Thursday, December 10, 2009

It is interesting reading the end of Cosmopolitanism”. It certainly strikes me as an accurate description of how the world works most of the time. I was especially interested in how culture meaning and specific parameters can be defined differently within and without any culture.

Who gets to choose the definition ... The participants, in a democratic way? The observers in a clinical way? And especially how is a culture allowed to be dynamic if it is expected to retain it’s “authenticity”. The world is turning! I think the world is going the way it’s going to go and people will always find a way to circumvent ill intent.


I liked the quote on page 113 “If you are right, I’ll do what you do. If you are wrong. I’ll set you straight.” This reminds me of my son and my conversations with him about his travels and interests. This quote was very similar to what he told me. He has spent several weeks in India and in South Africa. He has been to Egypt and Istanbul. His work in the EU keeps him working with all different cultures and ethics. He maintains his respect for those who behave honorably and tries to speak up only when someone seems wrong. His first cultural outsider’s experience was going to school in Alabama, which is in many ways was very different from the Southern California environment he was raised in. In a way similar to the city/country homogeneous areas Appiah describes in the Global Villages section. One day when he was home for Thanksgiving, college football was on television. The commentator noted that one team was saying a prayer in the huddle. From the kitchen I made a flip remark about how god couldn’t possibly care who won whatever Bowl Game it was. Of course, I have never forgotten that then my son said. “No Mom. I met some of the team. They pray that no players are injured in the game.” How could that never have occurred to me. that lesson has helped me listen and learn about my own suppositions and how I judge. In reality, if I were to pray before a football game, that would be exactly what I would pray for! It was interesting to me that I assumed that “they” would pray for something else.


In my service with Marin Literacy Project my learner is from Mexico. She has a family here and is learning English with intensity. She insists that she is here in the US to stay. She is very eager to master the English language and works very hard. Sometimes though she speaks longingly of the beauty of the area she grew up in. It is one of her main goals to be able to tell her sons exactly, and in English, about their cultural heritage in the place she left behind. By the act of deciding that they will hear her story in English, she is making decisions about, and actually modifying this cultural heritage. As an immigrant, she has affected the static story of her Mexican culture. So, in our lessons, I try to make sure that I don’t make assumptions about which “culture” she aspires to. I like to listen to her enthusiasm about whatever it is she is trying to communicate before I correct her language. Sometimes she refers to her life in Mexico, sometimes there is an aspect of US culture that she is enthusiastic about. I don’t allow cultural value judgement to enter into our discussion. I’m sure it would be easy to misrepresent my culture or to slight hers which I know little about.

The final chapters of cosmopolitanism were the ones that resonated the most to the service learning work I have been doing and the ideas set forth were ones that I actually understood.

One of the main truths that cosmopolitans believe and live by is, “Everybody matters: that is our central idea.”(p.144) How simple and beautiful. I can’t help but thinking what a better place this might be if everyone felt this way.

However there are some that do and I think another one of cosmopolitanism truths is to respect difference. “Cosmopolitanism is, in a slogan universality plus difference” (p.151) In my understanding its about being a whole comprised of many different parts and a care of each part.

A principle Appiah presents that correlates to my service work is this, “ if you can prevent something from happening at the cost of something else less bad, you ought to do it.” (p. 160) This is exactly what needle exchange is trying to do.

Studies show that “240,000 people die of AIDS each month.” (P. 170)

On page 102 Appiah asks the question, “What can you tell about a persons soul from the fact that she drinks coca cola?”

I will ask the question, what can you really tell about a persons soul from the fact that they are infected with HIV or AIDS?

So often we get wrapped up in stigmas or negative ideas about people or situations. We focus on the problem instead of what our goal really is or we focus on the “problem” instead of the person. It is my belief that if we are so rooted in the problems nothing lasting can be achieved.

Cosmopolitanism it would seem values everybody and their choices however all the while maintaining respect for the people that don’t. If people do not see eye to eye, cosmopolitans would have the curiosity and desire to see the other side or opinion. Cosmopolitanism is all inclusive.

In the article Towards a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World In-Suk Cha states, “there are organizations devoted to searching out ways we can live together in peace and harmony in a free and just world where all citizens from all corners of the planet could enjoy every right to develop their potentialities and realize their capacities to the fullest.” (p. 3)

It is my hope that one day this will come true.

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Text/Service Reflection: Cosmopolitanism (Ch. 7-10) and Toward a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World

In Toward a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World, In-Suk Cha writes, "Can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures? I stand with those who contend that we are already moving toward such and ethics and it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency. We have obligations though, as we never need have if we choose to believe that we are not responsible for decisions we make and the actions we take" (6). I found that this connected well with a point that Appiah seemed to reiterate in chapter nine. "One truth we [cosmopolitans] hold to, however, is that every human being has obligations to every other. Everybody matters: that is our central idea. And it sharply limits the scope of our tolerance" (144). We are responsible for our decisions, our actions, and how our decisions and actions affect every human being that we come in contact with. This is a prime component of cosmopolitanism.

Cha argues that human nature is conflicted: "That human nature is conflicted and oppositional, there can be no doubt. That is surely one thing that every society has discovered, just as every society discovers that whatever is decent, beautiful and just exists only because of societal living. Civil union can bring out the best and likely the worst in human beings, but without civil union, there is no humanity" (10). And in societal living there must be diversity and we must consider the views of others. This is echoed by Appiah as well: "Cosmopolitans think human variety matters because people are entitled to the options they need to shape their lives in partnership with others" (104). And, "We cosmopolitans think we might learn something even from those we disagree with. We think people have a right to their own lives" (145-6).

Cha is, without a doubt, a sort of cosmopolitan.

Text/Service Reflection: Cosmopolitanism (Ch. 4-6)

In chapter five, Appiah wrote, "Conversation doesn't have to lead to consensus about anything, especially not values; it's enough that it helps people get used to one another" (85). I found that this line in particular related well to my service-learning experience. That was what much of tutoring at Marin County Community School was for me: getting used to other people who are very much unlike me (though not so much that I couldn't imagine their beliefs or use my imagination to "walk a while in their moccasins," if you will (63)) and people getting used to me.

But the thing about this is that while conversation doesn't have to lead to agreement, it can often lead to an unearthing of commonalities. Commonalities, while not always present, usually are, and they can help us to see something of ourselves in others. Commonalities, no matter how trivial, can help to place us with people who are different than us, rather than against them. In my opinion, it is the commonalities that help us to fully appreciate the differences. Appiah elucidated this when he wrote, "Once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to enjoy discovering things we do not yet share. That is one of the payoffs of cosmopolitan curiosity. We can learn from one another; or we can simply be intrigued by alternative was of thinking, feeling, and acting" (97).

There was one particular instance of this (of which I have spoken before), when I had a conversation with a girl named Olivia about food. It was getting close to Thanksgiving, and I had asked her what she was doing. She told me, and then proceeded to tell me about all of the food her family makes. Some of it was conventional Thanksgiving food, but much of it was food that I was raised on: collard greens, baked macaroni and cheese--you know, soul food. My mother lived in various Southern states growing up, and makes the best Southern food I've ever had. We had found a commonality here--a love for tasty, home-cooked food. Thus, when we shared things that the other person couldn't easily relate to or understand, we still had this small, unimportant commonality that kept us united.

I realize this is silly. But I find magic in it.

Monday, December 7, 2009

Op-Ed: Swiss Ban On Minarets Intolerant

This 20 minute discussion on Talk of the Nation was very illustrative of Appiah's points about the conversations that need to happen and the dangers of counter-cosmopolitan thinking:
Egyptian-born writer Mona Eltahawy urges Europeans to use the vote as an impetus to address long-simmering questions about how they treats immigrants. She also argues that Muslims must examine the bigoted policies of many of their own countries.
You can listen here--it is a very interesting conversation--also because of the caller comments.

And you can read her Op Ed piece here. . .

Sunday, December 6, 2009

Looking back at the notes I scribbled in the margins of this week's reading assignment, I see words like identity, traditions, culture, hypocrisy, and the like. To find an umbrella phrase that can contain these words or ideas, I think it comes down to this: what does it mean to be human? And I suppose that could be interpolated into: what does it mean to be authentic?

If to be human, to be authentic, is to follow a path not of one's own making but one that has been made by one's parents or ancestors, then is that authentic? No, I don't see how it possibly can be. The only reason to do it, that I can see, particularly if one isn't interested in living that particular life, is to appease the ancestors. Well, who then gets to choose what path to take? Apparently the ancestors (distant or recent). Is this saying that what has happened in the past--a way of life, a way of worshipping, a way of dressing, a way of behaving--is important simply because it represents what has been the status quo for a long time? For some, that may be just fine. But, as Appiah notes when writing about the westernization of dress in Vietnam, "Shouldn't the choice be theirs" (105) and not the choice of their parents or ancestors or government?

When thinking of traditions, and following one's own cultural path, it is important to remember that those traditions, those ways of life, were undoubtedly new at some point. And if that is so, that means that those traditions were introduced or discovered or stolen or created; therefore, those "traditions" have only been traditional for a finite period of time--not something that was written as the world was created. Appiah notes that even the traditional kente cloth of Ghana was not solely a Ghanian creation. First of all, it was created--so that means at some point it was brand new and may have been cause for tremendous upheaval in that society until it eventually became part of the fabric (couldn't resist!) of their lives. "And so with our kente cloth: the silk was always imported, traded by Europeans, produced in Asia. This tradition was once an innovation. Should we reject it for that reason as untraditional? How far back must one go?" (107).

Appiah writes of the popularity of American soap operas in other countries, and how some people garner different "lessons" from these shows. This reminds me of something that happened within the last few years in my own family. My daughter, Lindsey, was living in Austria, in Graz - the second largest city in Austria (which isn't really very large at all), in the southeast corner of the country near the Slovenian and Hungarian borders. When she was living there, she was playing professional volleyball, and all her teammates were Austrian--most from tiny Alpine towns or the villages around Graz, with one from Vienna, so Lindsey was considered quite exotic. At that time, the television show, "The OC" was popular in Austria, although it was called "OC California." One time, some of her teammates overheard Lindsey on the phone with me. At the end of the conversation, she said, "I love you," and I said the same thing to her. When she hung up, one of the girls, Waltraute, said, "You sound just like the OC California" (said just the way you've heard Arnold say the name of our state). This prompted a long conversation into the differences between Austrian mothers and daughters and American mothers and daughters. Apparently some of the characters on The OC were pretty free-wheeling with the I love yous. Waltraute said that she would never think of telling her mother that she loved her--why should she?--it was just silly. When Lindsey and I discussed this, I mentioned that maybe that was a cultural thing, but now that I reexamine it, it seems more likely that it is a personal choice. As a child, I don't remember my parents telling me they loved me, and I don't remember telling them I loved them--so I don’t think my "I love yous" are a cultural thing. For some reason, as an adult, I developed my own custom of telling the people whom I love that I loved them and not keeping the sentiment locked away in my mind. So, like the Zulu guy who took what lessons he needed from "Days of our Lives," (110), so I have perpetuated my own, though certainly not original or unique, custom--and it is one that my daughter also perpetuates: we end our phone conversations with "I love you." Why? Who knows? I don't remember an instance that spurred it. But I don't think it can be a bad thing to share such a powerful and elemental emotional bond.

This, I think, ties in with the contamination that Appiah discusses. And really, isn't almost every culture--at least now--contaminated in some way by other cultures? So we aren't a bunch of islands connected only by the fact that we are all humans. There are bits of this culture and bits of that culture woven throughout the world, kind of like a big patchwork quilt. But the quilt's variations differ depending on the culture of origin because what has been gleaned by one culture might not be thought of as particularly significant by another. Sort of like what lesson can be garnered from watching a soap opera. And then, if one tries to start sorting out what culture "owns" which ideal or custom or work of art, it underscores the mishmash that makes up our global society. "It is that, in simplest terms, cultural property be regarded as the property of its culture. If you belong to that culture, such work is, in the suggestive shorthand, your cultural patrimony. If not, not" (118). Interesting. But this doesn't take into account the artist's point of view. Does this mean that an artist's work isn't original but is derived from his/her country/society/culture? That's rather insulting to the artist. Or is it a point of pride for a country/society/culture to say, "See? See what somebody from here can do? And if s/he can do it, then the rest of us are pretty special too." Appiah does a good job arguing against this perspective. "When Nigerians claim a Nok sculpture as part of their patrimony, they are claiming for a nation whose boundaries are less that a century old, the works of a civilization more than two millennia ago, created by a people that no longer exists, and whose descendants we know nothing about" (119).

Cultural patrimony, seems to me, is often a synthetic, artificial, and arbitrary decision made not by the creator of the product, but by a far-removed bureaucracy. This also makes me wonder about artifacts of a people who were annihilated by conquerors--and perhaps those conquerors are the very people/society/culture now claiming those artifacts as part of their own heritage. Seems pretty hypocritical. Also, as Appiah points out, there is contamination in the art world, where ideas have been borrowed, gleaned, copied from people from other cultures. And then there are those artists who have traveled far from home to practice their art. Think of all the American artists who called Paris home. Is their library of work French or American? Does a work of art belong to any land? And if so, is it the land of creation or the land of the artist's birth? And when tracing Viking relics, how sure can one be that those relics are truly Scandinavian when the Vikings traveled (and plundered) far and wide? By decreeing that Michelangelo's artwork is the property and product of the people of Italy and the Vatican, is, I think, robbing Michelangelo of his due and allowing these other people and governing bodies the opportunity to claim ownership of his glorious talent.

So, I think if I have to label myself--which is something I prefer to resist because I think it stymies my individuality--I would have to say that as far as cultural property, I agree more with the cosmopolitan point of view that the connection to the art and artifacts of our collective past is, "…not through identity but despite difference. We can respond to art that is not ours; indeed, we can fully respond to 'our' art only if we move beyond thinking of it as ours and start to respond to it as art. But equally important is the human connection. My people - human beings - made the Great Wall of China, the Chrysler Building, the Sistine Chapel: these things were made by creatures like me, through the exercise of skill and imagination. …that potential is also within me" (135).

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Shifting Perspectives

As I jotted down snippets of ideas that occurred to me as I read this week's assignment, I realized I had a common thread running throughout. Almost everything that struck me in these readings ultimately spoke to me in terms of shifting perspectives. This may not have been Appiah's point in chapters 4-6, but it is certainly the one that jumps out at me.

For instance, in recent years, when asked to explain my spiritual philosophy, I usually say that although I was raised in a protestant family, my brother and I were expected to view the bible as a collection of stories and ideas rather than the actual word of God (how can I believe that something is gospel when it says it is okay to sell your daughter into slavery as it does in Leviticus?). So, it comes as no surprise, at least to me, that I've never been able to accept, among other things, the idea of Immaculate Conception. Because of this, my personal spiritual philosophy has just been to follow the Golden Rule: Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Well, this has served me well, but thank God I'm not a surgeon who has to grapple with whether or not to give a Jehovah's Witness a blood transfusion (60)!

All these years, I have simply accepted the Golden Rule as a fair and just guideline for my behavior and my expectations for the behavior of others. And, I still think it is--for the most part. But Appiah's argument has caused me to shift my perspective; I had never thought about the Golden Rule in the way that he discusses--that is, that my behavior expectations might not agree with the behavior expectations of others. "The first problem with the Golden Rule, in any of its versions, in practice, is that to apply it I have to know not just why I am doing what I am doing unto others--the description of the act that matters to me--but also how the act will strike others" (61). Given this shift in my perspective, I am no longer sure that my work with my service learning partner is truly beneficial. I see it as beneficial to the homeless population, but those individuals might not agree.

"The idea behind the Golden Rule is that we should take other people's interests seriously, take them into account. It suggests that we learn about other people's situations, and then use our imaginations to walk a while in their moccasins. These are aims that we cosmopolitans endorse. It's just that we can't claim that the way is easy" (63). Hmmm. Yes, I agree; perhaps my definition of the Golden Rule should be to be respectful of other people's beliefs and expect that they will be respectful of mine. Is it enough to recognize individuals rather than masses? Will this alone be enough to help one recognize what someone else's life means within the context of that person's society? While it might, I think that imagination can come into play, as Appiah noted above. As a writer of fiction, I often play little games with myself. I like to imagine a person and "walk a while in their moccasins." This is an exercise that can kick-start the writing process for me, particularly when I am trying to determine a character's actions or motivation. Sometimes, the person I imagine is very much like me, but often the person is as different from me as a sock is to a slab of marble. What, I wonder, is that person doing at that very moment? Time shifts, climate, and societal circumstances are all part of the picture, but I fill in the blanks with my imagination. This exercise provides me with writing material, but the byproduct is that it has helped me to be a more compassionate human being.

Shifting perspectives can happen because of differences in cultures, or even in changes within one society over the course of several generations. What was accepted may be no longer. What is acceptable in one culture may not be acceptable in another. In writing about values, judgments, and reasoning, Appiah notes that "…a good deal of what we intuitively take to be right, we take to be right just because it is what we are used to" (72). In writing about shifting perceptions of why we think certain things, Appiah writes, "And when it comes to change, what moves people is often not an argument from a principle, not a long discussion about values, but just a gradually acquired new way of seeing things" (71). During this portion of the text, Appiah writes about shifting perceptions of homosexuality, social and cultural trends, choices, etc.

But shifts also occur in language, as Appiah notes on page 96. I was recently reminded of this shift when my daughter sent me an e-mail with a quote from a book she was reading. She was aghast at the language used--not, I might add, because she is averse to the use of vulgarity or profanity (wtf!), but rather that a well-known author would use a term that she personally found offensive and demeaning to women. "… it's my own particular, one and only, four starred pussy. The super pussy of all old pussies." Well, my daughter was reading a book that my mother, a very ladylike octogenarian, had lent her. What, my daughter wondered, was Grandma doing reading about pussies--and why did Grandma see nothing wrong with that word? When my daughter asked her this, my mother replied, "You're being willfully obtuse." Hence my daughter's e-mail to me. So then I asked her what book she was reading. It was Agatha Christie's Death of an Expert Witness. Pussy, back then--particularly in England, was a term used to describe an old woman. Hmmm. It makes me wonder why that term was used. Was it because women were considered catty? Was it because they were warm and purred if you treated them well? Was it, in fact, actually rather demeaning? Whatever it was, it was an accepted description of females in the earlier part of the 20th century, but now it is defined as a more vulgar term--and one that implies being female and being weak, i.e., "He's such a pussy," or a crude reference to female genitalia.

Toward the end of our readings this week, Appiah delves further into universals and commonalities. He writes about the differences in perceptions of color, etc., and it got me to thinking about whether there really are any universals. Appiah had already put the kibosh on my personal, but not original, credo: the Golden Rule. Well, of course there are universals, I said to myself. How about this: to be human is to have a gender. To be male or female. But then, I thought, is this really true? Sure, the majority of humans fall into these broad categories, but what about hermaphrodites? What about the man who is sure he should have been born a woman or the woman who is sure she should have been born a man? And then, how do we even categorize what it means to be a man or a woman? What is gender? Ultimately, I suppose, it is that a man has reproductive organs that produce sperm, and a woman has reproductive organs that produce eggs and allow her to carry a fetus. So then, if that's true, what about a person who is born without a uterus or ovaries? Is that person then not a woman? And what about a man who has a vasectomy? Has he rendered himself genderless? And those who are barren--are they genderless? And what about those of us who have the reproductive apparatuses but choose to stymie them by using birth control? Are we denying our genders? And maybe this is a silly argument anyway, since a universal refers to one--it wouldn't be split into two, like I did by defining gender as being male or female. I am giving myself another headache.

But all this also brings me back to my point about shifts in language. When Thomas Jefferson wrote, "…all men are created equal…" one could argue that he was just referring to the male, white, property owners. But it is also likely that he used the word "men" to refer to all humans regardless of gender. I wonder why he didn't say "people"—perhaps he did mean just men. The utilization of words like this to refer to either gender isn't really inclusive; rather, it is just the opposite. I think it underscores the differences and, perhaps, general lack of respect for generations of women. And on this note, sometimes one wants to be able to refer to an individual without qualifying that individual with a gender-specific pronoun. One can do this in the plural with "them," but not in the singular unless you want to refer to someone as an "it." But perhaps I digress.

Appiah notes that humans have many common traits and biological natures (96). In defining Wittgenstein, he writes, "It's a shared human nature…that allows us to make sense of one another" (97). I am thinking about this in relation to my service learning work. To understand the homeless, do I need to understand that, "…the points of entry to cross-cultural conversation are things that are shared by those who are in the conversation. They do not need to be universal; all they need to be is what these particular people have in common. Once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to enjoy discovering things we do not yet share…We can learn from one another; or we can simply be intrigued by alternative ways of thinking, feeling, and acting" (97). Perhaps what I share with the homeless population that I am trying to serve is, in addition to our geographic location, the need for food, shelter, and hope. Whatever those commonalities might be, I think my perspective has gradually shifted to see what we share rather than what we don’t.

Thursday, November 26, 2009

prompt for Cosmopolitanism

Please use this prompt and weave in other aspects of the reading to support, illustrate, expand these ideas and to further explore other areas of the text:

Options, please use one or both of these suggestions to link your service experience to the themes in this week’s reading.

1. Appiah writes: “I am a philosopher. I believe in reason. But I have learned in a life of university teaching and research that even the cleverest people are not easily shifted by reason alone—and that can be true even in the most cerebral of realms” (84). Thus, he believes that conversation between people is not so much about arriving at shared agreements or to persuade the other. Instead, he sees conversation as “practice” or “deed” that may help us “to live together in peace” more than any abstract principles . “Conversations across boundaries of identity…begin with the sort of imaginative engagement you get when you read a novel or watch a movie or attend to a work of art that speaks from some place other than your own…And I stress the role of the imagination here because the encounters, properly conducted, are valuable in themselves. Conversation doesn’t have to lead to consensus about anything, especially values; it’s enough that it helps people get used to one another. (85)

Think about this statement in relation to the type of learning/understanding/expanded perspective that may be happening for you in the way that Appiah describes above.

2. Appiah discusses the idea that collective/shared identities gain strength by “othering” or defining themselves over and against an “out-group.” He suggests that one way to deal with reflex in human nature is that of the cosmopolitan who certainly holds loyalties to certain groups, to family, but also recognizes the commonality of simply being human and “once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to discuss things we do not yet share…We can learn from one another, or we can simply be intrigued by alternative ways of thinking, feeling, and acting” (97).
He continues, stating that the objection to the cosmopolitan understanding of shared humanity is that any moral interest we have in strangers can only be abstract, “lacking in warmth and power that comes from shared identity” (98). Yet, he argues, even if they are strangers, the fact of engagement itself, makes them “particular strangers; and the warmth that comes from shared identity will often be available.”

Do you have an example, a story of engagement/conversation from your service experience that illustrates this point?

Thursday, November 19, 2009

The main thing I took from this reading thus far is to learn from our differences. No one is alike. We may share common interests or have similar qualities but the whole of every person is different. So often we look for the similarities and shy away from those who are not like us, who seem strange, annoying, ignorant or unkind. I must admit I have fallen into all these categories, but I have learned the most from the people that did not come from the same places as I did or have all the luxuries that I take for granted. I have learned the most from the people who see the world in a different light then mine. " The deepest mistake, he supposed, is to think that your little shard of mirror can reflect the whole." (Appiah p.8)

The whole bit about positivism confused me a bit and I must admit also I am still plugging away with this reading as I am only on page 27.

I still get a little confused when an author starts out describing their “ism” or non-ism with another “ism” that i don’t completely understand. I get intimidated about not being able to inhabit the position of perspective that the author is asking the reader to view the argument from.


There is a little of this in Cosmopolitanism. Chapter two was a little tricky with the examples of positivism. Just when it seemed to make sense to me as he flipped backand forth between Positivism and Relativism, he seemed to lose me, but it made more sense at the conclusion of chapter two. His conclusion that “...people often recommend relativism because they think it will lead to tolerance. But if we cannot learn from one another what is right to think and feel and do, then conversation between us will be pointless. Relativism of that sort isn’t a way to encourage conversation; it’s just a reason to fall silent.” is interesting. I can’t help but think that sometimes the skills that we need to notice needs are not the same skills that we need when we are involved and occupied. Maybe relative thoughts are what gets us to the table and another set of skills will get us talking…


So then, the examples in Chapter Three underscore the value and limitations of facts when trying to come to terms. In passing I heard someone say on the radio that it is impossible to prove a negative. So many times when we disagree with what we hear and read we throw out opposing or negative arguments and they don’t lead to discussion or exchange of truth, the lead to impasse and non communication.


The metaphor of the shattered mirror was great and kept me going. The extreme examples of witchcraft, coincidence and science were helpful. I must admit that by the time I got to the end of the assigned reading I was captivated enough by the argument to read ahead. I am enjoying the book and also finding "relative" arguments to my research project..


Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers

I greatly enjoyed Appiah's introduction. Before, I was grappling with just what cosmopolitanism meant. I couldn't find a definitive answer in the previous reading, and I was--frustrated. "Citizens of the world" only went so far, but the quote from Christoph Martin Wieland put it all into perspective: "Cosmopolitans. . .regard all the peoples of the earth as so many branches of a single family, and the universe as a state, of which they, with innumerable other rational beings, are citizens, promoting together under the general laws of nature the perfection of the whole, while each in his own fashion is busy about his own well-being" (Appiah XV). And this does entail a certain sense of responsibility. Appiah suggests that we believe firmly in the significance of human life, that we have a responsibility to every person who we come in contact with.

I did find certain connections with the previous reading, especially in chapter three of Lukes, where Las Casas refutes Sepulveda: "His argument was that all human beings were alike in being rational, possessing understanding and free choice, and that all are made in the image and likeness of God--that, in short, the entire human race is one (Lukes 84). There were also connections with the discussion of anthropologists and cultural relativism, and how this may lead to a moral relativism. ". . .Many anthropologists mistrust talk about universal morality, and spend a great deal of time urging us not to intervene in the lives of other societies; if they think we have a responsibility, it is to leave well enough alone" (Appiah 14).

While I found the notion of positivism interesting, I found that I related more to the chapter "The Shattered Mirror." Though I didn't whole-heartedly agree with the idea, I do acknowledge that our perception is limited: ". . .you will find parts of the truth (along with much error) everywhere and the whole truth nowhere. The deepest mistake. . .is to think that your little shard of mirror can reflect the whole" (Appiah 8). This differs from moral relativism in that it does not say that there is no universal truth, but rather that there is no possible means of knowing the entire truth. It is a challenge for us, in our modernist age, to believe in a sense of absolute right and wrong, because science simply will not back it--but it is possible that we can know some things. This is vital.

Sunday, November 15, 2009

Text Reflection: Cosmopolitanism

Text Reflection: Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers by Kwame Anthony Appiah


I found our readings to be very interesting, and I appreciate that the author inserts his parenthetical humor into the text. Actually, I think I followed most of the text, but I confess that I found the second chapter a bit confusing; however, since (per the syllabus) we will be discussing this chapter in class, I won't try to hash it out too much right now.

It seems to me that Appiah, in Cosmopolitanism, is trying to find how different cultures are united--or if they are or can be united--by common beliefs and shared responses. I think. Furthermore, I believe Appiah is saying that our universe is full of strangers, but that there are universal characteristics: "Folktales, drama, opera, novels, short stories; biographies, histories, ethnographies; fiction or nonfiction; painting, music, sculpture, and dance: every human civilization has ways to reveal to us values we had not previously recognized or undermine our commitment to values that we had settled into" (30). He notes that, "…evaluating stories together is one of the central human ways of learning to align our responses to the world" (29).

I also thought that Appiah's discussion of how witchcraft comes into play in his homeland of Ghana was quite fascinating. At first I thought, "Pshaw," regarding witchcraft, but then as he went on to explain that just as my type of reaction was undoubtedly due to my upbringing, his Ghanaian relatives were brought up to believe in witchcraft and its power. And really, is that much different from believing in a Holy Trinity (as he also notes) or in omens or superstitions? Is it that different from believing in miraculous births, i.e., those of Jesus, Siddhartha, Lao Tse, etc.? The power of tradition is incredibly influential; likewise, so is the power of thought. If one truly believes something, I think it might be the strength of that particular belief that sustains the individual rather than whether the belief is true or not. Appiah notes, "In belief, as to everything else, each of us must start from where we are" (38).

I will end with a quote from Stuart Chase that I think is apropos: "For those who believe, no proof is necessary. For those who don't believe, no proof is possible."

Saturday, November 14, 2009

Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Stangers

I've decided that I don't need to give you a prompt. You all do a great job at engaging the text and linking to service--so, I'm leaving it wide open. If you find yourself struggling to link--email me and I will give you a prompt, no problem.

Here's my quote for the day that relates to relativism and whether or not there ARE universal moral truths:

The truth does not change according to our ability to stomach it.
- Flannery O'Connor (a great Southern novelist)

Thursday, November 12, 2009

Bioneers and social justice issues
Moral relativism is can be very difficult depending on th context and the issue at hand. Reading these articles gives me cause to examine how I might interpret a number of situations. I find myself a bit all over the place depending on the issue. Lukes speaks of switching roles between descriptive and normative as being possible but not easy (26-27). Every sort of human rights issue comes to mind.

Lukes says, " ...the relativity of morals does not mean the absence of universal acceptance, but rather denial of universal applicability" (28). I cannot help but think there are many issues that are universally applicable from a human rights stand point but not universally accepted. When each side weighs in and is at opposite ends where does that leave things personally, politically, globally? I am thinking this is why we have war. Where might the world be if the United States agreed to let Afgahnistan turn Bin Laden over to a Muslim country? Our leaders saw this action as to great a compromise...was it? Does it make since to let a particular population deal with their own extremeists? Possibly the problems are better understood by those that fully under stand the fundamentals such extremes are based on and can hold up the mirror in a more "relative" way?

I have no answers. I do know that these readings give me cause to reflect upon and examine how and why I shape my morals now and in the future, how to shape them with diversity without compromising my values in the process.


Thursday, November 5, 2009

After reading Outcasts United, again I was reminded that things are not one sided. There are always two sides to something. I felt for the old inhabitants of Clarkson and missing the “familiarity” and “simplicity” of things but also saw how with the refugee’s arrival culture grew and Clarkson expanded into a diverse town, which brought with it many positives and negatives. Some of the older inhabitants of Clarkson and police officers were not responding well to the new arrival of refuges. This was handled in many various ways but I especially resonated with the quote “ America is changing…get over it.” (p. 177) The quote reminded me of a Dylan song and also sometimes in life, you just have to get over it, accept it and not fight the changes. There will always be pros and cons to any situation.

I grew up in the south part my life and honestly feel somewhat ignorant to the fact that I never knew about refuges being sent to places like Clarkson and how much the Atlanta airport, the main hub I fly into changed smaller towns. This was an interesting thought, a cultural maelstrom of more than hundred nationalities in an area slightly larger than one square mile.” (178) That was the challenge Scipio saw and in some ways people made it work while others still had a hard time adjusting to the change. Change always has two sides and for me that’s the beautiful thing. What really moved me however was Mandela, the soccer player’s story. His love for the sport and his attitude just struck a chord in me for some reason. All and all, what a satisfying read.

Is it possible to make this required reading for society? I thoroughly enjoyed this moving, tragic and inspiring account of What is happening in America today even as I type this. I found my self relating to both sides of the issues presented in OUTCASTS. As I began reading this I Was instantly reminded of of a book I read a few years back, The Spirit Catches You and You Fall UP. I cannot remember the author. It was about a Hmong child's seizure disorder and the medical community in Merced, CA. I am a former paramedic for many years and was a young child and teenager during the Vietman War. I did not know anything about other cultures.As a paramedic in the Bay Area I was frequently called into multicultural settings though I did not recognize them as such. My measure of how to conduct myself in this "professional" setting was the other emergency personel from other agencies. I was to learn many years later how horribly we all missed the mark on serving a number of communities by not making efforts professionaly to understand cultural practices. I still feel badly about my ignorance even though I am not sure how it could have been avoided...now that is true ignorance.

Many years later upon moving to Marin County I was to find myself as being continually perceived to be on the new immigrant side of the fence. It still happpens to this day. My family has been in California since the mid-1700's. The only more indigenious people than my roots are Native Americans. But suddenly I move to Marin County and folks are treating me as sub-human, assuming I can't speak english and have no money. The stories I could tell, but back to the text.

Chapter 24, Coming Apart really states the essence of what we need to do individually, and that is be "capable of "reframing the terms of transaction between [ourselves] and newcomers in a way that emphasizes the benefits of getting involved" (220). The authors state we must first stick it out through the frustration, remain committed, understanding this is part of our lives. This is the service learning connection to strive for. Everyone benefits when one gets involved. I think this is what the Obama's are pushing for and current economic and imigrant issues are ripe for America to dive in.

Wake -Up America and embrace the ongoing changes that make this country great!


Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Reflections on "Outcasts"

Wow! This was a fascinating piece. The narrative was quite absorbing, and now I wish we'd read the whole thing. I just may need to check it out of the library so I can get the entire story.

Although I found it all interesting, I think my "aha" moments came while reading Chapters 19-24. One thing that really struck me was about how we often perceive things. For instance, some people in Clarkston focused solely on the past—and how the newcomers didn't fit into their comfortable view of Old Clarkston. But some others, even though their original intentions may have been motivated by self-interests, viewed the newcomers differently. The face of Clarkston changed from mostly native-born white Christians to a multicultural stew. The pastor of the local Baptist church said, "I tell people, 'America is changing,'…'Get over it'" (177). And although there are many challenges to integrating these vast numbers of immigrants, there are benefits to those who recognize them: "…while self-interest – economic, spiritual, emotional – might have been a motivating factor, …what was most interesting was what happened once the connecting kicked in. Bill Mehlinger …was so busy going to weddings of his current and former employees. William Perrin…looking forward to his church's potluck dinners because he so enjoyed the exotic meals… The police chief of Clarkston came to identify with the refugees…when it dawned on him that as a black man…he could have been singled out by Clarkston cops" (183-184).

Something else I found interesting was the change in perspective when looking at common denominators. If one only focuses on the differences, i.e., race, religion, traditions, it is hard to see any common ground between individuals of hugely different backgrounds. But, if one instead focuses on all the commonalities, i.e., "A Liberian refugee might be a woman, a Christian, a worker, a single mother concerned about neighborhood crime and the safety of her children…" (184), this "…renders any single category less meaningful" (185).

The final thing that struck me was that ignoring the differences between cultures was more successful than focusing on or even celebrating the differences. "As diversity becomes the norm … people cease to focus on it. Diversity becomes 'no big deal.' The key to making super-diversity work … may have less to do with embracing it than ignoring it" (185).

These readings certainly tie into my service learning, since I am doing work for an organization that tries to help the homeless, Warm Wishes. I have never been homeless, so I do not have that in common; however, as Outcasts pointed out, I have many, many more things in common with the population served by Warm Wishes than our differences. I also think that by ceasing to focus on the differences, one just might help to preserve the dignity of those one is trying to help, because I think that would help to reduce patronizing attitudes.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

A static thought

Find me a static thought

A wanton thought?

Tell me what you think

I don’t think I know

I don’t think, I know

I don’t think. I know

Become what you are

Why am I not who I am?

Because of who you are.

Facticity

If I discover that I am inauthentic
and accept it.

Is that an authentic act?

Gelassenheit

So be it.
As I think about this week's readings, I keep coming back to an image that has been popping into my mind: a gyroscope. A gyroscope, as you undoubtedly know, is a spinning wheel whose central shaft is free to take any orientation. It can spin up and down, forward and back, side to side. And like the movements of a gyroscope, authenticity does not seem to be a finite, totally definable quality, but rather one that has numerous definitions as well as an ability to change shape depending on external and internal variables. "But it also has a circular structure insofar as there is a constant back-and-forth between the meaningful possibilities of action opened by the past and the range of goals that open up the future" (129).

In addition to the various definitions and histories that Guignon has shared with us over the course of his book, I still wonder if this – authenticity - is one big ball of yarn that has no end. After all, there are so many unknowns. We know now that we on earth aren't the center of the universe, but we as individuals might often think that we are. "It's my world and you just live in it," are words that have been thrown at me by a certain angst-ridden teenager. So we are and we aren't. "…we are always embedded in and dependent on a wider, shared context of meanings we do not create ourselves" (127). And like that angst-ridden teenager, it would seem that authenticity has a singularly personal definition and yet that definition is filtered through a societal lense. It is both singular and plural. "…what is crucial about authenticity is not just the intensity of the commitment and fervor of the expression it carries with it, but the nature of the content of the commitment as well. …for a commitment to count as authentic, it is not enough that someone feels strongly about the commitment or firmly believes that undertaking it is worthwhile. For the stance to count as authentic, there must be a way for us to see how a person might have reasons to think that such an undertaking really is worthwhile at some level" (158).

What if we – the earth – are just some other-world kid's science experiment. A giant ant farm, perhaps. Would that change our perception of authenticity? Does it really matter what the external "truth" is—all those things that we cannot know? Do our lives have any less meaning if we are just "ants" to some greater mind in some other universe? I don't think so. We all have minds and the ability to think. Our thoughts, though colored by external events, are nevertheless "ours." And to have something that is "ours" or "mine" is, I believe, a form of authenticity.

I think authenticity is the "skull beneath the skin"—the very foundation or substructure that allows us to be human. "To be authentic, on this account, is to take a wholehearted stand on what is of crucial importance for you, to understand yourself as defined by the unconditional commitments you undertake, and, as much as possible, to steadfastly express those commitments in your actions throughout the course of your life" (139).

Ok, so as you guys know this blog thing is totally new to me. I think I finally figured it out though.... J

The whole time I was reading Charles Guignon’s book, On being Authentic I had the notion that we would reach one finite conclusion on what it means to be authentic. However, this was not entirely the case. Guignon’s aim I believe was to show us different and conflicting ideas of authenticity and as he states, “I am trying to call attention to the dangerous one-sidedness built into the concentration on authenticity that can arise in the self help movement. What is problematic is not the idea of authenticity, but a narrow and obsessive concern with that ideal at the expense of other valuable ideals and orientations open to us in life.” (p.167)

What a relief.

However, besides my own breath of fresh air for a criticism towards the self-help movement what is important here in a larger picture I think is the idea of one-sidedness. In the final chapters Guignon purposes that authenticity should be thought of as a social virtue and not just a personal virtue.

Calhoun raises the idea that integrity should be seen as a personal and social virtue as well and Guignon purposes that integrity is linked with authenticity which we now know is both a social and personal virtue.

It is obvious how authenticity/integrity can be identified as a personal virtue especially with correlation to the self help- movement but how is it a social virtue? Guignon summarizes Bernard Williams philosophical view, “It is only through our social interactions that we become selves whose inner episodes are given enough steadiness and cohesiveness so that our relations to others can be built on cooperation and trust.” (p.155)

This rings especially true with working with the Marin Aids Project. If the patients don’t trust their staff members, doctors etc. how can they be expected to have hope and feel safe? How can anyone be expected to help themselves or others without relating to other people and the world around them? If there are so many stigma’s and so much ignorance placed on those with HIV, AIDS Hep C or just the disease in general how can one be expected to be able to educate society and possibly help prevent the spread of this rampant disease?

We must know ourselves. We must know ourselves in relation to others. We must know others in order for they’re to be any kind of authenticity and possibility for change. We must let go of stigma’s and we must let go of our one sided minds.

“Instead of being encouraged to master every situation, it envisions a way of letting go of our own personal agendas and experiencing ourselves as participants in a shared event that is greater than ourselves. In this orientation to life, we focus not on what we can get out of a situation, but rather on what we can contribute to the situation.” (p. 166) It has been and will continue to be an honor to work with the Marin AIDS project.

Authenticity then is not a means to an end of finding the true/inner self which is so prominent in the self-help movement but rather a life process or “story” that blends self with others.

Once again I will be unable to apply this to my service but did ponder how my thoughts might relate to service in general. While reflecting on what it means to have an identity with integrity, personally and socially, I felt Calhoun explained things very well. In reading Guignon first I was annoyed and confused by Franklin's idea of wantons along with the use of the example of addicts as "lacking the kind of will necessary to being a person" (138). I initially understood it to mean these folks were to be thought of as non-human and found this profoundly wrong on many levels. I began to wonder about my classmates who work in the needle exchange program and how they perceived this statement. Guignon continues that wantons contrast to persons as a human agent because persons care about the desires that motivate them (138) a wanton knows but does not care about their motivations. This part may be true but to characterize such individuals as non humans is socially irresponsible. Who is to say what another honestly cares about or if a weak will or a genetic issue is the cause.If one defines a person as a self it is true that addictive behavior interferes greatly with authenticity and colors the ability to know ones true self. The addict however is still a human person who struggles differently than most who undoubtably has cares and desires. Calhoun cleared things up for me by explaining Franklin's wanton in a different way using terms like passive, desires and actions that are not his (236). I still think such individuals have a self as opposed to Franklin who believes they do not. The issue of integrity is another matter as this may be continually compromised by addictive desires. Calhoun continues that wantonness can effect second-order desires causing a disconnect in who they want to be and falling in with a group, not thinking on ones own and questioning if these are right values and hence not ones own values (237). This makes sense. Where does this leave us with those who make informed choices that are in opinions of others not personally or socially responsible? I am not sure. I do agree with the authors of our reading that authenticity and integrity are personal and social. Each is very individual deeply interwoven and not extractable from the other (260). Just as the world seems to be a huge puzzle and the pieces probably fit together in ways we cannot begin to imagin. This is the truly facinating part of being a human person as we interact with each other. The constant evaluation of new experiences and ideas or perspectives of others, yes even the others that may not appear to have the same idea of self and authenticity as I do can help me be more authentic and contribute with integrity. These two readings were the most illuminating and interesting since Freire. Calhoun is right on about integrity being a social virtue and out that comes service.

Friday, October 23, 2009

Prompt for On Being Authentic and Flesh and Standing for Something

In the final 2 chapters of On Being Authentic, Charles Guignon makes a few statements that should help us synthesize his proposal that authenticity might more fruitfully be considered a social virtue, as well as a personal virtue He has described the historical movements in intellectual thought that brought us to our present crux where we place high value on the development of our individual being. Yet this understanding of self-fulfillment, as an ends in itself, tends to conflict a bit with the democratic understanding that rights come with responsibilities. Our individual survival is interconnected to the condition of others.

Additionally, Chesire Calhoun, in “Standing for Something” reinforces Guignon’s final point that authenticity can be most fruitful understood as a “social virtue” (156) in which the personal undertaking of seeking to be and act authentically is “made possible by a social world in which certain democratic ideals have emerged.” Thus, “when the ideal of authenticity is understood in terms of its social embodiment [the ways in which we engage with the world] it is clear that being authentic is not just a matter of concentrating on one’s own self, but also involves deliberation about how one’s commitments make contribution to the good of the public world in which one is a participant” (Guignon, 163). Calhoun similarly argues that “integrity” can and should be seen as a social virtue for similar reasons:
Integrity calls us simultaneously to stand behind our convictions and to take seriously others' doubts about them. Thus, neither ambivalence nor compromise seem inevitably to betoken lack of integrity. If we are not pulled as far as uncertainty or compromise, integrity would at least demand exercising due care in how we go about dissenting. (260)
Please think about these ideas and one or more of the following statements in relation to your service using other quotes and concepts from the text and specific illustrations from service:

From “Story-Shaped Selves”:
Guignon describes Charles Taylor’s views:

To have an identity––to be able to answer the question, ‘Who are you?’––you must have an understanding of what is of crucial importance to you, and that means knowing where you stand within a context of questions about what is truly worth pursuing in life…To have an identity is t have some orientation in what Taylor calls ‘moral space,’ where the term ‘moral refers to whatever gives meaning and direction to a life. (136).

From “Authenticity in Context”:

G. summarizes the philosophical views of Bernard Williams:

“It is only through the our social interactions that we become selves whose inner episodes are given enough steadiness and cohesiveness so that our relations to others can be built on cooperation and trust” (155)

Thursday, October 22, 2009

In Chapter 5, Guignon uses the story of Tolstoy's Ivan Ilych to illustrate how one's perspective of success changes depending on life circumstances. For instance, Ivan Ilych had thought he was happy with his life until he became terminally ill. At that point, as he reflected upon his life, he realized that what he had classified as happy and successful was really empty and relatively meaningless in the scheme of things. He came to understand that he had been at his happiest when he was a child. "It is the nature of grown-up life that we are forced to put on masks and play out little games in order to measure up to the demands of the world. But in gaining the world, we lose our souls" (86). To put circumstances in my own life in perspective, I usually ask myself if "it" will matter to me (or others) when I am 100; this often helps me to weigh the importance of my plans and set my priorities.

Childhood, for many of us, is often remembered as a time of innocence, purity, and happiness. "Whatever the origin of the idea of childhood may be, it is now commonly assumed that the child represents human nature in its purest, most essential form. The condition of childhood is the primal source from which all else arises and unfolds" (84). But childhood, for some, can be where abuse and victimization starts.

Think of the recent news story of an Oklahoma mother of seven who allegedly kept one of her children, a boy, locked in a closet for four and one half years. The boy, who escaped, alleges that he was regularly beaten with chains, starved, and tortured by the mother and her boyfriend. As it turns out, his mother served time briefly many years earlier for killing another one of her children. Now, I have no idea if this woman beat and tortured her other surviving children, but this boy wasn't even allowed to go to school, let alone live in a clean, safe, and loving environment; it appears that this woman was picking and choosing the victims of her unbridled abuse. Clearly this young man has not had an ideal childhood.

Freud explored the "…capacity for cruelty and destructiveness in humans… " (100), saying that "Man 'is a savage beast to whom consideration towards his own kind is something alien'" (100). It is this capacity to behave horribly to others that can be manifested, according to Freud, in everything from nasty remarks to "…the atrocities of dictators…and in the actions, reported in the newspapers on a daily basis, of 'ordinary folks' who starve and beat and shame their children" (101).

The last few weeks, I have been reading about the kidnapping of Jaycee Dugard, the torture of the Oklahoma boy, and also a lengthy article about children who are sold (usually by their parents) into the Cambodian sex trade at the age of 4 or 5. It is with these unspeakably evil happenings in mind that I have filtered this week's readings. And at first, I thought Richard Rorty's positive outlook on social constructionism made sense. But then I tried to filter it through the lense of the boy who was tortured by his own mother or the children who were sold as sex slaves. "…all our possibilities of self-understanding are drawn from the pool of possibilities laid out by our historical culture, and once we see that all these possibilities are contingent, non-binding, we will see that we are free to cobble together whatever personal identity works for us" (116). So, does that mean that these children, whose historical cultures have been one of torture and betrayal by the people who should have loved them unconditionally is limited to that which they know? Or is it more like Foucault, who focused more on "…the way that modern ideas produce forms of power that dominate and oppress us, forcing us into molds that keep society functioning but do little to improve our lives" (117).

What happens to the "self " of people like those I have just mentioned? Guignon writes that, "To be a self is to be buoyed up and carried along by social forces one can never objectify and master, but it is also to be a respondent, capable of saying 'No' to some of those forces in deciding one's own life course" (122). But for some people, saying "No" might not do a thing except to bring on more torture. As Guignon notes, the postmodern self can be extremely fragile.

Finally, I would like to say that for my own "self," I like this quote: "Maturity means accepting the bad with the good" (90).

***

Julia asked if we can "… illustrate ways in which your own identity has in any way been shifted/morphed/altered through any aspect of the interactions that you have had with others through service-learning?" I don’t think my service learning with MarinLink has changed me at all. I am doing some of the same sorts of things that I do for work, so any changes would have come long ago. On more personal volunteer projects, I have felt an illumination to my outlook—an articulation of deep feelings and a greater appreciation for life. For instance, last Christmas my family decided not to give gifts to each other but to sponsor needy families instead. My daughter and I "adopted" a family where the parents do not speak English, the father works as a laborer, and the mother was recently diagnosed with cancer. Lindsey and I spent far more than we ever would have spent on our normal gift exchanges, but the experience of providing food, clothing, household supplies, and gifts to people we would never meet was heartwarming—and it also helped me to appreciate my own circumstances more. From my point of view, I appreciated the anonymity of the family—to preserve their dignity—and for us as well, because I think it is better to act without self-interest, do our duty not to seek the benefits, and not manipulate others for own interests (thank you, Mr. Kant). Okay, so now I suppose I've screwed it all up by writing about it here! That really wasn't my intent when we joined Adopt a Family Marin.

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Well, so far I have sat in front of my computer for over an hour on three separate occasions to type an intelligent response for this blog. During this time I discovered I could change the font and color. This made me happy. It is late and I have just decided to be authentic and hope I can fit a quote in for credit. The only part I resonate with is the mention of "polarized." I feel polarized and I see it all around me. To participate on this planet many faces are required of us and if we step out of the expected norm we invite problems for ourselves. I do not quite know what to make of all these ideas about the inner human. I found Freud deeply disturbing, and envisioned his theories applying mostly to the artwork of psychotic inmates (100-101). While I understand that humans can, and indeed some do, have a capacity for cruelty, I do not believe it is innate to all humans. Freud might have something when he says "...the total release of all energy is achieved only in death..." Yes this would be true, no more energy because we are dead. I can understand Miller a little better (90-91). I think the feelings he refers to as experienced by the child versus the adult is a bit like the polarity we live with daily. I was thinking of this today as I watched some preschoolers having "an incident," the perceived injustice, the anger, the defense, the breakdown, the reconciliation, the return of unbridled enthusiasm...all in a couple of minutes. We can't do that we are adults and we can "control ourselves," carry it around for an undetermined number of years and untold dollars in therapy or we can express ourselves and learn to hear and be heard (on a mature level of course) I ask which is more authentic? who is unburdened, happier? These are just some thoughts I had during the reading.

How can I apply the readings to my service learning at Asante Foundation? I really have no idea. I guess I did have two persona's at the one event I attended. The professional, I am hear to do a job and assist and be enthusiastic. While the real me was feeling foolish spreading fliers for a foreign aid fundraiser in an impoverished neighborhood. Did I say anything about the situation? No. I was not authentic. Was I socially appropriate? Yes.
This is but a small glimpse of why I feel polarized and confused.The readings have so many facets I cannot even begin to unpack it to have an opinion. Enough rambling from me. Sorry Julia it was a small bite from the other side of the cookie. See you all in class.

Friday, October 16, 2009

Prompt for On Being Authentic, Chapters 5 and 6

Okay, this is a big one--bite off what you can!

Guigon continues, in Chapter 5, to describe the ways in which our world and self views are influenced by “two deeply opposed conceptions of what life is all about” (78) and the ways in which these conflicting views have contributed to a kind of split modern personality and a series of binaries which we, consciously or unconsciously, use to understand ourselves and our relationship to the world. Guignon states that “most of us deal with the conflicting demands on us in the modern world by being instrumentalists in public and Romantics in private. That such an existence is polarized, that it breeds confusions when the private comes to be colonized by instrumentalist tendencies ––these are seen as inevitable problems of living in modern circumstances” (79-80). He goes on to say that what is of interest here is to consider the ways in which the “modern outlook is shaped by a distinctive set of binary oppositions that governs the way we sort things out in everyday life” (80). Use this chapter to explore (briefly) the implications of these opposing conceptions of selfhood and any examples you have from your own life, especially your service experience, this semester. But don’t stop there!

In the beginning of Chapter 6, Guignon sums up the concepts and ideas that he has presented thus far and then goes on to detail the post modern conception of the self which is really a non-self. Basically, the postmodern view, in this depiction, is an extension of the idea that society is a social construct–– now the individual is a product of that construct. Yet, while Guignon dismantles much of this view, he also shows how this “undoing” of the individual is also useful to countering the ways in which the ideals of individualism have gone astray in leading us to strive for an autonomy and “freedom” from worldly constraints which is neither possible or necessarily desirable. Guignon notes Richard Rorty who believed that a recognition of ourselves as socially conditioned was important for helping us to question and challenge that conditioning, even challenging what we think we believe or, as Rorty called it, our final vocabulary. For Rorty, it was important to be an “ironist”—doubting and questioning what we think we know, what may seem like the basis of our identity—for him this was the counter to fundamentalist thinking that has no room for doubt and is dangerous in a world filled with so many different worldviews.

Towards the end of the chapter, Guignon presents a “remedy” that puts the meaning back in a self and that helps us to think about the “unfinished” self that is the catalyst for Freire’s work.

To this end, Guignon introduces the concept of the dialogical self developed: by Mikhail Bakhtin. He tells us:

“The conclusion to draw from the dialogical nature of experience is that we experience the world through a “We’ before we experience it through an ‘I’…The dialogical conception of self has the advantage of making social interactions absolutely fundamental to our identity. It lets us see that being human is inextricably being part of a ‘We’” (121).

Can you illustrate ways in which your own identity has in any way been shifted/morphed/altered through any aspect of the interactions that you have had with others through service-learning?

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Text Reflection Six: Guignon and Porter

In this section of On Being Authentic, Charles Guignon investigates the self-help industry and its effect on modern consciousness. Ultimately, though, the text seems to me to be about the modern ideal of turning inward, of what being "authentic" means and how this affects our larger, social perception and awareness. Guignon also explores the historical context of the principle, shedding light on its development throughout the ages.

While striving to attain the quality of authenticity may seem, upon the initial inspection, to be absolutely constructive, there may be problems with this. In the preface, Guignon writes:


It is because of the way they lead to obsessive, almost addictive immersion in ever renewed self-improvement projects that New Age culture and self-help programs have gained a reputation for leading to excessive genuineness--the 'me, me, me' culture... (Guignon x).

In the introduction of Flesh in the Age of Reason, Roy Porter composes something not too dissimilar. While Porter delves much further into the historical context and its development over time, he too is concerned with authenticity, with what it means to "know yourself." While Porter's outlook does not seem to be so overtly negative toward the contemporary value of genuineness, it does note similar flaws (though perhaps in another manner).

The evolution of what it means to confess was intensely fascinating, and something I had never before recognized. Porter writes:

Confession was thereby transformed from an office of the Church into an
affirmation of the 'will to truth' of the sacred sovereign self within (Porter
8).

I found this significant because it seemed to show how the earlier focus on renouncing the self shifted to the modern-day focus of centering on the self.

More thoughts

The selection we read from Roy Porter's Flesh in the Age of Reason is refreshingly lucid in its discussion of "knowing yourself." Porter runs through the ages, noting examples of how and when some members of various societies started to question who they were and why they were. His integrated approach not only touches on the reflections of philosophers, but it brings the greater context into focus by including religion, art, writings, and major turning points in history, like the Reformation.

Now, I'm not sure I can articulate what it is I want to say, and that is why I did not include it in my earlier post, but here goes: I think Porter (and Guignon and Taylor too, although I didn't find them as comprehensible) really spells out how the more "we" think one way, the more likely it is to be eventually disavowed; in some cases, whatever had been disavowed, sometimes comes back into favor. I wonder if because we are human and therefore imperfect, if our thinking is imperfect too, and if this explains how ideas appear to gain or re-gain popularity throughout the ages—or is it all a series of power plays?

"Stoic philosophers like Seneca valued suicide as the only permitted expression of freedom and autonomy" (4), and later, the Catholic Church taught that "…self denial was the supreme good…" (5), and it "… squared with the medieval feudal principle that everyone had a preordained position…" (5). This would seem to me to be the power of a ruling entity (government, church) laying down the law as an absolute—and why?—because it threatened their way of life and/or their power? The ancient Greeks, too, when "Socrates and other philosophers began to give expression to the ideals of inner goodness, truth and sacred conscience…" (4) were so threatened by "…such new convictions that …advanced Athenians forced Socrates to drink the hemlock" (4).

With the Reformation, came more of a focus on the self in art and thought. And yet the pilgrims—good protestants who came to this land a couple hundred years later—were both free-thinking and terribly rigid in their thinking. That is, they wanted the freedom to pursue and practice their religion, but their religion and society were inflexible and uncompromising—and that seems to be reminiscent of many of the other societies we have learned about.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Questions. Always more questions!

Like a tree heavy with fruit, some of which is overripe, some of which is not ready to be picked, and some of which is diseased and pitted with parasites, there are maybe one or two pieces of fruit which are just right for eating. As I harvest the bounty from this tree, it is difficult for me to tell which of the fruit is just right, because from the outside they look just the same as those that aren't ready to be picked, or those that should have been picked long ago, or those whose flesh hosts unwelcome guests.

And so it is for me as I try to wade through the various theories and ideas of what it means to be authentic. In Julia's prompt, she asks that we not make judgments until we actually understand the points that the writers are making. I understand and appreciate this expectation, but how do I know whether or not I understand their logic? I don't. At times, I might think I do, but I would bet you that I don't.

I confess that I have refrained from posting on this blog until now because I have felt stymied. But I've decided that I need to do what is right for me (authentic? maybe so) and dive right in regardless of whether I am confident in my abilities to understand the concepts in this week's writings. So here goes—and I hope you will forgive me if I completely miss the point!

After reading Taylor, Guignon, and Porter, my take is that there are no right answers to the question of what it means to be authentic; however, there appear to be plenty of wrong answers. And some of the answers, right or wrong, are almost circular in that they seem to go around and around an idea but not through its heart. Maybe, though, that is the nature of philosophical writing. And the more I read about being authentic, the more I wonder just how important it is. Well, now that I see that in black and white, that statement seems silly—of course it is important to be authentic! It's just that it seems like these writers are making it more complicated and confusing than necessary.

Last week, when I was reading Taylor, an impression I noted was that a personal mission statement—something like corporations and school districts and other entities use to define their goals and intentions—might be necessary to be an authentic human being. But then that also seems kind of silly. After all, I know me, I know what interests me, I know what expectations I have for myself and others, and I know my faults. If I intrinsically know these things, why is it necessary to spell them out?

Maybe I'm not explaining this well. I guess it is that some of what these writers espouse seems so clearly manmade and somewhat artificial (surely the antithesis of being authentic) and are therefore off-putting. Should we look within to find the answers? Well, yes, but don't forget to think about society. If the answers are within me and I find them, and if I remember to include society in my mission, will I be an authentic human being? Maybe, but probably not. But then, if the answers really are within me, don't I run the risk of being selfish and self-centered? Yes. And if the answers are within me, why would it matter how someone else defines being authentic, because wouldn't that person's definition be centered on his/her own beliefs? And if I decided that following my own common sense and trying to live the Golden Rule weren't authentic and instead tried to follow someone else's definition, how authentic could that be? And in doing that, wouldn't I lose the essence of me?

Fairly early in On Being Authentic, Guignon writes, "The ideal of authenticity has two components. …get in touch with the real self we have within…through introspection, self-reflection or mediations…express that unique constellation of inner traits in our actions in the external world—to actually be what we are…in our relationships, careers, and practical activities" (6). This would seem to support my personal definition of being authentic, but I have a niggling feeling that I am missing his point. And, to paraphrase Gertrude Stein, what if when we listen to ourselves there is no there there? Guignon, too, writes, "What if it turns out that this true self includes some fairly nasty—or even worse, banal—characteristics, traits we would prefer not to think of as really us…and…are actually products of the latest fads and fancies…" (9).

"For many people, the quest for authenticity has turned out to be a setup for disappointment and failure…'they must not be doing it right'" (8). Guignon also notes the possible pitfalls of self-help programs, "…many people…end up feeling frustrated and defeated, unable to understand why such a good program of self-improvement turned out to be so disappointing" (x). But then, Guignon also skewers some of my own philosophy—at least some of which is mentioned in the previous two paragraphs (finding the answers within me and following the Golden Rule)—he writes that what is lost includes, "…the notion of an authoritative source of direction and insight I can turn to in order to learn how I should live my life. For when my guide is understood as nothing other than me, it is hard to see what authority this guidance could or should have" (xii). That seems rather paternalistic to me. As humans, we are blessed with brains that are individual and creative and reflective; why can't we be our own authorities? I don’t think life, or authenticity, is like an algebraic equation where variables (our goals and ideas) can only be solved in one way with a theorem or formula.

If self-help gurus "…have an effect of pressuring people into thinking in ways that confirm the ideology of the founders of the program…" (9), how is this different than following what Guignon has to say? Now, I might be the only person in the U.S. who has never seen an Oprah show or Dr. Phil, and I have never followed (at least, I don't think I have) a self-help program, but I do think that whatever means that might help someone live a happier, more fulfilling life is wonderful. However, since it appears that Guignon may be opposed to the self-help movement, what is he doing, then, writing about authenticity? Or is his view that learning to be authentic is fine for philosophers but not for regular people? Couldn't his book be defined—if one is bent on always defining something—as a self-help book? And isn't "self-help" just a label, just as "being authentic" is too? (I'm giving myself a headache.)

If I am a doer and am reflective and consider others, does that make me authentic? Or am I just occasionally authentic—like a tourist? Do I need to have a place in the scheme of things as Guignon notes that a Platonic reading of Socrates would suggest? I don't think so.

I will be interested to see where Guignon takes his thoughts in future chapters. Right now in the book, stuck in premodern times, with ancient rites and rituals, the biblical narrative structure (more circular thinking), it would seem that there are no right answers. But then, maybe we don't need the answers from outside sources; maybe all the answers we need are within us.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Prompt for On Being Authentic and Flesh in the Age of Reason

In our reading from Ethics of Authenticity, Taylor points to the ways in which the moral ideal of authenticity was morphed into a focus on self-fulfillment that focuses only on the self, as if meaning/authenticity/true selfhood can best be "achieved" through a solitary process requiring a kind of retreat from the mundane, the everyday aspects of our lives (think Siddhartha as an aesthete). But, Taylor suggests, that in order to find the meaning we seek, that true self, it is important to understand that "we exist in a horizon of important questions" not just our own. We are embedded in a larger and very significant context. Maybe not all good or ideal but part of who we are and the self-defining choices that we make. He writes, "To shut out demands emanating beyond the self is precisely to suppress the conditions of significance, and hence to court trivialization" (40).
Guignon basically takes up Taylor's argument right there by examining the self-help movement and the formulaic approaches to "finding oneself" (again, think Siddhartha!).
Both of this week's readings deal with the tension between different ideas of selfhood and the striving for meaning/authenticity. Taylor and Porter begin to outline two different and often conflicting conceptions relating to the ideal of "being true to oneself," what it means to be "authentic," to "know oneself" that Taylor circled around. Both are extremes: self-denial/self-emptying/self-loss/self-abnegation/releasement vs self-possession/enownment/author of your own destiny.
Porter writes, "Thus, at the dawn of the twenty-first century, the sense of self needs rethinking" (16). Guignon believes that the "very notion of an intrinsically good, substantial self lying within becomes increasingly problematic in the contemporary world" (xii-xiii).
Use the texts to explore and illustrate the different, if flawed or extreme, ideals of selfhood that the authors describe. Some of you didn't quite catch the nuanced way in which Taylor forms his arguments, he lays out different perspectives but this doesn't mean that he is defending or putting out these ideas himself. You will see that Guignon does this also, he talks about this methodology in the preface. Philosophical writing is complex, so please try to understand what the authors are saying, what their project is, before deciding to argue a point. Critical thinking/reading is about investigation of and interaction with the text to increase your understanding of the concepts, if you disagree then be sure to use quotes to argue your point and make sure that you understand the larger context from which you pluck them. . .

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Of all the quotes I gathered in my notes, I'm drawn back to this one: “To accept and respect what is different is one of those virtues without which listening cannot take place. ... If I consider myself superior to what is different, no matter what it is, I am refusing to listen. The different becomes not an “other’ worthy of respect, but a “this” or “that” to be despised and detested. This is oppression....”


When we accept this definition of oppression, we become obliged, now that it is named to recognize it when it occurs, and speak up for ourselves, and for others who might not be able to speak up for themselves, and to guard against our own ability to oppress others.


I think that everyone has had the feeling that they were not being listened to at one time or another. The older we get the more opportunities we have to feel this way. When the word oppression is applied it is surprising to feel or realize the truth of that. We sometimes accept too much that our opinions don’t count as much as “experts” or authorities. Listening without judgement is a practice.


Thursday, September 24, 2009

I thought I'd share a couple more quotes from Pedagogy of Freedom that I really like:

“My security is grounded on the knowledge, which experience itself confirms, that I am unfinished. On the one hand, this knowledge reveals to me my ignorance, but on the other hand, it reveals to me that there is much I may still come to know" (120).

I love this because it affirms exactly how I feel. Ignorant? Well, perhaps. But how conceited it would be to assume one already knows everything there is to know. And how boring would it be if we were all perfect, finished products? When I make mistakes, I often say, "Perfection is boring--or so I have been told." I would rather believe that there is always something more to learn, more to grasp, more to share, more to enjoy. And I believe there is.

Here's another quote I really like:

“Joy does not come to us only at the moment of finding what we sought. It comes also in the search itself. And teaching and learning are not possible without the search, without beauty, and without joy” (125-126).

I don't think this needs any elaboration!

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Pedagogy of Freedom-comments

I agree with Peggy's comments on curiosity. I feel it is a vital human element without which we might not have progressed at all. It is my favorite thing about preschoolers-everything is new, exciting and wonderfully cool. If you are excited, they are excited. I believe Freire wants us to approach our experiences in much this same manner. On page 119 Freire talks about "permanent openness." He says we need to be "open to approaching and being approached, to questioning and being questioned, to agreeing and disagreeing." this is my favorite "It is an openness to those who call on us and to the many and varied signs that catch our interest..."

The responsibility we have with the new information we gain from our curiosity Is to "accept and respect what is different" Freire continues that this "is one of those virtues without which listening cannot take place" (108). Listening to other is crucial. Peggy gives a perfect example when seeking around the issue of gay marriage. She talked to those whose lives were involved, she listened and formed her ideas and since we are all human it is a human rights issue and all humans have equal rights. As Freire also says if one is prejudiced against someone or something, then one cannot listen to them or speak with them, only at or to them. He says that person forbids themselves from understanding them, considering themselves superior to what is different (108). This is the dangerous ground we live in. It is through curiosity and listening with out judgement that we tackle the ethical issues that confront us. If we listen to others with an open curious heart and mind we may begin to understand the ethical decisions of others and we may find our own ethical ground becoming stronger as a result.

"It is thus that I travel the road, knowing that I am learning to be who I am by relating to what is my opposite" (Freire 119).

FYI this is my first time blogging and I was a bit intimidated and afraid (I do not know why). I almost did not do it. But guess what? I opened myself up to it and it was fun!