Friday, September 30, 2011

Prompt for Whatever it Takes: Geoffrey Canada's Quest to Change Harlem and America

Find quotes and places in the text that point to:
What motivates Canada?
What are some of his personal ethical challenges/inner debates?
Can you relate to anyone you have met in your service-learning or to your own experience, thus far?

The second chapter, "Unequal Childhoods," chronicles some of the history of the debate surrounding the causes of generational poverty: "Canada had come up against one of the most nettlesome questions in all of social science: Why are poor people poor?" (23). It is interesting to note how non-objective science can actually be, depending on who is designing the tool of measurement, deciding what should be measured, and how this data should be interpreted--on top of all of this, politics also enters the picture. Paul Tough does a good job of laying out some of the different approaches and attitudes to the issue.
What most surprises you? What appears finally to be fair and less biased accounts of some of the root causes of poverty? Can you relate any of these findings to your service-learning or why your community partner organization exists?
Watch Canada on 60 Minutes and check out Harlem Children's Zone

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Democracy: Government of the Majority

Starting at childhood, young American children are taught that democracy is the best form of government and that we are lucky to be living in a democratic country.  We grow up thinking that every single person's opinion matters because it is the only government in which the people are in charge.  However, the truth is that all the people in a democracy are not in charge; the majority is.  Majority rule, not moral rule, is the deciding factor in American government and society.  This would not be an issue if the majority decision was the most logical, moral, and justifiable decision.  According to Cornel West's The Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society, "Dialogue is the lifeblood of democracy and is predicated on certain bonds of trust and respect.  At this moment of cultural decay, it is difficult to find places where those ties of sympathy may be nurtured" (212).  The culture in which people live in has a profound impact on the mind set, thoughts, beliefs, and morals of the people themselves.
It is obvious that in today's modern American society, market culture has taken hold.  "The ultimate logic of a market culture is the gangsterization of culture: I want power now. I want pleasure now. I want property now. Your property. Give it to me" (213).  Not only is today's society doing anything to stem the influence of this type of culture, corporations are using it to their advantage in order to gain a profit.  One cannot watch television for a full hour without seeing commercials showcasing a half naked woman, glamorous cars, and/or the "coolest" new fad.  We are being brainwashed into thinking that in order to be happy, we must always get what we want when we want it.  We must find the fastest way to make to most money or else life is not worth  living.  Young people are especially susceptible to the power of market culture, and I have witnessed real life examples of this while mentoring at MCCS.
West's passage opened my eyes even further to the impact modern culture has on American youth.  The majority of the students at MCCS are more concerned with appearing "cool" and confident to their peers instead of concentrating on their studies.  Defying their teachers make the students feel powerful and shows that they are in control of themselves.  I had an experience today while mentoring during which one student openly defied his teacher and played a game on the computer instead of returning to his classroom.  He did so because the teacher asked him directly in front of his peers to do something that he did not want to do, so he decided to show the room who truly held the power.  Our culture must change in order to allow society to change for the better.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Where is compassion without suffering? -Jessica D.

West uses Du Bois’ reasoning on the negative effects of prejudice in a so-called democratic nation to shed light on the importance of our individual responsibility in a large democracy. Barzun dictates, “Nature, which we are taught to see as a machine, contains the unmechanical mind of man-which it is a disgrace and a danger to let lapse into automatism"(4). The majority of middle-class Americans are at risk for being “problem people” due to the prevalent deterioration of families, and growth of indifference toward others and the government. Jane Goodall explores the innate human desire to survive as evidenced by scientific and biological design, but asserts that we humans possess a capacity beyond that. Her solution in this cycle of degradation is to start with the youth. Goodall states, “The single most important contribution that we can make, those of us who care enough to try, is in the sphere of child upbringing and education" (5). Raise them to become good people so that they don’t develop the bad habits and spread it to their future relationships.
These authors explore themes that portray a recipe for the death of society. First, marginalize those who are different from you, next is indifference to the injustices of society because they’re the norm, and lastly keep the cycle going because generations after are raised in this downtrodden society.
This leads me to ask, “Then what happens to those already caught in the cycle of degradation like criminals and murderers?” West uses James Baldwin’s quote, “love is the most dangerous discourse in the world… because it makes you vulnerable, but if you experience it, it is the peak of human existence” (213).
To be human is to love. The peak of human existence is to love unselfishly. “Love thy neighbor” as the Bible reminds me. But some people ask, “If God is all powerful, why doesn’t he stop all suffering? Why do bad things happen to good people?” If we look at imprisoned criminals, we are less likely to sympathize with their suffering because we feel like they deserve their punishment. But if we gaze upon the eyes of an abandoned innocent child, we are more compelled to reach out to them because they deserve the help. But should we only help those who we feel are the ones deserving of our help?
I say yes, help even those who don’t deserve our sympathy. Why? Regardless of people’s actions, we all share the same essence of being. This is what sets us apart from all other animals. We are not restrained by survival of the fittest or survival of those “deserving”. We humans have the capacity to choose to break beyond that barrier. But, even if we wanted to, it’s physically impossible to help EVERYONE. For me, this is where my belief in God comes into the picture. In addition to physically going out and helping people through tutoring and relationships, I pray for all people. I have faith in the power of God, that my prayers are my way of reaching out to my neighbor, whether that person is a student I tutor at MCC or a criminal I’ve never met on the other side of the globe.

We should be even more empowered to use our energy to freely help others because we are blessed to be living in a democratic nation.

Togetherness

Between the two readings, I felt very moved by Cornel West's The Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society. West talks about the problems of racism and democracy in such an interesting way. First, racism is not just between skin colors or "black bodies in white space." (210) Racism is a view point where one sees a "problem people rather than people with problems." (210) I asked myself, how could one think like that? West responds that these thoughts arise from "the assumption [that] their lives were less complex and one-dimensional." (210) This lack of empathy, respect, and love coincide with the second issue, our threatened democracy.
The political, moral, and cultural decay are not separate, but inseparable. Along with the economic decline, "Americans are concerned more about the low quality of their lives, the constant fear of violent assault and cruel insult, the mean spiritedness and cold heartedness of social life, and the inability to experience deep levels of intimacy." (212) Where did we go wrong? In this present day, our own culture and media praise the idea of instant gratification and independence.
This in itself is not a bad thing, but it is what we have abandoned them for that disturbs me. In exchange for these ideals, we have disregarded "mutual respect, personal responsibility, and social accountability." (213) These are the ideals that make the roots of democracy. Along with that, we have degraded empathy, hope, and love to mere passive feelings when in actuality, they are strong actions.
Tying this back into his first point of racism, I think what strikes me most is that this is all connected. The fact that we are so quick to isolate one group, judge each other, and ourselves the way we do, stems from the fact that we have lost a lot of self-respect for ourselves, our environment, and our brethren.
I see this so apparently in my service with the kids of MCCS and in my own life. The kids have forgotten the power of hoping for something better, the power of loving themselves and each other, and the fact that those actions take REAL courage and strength. Instead they hide behind their words and their apathy, when in reality, they could achieve anything. In my own life, I see how I strive for that instant gratification of a good grade or a positive comment. I dress myself in clothes I hope others will like and I speak in words that I hope will strike a giggle from someone I'm talking to. I myself have forgotten that, although these things aren't bad, making them the center of my life is not really living. West speaks that truly thriving in this society takes a little bit of spirituality, of knowing and understanding who you are in terms of your world. Instead, I have let my world define who I am, surrendering my own courage, my own strengths for acceptance.
I have forgotten that "we are all in the same boat, on the same turbulent sea. The boat has a huge leak in it and in the end, we go up and down together." (211) It is this togetherness and inner courage we all lack and need to better ourselves, our political lives, our environments, and each other.

A Successful Democratic Society

To live in a democratic community is to take part in the whole, but that is only if one chooses to be an active citizen. That is one of the growing achievements and downfalls of our society today. On one hand, we have more and more people, especially the youth, becoming aware and interested in social and political issues. On the other hand, however, we have many people who are disengaged from the system and refuse take part in the democracy. In order for the ideal democratic community to exist, everyone must take part by voting or giving their opinion. Otherwise, as Cornel West said in The Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society, “Problem people become indistinguishable and interchangeable, which means only one of them has to be asked to find out what the rest of them think.” (West 210). This does not happen only with the poor, but with others as well. When one is identified to be part of a stereotyped group, then their actions and thoughts will be used to represent the whole, whether that is what they intended or not. If everyone takes action in issues that are important to them, then they will be heard and accounted for.

Later, West comes to the discussion about economic’s influence on a democratic society saying, “the preservation of democracy is threatened by real economic decline,” (212), but isn’t that fairly obvious? No matter what kind of society, when the majority of the population suffers economically, the society and government will suffer also. I do agree with his point that “It is past time that we consider in our public discourse the civic responsibilities of corporations.” (211). Currently it seems that corporations have more rights and less responsibilities in the community than citizens do. If that were to be reversed so that they had more responsibilities, then I think our democratic society would function much smoother and less influenced by the needs of selfish people and companies.

Although I believe what is written above, I must say that I am fairly hypocritical. I am not registered to vote and I pay far more attention to things that go on in my life than what is going on on the global scale. I know that at some point I will become an active citizen, but that will be when I have the time and will to research what I am voting on and acting out for. I think that so many political bills and laws are passed without us knowing their full consequences and I do not wish to be responsible for helping to vote something in that has an overall negative impact.

Democracy - Whitney Myers

One purpose of a democratic government is to prevent the exploitation of the Many by the Few. In providing the Many with the capacity to assist in governing, the formation of an elite Few with dictatorial powers is less likely. Unfortunately, the nature humans have exhibited thus far, in terms of external gain, has been one largely determined by self-interest. Once the Many are given influence, the Few quickly become the victims. Any factor that can be used to separate one group from another can be used to create the perception of an inferior group, one that can be exploited to further the aforementioned self-interest. Barzun’s explanation of the mechanical is similar to the exploitative quality present in human nature. “Any ossified institution – almost every bureaucracy, public or private – manifests the mechanical. So does race-thinking – a verdict passed mechanically at a color-coded signal. Ideology is likewise an idea-machine, designed to spare the buyer all further thought” (Barzun, 5). Humans can accept their exploitation of other groups if they can rationalize the exploited group as inferior. Mechanical division into groups allows humans to thoughtlessly exploit one another, defeating the function of democracy as a tool to create equality.

The formation of respected versus exploited groups in humanity causes a loss of trust and respect between factions of society that prevents functional dialogue. West explains, however, “dialogue is the lifeblood of democracy and is predicated on certain bonds of trust and respect” (West, 15). A functional democracy requires that the society involved be educated about the options that democratic government offers them. If disrespect and a lack of trust prevent education across groups, then any democratic decision the fractured society comes to will not be representative of the community as a whole.

Democracy also requires participation to be truly representative. If a section of a society does not participate in that society’s democratic process, or is prevented from doing so, the government will only represent part of that community. West describes the “political lethargy” (West, 10) and other situations in which humanity is lacking as a result of humanity’s self-interested tendencies. “Parenting is a nonmarket activity; so much sacrifice and service goes into it without any assurance that the providers will get anything back. Mercy, justice; they are nonmarket. Care, service; nonmarket. Solidarity, fidelity, nonmarket. Sweetness and kindness and gentleness. All nonmarket” (West, 25). When humans are only interested in capitalistic gain, all of these societal necessities fall by the wayside. One does not immediately gain by participating in the democratic process, and so political participation is devalued based on human self-interest in attaining material goods that have a defined market value.

Subscription to Barzun’s concept of honor seems to be the best alternative to the self-fulfilling lifestyle based solely on market motivation. “‘Honor’ here means knowing how little one brings and how much one has received, and feeling impelled to discharge the debt” (Barzun, 9). When we consider all that is offered us within a democracy, it is our duty to discharge that debt by participating in the democracy, though “it is doubtless less agreeable to think of debts than to think of rights, which serve our needs incessantly and so make us by instinct rights advocates” (Barzun, 9). Barzun points out that rights, such as the right to refuse to participate in the democratic process, or the right to seclude one’s self and forever ponder reality, can make life simpler than the obligation to act on those ponderings or take a dissenting stand in a democracy. Lack of action is the self-serving answer to one’s societal debt, while action, however small the acting group, is the only way to generate change, and the only way to participate in a democracy. One person has the ability to facilitate education between factions in a society, or incite thought in a population, and eventually lead to the more effective use of democracy. After all, “it is impossible to overemphasize the power of the individual in the shaping of the values of a society” (Goodall, 19).

Generalizing, it’s apart of everyday society. As West puts it, once you ask one person of a specific race something, it applies to everyone else (210). Sadly, this has become true in society. When once status quo meant something and consensus had a place in society, now the consensus focuses on a certain location and comes out with a theory that applies to everyone. But even before the research starts, the hypothesis itself is thought to apply to everyone.

Before I went into my service learning project, I had a mind set of the students I would be dealing with, an idea already implemented in my head given by the various people I talked to. When certain words are said, certain things are triggered in the mind, linking the thoughts together to formulate an opinion. In a way, this is called generalizing.

However, when I got there, I was happy to find out that these students, while they have or still are leading what we may see as “bad” lives, are still people who are like us. They too act on feelings just as any other human being does. While I knew this fact, I was still under the impression of seeing tattoos and piercings everywhere and the connotations we see from prison and etc. While I did see a few here and there, it was so gruesome that it was overwhelming for me to handle. And, since I have never done anything like this before, it was new and I didn’t know what to expect.

I really liked working with this one girl. She had came in a bit late and was upset as I could see tears coming out of her eyes during “circles”. Circles is when they talk about a topic and go around the table passing the cat with stories that relate them to that topic. They not only talk to each other but listen as well. I found this out as they were asked to pass the cat and tell me the purpose of circles. This girl I was asked to work with couldn't make it for a while so she was behind and I had to catch her up. The assignment was to write about a hero and her hero was her niece. After a while of just talking to her about her niece, I realized that she wasn’t that much different from anyone else. Just as others would do, when having kids around, you wouldn’t engage in inappropriate activity and rough-housing. By the end of my tutoring session, I gained an added respect for these students. They might have made mistakes in the past, but that’s just the nature of humankind. And when you look deeper, you just see a regular person like you. Hard exterior but soft interior.

Some Thoughts.

Cornel West's The Moral Obligation of Living in a Democratic Society truly resonated with me in regards to the prejudice in society. Once a specific group, specifically Blacks, has been targeted "Their beauty is attacked; wrong hips, lips, noses, skin texture, skin pigmentation, and hair texture. Black intelligence is always guilty before proven innocent in the court of life and mind"
(pg 210). As humans, we all know, or most would know, what it feels like to be outcasted from the greater group, or looked down upon. While for some it is only for a moment, for Blacks it continues to present day. Morally, how can we be a democratic society and work together when we do not respect each other? How it is possible that ‘the top 20% own 94% of the wealth while 80 percent of the population is experience stagnation &declining wages?’ (pg 211). How is it possible that corporations continues to talk about downsizing when so many already do not have jobs and the companies have’ the highest profits since 1948?’ (pg 211). How, in our modern day society, can we be so prejudice and selfish with a democratic system. It is a system where everyone gets a voice and therefore should all have an opportunity to thrive? The people in our society are becoming desperate and insecure which in turn influences them to blindly ‘accept any authorization option in order to provide normalcy and a sense of security’ (pg 211). Further, the American people are being categorized as simply potential buyers/customers/paychecks. Everything is being marketed to them. The result of this is that we have become stimulated only by new toys, such as the iPad and plasma 3D televisions, and the urgency to have those toys before anyone does. Because of this, values that are not marketable, such as kindness, sweetness and mercy are not emphasized. I feel that American society has lost touch with their own selves and the ability to be compassionate for more than just a select few. People simply rush by on their iPhones not caring to smile or say hello to the person next to them. Soon, we may never meet our best friends on a bus or in a coffee shop because we will keep to ourselves.

I really related to one of the quotes from Barzun in that I feel that it is one of our society’s growing problems. ‘To keep from climbing on is harder than ever since that other machine, the media, has been installed’ (pg 3). The emphasis on technology and its use is growing and has become addicting to so many. Those who are a few years below me may never know what it was like to write a letter to someone, or to dial a circular phone. Personally, I just have a problem with this ‘technology movement.’ It has made our society want more everything and when something does come out, they want more. They are influenced to believe that they need every product that comes out on the market regardless of the price tag; a price tag that could have taken care of eight textbooks, a bike, or even a family picnic. Technology is taking away from our opportunities to spend time with nature and with each other. Barzun also talks about how these products seem to come out of thin air. There seems to be no by products, no waste, no negatives which encourages users to buy them. Yet, we aren’t thinking. We do not realize the capacity of our waste. Each individual takes up an incredible amount of space and we don’t even realize it. We just take, abuse, and waste the precious resources of our planet without regard to the repercussions. Again, the nonmarket values such as kindness, justice and compassion may have prevented these blind crimes from happening.

In Jane Goodall’s Respect for Life, she emphasizes that human life has the potential to do incredible things and that we have spent much of our time on Earth perfected our skills. However, our arrogance and greed have become greater influences on our history than respect for another’s life (pg 2). We now only think of our self-gain, with no regards to the consequences. To get a better job we are willing to be cut-throat and throw our co-workers under the bus to get a promotion. Again, the reoccurring theme in the other two articles is also that we have lost touch with our inner selves and our interdependence on others. “The behavior of one prisoner in a concentration camp sometimes gave so much encouragement that people survived who might have died—and who knows what the survivors may be contributed in turn” (pg 3). Our actions affect the entire human race. Whether it be small or great, our efforts contribute to the well being or the detrimental decline of mankind. I, too, believe that there is hope for mankind. We may not be able to fix all of the problems that we have caused, nor can be take back the bombs we have dropped. But we can begin to spread kindness, respect, security, trust, love and more through our social interactions, and not through technology. We must become more in touch with nature and our own spirituality. We must acknowledge that we are interdependent and that we don’t need technology to make friends.

Humanity: The Larger Picture

This week’s readings are very distinct from what we have been looking at in the sense that they all focus on humanity in a broad sense. Cornell West brings up prejudice, while Jacques Barzun looks at complacency and Jane Goodall talks about making an impact.

One facet of humanity Cornell West targets is prejudice. In one section of the text, he writes, “[Du Bois] understood what it meant to be cast as part of a problem people rather than people with problems… Their beauty is attacked…Black intelligence is always guilty before proven innocent… The Bell curve is just a manifestation of the cycle… Du Bois also underscored that to be part of a problem people is to be viewed as part of an undifferentiated blob, a monolithic block. Problem people become indistinguishable and interchangeable…” (5). West is describing the phenomena of prejudice where an entire group of people, such as every person with a specific skin color, are associated with particular stereotypes. He goes on to list common stereotypes related to black prejudice, such as: unattractive physical features, a lack of intelligence, a dependence upon welfare, and female laziness (5). These stereotypes can hardly be representational of the group as a whole, but have nonetheless become known throughout society.

Jacques Barzun and Jane Goodall also bring up humanity issues of their own. In his writings, Barzun notes his resolve to “fight the mechanical” (4). He goes on to explain that he sees the mechanical as “where human judgment abdicates”, including situations such as bureaucracy, prejudice, ideology, and specialism (4). In short, Barzun warns against letting other people or groups reason for you. Goodall, meanwhile, emphasizes the power individuals have in shaping society. She provides exemplars such as Hitler, Jesus, Gandhi and Ayatollah Khomeini, yet insists that unrecognized contributions can also make large differences. Goodall goes on to suggest that the most important contribution people can make is to provide children with a positive environment and education (5-6).

Jane Goodall’s thoughts on putting children in a good environment fit in nicely with my service at Coleman Elementary School. Since I volunteer on Fridays, my service consists of helping kids enjoy their “free day.” I help ensure that the children are actively having fun, while also helping enforce discipline. I imagine some of the reasoning behind such a program is to set aside a section of time where the children are sure to have positive experiences with each other.


- Christopher Galbick

Living in a Market Culture

Upon reading Cornel West's The Moral Obligations of Living in a Democractic Society, I immediately thought of very real struggles manifested in my own everyday life. On page 213, West talks about what it is like to live in a "hood" versus a neighborhood. "It is a big difference, A neighborhood was a place not only for the nuclear family, but also included aunta and uncles, friends and neighbors, rabbis and priests, deacons and pastors, Little League coaches and dance teachers--all of whom served as a backdrop for socializing young people." I agree with Cornell, having a community is significant. "This backdrop provided children with a sense of what it is to be human, with all its decency, integrity, and compassion. When those values are practiced, a neighborhood emerges." This past summer, I volunteered as a camp counselor for a summer camp in San Gregorio. This summer camp fostered "high risk" children from notoriously dangerous communities. These kids were there solely on sponsorship in order to give them a taste of what it is like to be in a safe, tight-knit community away from home. Although each session only lasted a mere five days, I saw what difference it made to these kids to have people around them. It was amazing to serve as a support system for someone living in a highly disfunctional home. They emphasized what it meant to have friends, and to build a second family around people. They became vulnerable throughout the week, breaking out of their hard exteriors. For once, these kids acted like innocent kids and not hardened people that they are conditioned to be. "The ultimate logic of a market culture is the gangsterization of culture." Sometimes I see the kids at Coleman falling into the same trap that those camp kids were in. They can't help it. They became part of a minority and might have to live with the burden of what W.E.B. Du Bois defines as a "problem people." Coleman Leap is a program that seeks to enhance their experiences at school but moreso, I commit my time there because it builds a community for them, a place where they can be safe. I do not want them to be a part of "an undifferentiated blob" who may become "indistinguishable and interchangable" (213). Each one of those kids has potential and they are only human. They grow up influenced by their neighborhood. I just hope they have the wisdom to know that they can be great.

Monday, September 26, 2011

Gluttons- J. Kiefer O'Sullivan

Humanity has become a glutton on its own vices. Of all the readings, Jane Goodall’s insight on animal behavior really stuck with me. Comparing humans and our primate relatives really does shed light on how close humanity really is to nature. That we are not as distant as we think we are. However, I believe that we should be distant. I do not mean that we should abandon our ties with nature, on the contrary. In nature, you could say that each animal has enough responsibility to suit its capacity. Animals will not use their abilities to destroy their environment, instead they harmonize with it. Humans have such a greater capacity to destroy or create that we need to hold ourselves hugely more responsible for our behavior to each, to the planet, and all its inhabitants. Goodall similiarly puts forth that “Of course we have aggressive tendencies. Cruel streaks that are innate, deep-rooted in our primate heritage. So what! Our uniqueness is lies in the fact that, for the first time in the evolution of life forms on this planet, we can, if we will, control these ancient instincts. That is, or should be, what humanity is all about” (4). This combined with West’s piece got me thinking about human greed and how it is a founding cause of discontent and depravity across the globe. West cites how “80 percent of the population is experiencing stagnating and declining wages” while “one percent of the population own 48 percent of the wealth.” (211). Humans have become addicted to “stimulation and titillation” (213), we have become accustomed to getting and hoarding. Biological, it has been engrained in us to get as much as we can, because we never know when we’ll be able to get the chance to get more again. This manifests itself in the form of greed in modern man; a twisted perversion on nature’s principle of survival of the fittest. As a species that can reason, it is our duty to correct ourselves and use our higher logic to think about the consequences of what we do for our fellow inhabitants of this planet. If we are so keen on being the masters of this planet, we need to start behaving responsibly, for the sake of everything.

Find Your Voice

A society is only as strong as its weakest link. As West put it, “What is the role of the most disadvantaged in relation to the public interest? (212).” Society thrives with a large middle class. However, when there is a small upper class and a small middle class and a very large lower class, society cannot function on any level. Chaos breaks loose and the poor get the blame.

I agree with West that our current way of living is hurting the youth in society. “Any civilization that is unable to sustain its networks of caring and nurturing will generate enough anger and aggression to make communication impossible. The result is a society in which we do not even respect each other enough to listen to each other. (212”) I noticed a lot of lack of respect when I went to Coleman to tutor. I was working with some 5th grade girls on their homework and they kept lying to me when I would ask them a question, even one as simple as, “Do you have any brothers or sisters?” I later found out that these kids (most were of non-Caucasian ethnicity and from poor families) were actually very below average in their studies and this program is helping them catch up to the education level that they should be at. I blame society for holding these kids back because of their ethnicities and their economic background. They haven’t done anything wrong, yet society has held them back from their full potential and I think this is the main cause of their disrespect and their attitudes. Whether they realize it or not, they are resentful. But programs like Colman’s and Canal Alliance hold the key to their future. They are too young to fight for their voices in society, but these special programs and organizations can push them and encourage them. These kids have seen the ugly side of life, but I think that’s what’s going to make them outstanding citizens because they know life isn’t perfect, and that will make them stronger, more rounded, and more understanding adults. Young people with a cause are going to make the biggest changes to the world. Jane Goodall describes this perfectly, “Every single one of us has, I believe, a significant part to play in the scheme of things. Some contributions that go unrecognized may nevertheless be of utmost importance (9,Right).”

West encourages each able person to contribute to our society rather than to wait around for somebody else to do it for us. “To engage in that struggle means that one is always willing to acknowledge that there is no triumph around the corner, but that you will persist because you believe it is right and just and normal. (214).” Utopias do not exist and I believe that struggles make us stronger if we can fight through them. Then we can become a better people. Citizens need to stand up for what they believe in. If they don’t have a voice, then they need to fight for their voice. Everybody has something to live passionately for, it’s our job as individuals to find out what that is and then to stand up for it.

~C. Standridge-Folsom

Reflection for West, Barzun, and Goodall

In Cornell West’s piece, The Moral Obligations of the Living in a Democratic Society, the question of responsibility is brought to the attention of the reader. He opened his argument with the statement that “if you want it, you must sacrifice for it (209).” The example that he uses is the struggle for African American citizens to get equality in America. W.E. B. Du Bois recognized “being Black in America is to be a problem (210).” Being a part of the minority is what caused this feeling for Du Bois and because of his struggle he earned his right of equality. Because we have no need to struggle we have become a society of stimulation. According to West, “the good life [for many people] might mean being hooked up to an orgasm machine and being perennially titillated (213).” Bordering on inappropriate West has a point. We have become a society focused on immediate gratification and because of that we have lost the fight in us. The result, we have become an “undifferentiated blob (210).”

Barzun’s argument in his piece, Toward a Fateful Serenity, is that the in order to avoid corruption of society you must fight the mechanical. The definition of mechanical, according to Barzun, is, “the smoothest machine-made product of the age (page 2, right hand side).” In order to avoid corruption, it is crucial that we must have a sense of “how things go (page 3, left)” in history and realize that “help is wanted (page 4, left).” To fully help another you must adopt the idea you should think of human kind is, “naturally good and not hopelessly bad (page 4, right).” Jane Goodall’s argument aligns with Barzun when she states that, “it is impossible to overemphasize the power of the individual in the shaping of the values of society (page 8, right).” The focus of her article is instead on the focus of human’s effect on the world. She studies chimpanzees and aligns a lot of her research to humans. She states that, “we humans began that explosive development of the intellect (page 8, left)” and because of, “our uniqueness, for the first time in evolution of life forms on this planet, we can control the ancient urges (page 8, left)” such as aggression. That same development can work evils for this planet like pollution. But we as humans have the ability to make changes or “triumphs of the human spirit (page 9, left) in Goodall’s words.

All of the readings have a common theme. Life is full of hardships and events that test you but it is you that decides whether or not you survive. It is evident in history that humans have the ability to survive but there are bigger things then just surviving. Those are to fight for your rights and give back to the community you live in. If everyone would fight and give back we would live in a world that we would all be proud to be a part of.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Prompt for West, Barzun, and Goodall reading

(The prompt simply provides some ideas for your reflection. Responding directly to the prompt is not required! You are completely free to engage other ideas and to make connections between readings and with service in whatever way makes sense to you. But the central reading here is the West piece, so please place your focus there.)

Cornell West starts his piece "The Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society" by stating the inherent complexity and irrationality of tough social issues, especially those related to race. He restates W.E.B. DeBois’s analysis that “Being Black in America is to be a problem . . . Problem people become indistinguishable and interchangeable, which means that only one of them has to be asked to find out what the rest of them think” (5). He connects this issue to the idea that democratic sensibility “cuts against the grain of history” in which the ruling class exerted its power over the underclass, effectively dehumanizing the “ordinary” individual. Thus, West asserts, if we are to live justly and democratically, we must critically engage and examine issues of race and power: “No democracy can survive with a middle class so insecure that it is willing to accept any authoritarian option in order to provide some sense of normalcy and security in their lives. It also opens the door for significant segments of that middle class to scapegoat those who are most vulnerable” (10).

Think about what this means and if you can relate to anything related to your service or community partner. Also, see if you can connect to similar ideas conveyed by Barzun and Goodall:

What does Barzun mean by his struggle against the “mechanical.” He writes that “any ossified [fossilized] institution . . . manifests the mechanical. So does race-thinking—a verdict passed mechanically at a color-coded signal. Ideology is likewise an idea machine, designed to spare the buyer all further thought” (pg. 3 of pdf, right hand side).

Jane Goodall writes that it is “impossible to overemphasize the power of the individual in the shaping of the values of a society. . . In human society, the legacies of a Hitler or a Jesus, a Gandhi or an Ayatollah Khomeini, are testimonies to the impact they made during their brief years on earth. . . Every single one of has, I believe, a significant part to play in the scheme of things” (pg. 9 of pdf, right hand side).

What does it mean to be part of a larger, democratic community. What happens if we don't struggle/question/strive as individuals but wait, instead for someone else to do it for us?

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

From Jessica: Self and Happiness

Balance is key

I find that a big part of living a fulfilling life is continuously striving to balance the “self” and relationships with others.

Porter and Taylor together shed light on the two extremes. Porter mentions how in the medieval
times, “the Catholic Church had no investment in self-exploration for its own sake” (4). This is allows no exploration into developing oneself. Whereas Taylor writes "It's not just that people sacrifice their love relationships, and the care of their children, to pursue their careers. Something like that has perhaps always existed. The point is that today many people feel called to do this, feel they ought to do this, feel their lives would be somehow wasted or unfulfilled if they didn't do it” (17). This is disregarding others to pursue one’s own goals and ambitions.

I’d like to emphasize that the Catholic Church during the medieval times was very flawed
and corrupt. Many clergymen stressed self-denial so that they could keep their position and
power without being questioned by the ignorant masses. However, I’d also like to clarify
that the Church has undergone much improvement since then It’s teaching on self-denial is
grounded not in the corrupt clergymen of the medieval times, but by the example of Jesus
Christ. The concept of self-denial pertains to sacrificial love; the greatest form of love. It’s the
love where the individual values another over himself or herself. One great example of this love
was personified by Jesus’ crucifixion. Now, this does not mean we totally disregard ourselves
and deny ourselves of exploration. I think exploration outside ourselves is crucial to better
understanding our world and others.

I also don’t think that it’s good sacrificing the precious relationships we have to pursue our
own desires and goals. I think that making goals which doesn’t involve others is quite sad and
for me, practically impossible. My own goals of happiness and the community at large are
inseparable.
While reading portions of the books “Know Yourself” and “The Ethics of Authenticity,” both authors raise two very interesting points. One author begins by asking us “Who are we?” (Pg.1 of “Know Yourself”). The other states “People no longer have a sense of a higher purpose, of something worth dying for.” (Pg. 15 of ““Ethics of Authenticity”) When I read these two statements, they instantly stood out because these were the very questions that several of us (including myself) have struggled with for years. When trying to discover who you are, it seems as if one is constantly at a dead end. Everyday people learn and discover new things about the world around them as well as themselves, causing them to continuously shape and form new opinions and characteristics. It is truly a lifelong learning process. It is also through this process that we discover what it is we are passionate about. When looking around at my fellow peers, it saddens me to agree with author’s observation of a lack of passion when applied to our generation. It seems as if today’s society has adopted a somewhat selfish attitude and developed a lack a love of their fellow man. It seems as if we are only concerned with obtaining the latest and greatest, and down grade any situation that does not pertain our personal well-being. As a result, we have neglected critical issues that affect our world, and have diminished the effect of our voices.
It seems as if our generation is so distracted by the media and new waves of technology, that they fail to see the world slowly around them crumbling. I am totally for being an individual and focusing on one’s self, but do not become too much of an individual and not be willing to help out others and become oblivious to the situations around you.

Self - Whitney Myers

I have always had trouble with the idea that there is an ‘inner me’ that might not be the ‘me’ that I live as every day. Statements such as ‘Be true to yourself’ or ‘Always be yourself’ only make sense if it is possible to be someone other than yourself. What does it mean if I do not have a defined ‘sense of self’? If I cannot perfectly, consciously, and articulately communicate every detail of my ‘self’, does that mean that I don’t even know who I am? Do I consciously need to be the person I am supposed to be? Is it possible to unconsciously be another person? In order to make sense of these readings, I have had to put aside doubts that I have the ability to be someone other than me (assuming I attempted to create that disconnect). I have had to assume that it is a possibility that people can choose to exist without relation to the person they ‘truly are’.

Operating under that assumption, I can begin to understand Charles Taylor’s discussion of defining one’s self from inside. I understand that this is merely a statement describing a change in perception, and that Taylor does not state this as fact, or even an idea he supports. Rather, it is a notion that is useful in communicating the shift in social perception that occurred leading to the current fascination with the individual. He describes the transition from outward definition to inward. “Being in touch with some source, God, say, or the Idea of Good - was considered essential to full being. Only now the source we have to connect with is deep in us” (Taylor, 26). Rather than relying on an idea or other external influence, we must use our ‘inner self’ to become fully whole. Following this logic, we cannot possibly be a complete person without knowing exactly who the ‘self’ is inside us. Without contact between our mind and this perceived person existing within, the outer person the world sees will be inevitably false. I, like Taylor, do not believe that we can come to fulfillment solely through internal reflection, and I do not even believe that it is totally necessary to be consciously tapping an inner source of humanity to reach full potential as a person.

In addition to the concept of ‘inner self’ being necessary in discovering the person you truly are (inside), Taylor discusses the idea that inner self is necessary in defining one’s moral code, or the ‘model’ that we live by as we move through society. Taylor discusses the social conception of the necessary inner moral guide. “Not only should I not fit my life to the demands of external conformity; I can't even find the model to live by outside myself. I can find it only within” (Taylor, 29). According to this idea, the only way to understand the guidelines that should determine one’s actions in society is to examine the inner self. I disagree, and believe that much of what determines our actions in society should come from society. Taylor says: “We are expected to develop our own opinions, outlook, stances to things, to a considerable degree through solitary reflection. But this is not how things work with important issues, such as the definition of our identity. We define this always in dialogue with, sometimes in struggle against, the identities our significant others want to recognize in us” (Taylor, 33). Though some activities can be determined purely through though, others require interaction with the world. Identification of self, as well as morals, necessitates interaction with society.

I found one piece of Taylor’s evidence against the myth of the individual particularly interesting. He says: “We become full human agents, capable of understanding ourselves, and hence of defining an identity, through our acquisition of rich human languages of expression… But we are inducted into these in exchange with others. No one acquires the languages needed for self definition on their own” (Taylor, 33). According to Taylor, in order to identify one’s ‘self’, interaction with others is necessary. Therefore, the myth of the individual is, as Roy Porter says, a social construction (Porter, 16). Society is necessary for the individual to identify himself or herself and for the individual to construct the model by which they will live. The individual, or their inner self, could not exist without the larger context of society.