Lehrer’s, “The Moral Mind”, definitely catches a reader’s eye. By opening with a story of a psychopath that no one knew existed he gets the reader hooked. What interested me the most about his introduction was not the story of the psychopath but the fact that he emphasized the element of making decisions. When you think of it, a psychopath that goes undetected is very well thought out and knows what he or she is doing in order to go under the radar. The immediate reaction when thinking on the subject is to just dismiss the person as a monster when in reality he or she is just a person lacking emotional response. A quote provided in the text given by James Blair, a cognitive psychologist that researches this topic, stated, “You know when you see a scared face in a movie and that makes you automatically feel scared, too? Well, psychopaths don’t feel that (170).” To build on that concept, another quote that struck out to me was, “When it comes to making ethical decisions, human rationality isn’t a scientist, it’s a lawyer (173).” We all make decisions after a careful analysis of the situation is done. Psychopaths do the same thing, only they lack an emotion piece that is needed when making moral decisions.
Not only is emotion needed when making moral decisions but emotion is needed in a child’s development. What really caught my attention in “The Moral Mind” was the report given from the orphanages of Romania. It is eye opening to read things like, “babies were left in cribs with nothing but plastic bottles (192)” and, “in some orphanages, more than 25 percent of the children died before the age of five (192).” And if that wasn’t enough to give you pause it was the life-long effects that the orphanage experience had on the children that survived. Not only did the children suffer physical side effects, such as permanent scarring and stunted growth, but they suffered psychological effects as well. The children tended to be violent or abusive to others or could even stare at nothing for hours at a time and just randomly break out into a violent rage. The children’s brain analysis showed, “significantly reduced levels of vasopressin and oxytocin, two hormones crucial for the development of social attachments (193).” It is evident that an emotional aspect of learning is a key component during the early stages of life and necessary in order to become a morally conscious adult later on.
In Lehrer’s other excerpt for the class, “The Brain is an Argument”, he changes gears from an emotional focus to the inconsistencies of the brain. One statement that Lehrer made in the beginning of his argument that stuck out to me was, “There’s something unsettling about seeing the brain as one big argument (203).” I took this quote and asked myself what I thought about the concept of the brain being an argument and I have to say that it didn’t feel right to me. I completely agree with Lehrer in that an argument, or dissonance, in the brain doesn’t sit well with me. When I think of the basic decisions in my life, like what will I wear to school, it seems automatic to me but if I really sit and think about it I do debate about it. What you are going to wear depends on what the weather is like or what you are going to do that day (if you are going on a hot date you aren’t going to wear your fat jeans).
An example that Lehrer used to explain the argument that our brain undergoes is the analysis of split brain patients. Split brain patients undergo a surgery where the brain is split in two at the corpus callosum. The patients were given a shown a two pictures and asked to pick out of a different set of pictures the patients were asked to pick out the one that would best compliment the pictures they had seen at the beginning of the experiment. What is peculiar about these patients is they will point to two different things. For example, if you were to show the subjects shows a cow on the right side and a barn on the left side the subject will later pick a cow bell with the left hand and a bale of hay with the right hand. Because the patients’ brain is split they are unable to make it a whole picture but instead of accepting that there is an argument between the pictures he or she will make up a story that makes his or her answer plausible. The reason for this, according to Lehrer, is, “[There is] a deep need to repress inner contradictions is a fundamental property of the human mind (211).” Instead what we should do is accept the inner argument and let it happen.
In regards to my service projects, I can see evidence from both articles in my service. The kids at Marin County Community School are products of unstable homes, like the orphans in Romania. Because of that unstable home there is a possibility that were not able to develop the same emotional component that is necessary to make the moral decisions that are acceptable in society. For example, because they were raised around stealing they would be able to steal without any regret even though it is not acceptable in society. For the young moms of Marin, there is a concept of ignorance that led them to the situation they are in. Because suffer from the “superhuman” complex that all teenagers have, also known as “it will never happen to me” complex, they were having unprotected sex without the acceptance of getting pregnant. In “The Brain is an Argument”, Lehrer argued that, “we all silence the cognitive dissonance through self-imposed ignorance (207).” Ignorance is also evident in the Marin County kids who think that they can do things like drug dealing and steal cars but not get caught. Unfortunately, you do get caught and they are forced to learn the lesson the hard way. By approaching the situation with these two articles in mind it broadens my perspective of the way these kids I work with might be thinking. Because I am not in their position it is hard to put myself on the level but I feel that with these two articles I can understand a little bit better than before.
By: Meghann Jones (in case anyone is wondering)
ReplyDelete