Arendt defines collective responsibility as a whole linked collective being held responsible for the actions of the collective, and not due to any act of the individual. Arendt also defines two conditions that must be met for something to be defined as collective responsibility. Firstly, she writes that “I must be held responsible for something I have not done” (149), that individual acts are pointless in the evaluation of the collective responsibility. She then goes on to define the second condition, that “the reason for my responsibility must be my membership in a group which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve” (149). This means that the collective being held responsible must have set members that are “non vicarious” participants in the event in question. This means that no participant is acting through another and all are active in the group membership. The most common example she cites of a situation where collective responsibility is often identified and used is in regards to politics. She writes, “Every government assumes responsibility for the deeds and misdeeds of its predecessors and every nation of the deeds and misdeeds of the past” (149).
In chapter 2, “Significance of Thinking”, Arendt describes her three main propositions that define thinking. The first is that man is a thinking being. If you are human, you think. Regardless of your level of intelligence, be it quite low or high, you still go through the same process of thinking about objects as everyone else does. She writes that “the faculty of thinking. . .must be ascribed to everybody; it cannot be a privilege of the few” (166). Secondly, she continues, is that thinking is a fruitless effort due to the fact that the mind “has a ‘natural aversion’ against accepting its own results as ‘solid axioms’ . . . [and therefore] no final code of conduct from the thinking activity [can be safely derived] (167). Thirdly, that thought deals with objects that are completely abstract and out of sight. In a world of visible and tangibles, thought is invisible and intangible.
Knowing means having information stored in your brain. You have information built up in almost a scientific method that cumulates into the worldview you hold. Thinking is almost a clandestine activity, which relates secret thoughts in a great changing environment. So, following from this, Arendt asks the question: “How can anything relevant for the world we live in arise out of so resultless an enterprise” (167).
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.