Friday, April 30, 2010

from Katherine

=

Explanation And Exonerated Or What We Can Hear

“Since the events of September 11, we have seen both a rise of anti intellectualism and growing acceptance of censorship within the media.” ( p1)

I agree with Judith Butler that after 9/11 the American public lost its voice because the media propagated the horrific event into the psyche of the Nation. The mass media for days filled the air - waves on every channel of the surreal images of the airplanes flying into the World Trade Center. Newspapers, magazines, talk shows, flooded the market with these images and that instilled fear into the public about their safety.

The media orchestrated and instilled fear into the incalculable majority of Americans, and that fear made them unconscious to have thought or ought, to react to the covert actions that the government was assembling. FEAR then triggered the loss of American intellectualism and the acceptance of media censorship.

Through the use of phrases such as, “We are at War” and “War on Terrorism,” the government gained the approval of both liberals and conservatives to abandon the importance and principles of an individuals’ right. Since the Bush administration had attained the approval of the public through fear, this then enabled them to lobby and acquire the necessary votes to pass the “Patriot Act.”

Fear opened the portal for the public to accept the invasion of these rights.

The phrase “We are at War” does not justify the government’s suspension of our civil liberties, or the development of interrogation programs that have used torture to extract information from detainees.

Fear has eroded the confidence of the American people, because fear manifests insecurity and results in the abandonment of our values and principles. After 9/11 the American Government declared war on Afghanistan, and then Iraq. The mass media have been extremely lax in it’s investigative reporting and our government lied to us about arms of mass destruction.

Fear erodes our humanity.

The “public mockery of the peace movement” since the U.S. no longer has a draft system, nor any influential citizens whose sons or daughters been placed in harms way; as a result, their was no voice, that may have incited and supported anti war sentiment Fear is perpetuated in the American psyche, because we now use the explanation that if we allow ourselves to have anti war sentiment, then we will be dishonoring the soldiers like we did in the sixties and the seventies.

Franklin D. Roosevelt uplifted the spirit and the psyche of the American people in his inaugural speech in 1932 during the “Great Depression”. This particular phrase from his speech is just as relevant today as it was then.

“The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself.”

“Who is against us?’ As a result, we respond to the exposure of vulnerability with an assertion of U.S. “leadership” showing once again the contempt we have for international coalitions that are not built and led by The U.S..”(7)

American men and women, Afghanistan-Ian’s, and Iraqis are dying and being maimed every day, we may have a little more media coverage but the voices are silent and the war continues. What will we have gained after the war is over? Today

is April 30th and the 35th anniversary of the end of the War in Vietnam.

According to Political scientist, historian, and diplomat George R. Keenan describes the Vietnam War as “the most disastrous of all Americas’ undertaking over the whole two hundred years of its history.”

58,226 Americans died and 1.5million Vietnamese died.

Current wars 4,394 have died and 31,790 have been wounded.

Blessings and Peace on Earth

Thursday, April 29, 2010

Who Counts, Depends on Who’s Counting

There have been a number of times during my service with Phoenix where the question "who counts?" seems appropriate. Since the work that Phoenix does is with the fringe of the community, the ones which many in the community would rather see in jail and off the street than to lead productive lives within the community.

Butler asks the question, "Who counts as human?" (20) and describes the ways in which our American culture dissects itself from other countries on this principle. While Butler's focus seems to be focused almost exclusively on differences of race and ethnicity, my experience is that it can be applied to ANYONE at ANYTIME. There are areas in this country where blacks and whites were (are) not permitted to be buried in the same cemetery. There are criteria we place on human life in other ways like organ donation lists, and distribution of much needed pharmaceuticals to prevent the spread of AIDS and other devastating diseases.

I believe that the point that Butler is trying to make is that while we have progressed (mostly) beyond the need for Civil Rights the way it was just 50 years ago, that the problem of devaluing others' lives still continues, but in a more covert rather than overt way. Yet our collective devaluation of others is connected to our own. We are all connected through our shared vulnerability of our flesh and bones. This barrier of cells is the thin line that separates us from others, and we get stuck in the idea of our separateness until we are propelled by grief and loss.

Responding to the prompt: "The rise of anti-intellectualism--what does Butler mean by this/how does she illustrate this phenomenon/what are the implications?": On page 2 Butler wrote: "Although we have heard, lately, about the abusive treatment of prisoners, and war "mistakes" have been publicly exposed, it seems that neither the justification nor the cause of the war have been the focus of public intellectual attention." No, well of course not. Despite much public outcry at the time the Bush administration decided ousting Saddam Husein in Iraq was the right way to address preventing further acts of terror of the likes of 9/11, people were forced to shut up under the premise that to keep on arguing and protesting how misdirected the operation seemed (did we forget that Osama bin Laden was behind the twin towers attack?!!), it suddenly became politically incorrect to risk and offending the troops and their families that we just sent off to the war on terror in Iraq. All of a sudden, it was unpatriotic to object, no matter how insane the misdirected attack seemed to so many people. The repeated refrain "if you're not with us, you're against us" made any grey area in public discourse politically dangerous. Peoples right to privacy was being scaled back to the point even our library checkout activities became subject to review, and rules of spying loosened to increase law enforcement's advantages at potentially apprehending terrorists before they act. This is one way in which our intellectual instincts were beaten back.

The discussion of Prince Alwaleed bin Talal's remaks on October 11 in New was a great example of how criticial discourse got completely lambasted during that time as well.

Regarding "Who counts as human?" The discussion of loss of Palestinian liberties and lives compared to Isreali lives in that ongoing conflict, hits home for me. I know many people who are afraid to voice their opinions too openly (like me right now--I admit to being apprehensive) that the Israeli methods of cracking down has gotten out of hand. There is great fear of offending those in powerful positions who put more emphasis and deem Israeli lives more important and worth defending than they do Palestinians lives. Both cultures are human and deserving of basic human dignities and both have a history in and claim on the area. Neither of them will win this fight to control or rid themselves of each other without continuing to incur such sever suffering themselves that the whole effort becomes pointless. It will never create peace or security. But the point Butler seems to be making is that people are afraid to speak their minds, due to the First Worldish "might makes right" attitude. I think this is also might be one of the factors of anti-intellectualism. People are made to be afraid of talking about things in a circumspect manner, because of fear of offending the powerful.

We are right and that is that!

“We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). I realize a few other students have used this quote but I think it sums up a lot of the reading in Precarious Life. For some reason we are very focused on finding a "black or white" answer. For example the quote Judith Butler uses in the Precarious Life by former President George W. Bush, "Either you're with us or you're with the terrorists". Here Bush seems to be giving us two options, but of course there is only one option given. I cannot stand to hear things said like this. These kinds of statements do not allow anyone to think at all, let alone think critically. I believe these statements encourage close-mindedness, laziness and ignorance. Statements like this tell people they do not have to do any of their own research into the issue/situation at hand, that the solution is easy, "you're with us or the terrorists". And if you are "with us" you will do whatever it takes to obliterate these "terrorists". Unfortunately many people do not know the history behind the terrorists, or even who they are and where they come from. I also believe that often people do want to take the easier, lazier route and believe what they are told to believe. But any important decision in portion of life deserves a little more individual research.

I was floored after reading that Rudy Guiliani refused to take the $10 million donation from the Saudi Prince for the World Trade relief effort. What an insult, what disrespect! I agree with the author of Precarious Life in that the Prince only meant to express his thoughts on the issue and suggest that the US take a step back and think about how it is impacting the rest of the world. Clearly many of our leaders in the US are not thinking openly to the other countries of the world.

I think if this kind single-mindedness is encouraged by our governments then it will only lead to single-mindedness and a lack of critical thinking in all aspects of life. Working in the field with my community partner I realized that the main part of the work that they do has to do with education and encouraging people to look deeper into issues like the health of our oceans. Working with the Sea Turtle Restoration Project has opened my eyes to issues I would not have payed any attention to otherwise. I knew that our oceans were in trouble but didn't look any deeper for what the problems were and how I could possibly make a difference. Making educated, well-thought out decisions about every issue in our lives is of extreme importance for our country and for individuals.

no title

If we are not connected to others, we can be consumed by our own little world and our own problems. In everyday life, if we do not take others into consideration, their feelings of grief, accomplishment, pain and pleasure, then we live in a world that is lacking a full range of feeling. One cannot live in a community if they feel no sense of community. Starting at a local level, each individuals everyday life impacts others in a number of ways, as well as others impacting you and I. I think it is unfortunate that most people turn a blind eye to others. Truly an example of "out of sight, out of mind". Having done work in the community, I not only feel like a stronger and more personal attachment to the community, but I also marvel at the unwillingness of many to even lift a finger to make the world, our world, a better place. In most cases, if people just admit that there is an unmet need, or that other people are hurting or going without, then individuals will step up and take action. It certainly is nice to know that as a community and society, there are people that are passionate and care, although it can be a small minority.

From Marty

Connectivity!

Today I was filling out the “Student Final Self-Evaluation” form for my service learning, answering the question of, “In what way were you served by your community partner and the people/communities they serve?” I stated that the experience has expanded my awareness of the struggles of many people who live very near to me, in my own community. The extent of the needs that these people have is enormous and I was surprised by the fact that they are essentially discarded by society as a whole. Butler asks us to ask the question, “Who counts as a human? Whose lives counts as lives? What makes for a grievable life?” (20). It seems there are large sections of our population whose lives do not count and are left by the way side and never grieved for.

Julia, in your prompt you use the quote, “Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something” (23). We are missing something when we are not undone by our connection to the suffering of others. We are not undone when we segment our population, when we insulate ourselves from our fellow man and the issues they face and thusly feel no empathy for those who suffer. I finished my service learning several weeks ago, but not a day goes by that I don’t think about the people I interacted with at Vinnie’s. I have been undone by my short relationship to this community. I will go back to it, but my bigger question is how do I get other people to see and feel what I have felt? Can I pass along this “undoneness?” When I try to tell friends and colleagues about my experiences at Vinnie’s there are not many people, outside of my wife, who really care to listen. I have always felt that when people are fat and happy they will never get off their ass and do anything. It is this feeling of uneasiness, this undone instability that forces people to act. While Vinnie’s is doing an incredible service for these people in need, in a strange way, it to is segmenting these people out from the rest of the population. If these folks were allowed to be helped in restaurants that most people frequent, I believe more people would me “undone” by their plight. Can you imagine how people would react? On page 5, Butler states, “Isolating the individuals involved absolves us of the necessity of coming up with a broader explanation for the events.” Now Butler is speaking in regards to 9-11 and Al Qaeda but it is the same basic principal of isolation, blame, make excuses, rashly generalize and move on with our own agendas. Vinnie’s is doing everything it can to help those who have fallen below the poverty line and also continues to keep others from falling victim to the same fate, but the root causes need to be discovered and addressed to truly fix the situation.

Julia’s final quote also made me come undone. “We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). Well I am the first to admit I was not grounded in any way shape or form with regards to Vinnie’s. I hate to say it, but if it had not been for Julia’s class, I never would have gone there to volunteer and expose myself to this community. The fact is that I just went there. I did not plan anything or worry about how I was going to fit in or how I was going to relate or communicate with the people there; I just went; I just acted. Hopefully I helped them in a small way and they certainly helped me. Can we force others to volunteer? Can we make everyone take Julia’s class? We can not gain from loss as Butler theorizes, unless we feel the loss first hand.

Failure at walking a very narrow line

Given that I am a former United States Marine, and served during the time when the primary focus of the United States military was in Iraq, which was one of the responses to the attack that occurred on September 11th, 2001, I do not feel that it is appropriate for me to respond to the subject matter discussed in this particular reading. However, I did find much of the questions posed, within the framework of the subject matter to be deeply interesting and worthy of reflection. As such, I will give my thoughts on a few of the questions asked in the text.


"Our fear of understanding a point of view belies a deeper fear that we shall be taken up by it, find it is contagious, become inflected in a morally perilous way by the thinking of the presumed enemy. But why do we assume this?" -- Precarious Life, p. 8

This is a basic fear of the unknown, of challenge to our own deeply held beliefs - ones that we may not actually feel to be on solid ground. We are afraid of the grey that exists in almost all situations - of the full story - as it may force us to adjust and find a complex answer to a question that we thought was simple. Worse, it may force us to examine our actual beliefs, and they may not hold up to support the person we thought that we were. And even more horrifying, we may find that contemplation of this sort will set us adrift - we will no longer have the certainty that we crave for the feeling of safety and self-righteousness that we depend on and that gives us such inner pleasure (that feeling of superiority).
We assume that they are wrong and we are right because to examine the unknown usually leads to understanding - the worst enemy of hate and superiority (or inferiority). The process of examination sends us, for a time, into uncertain waters ... waters that we fear may swallow us up and lead to our destruction. And it does - the destruction of our hate. What replaces this ignorance and these simple ideas is understanding and acceptance that the world is a much more complicated place, one that does not, in fact, much of the time, make much sense to us. This is partly due to the fact that we almost never have enough of the information necessary to truly make an informed decision. Not having all of the information can be maddening - to admit, even to ourselves, that we do not have all the pieces can lead to a feeling of being "out-of-the-loop" and that we are not as important as we like to sometimes think we are. It also can lead to a place of mistrust - which truly can be alarming.
Nevertheless, it is essential that we question ourselves and be willing to seek for other perspectives. There are always more than two. Open-mindedness is a critical tool towards avoiding violence and harm (both of others and ourselves). However, even violence requires an open mind - after all, if we are truly willing to look at different perspectives (especially those that we disagree with), then violence must sometimes be considered. David Webber once wrote that violence is a diplomatic even - it occurs if and when diplomats fail. I agree with this statement fully. I also believe that it is not the military that advocates war - after all, the military is the organization that will suffer the most in the event of such action. No, it is usually the politicians, special interest groups, and even the public that advocates such actions. But, if I am truly open-minded, I must be willing to look at the possibility that perhaps there are other forces (including the military) that encourages war.
All in all, though, it seems to me that the greatest reason for violence, lack of agreement, unity, and aggression, is not failure of diplomacy or anger - it is close-mindedness and willful ignorance.

Friday, April 23, 2010

Prompt for 4/29

I have just taken these straight from the reading notes that I have posted on blackboard . ..
“Who counts as human?” (20). Why are the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, mourning integral to Butler’s thesis? Do we agree that these are universal human experiences that might be a source of moral response? Can you illustrate with your community experience?

and/or

Awe: “Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something_ (23) Do you have a significant moment from service that illustrates this? I’m sure that everyone has a life experience that makes you tremble a bit when you read this.
Significance of the discussion of identity/autonomy/the body (24-38). Tie back to other points. This leads into important discussion of vulnerability—how does she then tie this back into the previous points she has built?
Can you illustrate with your community experience?

and/or

Dehumanization of the Other 32-49. Crucial points here and she weaves in all the other points.
“We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). Think about this in relation to in relation to your service-learning experience. Can you use a specific or significant moment to illuminate?

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Whistleblowers Pgs. 97-end

I was fascinated by the mentioning of the intimacy of power. One would think that an organization's relationship with an employee would be very intimate but as I read this book they break down how an organization is really only run by a few people. As the book puts it, the organization is a, "government of men, not laws" (111). Therefore the relationship between the whistleblower and their boss is very personal because they both threaten each others livelihoods if they do not comply with one anothers needs. I enjoyed reading about the intimacy of power and could not help but think how this is so prevalent all throughout life. In grade school and growing up the bullies or kids in the popular groups tease other children in ways that dehumanize, ab normalize and isolate the other children. It seems all to similar to when corporations diagnose the whistleblowers "as abnormal or disturbed", and then isolate them. Those who are not whistleblowers just try to do as they are told, so as not to be considered abnormal and then face the loss of their job.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Belonging to Me

There are several issues I had with the context of narcissism as Alford describes it. I do not want to belabor the terminology and all its nuances, however, he is overly simplistic in his insistence on whistleblowers being narcissists. I agree that they are struggling with an inner dialogue that required them to act in "choiceless-choice." But he only is drawing from the stories of a few whistleblowers who I agree are narcissistic, but they do not in any way seem to be representative of a majority. I do agree that there is a commonality of inability to "double." It was exactly that aspect in my own experience that drove me to speak out. I was intent on being true to my authentic self. Holding onto integrity. Does this make me narcissistic? I don't believe so. I also felt that I did not have much of a choice (if I was going to continue to stay with the organization). But it was a group of people I was associated with, that were also being affected by the perpetrator that made the choice seem more important. I thought I was one of the few who could take the risk of saying something, when others lived in fear of losing their paycheck or their health benefits. I had been the victim before and did not speak up because I was more isolated, and it was me against the world (so to speak). Now the issues I was faced with seem more systemic and less worthy of a fight. Perhaps this is the futility that the whistleblowers in the book seem to get stuck on.

I think that Alford fails to review in correct context that there are whistleblowers who do not get stuck. Many won't, and therefore do not partake in the whistleblowers support groups like the one frequented by Alford. So with this in mind, it does not surprise me that he found that such a majority had the symptomatic narrative that he describes. Most whistleblower stories are the untold story. They speak up tell their story to someone, they are retaliated against to silence or discredit their story, and so the whistleblower moves on and does not necessarily retell his/her story. The successfully silenced story, but no less a whistleblower story than the ones rehashed in the support groups Alford describes. Would these same whistleblower narratives possess the same qualities that he theorizes about? I am not so sure. I think that what Alford is proving is the narrative of a group of individuals that share in a commonality that happens to be in a whistleblower setting, but does not truly speak of either whistleblowers in general or the public at large. Instead what is presented is a theme of how individuals respond to conditions of tyranny, or put in lighter terms, in situations in which their freedoms are illusionary.

I think Alford states the dilemma beautifully on page 68, "The double meaning of 'belonging to' says it all: they are part of and possessed by the group." That statement brings to mind a comment that someone made to me when I was working with the Phoenix Project. This man came up to me and asked me, "Who do you belong to?" At the time I saw it as a rather sexist remark that I had to be possessed by a man or something. In the greater context, however, I see that many of these young men struggle with a sense of "belonging." Isn't that the whole reason that gangs form? They fill the void left by a lack of association in the culture at large or even within family units? Reading that statement has given me a greater appreciation for the double meaning of the word belong.

To belong implies a linking together, but usually a voluntary submission in exchange for meeting a need. In the case Alford puts forth it is the need to provide for our families and pay a mortgage that spurs the need to belong to an organization that we work for. And it is the loyalty or integrity to this type of organization that the whistleblower is intent on keeping intact. But as Alford stated in the previous chapters, the organization serves as an enemy of individual morality. This is what the whistleblowers he uses as examples cannot seem to come to terms with. Because they cannot live in duplicity they are forced to make a choice.

That need to live a duplicitous life I would suspect is what leads to other moral ills. Is it not the source of extramarital affairs? This ability to lead a double life. Neither of the two selves created in these examples is whole or true, and therefore loses meaning to me. Like Arendt mentioned before, you have to be able to live with yourself. Can you live with a person that can ignore morality for the sake of making money? For that is the choice presented to whistleblowers who are asked to do immoral acts, or who witness immoral acts and have to decide whether to follow orders and say nothing or speak out.

Alford gives an example of how morality is twisted in definition on page 72, "What is right in the corporation is not what is right in a man's home or in his church. What is right in the corporation is what the guy above you wants from you. That's what morality is in the corporation." I think perhaps this is the stream of conscience that allows people within organizations to check their individual morality at the door and continue in their duplicity. By believing such a statement can absolve any internal conflict of moral objection to actions taken by an organization (or its representatives). Yet another example of the good ol' "just following orders" approach that permits all kinds of suffering.

Overall, I can agree with Alford with his statement on page 93, regarding narcissism moralized being, "the goodness of the self is the highest value." We do need to question how people can live in a culture where "goodness of the self" and respect for others are not a valued quality. But it almost seems that the whistleblower has to volunteer for the role as scapegoat (even though unaware of this potential outcome), and I do not see how that can be viewed as narcissism in any context. In reflection of events as they are recounted later can be taken in their narrative as acts of narcissism. But this is because the whistleblower has to come to terms with what has happened, and to have a self-important review of the facts gives the events greater meaning than perhaps they did in reality as they occurred. All this to dissuade both themselves and others that their efforts were all in vain.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Alford has several statements that I feel are sign posts when looking for the root cause of why people do or do not commit awful acts to others. This is something we should look long and hard at when trying to discern the underlying issues. On page 75 he states “…we should consider what kind of world we live in when nobody feels shame for anything. This seems to be how it works, the capacity to feel shame for one’s own acts inextricably interwoven with the capacity to feel shame for others.” On page 67 he talks of Hannah Arendt and how she suspects that the ground of all ethics is the ability to take others into account. Finally on page 95 Alford says “Morality stems from empathy, in which we are deeply affected by the sufferings of others.” If we feel no shame in anything we do then we do not worry about the consequences and more importantly we do not feel for the people to whom these consequences affect. More and more it seems that the consequences to our actions are becoming less and less. What do I mean by that? In our celebrity based/obsessed society, not only are we prompted to watch and comment and be fascinated by all these terrible, selfish acts committed by these “famous” people, but they never seem to pay the full price for their indiscretions. See Tiger Woods, cheats on his wife with 20 plus other women then is cheered on by thousands at the Masters. Now Alford’s contentions are that the whistleblowers do not necessarily have empathy for others but are motivated by moral narcissism. But if morality stems from empathy, then these whistleblowers are thinking of others and not just themselves and they are taking others into account. I am just happy that no matter the reason they blow the whistle the most important fact is that they DO blow the whistle. I think the people committing these selfish, atrocious acts are the narcissistic ones. If the narcissism has led people to do what is right is it something we should promote in a good way?

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Whistleblowers

A whistleblower is a person that does what he or she thinks is the right thing to do. Whistlebowers think about their moral and ethical self when doing what they do or to be more exact blowing the whistle. Whistleblowers are those that do not follow the norm but instead follow the "right thing to do". Sometimes it is about being human and doing the right thing. But then the consequences come and the whistleblower may loose their job. That makes me think of the say of "good guys finish last". Could this be said of the whistleblower since the consequences of doing the right thing end up affecting them in the wrong way?

"Whistlebowers' loyalties are different, more abstract. They are acting against an aspect of human nature, which tells us something important about "human nature"(p68)"

What is human nature? Isn't it being kind, loyal and doing the right thing? Doing good for others and not being selfish? Or is human nature all about survival of the fites and having a life of selfishness?

I find that at my services leaning there are many that could be those Whistlebowers that think of others before themselves. Those tutors at Colman that take their time and help a child in there academics are thinking of the child before thinking of their time that could be use for their benefit. But in a way they are benefiting by leaning from the children. Not only are they leaning the child's culture but they are learning the students needs and where they come from that the tutor may find ways to help in what ever the student needs.

from Katherine

April 8, 2009

The whistleblower's actions are never dramatic, because his or hers moral conscience has not made compromises; therefore their image of self has not faded in the mirror. Their individualism defines their moral conscience is embedded in their psyche. While other members of society have compromised their moral conscience; as a result, each compromise diminishes their moral integrity and values, and chips away at the essence of who they once were, until one day the reflection of themselves in a store window is un-recognizable. There moral conscience has fade away.

“To run up against the organization is to risk obliteration. In a totalitarian regime nothing remains after one run’s a foul of the organization. Before his arrest, Winston Smith’s job was to alter the historical records so as to make it appear, as dissidents had never been born. In a democratic society, the sacrificed individual remains. If we listen to him or her we may learn something or not just about individuality but about the forces that confront it”.

While reading the book my hair raised on end and felt this eerie feeling and questioned why did these self appointed demigod’s want to subliminally and deviously eliminated the whistleblowers from being able to be employable in another organizations. Why did they blackball them and pushed them to the back of the bus without a seat. I question the reasoning behind the upper echelon executives who protect the owner or owners that destroy the lives of those human beings who thought they were doing the right thing. The self appointed demigods must be lacking a primal positive emotion that incur that occurs from their pre-meditated thought or the essence of being human these creatures who have amassed authority empower parentheses oblivious to the humanity of those around him unconscious according to the authors of the book “Kindness.” (p. 33) In other words they lack the social feelings for another person their awareness has been dulled by not being able to transport themselves outside of themselves. Unable to identify with the sufferers whom they have inflicted adulterated pain that affects every aspect of their lives including future possibilities of employment in their fields of expertise.

“We usually know the kind thing to do is in kindness when it is done to us and registers its absence when it is not.” (Kindness p9)

The social issues that plague us today are not new; however society needs to awaken itself from its self inflicted deep sleep of unconsciousness and emerges as collective and addresses the issues that eventually will splinter the psyches collective consciousness about humanity. The essence of choosing between wrong right in humans may become a faded memory and unable to be revived if select members of the society continue in their attempts to destroy select individuals who have a moral conscience as well as a voice.

“The readiness to tell the truth at whatever cost to oneself may be a source of tremendous power for change. Not always perhaps not often, but sometimes. For some that’s enough.” (Preface xii)

Theory and Practical Application

"The narcissist wants to be whole, good, pure, and perfect. There are two ways to
do this. Either one lowers one's standards of wholeness, goodness, purity, and
perfection until they correspond to one's miserable self. Or one raises one's miserable
self as high as one possibly can so that one comes a little closer to these ideal standards."
- C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 63

"... we go back and forth between moral psychology and moral theory, using one
to illuminate the other." - C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 83

"... it is not the job of moral theory to talk with moral actors."
- C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 83

"Morality stems from empathy, in which we are deeply affected by the sufferings of others."
- C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 95
When we first began this class, an orientation was given. It was made clear that the purpose
of this class was to connect theory of the classroom with practical experience. It was to take on
the application of morality in the real world - to work to fight injustice in a very real and
experiential sense. It was to connect the theoretical with the actual.
Is that not what the whistleblowers have seem to have done? To have internalized
the espoused values that they have been taught to the point of actualizing what was intended
to simply be a best-case scenario theory?
According to the first quote above, wouldn't the vast majority of people then be narcissistic?
After all, most people seek to improve themselves in some way. Either that, or they learn to
adapt themselves to their current situation. This sounds very close to meeting the threshold
articulated. Where is the distinction?

The analogy of the baseball player and the physicist is an intriguing one - as far as the use
of different language and terms go. The idea that the physicist would be able to explain the
motion of the ball traveling through the air, while the pitcher simply does it and offers different
verbiage seems to be sound. However, the question that I would ask is this: Would the
physicist have the desire to learn to throw the ball in a curve? If so, would the ego of the
physicist allow him to learn from the pitcher? And, vice versa, would the pitcher be interested
in learning the mathematical model behind what he does? Would he be willing to learn new
terminology in order to understand, and take further advantage of that knowledge to make
the ball do even more challenging flights?

Morality and empathy are not necessarily the same thing - and should (and do) not always require one
to know the "other" that is being helped. In my own case, I have taken to calling various business
owners that are close to defaulting on their business licenses in order to save them the grief of
having to pay a late registration fee. Sometimes it turns out that they have gone out of business
and have simply forgotten to inform the city. Other times, they have been too caught up in other
things to find the time. The end result of this is that it saves both them and the city money
and time. This is not an act of morality or empathy - this is simply a way to be kind in such a way
as to save others trouble. I don't do it out of a sense of obligation, and I certainly don't do it
out of a need to see myself as better than I actually am. I do it because it makes me happy to
be kind.

Now, I know that I am not a whistleblower, but could there be alternative reasons that have
not yet been explored behind the actions that these individuals take and why they feel there is
no choice left for them? Could it be that they feel that they have been placed in a catch-22? They
are damned-if-they-do-and-damned-if-they-don't? Wouldn't such a situation give a remarkable
amount of freedom to do what one wants and feels is the best moral choice? Having been placed
into that situation, wouldn't it seem to cease to be a choice? For example, if one was told to lie
to the Feds about the company's practices (which are illegal), wouldn't there be the catch-22
scenario? If the Feds find out, one goes to jail - no matter how long has passed potentially. As such,
would this case result in being free to tell the truth as it could be seen that the job is lost no matter
what? Better to tell the truth and simply loose the job than to lie, be caught, go to jail, and still loose
job anyway.
I have a hard time believing that being placed in such a position makes one narcissistic. However,
I also have a hard time believing that this would lead to a person being caught in the past. So,
maybe, in the end, I have no idea what I am talking about.
I'm having lots to trouble identifying any of the concepts raised in Whistleblowers with my community service work. However, I have lots of things to identify with as an employee of various companies and organizations for my entire work life, which spans 31 years--and if (big if) I had anything to say about my current employer I certainly would not feel comfortable posting it online--I care more about my family well being than my own "moral purity" and since I'm not aware that anyone was at risk of losing their life from anything my current or former employers ever or worked on, I really don't know if I'm of the kind of moral fiber to become a hero in the way whistleblowers do. I just haven't been in a position to know how I'd react.

This is somewhat of a frustrating assignment because I believe my blog post is going to fail to meet the professor's expectations. Having said that, I'll do what I can to make a fit for my experience with my community partner and the current reading assignment. On the final prompt, Prof. van der Ryn wrote: "Basically, I am hoping you will think about your own resources for ethical action, and/or what motivates those you serve with, and how you or someone you serve with bridges the gap between nice idea and lived reality. . . "

Okay, let's try this on for size: Warm Wishes', founder, after trying to run the non-profit that provides warm clothing and "Streetpacks" to the homeless from his home, had to pull back and ask for some help running the non-profit. One time, because he used his home address and phone number, he was contacted very early in the morning by a woman who had just lost her housing and was on the streets with her kids. There comes a time when you feel too exposed, and not wanting to get in the business of actual homeless sheltering, he decided it was time to de-personalize the project and get a business address, phone number and the like. While this man has a huge heart and wants to help, he also has boundaries between his wish to do good deeds for others and his willingness to allow it to affect his personal life too up close and personal. Does this mean he is good at "doubling" --the concept brought up repeatedly by Alford in the chapters we read this week? I'm not sure it's a good fit by that's all I can come up with relating to my CP.

On the text:
One of the pieces that really stood out for me in the readings is on page 78, where the idea of "thumos" is discussed "the human spirit that feels indignation at baseness and corruption. Above all, thumos rebels at anything that would bring shame upon the self. The trick is to educate thumos so that it gets shamed by the right things . . . " Then, on the same page the discussion of soldier who reported on the My Lai massacre relates how "the brass corrupted his buddies' innocence. Suddenly he was in a whole new world, a world in which he would have to act to purify himself of knowledge he had gained but never wanted. That too made him furious. While he felt genuine compassion for the victims at My Lai, their suffering was not, it seems, the deepest source of his anger. That was reserved for those who would corrupted his, and his buddies', innocence. [next paragraph] The narcissistic rage of the whistleblower is in some ways his least attractive aspect. It is , in an sense, utterly selfish: a sense of "Look what you have done to my moral purity! What distinguishes the whistleblower's narcissism from that of the ordinary narcissist is that the whistleblower's narcissism is wounded by the right thing: . . . [next paragraph] Not too many things will make a man or woman give up everything for his or her beliefs, but wounded narcissism is one. Some people will go to the ends of the earth to salve their wounded narcissism, devoting their lives to moral purification. It is, I believe, the source of the lives of the saints and the lives of not a few sinners and fanatics too." (78-9).

So, for those of us who are not of the moral fiber to be saints, martyrs, etc. but who still feel outrage at what we experience and have an urge to act, but feel like doing so is too dangerous, we do other things, often destructive--self medication is one, and one in which many Vietnam vets fell into the practice of during those troubling times. I know numerous Vietnam vets, some of them still on drugs, others that were able to overcome the psychological trauma some how, drug free, and still live relatively normal and successful lives. Perhaps the latter group are more adept at "doubling."

I'm curious if others in the class have thoughts about this. Are those who can double somehow less morally correct than those who cannot? Can they be more effective in life and society by staying "in" (not getting themselves scapegoated)? Are there ways to remain operative without wounding your morality when incidents expose one's organization's activities don't sit well with them from a moral standpoint?

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

I found it to be interesting that Whistleblowers do not identify with the victim but make the victims fight their own according to Alford. When thinking of a whistleblower, I think of someone who is trying to help others but does want somekind of recognition themselves. Most of them want to be considered a hero of sorts but only outsiders would think that. The organization in almost all cases would will label you as a troublemaker. The author uses the army of an example of an organization that does not tolerate whistleblowers. "5.Your job is to not report something that your boss does not want to be reported, but rather to cover it up"(102)

The organization will label whistleblowers as people who are not thinking straight in order for the organization to justify their actions. "treating the whistleblower not as someone who has challenged the power of the organization but as one who is sick, ill, morally suspect, criminal or disturbed" (104). It is easy for groups in power to label the whistleblowers this way because it is convenient and in their best interests. Laws that protect whistleblowers are not helpful or effective because Corporations have so much power that laws are hard to enforce.

Ralph Nader discusses the idea of being a hero on page 116. This quote describes what I think whistleblowers believe. "To be a hero means no more, and no less, than to be a citizen"(116). Whistleblower do what they think is right for humanity and think others should as well. At my volunteer position,Alex (who oversees the non-profit M.O.M.) just looks at himself as a normal everyday citizen. He would never think of himself as a hero because he is doing what he thinks is right and in the best interests of his clients.

Saturday, April 10, 2010

prompt for week of 4/12--2nd reading in Whistleblowers

Again, the purpose of this prompt is to encourage you to think about textual concepts in relation to your work with the community (as this is what the final paper is all about!)--at the same time, the expectation is that the class discussion will engage many more points in the reading. The more textual concepts that you can bring into your posting, the better, but we will be covering more in the class discussion then you probably be able to unpack in this blog.

Alford talks about Arendt's "suspicion" that ethical behavior is grounded in our imaginative ability to "take others into account"(60). What Arendt means is that although we are subjective beings and can only experience reality through our own set of conditions--we have the capacity to imaginatively project ourselves into the reality of others. Thus, identification, humanization of the other, becomes a source of or motivation for ethical behavior.

Alford elaborates on the whistleblower's challenge using Buber's idea that "empathy is like a bridge, thrown from 'self-being to self-being across the abyss of the dread of the universe.'" He adds that for whistleblowers, "one end of this bridge must be supported by an imaginary abutment" (60). He uses the experience of the rescuer to unpack this distinction, explaining that unlike the rescuer who deals with particular persons, the whistleblower is driven to act by abstract ideals, not the concrete presence of the other.

He goes back to this idea at the end of Chapter 5: "Morality stems from empathy, in which we are deeply affected by the sufferings of others. . . It is easy to feel empathy for the sufferings of others, even when fear and ideology often team up to muffle this feeling." He sums up: "In a sense morality is easy, if by morality we mean feeling empathy and concern for others. What is difficult is acting on this basis when the self must pay a terrible price. . ." (95).

Of course, we don't all have to be whistleblowers and sacrifice all that is good in our lives for our ego-ideal--the values that we believe make our life worth living. In the service that you do for this class, hopefully you have more to gain than to lose--especially as the hope is that this experience, if nothing else, will deepen your learning in this class.

There are many different ways you could go with this prompt--if you are doing indirect service, you might reflect on the resources you have drawn on to address a larger ethical concept than that embodied in the presence/suffering of another individual. Even if you are doing direct service, you might find the larger issue to be the true motivator.

Or, you might describe the ways in which you have experienced that bridging to another human being or a cause that Buber describes. Or, you might reflect on the ways you have seen others do so in your service. Or, you might think about what you or others you work with sacrifice for shared ideals.

Basically, I am hoping you will think about your own resources for ethical action, and/or what motivates those you serve with, and how you or someone you serve with bridges the gap between nice idea and lived reality. . .

Monday, April 5, 2010

Stories, Words, and Perspectives (Whistleblowers)

The choice of the author to look at support groups as a means to attempting to understand whistleblowers is a great idea. However, I believe that the author lacks the basic necessary background of support group purposes, aims, and purposes to truly be able to use his resources to full potential. As a person that has spent many years working with alcoholics and addicts, I find the idea that any support group charge an entry price of a person's story to be ridiculous. Also, to then discount the entire purpose of a given support group, once it becomes clear it is not the same purpose of the author's, is very close to being insulting to the group - and its members.
For any given 12-step group (which this whistleblower group is NOT), there is no requirement for membership. The idea that a person's story must be told devalues the fact that it is considered to be a privilege to be asked. Most groups seek out fellow members that they believe will carry a message that will help in the recovery of the group's members.
However, even a cursory glance at a support group for whistleblowers - a place where such persons can feel safe to let their feelings of hurt actually show, and discuss their bafflement at life along with those few people that will actually understand - that won't place them on a pedestal, nor look upon them with mistrust - has a completely different reason for existence. There is no need for any sort of "recovery." Instead, there is simply the need to be a part of an "organization" that understands. After all, is this not what they were under the impression that they belonged to in the first place?
For the author to attempt to compare such groups, and purposes, and determine that they are the same leaves me with serious doubts about the author's analysis.

However, the author goes on to discuss the style and verbiage of different members. He discovers themes among the various narratives. This I found to be worth pondering on. It led me into an interesting area: the manner in which different people attempt to communicate.

The duality of each of us leads to some of us to refer to themselves, or even a collective "we" as "you." As in "you must ..." which is really saying "I must ...," "We must ...," or even "I have, you could ..." However, it often appears (at least, according to the author) that this duality is has become submerged in the whistleblowers. They have ceased to think in duality - to see themselves as separate from themselves in some way (or they see themselves as completely separate and are unable to reconnect - they have become the archetype in their own mind). This leads to a style of communication that removes the words "you" and "we" and replaces them all with "I." However, this individualism allows for communication that has the ability to impart knowledge in a way that few other ways can. After all, if I am listening to your story, I can take parts and make them my own - those parts that I identify with.

Also worthy of note: It is always to be remembered that one is only paranoid when one is wrong - otherwise it is intuition.
While some of the stories that the author used for his examples definitely fall into the category of being paranoid, some of the of the thoughts express I believe have merit - and so does the author. For example, not being able to talk about the issue that needs to be discussed could be called paranoid, but it is not when this is actually occurring.

I look forward to discussing this further, and learning more about the struggles that come after making such a great sacrifice.

Friday, April 2, 2010

more about vulberability and ethical being. . .

“Perhaps most importantly, we must recognize that ethics requires us to risk ourselves precisely at moments of unknowingness, when what forms us diverges from what lies before us, when our willingness to become undone in relation to others constitutes our chance of becoming human. To be undone by another is a primary necessity, an anguish, to be sure, but also a chance—to be addressed, claimed, bound to what is not me, but also to be moved, to be prompted to act, to address myself elsewhere, and so to vacate the self-sufficient ‘I’ as a kind of possession. If we speak and try to give an account from this place, we will not be irresponsible, or, if we are, we will surely be forgiven.”

––Judith Butler, Giving an Account of Oneself