Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Perspectives and Viewpoints

This week we were asked to read the first two chapters of Judith Butler’s Precarious Life. Her writing felt complex and extensive, yet had a multitude of impressive insights woven in throughout the text. The first chapter looks at more holistic perspectives, while the second chapter focuses on the viewpoint of the individual.

The first chapter of Precarious Life opens with Butler discussing anti-intellectualism. It becomes apparent to the reader that this term refers to situations where dissenting opinions, even when expressed in an intelligent manner, are rejected out of hand and associated with “the enemy.” Butler exemplifies this with the Iraq war, as well as with the segmentation of the “East” and “West” (1-2). Further in the text, Butler discusses what she refers to as “First World complacency” (7). She seems to urge Americans to look at events from something akin to a third person or global perspective, as well as the first person or national perspective that is so easy to adopt (7-9).Another topic Butler explores in the first chapter is the line between individual and collective responsibility. She proposes that the individuals behind acts of violence certainly have a level of responsibility, but that external forces ultimately helped condition those individuals to make the choices that they made. The responsibility is essential shared between conditions that led to the act as well as the act itself (15-16).

In Butler’s second chapter, the focus alters significantly. Butler starts out by making the argument that, from a particular individual’s perspective, certain human lives are considered more valuable than others. She even goes as far as to making the distinction between lives that are considered “grievable” and those that are not (20). Butler appears to see grief as an expression of how important a person’s relationships are to him or her. She also believes, sensibly, that a lack of grief is abnormal. Both of these propositions are evidenced in her words: “Let’s face it. We’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something” (23). Later in the chapter, Butler brings the conversation back to viewpoints of individuals by discussing “derealization” (33). Here she suggests that if human lives are never made into real and grievable beings to the individual, then that individual will not see those lives as noteworthy and therefore will not be affected if those lives are affected by violence (33-34).

One of Butler’s earlier points, the contrast between individual and collective responsibility, was brought up just last week when we read some of Arendt’s work. In Arendt’s book Responsibility and Judgement, she gives a definition of sorts for collective responsibility. She writes, “Two conditions have to be present for collective responsibility: I must be held responsible for something I have not done, and the reason for my responsibility must be my membership in a group (a collective) which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve, that is a membership which is utterly unlike a business partnership which I can dissolve at will” (149). These thoughts can be applied fairly well to Butler’s example of the Iraq war in relation to Americans. Americans certainly did not enact terrorism upon themselves, but they are a fairly permanent element of the United States government. Previous actions of the U.S. government, in turn, had undoubtedly created a negative effect on those who would later become terrorists. A much simpler example of individual and collective responsibility could be seen in my service at Coleman Elementary school. I volunteer with the afterschool program designed to help students who are behind in their studies. It is not completely the fault of students that they are in this situation. More likely, a combination of factors at home and in the classroom have contributed to this outcome.

- Christopher Galbick

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.