Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Never mind who suffers, your duty is to prevent it.

Arendt argues that collective guilt is nonexistent. He states that there is no way for one to feel guilty about something if they are not actively participating in the event. 'Guilt, unlike responsibility always singles out, it is strictly personal. It refers to an act, not intentions or potentialities.' (147) I disagree. Guilt is defined as both the act of committing a crime and the feeling of responsibility. While I obviously feel guilt about a crime that I may have committed I also feel guilt in the event that I lacked action. For example, I may feel guilt eating a hamburger, fries, milkshake, soda and chocolate chip cookie after I have finished watching a presentation on hunger in a third world country. I may feel guilt when a friend fails a test because I could have prevented it by helping them study. Others may classify my feelings differently but I feel responsible for the 'crime' and I feel that I have committed a moral crime by being able to enjoy luxuries that so much of the world cannot. Therefore I don't feel that guilt singles out. Collective guilt is existent because lack of activity is a cause of guilt.

'Never mind who suffers it; your duty is to prevent it.' (153)
While it may have a different meaning out of context, this may be my new motto for life. This reflects both of nursing and of Teresa Ashby's efforts with Young Moms of Marin and County Community School. Those who are philanthropic and love giving their time are preventing suffering by substituting happiness or love. They are giving those who may be prone to suffering an opportunity to thrive. This is a saying that should be taught to every individual. I feel that in today's world, we are more sympathetic than empathetic which leads us to exhibit less pro-social behavior. What I mean by this is that we are only feeling sorry for the other party but remove ourselves with the thought that 'It's not my problem.' While if we were more empathetic, we would be understand what the other party is feeling because we would be putting our own selves in that situation which, more often times than not, results in action. The political answer to the Socratic proposition '..suffering wrong and doing wrong are equally bad..' (153) implies that because we are suffering wrong, we are allowing wrong to occur without our intervention. We must be more active in what is going on in the world rather than simply thinking of ways it could be improved.

'Our desire to know, whether arising out of practical necessities, theoretical perplexities, or sheer curiosity can be fulfilled by reaching its intended goal; and while our thirst for knowledge may be unquenchable because of the immensity of the unknown, so that every region of knowledge opens up further horizons of knowables, the activity itself leaves behind a growing treasure of knowledge that is retained and kept in store by every civilization as part and parcel of its world' (163).
I thought this sentence was absolutely beautiful. The first part of this sentence I'd like to address are the bolded words; they are absolutely true. The catch is that although our thirst may be unquenchable, we continue to thirst, we continue to hunger. There is this drive within us that wants to know more and more with each new lesson learned. This takes us on a never ending but desired life long path of learning. It captures the concept that there is so much to learn that we cannot possibly learn it all, but we still try. In addition, because we continue to try, we open new doors for research and other learning as well as add to the world knowledge base.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.