For this week’s reading we were asked once again to try to understand the ideas presented by a philosopher. More specifically, we took a look at two chapters from Hannah Arendt’s Responsibility and Judgement: “Collective Responsibility” and “Thinking and Moral Considerations.” The first chapter seemed to focus on a comparison of guilt and responsibility while the second chapter took an abstract look at thinking.
Arendt opens the first chapter arguing that responsibility can be accurately applied to a collective while guilt cannot. She writes, “…there is no such thing as being or feeling guilty for things that happened without oneself actively participating in them” and continues “guilt, unlikely responsibility… is strictly personal” (147). Arendt goes on to support that there is a very distinctive line between political or collective responsibility, and legal or personal guilt (150-151). A famous line of Socrates is brought up, “It is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong” (153). Arendt understands Socrates to mean that he would rather suffer wrong immediately than do wrong and have to live with it afterwards. However, she contends that this moral argument is very subjective and therefore difficult to analyze (156-157).
In her second chapter, Arendt brings up the complicated topic of thinking. One aspect she discusses is that objects of thoughts are representations of real things that have been created by the imagination (165). Since there is very little recorded as to the thinking experiences of “professional thinkers,” Arendt again directs the conversation to Socrates. It is explained that Socrates had these philosophical sessions of questioning things that tended to come right back to where they started (168-171). Examination of some of the things Socrates stated then leads to discussion of Socrates’ self-imposed label of a “gadfly” as well as another person’s label of him as an “electric ray.” Arendt’s interpretation of the “gadfly” label is that Socrates stimulated people into thinking and reflecting. The “electric ray” label, meanwhile, is suggested to refer to the idea that people can be paralyzed by too much uncertainty as a result of much reflection (173-174).
The article “Auschwitz Shifts From Memorializing to Teaching” by Michael Kimmelman can easily be related to Arendt’s first major point. In the article, Kimmelman explains the proposal of a revised exhibition at the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum. The new exhibition is not designed to revive blame against any group of people on a large scale, but rather to emphasize personal stories and experiences of those who experienced the atrocities of Auschwitz. In fact, the director specifically said that the new exhibition should inspire “responsibility to the present” in viewers (2). In short, the purpose of the exhibit shies away from distributing guilt on a broad level but instead seeks to perpetrate a collective responsibility.
- Christopher Galbick
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.