life and re-empowered my passion for mentorship.

With the understanding that I am unfinished yet enthusiastically watching the person I see myself becoming, I am able to be secure in who I am at this present moment; as Freire said, "My security does not rest on the false supposition that I know everything or that I am the 'greatest.' On the contrary, it rests on the conviction that there are some things I know and somethings I don't know" (p. 120). This final piece of the puzzle that he has placed in his description of the ideal teacher-student relationship gives me confidence in a mutually beneficial educational relationship that will help me to mentor and guide others through community involvement and ministry.

The Humanness of Teaching

In this last chapter of his book Pedagogy of Freedom, Paulo Freire explores the idea that teaching is a human act. He also explores the concept of symbiotic relationships. Whether it is between teacher and student, parent and child, man and woman, or just between friends, a healthy and ethically correct relationship should help the individual grow while at the same time helping the other grow in the process of evolving the relationship. We can see examples of this in the natural world with birds picking the teeth of crocodiles and hippopotamus, and small fish getting protection while also cleaning the big sharks. As humans, we have a tendency of forgetting that we need others in order to improve ourselves, and we cannot always do things on our own.

For example, Freire points out that with a teacher and student relationship a teacher "cannot help the students to overcome their ignorance if [they are] not engaged permanently in trying to overcome his own"(89). This applies to all relationships; there is always something to learn from the other person and in teaching something you too are learning something in return. In terms of service learning, we should always be open to improving ourselves as we try to improve others; it is a very human act that we should all be aware of.

Also, life experience is a fundamental tool that can be uses to educate and nourish knowledge in those who have not had the same opportunities. The fact that we all come from different cultures, backgrounds and hold different beliefs and morals makes us not only unique but gives us the opportunity to learn things from others who are different form our own. As Freire says "it is a posture of unconditional respect for the students, for the knowledge they have that comes directly from life and that, together with the students, I will work to go beyond"(94).

Another important section in this chapter, and one that really resonated with me was the section on listening. In this fast paced world, we are so preoccupied with talking and going and never quitting that sometimes we forget the importance of stopping and listening. In a relationship, Freire says, in order to be able to get your thoughts out, you must first listen to those of others so that you may fully get their attention when it is your turn. This also re-introduces the concept of "talking with" instead of "talking to" because a successful relationship has to consist of a communication structure that includes listening, responding and engaging with each other. A point that Freire makes is that "good listeners can speak engagedly and passionately about their own ideas and conditions precisely because they are able to listen"(107). This skill improves the self and enables the individual to reinforce his or her beliefs by taking in new ones and refining their own. One of the things that Jana, my service learning partner, stresses in me is listening to the needs of the families we are trying to help. Nothing comes out of talking over people and forcing your ideas into them if you do not listen to what they need and want so that you can understand where they come from and what their morals consist of.

After reading this book I have come to see the deeper ethical engagement that teaching requires. It made me appreciate the work that teachers do for their students and this book has also opened my eyes to the humanness teaching and learning.

-Ilaria Guerra

Saturday, October 2, 2010

Prompt for last part of Pedagogy of Freedom

In "Teaching is a Human Act," Freire describes many of the ways that teaching can counter ingrained societal views and inequities. At the same time, I believe that everything he says holds true for all of our relationships and how we can all strive to expand ourselves ethically in the world. As Freire writes: "And the more I give myself to the experience of living with what is different without fear and without prejudice, the more I come to know the self I am shaping and that is being shaped as I travel the road of life" (120).
He describes many of the ways and processes that shape the self and others and the attitudes that may challenge and inhibit this "becoming". Explore some of the ideas that interest you and of course, as always, illustrate with or connect to your service-learning experience when so moved!