Well here you go!
Watch the full episode. See more FRONTLINE.
Watch the full episode. See more FRONTLINE.
Butler explained how communication from the government and media discouraged open discussion about the war and how the popular opinion was guided to support the war effort. She commented, “to oppose the war meant to some that one somehow felt sympathy with terrorism, or that some saw the terror as justified” (2). The idea of possibly giving support to such horrible actions by stating an opinion, effectively silenced people.
Butler suggest that we should at least be open to conversation and not put people down because they want to review the topic of terror, retaliation, and war objectively. She asks to separate the discussion from the act of war; “allow an intellectual field to redevelop more responsible distinctions...and accountability might be understood apart from claims of vengeance” (3). Examination could provide alternate paths to approaching with the issue. Personally, I appreciate her comments because I did not agree with quickly going to war. We have expected other countries have to deal with painful circumstances and we have been influenced by mindfulness type of ideas from the east, yet we seemed to react rather than explore alternatives.
Butler portrayed the rise of anti-intellectualism by explaining the lack of support for questioning the government. She stated,“critical relation to government has been severely, though not fully, suspended”(1). Individuals are further discouraged from thoughtful inquiry due to the suggestion that it is unpatriotic to do so. Comments such as, “the time to reassert not only American values but fundamental and absolute values has arrived” (2) and “using the flag as a sign of solidarity with those lost on September 11 and with the current war(3). Implying if you are a true, loyal American, you will not question our involvement in the war.
Butler describes the effects of how events are framed, “the frame works both to preclude certain kinda of questions, certain kinds of historical inquires, and to function as a moral justification for retaliation”(4) and
“the frame decides, in a forceful way, what we can hear” (5). The manner in which the situation is presented suggests how it should be interpreted and the appropriate reaction, thereby controlling the general public’s response.
Butler examines our personal grief process and notes that we don’t realize the growth and potentially positive side of the loss until we have made it through much of the pain. She asks if our country could benefit from similar reflection and asks, “are we not interested in ameliorating this violence? are we not obligated to stop it’s further dissemination, to consider our role in instigating it, and to foment and cultivate another sense of culturally diverse global political culture” (9). Through this process we might find another meaning and take different action that will benefit countries throughout the world.
Butler discusses the universal human connection of loss and that we are all subject to violence because we have a body. She explains
how human loss (death) can be recognized or ignored and connects how this serves political purposes. Minimizing and ignoring deaths means the difficult questions of why and how do not have to be answered.
“Either you are with us or you’re with the terrorists.” I have heard this quote multiple times. This is the perfect example of the either – or logical fallacy. It deprives us from thinking differently, because to think differently is to be with the “terrorists.” Judith article encourages us to listen and remain open to what others think and to look at possibilities as to why violence like 9/11 occurred. By all means, it does not justify what these “terrorists” did, and it also does not make us responsible for their actions but we are responsible for our actions and make sure it does not happen again. Like Butler stated, “This is not the same as holding the United States exclusively responsible for the violence done within its borders, but it does ask to United States to assume a different kind of responsibility for producing more egalitarian global conditions for equality, sovereignty, and the egalitarian redistribution of resources” (14). It is in our nature to retaliate with violence when someone hurts us or hurt someone we love. Butler suggests that we should first step back and take a different approach and look for the root causes of such violence to prevent from happening again. Instead we didn’t and we still have not. Till this day it haunts me the thousands and thousands of innocent lives that have been lost due to this never-ending war. Yes, we have lost soldiers but we must also remember that we have lost innocent people in different countries in the Middle East.
I love how Butler mentions “collective responsibility.” Like Arendt, Butler wants us to take responsibility for out actions and accept it. This will be the only way we can change our nation. “Our collective responsibility not merely as a nation, but as part of an international community based on a commitment to equality and non-violent cooperation, requires that we ask how these conditions came about, and endeavor to re-create social and political conditions on more sustaining grounds. This means, in part, hearing beyond what we are able to hear” (18)
Butler tells us; “We’re undone by each other. And if we’re not we’re missing something”. Undone as defined by my very old Webster Dictionary is “brought to destruction or ruin, unfastened”. I wondered…how could I possibly tie something that sounds so negative to my service experience? And then I remember my daughter saying to me on the ride home from the airport for Easter break; “the work you’re doing with your student must make you look at EVERYTHING else differently”, and my immediate response was “yes, absolutely everything”. Making the choice and commitment to assist someone, did not require “undoing” or relinquishing the life and relationships that came before the experience, but it has altered them “in ways that challenge the very notion of ourselves as autonomous and in control”. (23) Appointments and plans are made around tutoring sessions, an occasional personal inconvenience is an easy exchange for the weekly success of someone I have made a “different kind of tie” with. (40) No longer having the patience to educate anyone who might foolishly say, “why don’t they just learn English or go back”, I simply distance myself and continue on this new path that “unfastened” me from “certain people”. (22) “Maybe when we undergo what we do, something about who we are is revealed, something that delineates the ties we have to others, that shows us that these ties constitute what we are, ties or bonds that compose us”. (22)
“Our fear of understanding a point of view belies a deeper fear that we shall be taken up by it, find it is contagious, become infected in a morally perilous way by the thinking of the presumed enemy” (8). Wow. Funny thing, while reading this I was not thinking about the U.S. 'rooting out' terrorists, or the government's view of our place within the global framework. After reading this section I was immediately drawn to my Service Learning partner Spectrum, and the issues they face from those who are uneducated. I became aware of this sense of fear that Butler is talking about while doing research for Spectrum. The fear comes from those people, parents, teachers, or administrators who are too ignorant about the subject of LGBT that they would 'black ball' or discourage Spectrum from coming to their school and talking to their students, teachers, and staff because of the reasons Butler mentions above. I have found a genuine fear that parents, teachers and administration, believe that if they allow Spectrum to talk about LGBT issues, than the students will become lesbian, gay or bisexual overnight just by hearing about alternative lifestyles.
Butler's reasoning speaks to the heart of this ignorant logic. “But instead of remaining open to a consequential decentering of First Worldism, we tend to dismiss any effort at explanation, as if to explain these events would involve us in a sympathetic identification with the oppressor, as if to understand these events would involve building a justificatory framework for them” (8). This is precisely why homophobia still exists and the illogical barrier that LGBT and Spectrum have to find a way to penetrate.
“There is as well a narrative dimension to this explanatory framework…we begin the story by invoking a first-person narrative point of view…If someone tries to start the story earlier, there are only a few narrative options” (5). The way one thinks is crucial because it is part of the process of the way we receive information pertaining to violence. The violence that we are subjected to around September 11 has been growing daily due to the war, as stated in This American Life, by WBEZ.
“Our own acts of violence do not receive graphic coverage in the press, and so they remain acts that are justified in the name of self-defense, but by a noble cause, namely, the rooting out of terrorism” (6). The acts of violence that an individual sees as self-defense shows the partner that has been continuous over time, and will most likely continue. Violence has been what many people resort to, which is justified by fixing an issue, and I believe that violence is something that will always be used as a way to resolve the problem at hand. “ But it is one matter to suffer violence and quite another to use that fact to ground a framework in which one’s injury authorizes limitless aggression against targets that may or may not be related to the sources of one’s own suffering” (4).
The work being done by Vy Higginsen at her Momma Foundation for the Arts along with her co-workers at Gospel for Teens, is about more than making music. Her goal is to take a generation of teenagers whose maturation would normally be accompanied by a Hip-Hop or Rap soundtrack, and teach them about their ancestors, what it means to be who they are, and that through the power of song, they can find a voice of their own.
The expectation Vy initially had for the teens who were selected to participate in Gospel for Teens, was that they enter into it completely. To check their ego and personal baggage at the front door. The expectation for the 'beginners' was to approach gospel like entering a sanctuary. Vy soon learned a lesson from those she was trying to teach. This lesson was that each of her students had a story, and background, and baggage that needed a voice. By checking their personal baggage at the front door, Vy realized the students would remain emotionally stagnant. With new insight, Vy could now see that through Gospel for Teens, her students could use the safety and comfort of her 'sanctuary' to tell their stories, and confront the things which made them ashamed or afraid. Forty-six teenagers entered the sanctuary and within the first day were singing in harmony. This is part of Vy's design – that even though before entering into the sanctuary people from different backgrounds, family dynamics, and social class might be strangers, once they walk through the foundation doors they would become one class, one family, one voice. To facilitate this personal growth, Vy would use exercises like the name game to encourage and foster confidence. “These little voices who seem to say, I'm ashamed of who I am and where I come from.” One student in particular caught the Vy's attention. She lacked the courage to speak her name when it was her turn. “I saw her tears. I saw her eyes. I saw her nervousness, about saying her name.” This particular teenager was being raised by her great grandmother, and only saw her mom two or three times a year. Sometimes personal experiences are so difficult that the walls we build around ourselves are so thick that we need to be reminded a sanctuary exists, or that we might actually be standing inside one.
Part of the mission of Gospel for Teens is to take those who come from nothing and give them the hope for something. When the participants in Vy's program sang at a competition they experienced something few, if any had ever experienced – success. “I just wanted them to feel what it was like to win.” I am moved by the devotion of Vy, her commitment to her students and assisting them unload their personal baggage. She gives them sanctuary made of glass and stone, but also sanctuary made from her own heart. “Don't ever let anybody tell you that you're anything less than beautiful.” She believes in her foundation and that it can help these kids face their lives. “How do you get it off of you?” The anguish, fear, and frustration of living within a violent society. “Stand up. Let people see you, and be proud of the fact that you are survivors.” Gospel music is “victorious, it grabs you”
I was reminded of W.E.B. Du Bois' Souls of Black Folk when watching this documentary. DuBoi's book was about the African American drawing strength and solidarity through common sorrow, understanding the past and how it relates to the present, and the freedom of expression through song. “Through all the sorrow of the Sorrow Songs there breathes a hope - a faith in the ultimate justice of things. The minor cadences of despair change often to triumph and calm confidence. Sometimes it is faith in life, sometimes it is a faith in death, sometimes assurance of boundless justice in some fair world beyond. But whichever it is, the meaning is always clear: that sometime, somewhere, men will judge men by their souls and not by their skins” (Du Bois, 214).
Chapter Four, p.76 (narcissism moralized).
“Narcissism moralized” – at first I thought this was negative. I have images in my head of a friend from high school who used to look at himself in the reflection of the school windows. This was my definition and understanding of what it meant to be narcissistic: in love with yourself, and only yourself. Alford challenges this when he speaks of how the whistleblower feels “...contaminated by the corruption of others” (76), because the view of themselves as being “...good, whole, and pure has been corrupted, and they feel ashamed” (76). Alford believes that this loss of wholeness and purity is the “...most important illusion of all. The illusion is narcissism” (76). He continues by saying the narcissist may be viewed as something other than negative if he or she “...raises himself to become one with high ideals, what I call narcissism moralized, or whether the narcissist lowers his ideals to meet the frustrated self” (76). This reminds me of our class discussion and the excerpt from Dan Pink's The Good Life, where we discussed the differences between 'profit goals,' and 'purpose goals.' The belief that “...attainment of a particular set of goals [in this case, profit goals] has no impact on well-being and actually contributes to ill-being” (Pink, 144). Take my high school friend who loved to make sure he looked good at every school window for example, his narcissism was not contributing to his happiness, it was in fact making him more self-conscious and the more he looked the more things he found that he thought he needed to change. Narcissism moralized relates to the whistleblower's sense of identity – everything reflects on them the right and true which they believe is shared by all. From the development of the ego, the infant believes he or she is the entire universe. Everything is me. Through ego separation you form the ideal principle – interconnectedness with the world, the self merging with the larger world. If we look at the whistleblower in this fashion, than the illusions they have are the positive hopes and beliefs in a good, whole, and pure world, which are actually positives. As Alford explains, “In a word, the whistleblower's narcissism has become moralized” (79).
Chapter Five, p.84-94 (Embodiment).
“Impartialist moral theory, the most popular theory in the Western world, is concerned with principles, obligations, and duties that are equally binding on all men and women in similar situations” (84). This, as Alford explains, is why the whistleblower feels shame - “Whistleblowers blow the whistle because they dread living with a corrupted self more than they dread isolation from others” (90). Another phrase I found interesting is when Alford explains that even though the whistleblower is concerned with the suffering of others, this is not why he or she acts. “The whistleblower acts because the unjust suffering of others leads the whistleblower to feel morally corrupted by association” (89). Another interesting phrase is Alford's position on Arendt's views of thought. He believes thinking leads to self-deception. “Not thinking but the self-revulsion that stems from having failed to live up to high ideals, the self-revulsion that so often takes the form of feeling corrupted by others' misdeeds, is the motive force. Thinking only (and it is a big 'only') makes this feeling more available” (92). Also one last phrase that caught my attention was Alford's suggestion that morality is more narcissistic than we think. “...morality is neither impartial nor particularistic. Morality is narcissistic, concerned to preserve the moral purity of the self. From this perspective, the question becomes not whether but how the self involves others in the project of its moral perfection” (94).
Chapter One. p.6-7 (goal and methodology of the book).
“To be a whistleblower is to step outside the Great Chain of Being, to join not just another religion, but another world” (6). Alford's goal in writing Whistleblowers is to raise a question. “What does the organization look like from the perspective of someone who has been forcibly relocated to this other world” (6). He compares the choice to blow the whistle to “space-walking,” in which the individual steps beyond or outside the parameters of society. Alford's methodology is to listen to the stories of the whistleblower, and then examine the sources of “disorder” and “conflict of voices” in the whistleblower's life in order to form his theories (7). He has made it clear that the book is not a 'recounting' of the whistleblower's stories, rather an attempt to use “these narratives, conveying enough of their content to share the with the reader, so as to know something about organizational life that is not apparent from the usual top-down perspective” (7).
Chapter Two. p.21, p.32 (how/why organizations 'sacrifice' whistleblowers). p.35 (workplace values).
According to Alford, the reason for how and why organizations 'sacrifice' whistleblowers is to “disrupt moral behavior” (21). By turning a blind eye the organization “quells individuality” and maintains its distance from the outside world. This is to minimize the morality of the organization's actions, because as Alford says, “Talking about what we are doing means talking about how what we do affects others” (22). Organizations use demoralization and humiliation to put “...him or her under so much psychological stress that it becomes difficult to do a good job” (32). Other tactics used by organizations to get the desired outcome (employee termination) are to transfer them into positions which they are not trained for, relocation to less comfortable working environments, and to “...transform an act of whistleblowing from an issue of policy and principle into an act of private disobedience and psychological disturbance” (32). It is interesting and disturbing to think of an organization taking steps to make the whistleblower the issue, but in the end, the organization doesn't want morality to interfere with productivity or profit. Alford makes an interesting observation about workplace values and their possible influence on democratic values when he refers to Richard Sennett's beliefs “...that the values of the contemporary workplace are undermining the values of the rest of our lives. The fate of the whistleblower heightens these issues, showing that not only does the modern organization do little to foster civic values but that it is committed to the destruction of the individual who displays them” (35).
Chapter Three. p.61-62. (failure of common narrative and how the organization disciplines the ethical individual).
Organizations look for justifiable reasons to terminate the ethical individual (whistleblower). These reasons can alienate the whistleblower from the society he or she has been fighting to protect and live with in. When the organization turns the table on the whistleblower and takes away their power, (their narrative) the whistleblower becomes obsolete. Without an audience to hear the story, the story does not exist. One whistleblower responded to when this occurs, “I have seen the truth, and the truth has shaken my belief in who I am because it has shaken my belief in the world I live in” (61). Organizations have sent individuals to see doctors as a way to place them on medical leave, and say they are too sick to work. This in effect removes the problem from the organization because he or she is not allowed to be in it. Organizations can also force an individual into early retirement with seductive benefit packages removing the threat with severance pay.
| Dr. Paul Farmer |
When Mabel and Sally asked me to participate on this panel, I said yes—I am fundamentally obedient when they are concerned—but with anxiety. It wasn’t the large-scale change part that worried me. That’s why we’re here at Skoll. But “interior dimensions” often leads to dismissive comments about singing Kumbaya. This year is different for many reasons. One stems from having worked in the “quake zone” in Haiti this past year. Another is the presence of “the Arch”—Desmond Tutu—who is no stranger to struggles for large-scale change, or for understanding its interior dimensions. My admiration for the Archbishop comes not so much from his Nobel Prize or other honors, but from his decades of humble service to the poor.
What is there to say about “deep leadership and the interior dimensions of large-scale change” when we’re talking about disasters natural and unnatural—from the Haiti earthquake to apartheid? One thing we can do here, in the city of dreaming spires, is to bear witness to difficult times—and the quake was the most difficult time I’ve been through. Another task, to paraphrase Haiti’s former President, who himself found shelter in South Africa for years, is to “echo and amplify” the voices of the poor majority and those who support them in their struggle for survival and for dignity. After the quake, this diverse group included local women’s groups, international teams of trauma surgeons, Cuban caregivers, and community health workers in the country’s rural reaches. It included so many of you gathered again at the Skoll Forum. Together, we can try to honor the voices silenced on that night fifteen months ago. This is, I believe, the most important kind of “deep leadership”—witnessing, building partnerships, and promoting collaboration rather than competition.
Alas, this has not been easy. Deep leadership will require social entrepreneurs to rethink siloed approaches to “branding,” innovation that is deemed proprietary, as if worthy of patent. It requires not that we reject these notions, but rather that we interrogate them whenever our humanity and dignity are under fire.
Let me describe the events of a single night at the General Hospital, Port-au-Prince’s largest. It was just after the quake. Although there were, in those days, never enough supplies or staff or space for the patients streaming in, expert mercy was not in short supply. Trauma teams from all over had set up tents throughout the damaged hospital. (There were even Scientologists in bright yellow t-shirts, though I didn’t know how to explain to my Haitian colleagues what they were doing, because I hadn’t a clue.)
In one tent, I spied a Haitian doctor standing anxiously over a thirty-four-year-old man who thought he’d escaped serious injury when his parents’ house collapsed around him but now presented in respiratory distress. He looked whole but was gasping for breath. I gave him morphine. His story came tumbling out in shreds: part of a wall had fallen on his legs; it took him an hour to free himself, but he was soon up and helping others in the neighborhood. A physical exam revealed a high fever, but only minor abrasions on his legs. He’d been treated with antibiotics in another facility (the General Hospital was the third one in which he’d sought care), but an X-ray suggested severe pneumonia. We gave him a broad-spectrum antibiotic, and tried to treat him for blood clots that might have traveled from the large veins in his legs to his lungs, but we didn’t have the right formulation of blood thinner on hand.
In a few minutes the morphine kicked in and he was feeling well enough to ask, in one of his first complete sentences, for something to eat. We knew the morphine was responsible for his improvement, but morphine doesn’t last long, nor does it treat problems at their root. Fearing that he wouldn’t survive the night without mechanical ventilation, we tried to transfer him to the USNS Comfort—a navy-ship-turned-hospital steaming, that day, toward Port-au-Prince.
We had many other patients to see that night. A slight elderly woman at the other end of the tent was wracked by the spasms of tetanus—the first of many cases we would see that week and the next. White-haired and weighing about ninety pounds, she had tears rolling down her cheeks. Every few minutes she would go rigid with potentially bone-breaking and suffocating spasms. The slightest stimulus triggered them; she needed to be in a dark, quiet room—but that would move her far away from medical care because, with frequent aftershocks shaking the foundations of the hospital, no one wanted to work inside.
With all this suffering hemming us in from every side, what was there to be said about our own “interior suffering”?
At one point, I ducked outside for a breath of fresh air, and saw a young woman, perhaps twenty-five, lying on a stretcher outside, all alone in the pitch dark. Had she died? No, she was breathing and warm to the touch. I said hello and asked her how she was; she raised her hand and said, simply, “I think my legs are broken.” I looked at an X-ray that had been tucked under her feet: both of her femurs were fractured high up, near the pelvis. I asked if she’d received anything for her pain; she had not. She had no family present; that was clear. She feared that her parents and infant daughter had perished. “The roof fell on us,” she said and began to weep quietly. The best feeling I had during that wretched evening was bringing her pain medications, which soon led her to what might have been her first sleep in days.
As with every night those days, there was no shortage of work and no reason to leave, except that we would be exhausted and useless the next day if we stayed. I tried to corral my coworkers into rest—it was almost midnight, and we’d made some progress: we’d secured for the young man in respiratory distress the promise of a transfer to the floating hospital by helicopter at daybreak; the old woman with tetanus had received antibiotics and heavy doses of diazepam; a number of patients with major trauma were now, like the young woman alone in the dark, resting thanks to pain meds.
We finally left the hospital for houses up the hill, away from the worst damage. We were spent. As our car climbed through a wrecked and darkened neighborhood, a dog darted in front of us and we heard a thud. No one said a word. I got to sleep in the wooden (and thus safer) house of some close friends, far above the heat and stench of the vast, blacked-out city below. There was a bottle of water by my bed and blessed silence.
But I couldn’t sleep. In the dim reaches of misery, insomnia is a constant companion, especially wherever twenty-first-century people die of nineteenth-century afflictions—minor injuries and simple fractures as well as pneumonia, tuberculosis, and other infections, such as tetanus, that are preventable with a vaccine available for pennies. Archbishop Tutu knows exactly what I’m talking about. I was pursued by the sights and smells and sounds of the day: the unrelieved pain; patients and doctors sprinting outside during an aftershock; phone calls from people trapped under rubble; the charnel-house odor from the morgue and from under the rubble. Counting sheep kept turning into the grim process of counting the dead. I even thought of the hapless dog. Was I praying, or fretting, or what? The image of the man who couldn’t breathe was still with me as dawn approached—had he survived the night? Surely the floating hospital could save him.
Hanging on to this hope, I fell into a deep sleep. But after an hour or so, I was shaken alert by a large aftershock. The wood of the house strained and creaked; the paintings in the room tilted; the plastic water bottle at my bedside started to tremble. My host yelled for us to “get out of the house right now!” The sun was coming up, and I watched impassively as the water bottle fell to the floor. I heard people in the house scrambling to get out, and saw, in my mind’s eye, the crushed limbs of people trapped in countless other houses during the quake. I knew I should move and thought of my children, who had spent the recent holidays in Haiti but, by the grace of God, had been spared the fate of so many a few days after they left. It would’ve been prudent to bolt down the stairs and into the street. But I didn’t move a leaden muscle and did not wake again until the sun was high in the sky.
Dr. Paul Farmer is a co-founder of Partners In Health; Kolokotrones University Professor, Harvard University; Chief of the Division of Global Health Equity at Brigham and Women’s Hospital; and UN Deputy Special Envoy for Haiti.
Gospel for Teens is an organization that was started by Vy Higginsen to keep gospel music alive within the youth of New York. Vy’s effort to spread gospel had only began to start the program and helped teens to realize that they have a positive future regardless of their past. Through out the years her program has helped many teens overcome battles and see that they are able to achieve anything no matter where they are from. The exercise that Vy has her students participate in by saying their name, age, and place they live helped the singers to understand that they shouldn’t be embarrassed of where they are from. Vy’s way of having the teens leave their personal problems outside, soon became more of challenge and she had them open up about their past, which seemed to make the group closer. Many of the teens have lost loved ones from gang violence and shootings, which was shocking to Vy to see that almost everyone had recently lost someone. One teen expressed that this was the first time that she felt as if someone cared about her and was so grateful for the program that Vy had started. She also puts so much effort into showing these teens that they can achieve anything, and does not give up on any of them. Vy Higginsen empowers and motivates teens to show then that they can achieve anything with effort that is put forth. Programs such as this have made huge impacts on teens lives and should be recognized more frequently within the community.
What would the whistleblower be left with if he/she didn’t blow the whistle and what do you think may be the biggest sacrifice? What does this choice remind you of?
If the whistleblower never blew the whistle then he or she would still have their “lives,” such as their jobs, families, and respect from other people. “…if by morality we mean feeling empathy and concern for other. What is so difficult is acting on this basis when the self must pay a terrible price: not just the loss of a job but the loss of one’s connection to the world…’space-walking.’(95)”Many people who are whistleblowers are doing it to stand up for what they believe in and it goes against their morals, which can be extremely difficult, it they didn’t blow the whistle for whatever their reason was. The whistleblower feels completely out of control with his life, because he once had control over a certain degree of his life and choice, but it was all taken away after he blew the whistle, which leaves him “space-walking.”
How do you see your concept manifested in your service? Are you able to use your own moral imagination as a “bridge”?
Through my service learning, I have had to listen and understand the students. By having “the ability to take others into account” (67), I have been able to get to know the students and find ways to interact with them on a more personal level. The students that I have grown close with have open my eyes to not judge so quickly, but to take each of their personal backgrounds and issues into account. County has helped me to understand and recognize that being able to take my own morals and thoughts to talk to the student and find ways to connect with them through my personal background as well. The ability to think of others and realize that everyone has much more complicated story than one might know has helped me to better understand.
Here are the notes that you can use to help you focus your discussion--notice that point 3 might provide you a good link to service, but please work in additional ideas from the text as well.
“Narcissism Moralized” A very simplistic breakdown of Alford’s concept: Primary narcissism is Freud’s description of the pre-egoic state in which the infant doesn’t differentiate him/herself from anything else in the world. This is a boundary-less experience of self-hood—the infant experiences him/herself as everything else. Freud also describes this as the “oceanic feeling” which is also associated with mystic experience—a sense of being merged with all reality. This experience of interconnection can then be seen as helping to form the ego ideal. The ego ideal is the perfect self to which the ego “should” strive to become. So, Alford is suggesting that a whistleblower’s conception of the perfect self is one that reflects the experience of primary narcissism in which one’s sense of self can’t be separated out from the larger reality. Thus, self-love, or the defense and the protection of this self is about protecting this greater whole with which one’s identity and selfhood is inextricably intertwined. The whistleblower is motivated to act out of desire to preserve the self, which is embedded/merged with the collective good. (See Alford, 76.)
Starting with the phenomenon: Like Arendt, Alford is starting with “appearances” or what the whistleblower does so that we may “reconsider what constitutes an ethical motive in light of ethical behavior” (65). Read this passage carefully as he is challenging the position of those who would say that narcissism in so a valid ethical motive. What follows will be his illustration of why he is proposing that narcissism moralized may be a new “ethical category” or source for moral behavior. Alford adds later on, “Why people act ethically is afar richer category and more mysterious phenomenon than we know, and our first category should be wonder, not judgment” (79). How does idea this fit with other readings?
Imagination/Empathy as a Bridge to the Other: Our imagination is not just about lightness and joy, but also about, as Alford cites Arendt, “the ability to take others into account” (67). How do you see this concept manifested in your service? Are you able to use your own moral imagination as a "bridge"?
What else stands out for you in Alford’s description of the five types of whistleblower stories? Please find quotes in each of these sections that encapsulate Alford’s meaning. Why is each “story” important to our own understanding of ethics?
Whistleblowers 83-138
Chapt. 5
Embodiment: “The difference between loyalty to universal principles (impartialism) and loyalty to ideal selves who embody these principles. . . The principles obtain value only as they are embodied in oneself” (84). As you know, from the course description, this course is trying to transmit philosophy not just as ideas about how we live, but HOW we live those ideas, “the principle become the self” 86). What is Alford saying about whistleblowers’ ethics in relation to other established theories? (pgs. 84-94). Find the significant phrases that help you to understand what Alford is saying about whistleblower ethics in comparison to each theory that he outlines. There are many notable points—go forth and find them yourself!
Sacrifice: “What is difficult is acting on this basis [empathy and concern for others] when the self must pay a terrible price . . . To risk this takes something more than empathy. It takes narcissism” (95). What if the whistleblower could choose? (Much of Alford’s theory about whistleblower motives implies that they either don’t see this as a choice or they don’t foresee consequences of the sort that actually occur. In the whistleblowers ideal, everyone else would share and act on these same principles—thus the whistleblower is also self-exiled from a world that doesn’t match his/her ideals). What would the whistleblower be left with if he/she didn’t blow the whistle and what do you think may be the biggest sacrifice? What does this choice remind you of? (I’m thinking of Arendt).
“In theory, anyone who speaks out in the name of the public good within the organization is a whistleblower. In practice the whistleblower is defined by the retaliation he or she receives (Alford, 18).” Alford gives the example of an employee reporting something that is unethical and they are not punished for it, which comes to the idea that not all who “blow” the whistle are punished for speaking out. Theory is used to give the example that if it for a positive rational belief that you are blowing the whistle for then, there will not be any negative outcome. The term practice is used to show that by being the one who is rewarded for blowing the whistle can have a positive effect, not always negative.
“Organizations are not just undemocratic. Organizations are the enemy of individual morality (Alford, 35).” Organizations have caused many issues for the one who are whistleblower. They are the reason so many have nothing to show for standing against such large companies and organizations. If a person is to challenge the organization, they face losing their jobs, as well as many other opportunities in their personal life. Organizations have more power than a single person, which causes most of the issues for whistleblowers. Whistleblowers spend such a vast amount of energy and effort on challenging that in the processes they lose more than they have gained through out the experience.
Intro
What the scapegoat knows. Why is this metaphor significant in helping to understand the role of the whistleblower in our society? Why is this “knowledge like a mortal illness” for the whistleblower (5)? What other whistleblower characteristics does Alford delineate? Make sure that you outline the different related points for yourself.
“The whistleblower is the last man, not just tortured but exposed and sacrificed so that others might see what it costs to be an individual in this benighted world. “ By scapegoat I think Alford means as someone that they can make an example of if anyone dares to question or threaten their power. In a way he needs to carry the burden of what society does not know.
Their knowledge is like a “mortal illness” because if they do not speak up they have to live with it and knowing that something is not morally right can slowly destroy them. I think this is especially true with whistleblowers that know about something that may potentially harm humans if they do not speak up.
Chap. 2
How does Alford define whistleblowing? Note difference between “theory” and “practice” (18).
“In theory, anyone who speaks out in the name of the public good within the organization is a whistleblower. In practice the whistleblower is defined by the retaliation he or she receives” (Alford 18). Alford explains that someone who blows the whistle may not necessarily get punished for speaking up, they will correct error and everything will be fine.
When someone becomes the whistleblower is when the company finds that his motives can potentially harm or destroy the company. The company will retaliate and make the whistleblower look like he has issues or that he is the problem. The whistleblower’s intention will never be to cause harm to the company, he is only looking out for the good of society.
Chap. 3.
Narrative Themes in Whistleblower Stories: Choiceless choice, stuck in static time, paranoid themes, “living in the position of the dead” (39). Throughout this chapter, Alford illustrates these themes. Make sure that you find a few crucial quotes in each section that help you to understand Alford’s characterizations.
“The answer is that choiceless choice is a formula for relief from the almost unbearable regret of having let oneself be sent on a suicide mission.” Most whistleblowers will do it because they feel like they won’t be able to live with themselves; they want to be set free. What they don’t realize is that the consequences or effects may not be what they expect. As Hannah puts it, “’Action to be free must be free from motive on the one side, from its intended goal as a predictable effect on the other’”(41). They may be free and able to please their beliefs but they may become trapped in society. Most whistleblowers will have a hard time finding a job in their field, and will live below poverty level. In a sense, whistleblowers will never be free because they will not be able to practice in their career fields.
For other whistleblowers, they become “stuck in static time.” Their story becomes a sequence of events that is never ending. Alford points out that it is normal for anyone be stuck in time especially when we experience a major event; it is soothing. Maybe for that particular reason whistleblowers become stuck, they want their lives to have meaning, “whistleblowers cling to chronology not to slow the world down but to keep it from falling apart” (46). I think that hey want to experience it like it just happened because they don’t want to see what it has done to them.
We will do a reflection in class to relate Whistleblowers to service-learning--so unless something is shouting at you about your SL, use this reflection to try to unpack some of the ideas presented in the reading. I have pasted in the reading points to help you focus, as there are many complex ideas presented in this reading!
What is Alford’s stated goal (6) in writing this book on this subject? What is his methodology? (Also see pages 32-33, 35)
What the scapegoat knows. Why is this metaphor significant in helping to understand the role of the whistleblower in our society? Why is this “knowledge like a mortal illness” for the whistleblower (5)? What other whistleblower characteristics does Alford delineate? Make sure that you outline the different related points for yourself.
Consequences and Costs: Power, Politics, and Who Pays? Or What Happens When Ethical Discourse Becomes Impossible” (36). Who benefits when ethics is separated from politics? What is Alford’s point? You should be happy to see that you already have some foundation here as you have just read Arendt (10-13). Connect these ideas to Alford’s point at the end of Chap. 2.
Chap. 2
How does Alford define whistleblowing? Note difference between “theory” and “practice” (18).
How/Why Organizations “Sacrifice” Whistleblowers: “The best way to disrupt moral behavior is not to discuss it and not to discuss not discussing it” (21). Make sure that you understand what Alford means by this (pay close attention to other crucial sentence s on page 22) and notice how he illustrates through whistleblower stories. You may want to reread after you read the themes section.
Themes in Whistleblower Stories (31-32): Alford lays these out for you. Make sure that grapple with these points.—you may want to reread the stories. (These are brief glimpses, he will go deeper in the next chapter)
Workplace Values: “Organizations are not just undemocratic. Organizations are the enemy of individual morality” (35).
Chap. 3.
The Significance of Narrative (shared vs. shattered meaning): What is Alford telling us about the way that we usually make sense of our own lives and those of others? Why is this cohesion lacking from the whistleblowers story (and reality)? Look for multiple points about this throughout chapter. These observations are important and fascinating on many levels, not just in relation the whistleblower.
Narrative Themes in Whistleblower Stories: Choiceless choice, stuck in static time, paranoid themes, “living in the position of the dead” (39). Throughout this chapter, Alford illustrates these themes. Make sure that you find a few crucial quotes in each section that help you to understand Alford’s characterizations.
The Failure of Common Narrative or The Story that Can’t Be Heard and How the Organization “Disciplines” the Ethical Individual: Alford will go into more detail on these points in future chapters. Anything here that you can relate to something in your own experience or in relationship to your service-learning?