Monday, October 31, 2011

Gains - Whitney Myers

The aspect of ‘service’ that I seem to struggle most with is the question of how to determine what actually qualifies as ‘service.’ Say service might be defined simply as any activity that helps others; do occupations like ‘teacher’ or ‘doctor’ count as service? They do not seem to be generally accepted as such, but are of great assistance to many. The main reason that those occupations are unacceptable as service seems to be that they are paid positions. Can a paid position be considered service? What if the pay is low enough? Or if the job is difficult enough? What the teachers at MCCS do seems to qualify as service to me, as does what most teachers do, though they are undoubtedly paid some amount. Does monetary return negate the help that an occupation might offer to society, so that it cannot count as true service? And if so, does any return at all remove an activity’s value as service? I do not believe so, but there does seem to be a prominent disagreement about the correlation between service and gain, even emotional gain.

The authors of On Kindness ask the same questions about kindness, and what might or might not qualify as kindness. They indicate that kindness also suffers argument between those who believe that kindness can be defined simply as any benevolent action, and those who believe that that action must come without personal gain to be valid. “The most long-standing suspicion about kindness is that it is just narcissism in disguise. We are kind because it makes us feel good about ourselves: kindly people are self-approbation junkies” (111). The suspicion that kind actions lose some of their value when the one performing the action might be performing in self-interest is one that the authors of On Kindness find unfounded. Kind actions stand whether they are driven by pure intent to help or not. Indeed, Phillips and Taylor do not support the validity of self-interest itself, let alone its ability to affect kindness. “The notion of self-interest implies that we always know what we want, by knowing what the self is and what its interests are…” (13). It does not seem viable that the conditions for self-interest can be met when it comes to the return gained from kind actions, as that return is largely indefinable, one of the issues that Phillips and Taylor cite in the disassociation between modern society and kindness.

I found another of Phillips’ and Taylor’s reasons for the detachment between our society and kindness especially interesting. They cite envy in this issue. “…Only the self-caring child who enjoys being alive will ‘seek to extend his being and enjoyments’ to others… People think that they envy other people for their success, money, fame, when in fact it is kindness that is most envied, because it is the strongest indicator of people’s well-being, their pleasure in existence” (111). According to the authors of On Kindness, because only one who enjoys life will seek to create joy in other’s lives, that one is in a position to be envied. Envy is not a friendly emotion, and might create animosity toward the kind one. Kindness will not be desirable if it should create such animosity, and Philips and Taylor believe that this is one of the reasons that kindness has become less desirable.

It seems to me that both kindness and service can be valid, as long as they accomplish their purpose, to better people’s lives and to help people find more joy. The authors of On Kindness seem to agree that it does not matter that they might also create emotional return, or even other types of gain, for those that are kind or do service.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.