Tuesday, October 11, 2011

----

Morality is a difficult concept to define and there are so many different factors that play into what one may believe is moral or immoral. First we realize that when determining which situations are moral and immoral we initially react with emotion and then with reason we support that reaction. Further, we know that were are person moral situations and impersonal moral situations where one directly involves another person and the other is indirect. But these two chapters just got me thinking about another moral conflict.

Why is it legal in some U.S. states for first cousins to marry but it is still illegal for gay couples to marry? I personally think that marrying one's cousin is immoral, but am unable to provide a legitimate reason such as those in the study of the case. Yet if that's something they want to do, that is their decision. It affects those two people and all others associate by choice In the beginning, I didn't understand why one was gay or lesbian, and it wasn't that I was ignorant or that I was against the idea, I just was not educated. After a while, it was that I just wanted everyone to be happy, their business is their business but I was still uneducated. Finally, I got some insight. A friend of mine was questioning a girl about why she chose to be lesbian, and her reasoning was that she didn't choose anything. There wasn't anything specific that a guy couldn't give her, it was just that the girl in her life was better than the rest. The argument was not about gender vs gender; It was about her partner above any other contender. That's when everything made sense for me. There are so many who would say that their relationship is immoral, but for what reasons? Is it beneficial or detrimental to society that our morals are first based on emotion and then later supported by reason? Because if given this situation to a sample of people, there would be those against it and those for it. If moral decisions require taking every one into account and we feel empathy towards all human beings, why is it that we stand in the way of someone else's happiness? Why do some engage in violent acts to prevent another's hopes and dreams? The extreme cases can even be termed hate crimes. That is what I believe is immoral. If we are truly an altruistic society and we have an innate ability to feel empathy for others, why are we so quick to cause pain in lives of these specific human beings?

Although it was a short response, I couldn't have felt more.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.