Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Arendt begins by talking about guilty and how, “unlike responsibility, [it] always singles out.. [and] is strictly personal” (147). She then goes on to talk about responsibility, collective responsibility more specifically. She says that there are 2 conditions, which are that “I must be held responsible for something I have not done and the reason for my responsibility must be membership in a group which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve” (149). This reminded me of a bank robbery. When a person holds up a bank, they usually have apprentices and the apprentices don't usually do anything to stop the robbery even though they know its wrong. They just go along with it, maybe because they fear they will be hurt by the robber or they want to “fit in”.

A line that resonated with me was when Arendt said, “the question is never whether an individual is good but whether his conduct is good for the world he lives in. In the center of interest is the world and not the self” (151). I feel like this line is very important and very true. The line basically states that a person’s actions not only affect them but the world around them. It’s the idea of “putting the world in front of ones self” basically.

Another line that resonated with me was that thinking is a continuous process and cycle. It never ends. It gives space to rethink, expand our thoughts and ultimately grow. I agreed with Arendt when she quotes Kant in “I do not share the opinion....that one should doubt once one has convinced oneself of something...Our mind has a natural aversion against it” (166). I feel like Arendt is conveying that when we fix our minds on something, we may not be entirely fixed upon it. There’s room for doubt that lies in the back of our minds but it is only accessed when something doesn't add up. We all say that this statement is true, once you are convinced, there should be no going back but we often find ourselves doing so.

I really like how Arendt took the word “house” and said that “the word...could not exist unless one presupposes thinking about being housed, dwelling, having a home” (172). This was very interesting for me to read because I know that as humans think, they come up with things but I never saw it written in such a way that could make an impact. Lastly, when Arendt states that “A man cannot try to discover either what he knows or what he doesn't know...he doesn't even know what he is to look for”, it reminded me of my philosophy teacher who said “How can you search for something when you don't even know what it is or where it can possibly be found?” (170). It seems straight forward, either you wait or you just search blindly, but nonetheless, it is one of my favorite quotes.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.