Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Morality, Decisions, and Beliefs

I very much enjoyed reading the two chapters from How We Decide by Jonah Lehrer. The text takes an in-depth look at how logic, emotions, and empathy are related to neuroscience. The sixth chapter focuses on morality, while the seventh chapter delves into decision-making.

Lether opens his sixth chapter by talking about a psychopath, John Wayne Gacy. He goes on to explain that the defining characteristic of a psychopath is that he or she lacks emotion responses and is therefore unable to empathize with others (170-171). The argument Lether makes is that morality is essentially what psychopaths lack. He writes, “When you act in a moral manner… you are thinking about the feelings of others, sympathizing with their states of mind” (169). Lether goes on to explain that the prefrontal cortex, the part of brain responsible for reasoning, becomes active only after the emotional parts of the brain have already reacted to a moral decision (172-173). He further explores morality by looking at a particular neurological study. The study found that impersonal moral decisions, such as having a trolley run over one person instead of five, were processed by the rational parts of the brain while more personal moral decisions, such as pushing someone in front of a trolley to save five people, were processed by parts of the brain related to empathy (176-177).

The brain continues to be examined at in the seventh chapter. Lether contends that when the brain makes a decision, different areas of the brain compete to provide the response (198-199). One neurological experiment mentioned involved the option of purchasing goods. The scientists found the brain was rewarded in proportion to how much the subject desired a particular product, but that a suppression mechanism and the prefrontal cortex were activated after the subject was told the cost (200). A separate experiment suggests that people are able to ignore information that contradicts their already held beliefs. Instead, they use their prefrontal cortex to rationalize the information and then reward their brains for coming to a favorable conclusion (205). Later on in the chapter, Lether offers a historical example of how people can become confident in their decisions to the point that they reject a plethora of evidence to the contrary. To this end, Lether encourages his readers to force themselves to think about opinions they oppose (216-217).

I think the neurological discoveries Lether highlights can have very real implications. For example, common wisdom suggests more informed voters are able to come to more rational political decisions. According to the evidence provided in these chapters, however, political decisions have much more to do with preexisting biases. I didn’t feel much of what Lether discussed applied to my service at Coleman Elementary. However, toward the end of chapter six he does mention monkey experiments that suggest social interaction is crucial for the development of children (190-191). This does tie in with the afterschool program at Coleman, as it provides an environment where the children have spend several extra hours interacting with each other.

- Christopher Galbick

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.