Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Causes and Effects of Poverty

I found the readings for this week to particularly engaging. Both chapters provide in-depth discussion about poverty, which is a very real and prevalent concern. The chapter on Geoffrey Canada relates to his individual experiences on the subject, while the second chapter tries to look at the root causes.

In the first chapter, we find that Canada grew up in a very similar situation to those of the children he wanted to help. Both have had to deal with “…substandard schools, unstable families, and a segregated city” (2). After a few years of creating isolated programs designed to fight poverty, however, Canada began to worry that his efforts were too haphazard (2-4). His ideas eventually manifested into Promise Academy, a tuition-free charter school that students can attend from kindergarten to twelfth grade (8). His hope was that this comprehensive approach would give the students a truly exceptional education (12).

Canada’s experiences lead into the second chapter, where Paul Tough looks at other people that have tried to pose solutions to poverty. Two theorists mentioned are Murray, who believed government welfare programs should have been completely cut, as well as Wilson, who believed that the government needed to overhaul the economy and provide “a wide range of financial supports to every American family” (32). Tough eventually brings the narrative to Annette Lareau, whose research suggests that each economic level – poor, middle class, and working class – each tend to have a very distinct method of raising children. Lareau contends that each parenting style has its advantages, but that the parenting model of the middle class best prepares children for the current educational and job systems (51-53).

I feel that the service I am involved in at Coleman Elementary School relates slightly to each of these chapters. Coleman took a similar approach to what Canada initially did by introducing an afterschool program, primarily designed to improve students’ performance in school. At the same time, however, the students who attend Coleman seem to be mostly from middle-class backgrounds. Lareau would argue that this background inherently tends to give these students a significant advantage at succeeding in the classroom and work setting when compared to students of other economic class backgrounds.

- Christopher Galbick

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.