Monday, March 29, 2010
Thursday, March 25, 2010
from Cathy. . .
I think the following passage explains her position on this question:
Where we are all guilty nobody is. Guilt, unlike responsibility, always singles out; it is strictly personal. It refers to an act, not intentions or potentialities. It is only in a metaphorical sense that we say we can say that we feel guilty for the sins of our fathers, or our people or mankind, in short, for deeds that we have not done.. . . (147).
By this, I think that she is saying that we can only feel vicariously responsible, because guilt requires a direct act by a single individual upon whom blame be laid. Collectively, though when groups are responsible, say in the example of an army committing war crimes, their leaders are typically to blame for massive troop crimes committed acives cording to what they felt their mission and marching orders were, as opposed to a rogue soldier acting out of line from the mission and stated tactics.
On collective responsibility Arendt writes: “No individual and personal standards of conduct will ever be able to exercise us from collective responsibility [because I think] . . . it is the price we pay for the fact that our lives are not by ourselves but among other fellow men, and that the faculty par excellence, can be actualized only in one of the many and manifold forms of human community” (157). I am having a hard time relating this to the mission of my community partner Warm Wishes, because it is difficult to convince myself that I a directly or collectively responsible for the fact that some people re homeless. Is my good fortune to be in a secure and stable position and have a home somehow contributing to the fact that some are homeless? I ask myself this question but know that those who respond to the call of my community partner for help (or not), may also have this question if they were to read Arendt’s work.
Implications of Not Thinking: absence of thinking and in re “the banality of evil”
Arendt; Responsibility and Judgement
Thinking and Moral Considerations
Hannah Arendt and the Modern Moral Standard
It would have been nice to have more time to let Arendt's concepts be absorbed upon the palate. Most of her points are arguments are drawn from other philosophical works, and are therefore it is easy to get lost within her lines of logic and reason. I have read several of Plato's works, and have fortunately read Kant and Machiavelli as well as several others she pulls her ideas from. Nevertheless, I immediately was able to connect to her concept of collective versus individual in her statement that "Where all are guilty, nobody is." It is very true! It is a way of wiping the slate clean when there has been so many wrongs committed that pointing fingers becomes useless. Also, guilt is a form of self punishment. It is the inner-dialogue we hold within ourselves when we feel that we have done wrong to others. This is what I feel Arendt is drawing attention to be connecting it to the Socratic proposition that "it is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong." But as she points out further in the reading, it implies that one or the other must exist exclusively. As if there is no option of neither being wronged or doing wrong. It is only in those marginal situations that Arendt argues that this moral proposition is valid. Yet even being valid, it can only be applicable among those of conscience who are willing to suffer. Only by being "used to living explicitly with oneself," does the argument have meaning. Those who are not connected to their conscience and self to this degree will not recognize the value in not "following the herd."
Unlike the idea of collective guilt, collective responsibility on the other hand can exist. But this is true in circumstances under which two fundamental rules apply. First, what a person is being held accountable for is for something that person has not done themselves, and that the group involved is a group to which that person cannot voluntarily be removed from. As an American citizen, for example, the actions that are taken in our name like acts of diplomacy or acts of war, speak for everyone who is here. How the world and others view us is through that lens. We are all held accountable for those actions whether or not we personally enrolled in the military or the peace corps to serve out various actions related to declarations of governmental entities. I see a bit of this collective responsibility in the work I do with my community partner. Many of the young men we work with view White people with ambivalence and distrust. To them they often represent the have-mores who make the rules for the have-nones, and their frame of reference is usually members of law enforcement or politicians with ulterior motives for offering assistance. So when I am there offering help, they are trying to figure out which of the two I am. Only after visiting on a number of occasions have they started to be open to me partaking in the meetings and events. My presence there reminds them of all the negativities in their world, so part of what I am doing there is providing an alternative view of Whites (even though I consider myself multiracial).
The way Arendt describes the thinking process and the concept of conscience, the connection is made that only "good people" are bothered by a bad conscience. This leads us back to the readings on How We Decide. Those who were capable of the most egregious violence were also very indifferent to the impact those acts of violence had on their victims and their families. They had an inability to plug into the collective emotional state. But this is a separate type of thinking than mechanical or rational thought. Many of these same criminals would test as geniuses on intelligence tests. It is the concept of empathy through connection to the collective body that permits the forms of moral precedence as laid out by Arendt.
The development of the (American) modern moral standard stems from when, as Arendt rightly states, "the emphasis shifted entirely from care for the world and the duties connected with it, to care for the soul and its salvation." We see examples of Arendt's statement in every governmental attempt to regulate morality based upon religious principles. We can also see this if we look at how Corporations are structured. They are structured as a collective to avoid responsibility as an individuals. The further away the individual is from the people directly affected by their negative (or immoral) decisions, the easier it is for them to dismiss responsibility. It is the slippery slope we slide in the insurance industry as well. The more bodies between the softer the blow of both guilt and responsibility.
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
Oops I forgot to tie this into our service learning
Thinking and Moral Considerations
Collective Responsibility
Julia… you were not kidding about Arendt. There is a lot to digest. You quote the line from Arendt ”We can escape this political and strictly collective responsibility only by leaving the community, and since no man can live without belonging to some community, this would simply mean to exchange one community for another and hence one kind of responsibility for another.” I highlighted this quote as well because of how I saw St Vincent de Paul’s and its place within our community. Do we all have “collective and vicarious responsibility in which the member of a community is held responsible for things he did not participate in but which were done in his name.” as Arendt states it on page 154; you bet. But my experience at Vinnie’s exemplifies that this is not how the “surrounding community” feels. It seems like the approach to the homeless and the poor is to try and force them out of the community. The larger community would rather not acknowledge this segment of the community. Marin county is in dire need of a overnight shelter, which the community, the city and the county do not want to provide because they are pressured from business’ and people living in the county who do not want to end up next to a shelter. Private interests don’t want to live or work next to a place that caters to the people who need this type of assistance. So here we see collective guilt being pushed away, not by leaving the community, but by pushing the issue, in this case the homeless and poor and they shelter they need out of the community. If we don’t see it, it does not exist, right? Out of sight out of mind?
I live in Marin; I have a good job and a nice home. Sometimes I lose track of the fact that there are many people who suffer from many hardships and struggle day to day, but these folks are still part of my community and I am still responsible for them and their plight, Vinnie’s reminds me of that fact.
"What is important in the world is that there be no wrong; suffering wrong and doing wrong are equally bad" Never mind who suffers it; your duty is to prevent it. page 153.
Arendt talks about they way "thinking" stops us from doing. "For it is true that he moment we start thinking on no matter what issue we stop everything else, and this everything else, again whatever it may happen to be, interrupts the thinking process." page 165. Later in that page Arendt relates that as soon as we "think" about someone or something it is "removed from our senses. And while our class discussions are great and putting our ideas into words via the blog or short papers helps us organize our thoughts it is the experience of our actual work with our community partners that I believe has the biggest impact. We feel, we sense, we relate, we have real conversations, we have real emotions when we are actually working in our community environments. Arendt does not use this argument to promote action. In fact later Arendt states ""How can anything relevant for the world e live in arise out of so resultless and enterprise?" page 167. She a few words latter proposes "we have to trace experiences rather than doctrines." Is this her way of saying to us to go out and live and involved life? Will this lead to more knowing than thinking? Marty
Sunday, March 21, 2010
Prompt for Week of 3/21
Please be aware that I am pulling quotes and not providing the full context. When using any quotes in relation to your service, or otherwise, you need to look at the context in which the statement is made in the larger reading in order that your interpretation honors the author’s project (at least to the extent that you understand that to be).
Consider how one or more of these statements/ideas are manifested in your service experience Think about the actions of those you work along side with in your organizations--those who run the organizations and/or the other participants, such as those whose interests are recognized/served etc. (For more ideas/questions that you can be asking yourself to aid your reflective process, please refer to the Tips for Text/Service Responses that I have posted under assignments).
Hannah Arendt writes in the chapter "Collective Responsibility": "we are always responsible for the sins of our fathers as we reap the rewards of their misdeeds, either morally or legally, nor can we ascribe their deeds to our own merits."
She continues in the next paragraph, "We can escape this political and strictly collective responsibility only by leaving the community, and since no man can live without belonging to some community, this would simply mean to exchange one community for another and hence one kind of responsibility for another" (150).
At the conclusion of this chapter, she writes that the "vicarious responsibility for things we have not done, this taking upon ourselves the consequences for things we are entirely innocent of, is the price that we pay for the fact that we live our lives not by ourselves but among our fellow men, and the faculty of action, which, after all, is the political faculty par excellence, can be actualized only in one of the many and manifold forms of human community" (157-158).
“I tried to show that our decisions about right and wrong will depend upon our choice of company, of those with whom we wish to spend our lives” (145-146).
And here is an extra interpretive challenge-- from, “Thinking and Moral Considerations”—can you use your service experience to help illuminate what Arendt means?
“Human consciousness suggests that difference and otherness . . . are the very conditions for the existence of man’s ego . . . For this ego, the I-am-I, experiences difference in identity precisely when it is not related to the things that appear but only to itself” (184).
Thursday, March 4, 2010
Kindness: its in everyone
Everyone is born good but situations and the environment the person lives in may make them an unkind person. No person is extremely kind all the time or extremely rude all the time. There just has to be a balance in many people’s lives. Even the kindest person can be the rudest at times. Every person is kind and mean. Those that are mean for the most part is because life has not treated them in a “fair” way. They have no other or know no other way but to be mean and act upon what has been done to them. I may ve a defense mechanism. At times feelings of greed or jealousy may trigger the act of unkindness or meanness.
Like all things or acts in live there is a pro and a con to kindness. Sometimes being kind may lead to others taking advantage of someone else. It may lead to using them for the interest of others. That is an example of how situation make or lead many to be unkind. It also gives many a reason to fear kindness. At times when someone is being kind one double thinks and might come to the thought that the kind person probably is acting kind because of something he or she wants.
What Hobbes says about human’s being selfish beasts could not be true. If it was, how could one explain how parents take care of their families? When doing so they are taking care of another being even if it is for self interest (this goes back to the parent/child relationship of kindness).
Kindness is a virtue but for the strong because those who are kind are willing to open up and risk getting hurt. They are willing to get to know and understand others that may not have it as easy. Kindness is an act of being fair; it is an act of being human. Kindness is also an act of humility, for no one is better or worse than any other. It is like a saying g in Spanish: Today for you tomorrow for me. Because no one ever knows when one may need a kind person.
from Katherine
Katherine 3/ 4/10
Kindness
According to the authors: “most people as they grow up now believe that kindness is a virtue of losers.”( 9)
A rather grim outlook on life if this is a true statement about most people. My perception of kindness is that it can only be derived from ones interaction with others and how he or she perceives self. Kindness is not derived or motivated by the adulation of others. Acts of kindness are not delivered in a big box nor wrapped with a big red bow but are silently distributed unwrapped by the actions of thoughts for another person not by an “ought.”
The people who believe that “kindness is a virtue of losers.” Who are they?
Are they a part of a collective society that engages with others or are they on the sidelines observing, pre-judging, and finding faults in others? If that is the case, then the grim attitude towards kindness is manifested from within, not because of their interaction with others.
According to Marcus Aurelius: “A man’s true delight, is to do the things he was made for. He was made to show goodwill to his kind.”(18)
Generally speaking, I think people are basically kind towards one another and those who volunteer consistently year after year in their communities amaze me. Volunteerism describes what kindness does and makes possible. For example, non- profit organizations rely on volunteerism to provide services that are not otherwise addressed as a need by government agencies. Collective groups of men and women, young and older enhance their own lives through acts of charitable acts of kindness; such as, donating their time, and their goodwill towards a cause they believe in without pay. People are kind to one another everyday because it makes them feel good and connected to the human race.
According to Francis Hutchinson: “To be kind is the greatest measure of human happiness. Kindness to others produces happiness to the recipient of the action. Kindness is an innate quality that exudes from a person who gives it freely without primordial thought of the deed but is a form of love for our humanity. “We become in some measure the same person this is our source of our fellow being?(
I have numerous experiences of acts of kindness bestowed upon me all the time and it does radiate into my overall feeling of happiness. I also consider any act of kindness connects us to divine part of our selves and develops the desire to contribute to the well being of humanity.
My daughter Meghan has a classmate whose parents are recently divorced. The split of the family has so stressed this classmate that she pulls her hair one strand at a time and then eats any skin that is pulled off with the hair. While hearing this story I can tell Meghan and Jack are not sure how to react. They think it is gross, which it is, and because of being unsure and uncomfortable they tend to want to laugh at it. My wife Kate and I then talk to them about having kindness and sympathy for this classmate and try and get them not to pass along this story as gossip. We talked to them about what might be causing her to do this and why laughing at the story is not appropriate and that we all struggle at times and react differently. Where am I going with this story? I do not know, but I do know that the formative years are so important in any one's life that we need to look at this. How can we make sure everyone is loved, cared for, educated and shown a good example?? Now there is a question for you. Otherwise we end up as ON KINDNESS and Rousseau state on pg 36 in "Modern man has not lost just their kindnesss, but themselves: 'They don't know how to love themselves; they only know how to hate what is not themselves.'" Ouch!
Capitalism and Kindness
Still trying to figure out kindness...
I agree with the book that Modern society does promote individualism and independence from others. And it has made us think that being vulnerable and showing kindness to others is a sign of weakness. But I believe it is a sign of weakness if we cannot show this vulnerability to others and it shows that we are too scared to open ourselves to other people. "...the ways that we protect ourselves tend also to be the ways that we imprison ourselves" (pg. 63). If we do not allow ourselves to be kind to others, and allow that feeling of involvement with people, we are depriving ourselves of love and personal growth. I know personally, I have a hard time allowing myself to be vulnerable to another person, and I think it is because I am afraid that they will not reciprocate that vulnerability. But as I mentioned, this fear "imprisons" me, and I am left alone with my feelings. I am protecting myself from facing myself. "...our resistance to kindness is our resistance to what we can see in ourselves and others..." (113). Maybe we are all afraid of ourselves, but as the book says we are all vulnerable. And if we feel good after allowing ourselves to be vulnerable and kind to one another, why don't we just keep doing that.
On page 10, the book said "We are disturbed by kindness", and immediatley I thought, "No I am not!". But after reading the book and trying to think through what kindness really is, I see that I am at times "disturbed" by it, only because it forces us to be vulnerable and intimate with ourselves and each other. As the book says, "It is kind not to overprotect people from oneself...". By overprotecting yourself, you cannot help your self or anyone else. It seems like it is easy to avoid dealing with the aspects of life that we don't want to face, but in reality, it is makes life harder.
from Cathy. . .
The text spoke a lot about how Rousseau’s work. What bothered me about Rousseau, despite his fame for his philosophical prowess, was his inability to apply human kindness in his own life. Anyone who puts his own five children into orphanages to protect them from his wife’s relatives has a serious problem with human kindness (37)! It was disturbing to read that. As to whether the egoists or the benevolents have a better rationale for kindness, I’m not sure where I stand on that argument. I’d need to re-read this to get a better sense of who is who. But I recognize the male vs. female tendencies described in the book (the self-interested egoist male mentality, versus the bleeding heart feminine mentality) toward kindness (44), as, unfortunately, still relevant today in our society; an adamant man is perceived as assertive, while an adamant woman is perceived as hysterical….. and so on. Also interesting was the notion that helping those who suffer only encourages more suffering “overbreeding” (38-39).
I found the early philosophers who argued that infants are self absorbed, selfish beasts to be absurd. If we all acted out against our infants for such behavior the human race would have ceased to exist long ago. Thank heaven for the natural female sympathetic tendency toward her infant, and others, for that matter!
Ascending the Golden Rule
On Kindness stated it best I think on page 49, “In short, only an adult, who has learned to bear frustration, is capable of putting the needs of someone else before her own.” Couldn’t this be a definition for parenthood? I think every parent has had to learn how to bear such things on an almost daily basis. And perhaps because women have been expected to fulfill this nurturing role most often, it is inevitable that women should be seen as icons for this type of relationship as adults.
Where the text lost me was in getting all wrapped up in Freud. We have to remember to take Freud in proper context. Yes, he provided some fantastic insight into how the brain works and had some innovative ways of looking at human interaction and sexuality. However, his patients were primarily women who decided of their own accord that they needed therapy and could AFFORD the services he provided. In this way his findings are about a very specific demographic an not the population at large. I personally do not feel that the underlying intentions behind our actions are a cat and mouse game of sexuality. That is really an over simplification.
I agree with On Kindness on the theory that we seek from others the things that we are unable to provide for ourselves. And how we go about receiving those things from others without manipulation is the trick. Relationships between people have become so transactional that it can be difficult to know if we are being honest with ourselves regarding our intentions with others. This is becoming an ever greater concern as we are gradually losing our spiritual self amidst the materialness of our capital driven culture. The more we identify with the “things” around us the less we are identifying with what is within us: our spirit. It is when we are most connected to ourselves that we are capable of reading other’s needs. But in order to desire being kind one has to choose it of their own accord. On Kindness says this well on page 50, “Ordered to be kind, we are likely to be cruel; wanting to be kind, we are likely to discover our generosity.”
We do not like the shackles of obligation. We embrace free will! We want to see that we are choosing to be kind. If it is an expectation, it takes away the gesture of generosity altogether. This is why mandated community service becomes a sentence. Because it is seen as a punishment, the notion of helping others as a positive experience is almost completely lost.
It is easy for us to get lost also in the idea of individualism. Because we pride ourselves on our ability to be self-sufficient, we lose the beauty of our symbiotic relationship to every other being we share this planet with, animals and humans alike. On Kindness states, “We are all dependant creatures, right to the core.” (pp. 96) But this gives no credence to the truly collectiveness of it. Like we breathe in and out, bringing in what we need, we breathe out what others need. Balance. A careful construction of healthy co-dependency. To simply call it dependency, makes it feel again like obligation.
Kindness. Loving oneself enough to love others. That is really all it is.