Friday, November 27, 2009
Thursday, November 26, 2009
prompt for Cosmopolitanism
Options, please use one or both of these suggestions to link your service experience to the themes in this week’s reading.
1. Appiah writes: “I am a philosopher. I believe in reason. But I have learned in a life of university teaching and research that even the cleverest people are not easily shifted by reason alone—and that can be true even in the most cerebral of realms” (84). Thus, he believes that conversation between people is not so much about arriving at shared agreements or to persuade the other. Instead, he sees conversation as “practice” or “deed” that may help us “to live together in peace” more than any abstract principles . “Conversations across boundaries of identity…begin with the sort of imaginative engagement you get when you read a novel or watch a movie or attend to a work of art that speaks from some place other than your own…And I stress the role of the imagination here because the encounters, properly conducted, are valuable in themselves. Conversation doesn’t have to lead to consensus about anything, especially values; it’s enough that it helps people get used to one another. (85)
Think about this statement in relation to the type of learning/understanding/expanded perspective that may be happening for you in the way that Appiah describes above.
2. Appiah discusses the idea that collective/shared identities gain strength by “othering” or defining themselves over and against an “out-group.” He suggests that one way to deal with reflex in human nature is that of the cosmopolitan who certainly holds loyalties to certain groups, to family, but also recognizes the commonality of simply being human and “once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to discuss things we do not yet share…We can learn from one another, or we can simply be intrigued by alternative ways of thinking, feeling, and acting” (97).
He continues, stating that the objection to the cosmopolitan understanding of shared humanity is that any moral interest we have in strangers can only be abstract, “lacking in warmth and power that comes from shared identity” (98). Yet, he argues, even if they are strangers, the fact of engagement itself, makes them “particular strangers; and the warmth that comes from shared identity will often be available.”
Do you have an example, a story of engagement/conversation from your service experience that illustrates this point?
Thursday, November 19, 2009
The main thing I took from this reading thus far is to learn from our differences. No one is alike. We may share common interests or have similar qualities but the whole of every person is different. So often we look for the similarities and shy away from those who are not like us, who seem strange, annoying, ignorant or unkind. I must admit I have fallen into all these categories, but I have learned the most from the people that did not come from the same places as I did or have all the luxuries that I take for granted. I have learned the most from the people who see the world in a different light then mine. " The deepest mistake, he supposed, is to think that your little shard of mirror can reflect the whole." (Appiah p.8)
The whole bit about positivism confused me a bit and I must admit also I am still plugging away with this reading as I am only on page 27.
I still get a little confused when an author starts out describing their “ism” or non-ism with another “ism” that i don’t completely understand. I get intimidated about not being able to inhabit the position of perspective that the author is asking the reader to view the argument from.
There is a little of this in Cosmopolitanism. Chapter two was a little tricky with the examples of positivism. Just when it seemed to make sense to me as he flipped backand forth between Positivism and Relativism, he seemed to lose me, but it made more sense at the conclusion of chapter two. His conclusion that “...people often recommend relativism because they think it will lead to tolerance. But if we cannot learn from one another what is right to think and feel and do, then conversation between us will be pointless. Relativism of that sort isn’t a way to encourage conversation; it’s just a reason to fall silent.” is interesting. I can’t help but think that sometimes the skills that we need to notice needs are not the same skills that we need when we are involved and occupied. Maybe relative thoughts are what gets us to the table and another set of skills will get us talking…
So then, the examples in Chapter Three underscore the value and limitations of facts when trying to come to terms. In passing I heard someone say on the radio that it is impossible to prove a negative. So many times when we disagree with what we hear and read we throw out opposing or negative arguments and they don’t lead to discussion or exchange of truth, the lead to impasse and non communication.
The metaphor of the shattered mirror was great and kept me going. The extreme examples of witchcraft, coincidence and science were helpful. I must admit that by the time I got to the end of the assigned reading I was captivated enough by the argument to read ahead. I am enjoying the book and also finding "relative" arguments to my research project..
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers
I did find certain connections with the previous reading, especially in chapter three of Lukes, where Las Casas refutes Sepulveda: "His argument was that all human beings were alike in being rational, possessing understanding and free choice, and that all are made in the image and likeness of God--that, in short, the entire human race is one (Lukes 84). There were also connections with the discussion of anthropologists and cultural relativism, and how this may lead to a moral relativism. ". . .Many anthropologists mistrust talk about universal morality, and spend a great deal of time urging us not to intervene in the lives of other societies; if they think we have a responsibility, it is to leave well enough alone" (Appiah 14).
While I found the notion of positivism interesting, I found that I related more to the chapter "The Shattered Mirror." Though I didn't whole-heartedly agree with the idea, I do acknowledge that our perception is limited: ". . .you will find parts of the truth (along with much error) everywhere and the whole truth nowhere. The deepest mistake. . .is to think that your little shard of mirror can reflect the whole" (Appiah 8). This differs from moral relativism in that it does not say that there is no universal truth, but rather that there is no possible means of knowing the entire truth. It is a challenge for us, in our modernist age, to believe in a sense of absolute right and wrong, because science simply will not back it--but it is possible that we can know some things. This is vital.
Sunday, November 15, 2009
Text Reflection: Cosmopolitanism
I found our readings to be very interesting, and I appreciate that the author inserts his parenthetical humor into the text. Actually, I think I followed most of the text, but I confess that I found the second chapter a bit confusing; however, since (per the syllabus) we will be discussing this chapter in class, I won't try to hash it out too much right now.
It seems to me that Appiah, in Cosmopolitanism, is trying to find how different cultures are united--or if they are or can be united--by common beliefs and shared responses. I think. Furthermore, I believe Appiah is saying that our universe is full of strangers, but that there are universal characteristics: "Folktales, drama, opera, novels, short stories; biographies, histories, ethnographies; fiction or nonfiction; painting, music, sculpture, and dance: every human civilization has ways to reveal to us values we had not previously recognized or undermine our commitment to values that we had settled into" (30). He notes that, "…evaluating stories together is one of the central human ways of learning to align our responses to the world" (29).
I also thought that Appiah's discussion of how witchcraft comes into play in his homeland of Ghana was quite fascinating. At first I thought, "Pshaw," regarding witchcraft, but then as he went on to explain that just as my type of reaction was undoubtedly due to my upbringing, his Ghanaian relatives were brought up to believe in witchcraft and its power. And really, is that much different from believing in a Holy Trinity (as he also notes) or in omens or superstitions? Is it that different from believing in miraculous births, i.e., those of Jesus, Siddhartha, Lao Tse, etc.? The power of tradition is incredibly influential; likewise, so is the power of thought. If one truly believes something, I think it might be the strength of that particular belief that sustains the individual rather than whether the belief is true or not. Appiah notes, "In belief, as to everything else, each of us must start from where we are" (38).
I will end with a quote from Stuart Chase that I think is apropos: "For those who believe, no proof is necessary. For those who don't believe, no proof is possible."
Saturday, November 14, 2009
Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Stangers
Here's my quote for the day that relates to relativism and whether or not there ARE universal moral truths:
The truth does not change according to our ability to stomach it.
- Flannery O'Connor (a great Southern novelist)
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Lukes says, " ...the relativity of morals does not mean the absence of universal acceptance, but rather denial of universal applicability" (28). I cannot help but think there are many issues that are universally applicable from a human rights stand point but not universally accepted. When each side weighs in and is at opposite ends where does that leave things personally, politically, globally? I am thinking this is why we have war. Where might the world be if the United States agreed to let Afgahnistan turn Bin Laden over to a Muslim country? Our leaders saw this action as to great a compromise...was it? Does it make since to let a particular population deal with their own extremeists? Possibly the problems are better understood by those that fully under stand the fundamentals such extremes are based on and can hold up the mirror in a more "relative" way?
I have no answers. I do know that these readings give me cause to reflect upon and examine how and why I shape my morals now and in the future, how to shape them with diversity without compromising my values in the process.
Thursday, November 5, 2009
After reading Outcasts United, again I was reminded that things are not one sided. There are always two sides to something. I felt for the old inhabitants of Clarkson and missing the “familiarity” and “simplicity” of things but also saw how with the refugee’s arrival culture grew and Clarkson expanded into a diverse town, which brought with it many positives and negatives. Some of the older inhabitants of Clarkson and police officers were not responding well to the new arrival of refuges. This was handled in many various ways but I especially resonated with the quote “ America is changing…get over it.” (p. 177) The quote reminded me of a Dylan song and also sometimes in life, you just have to get over it, accept it and not fight the changes. There will always be pros and cons to any situation.
I grew up in the south part my life and honestly feel somewhat ignorant to the fact that I never knew about refuges being sent to places like Clarkson and how much the Atlanta airport, the main hub I fly into changed smaller towns. This was an interesting thought, a cultural maelstrom of more than hundred nationalities in an area slightly larger than one square mile.” (178) That was the challenge Scipio saw and in some ways people made it work while others still had a hard time adjusting to the change. Change always has two sides and for me that’s the beautiful thing. What really moved me however was Mandela, the soccer player’s story. His love for the sport and his attitude just struck a chord in me for some reason. All and all, what a satisfying read.
Many years later upon moving to Marin County I was to find myself as being continually perceived to be on the new immigrant side of the fence. It still happpens to this day. My family has been in California since the mid-1700's. The only more indigenious people than my roots are Native Americans. But suddenly I move to Marin County and folks are treating me as sub-human, assuming I can't speak english and have no money. The stories I could tell, but back to the text.
Chapter 24, Coming Apart really states the essence of what we need to do individually, and that is be "capable of "reframing the terms of transaction between [ourselves] and newcomers in a way that emphasizes the benefits of getting involved" (220). The authors state we must first stick it out through the frustration, remain committed, understanding this is part of our lives. This is the service learning connection to strive for. Everyone benefits when one gets involved. I think this is what the Obama's are pushing for and current economic and imigrant issues are ripe for America to dive in.
Wake -Up America and embrace the ongoing changes that make this country great!
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
Reflections on "Outcasts"
Although I found it all interesting, I think my "aha" moments came while reading Chapters 19-24. One thing that really struck me was about how we often perceive things. For instance, some people in Clarkston focused solely on the past—and how the newcomers didn't fit into their comfortable view of Old Clarkston. But some others, even though their original intentions may have been motivated by self-interests, viewed the newcomers differently. The face of Clarkston changed from mostly native-born white Christians to a multicultural stew. The pastor of the local Baptist church said, "I tell people, 'America is changing,'…'Get over it'" (177). And although there are many challenges to integrating these vast numbers of immigrants, there are benefits to those who recognize them: "…while self-interest – economic, spiritual, emotional – might have been a motivating factor, …what was most interesting was what happened once the connecting kicked in. Bill Mehlinger …was so busy going to weddings of his current and former employees. William Perrin…looking forward to his church's potluck dinners because he so enjoyed the exotic meals… The police chief of Clarkston came to identify with the refugees…when it dawned on him that as a black man…he could have been singled out by Clarkston cops" (183-184).
Something else I found interesting was the change in perspective when looking at common denominators. If one only focuses on the differences, i.e., race, religion, traditions, it is hard to see any common ground between individuals of hugely different backgrounds. But, if one instead focuses on all the commonalities, i.e., "A Liberian refugee might be a woman, a Christian, a worker, a single mother concerned about neighborhood crime and the safety of her children…" (184), this "…renders any single category less meaningful" (185).
The final thing that struck me was that ignoring the differences between cultures was more successful than focusing on or even celebrating the differences. "As diversity becomes the norm … people cease to focus on it. Diversity becomes 'no big deal.' The key to making super-diversity work … may have less to do with embracing it than ignoring it" (185).
These readings certainly tie into my service learning, since I am doing work for an organization that tries to help the homeless, Warm Wishes. I have never been homeless, so I do not have that in common; however, as Outcasts pointed out, I have many, many more things in common with the population served by Warm Wishes than our differences. I also think that by ceasing to focus on the differences, one just might help to preserve the dignity of those one is trying to help, because I think that would help to reduce patronizing attitudes.