Sunday, February 28, 2010

Prompt for On Kindness

In a sense, this is more than a prompt, it is also a bit of a reading guide to help you, hopefully, get to the crux of the ideas presented here--try not to react to the premise of these ideas but to reflect on the philosophical implications.

1. Against Kindness

The authors' thesis (you may not agree but try to see this on a societal level, not from your individual perspective) is that, “[m]ost people appear to believe that deep down they (and other people) are mad, bad, and dangerous to know. . . our motives are utterly self-seeking, and that our sympathies are forms of self-protection” (4).

The authors suggest that although many of us live the kind life in “instinctive sympathetic identification with the vulnerabilities and attractions of others. . . but without a language in which to express this, or cultural support for it” (4)

(Again, remember, at times we have to over-generalize in order to be able to examine collective issues, and if we look at the state of our own country in the moment, there may be some evidence that supports these claims.)

One of the reasons, that the authors suggest, for our ambivalence about our instinct for kindness, has to do with our own vulnerability, not wanting to experience our own weaknesses: “Bearing other people’s vulnerability—which means sharing in it imaginatively and practically . . .––entails being able to bear one’s own” (11). In a sense, what we have in common is our vulnerability (an idea that Judith Butler will elaborate on in Precarious Life).

Thus, kindness has an internal tension—it brings us pleasure but it also reminds us of all that we fear about ourselves including change. (There is also an interesting discussion about whether kindness requires selflessness—hopefully we will discuss in class as this is important and a theme that will come up in C. Fred Alford’s book on whistleblowers.)

Think about these ideas in relationship to your service. Can you illustrate through an experience that you have had already or in relation to your own process of starting this commitment? Use other parts of the reading to make more connections and elaborate. Such as:

2. A Short History of Kindness

(To continue the discussion of selflessness vs selfishness) Two Enlightenment views of kindness: “For most of pre-modern history . . . kindness was seen as a solution to a problem: the problem of other people”(27). Kindness was seen as a bridge between separate entities in which the motive was more about surviving as an individual. The alternative view did not see people as separate entities but as interconnected (28). The authors illustrate this view with Adam Smith’s philosophy of “fellow feeling” and “imaginative projection of self into other” (29).

Continue to probe and unpack these ideas and use other parts of the history to explore and connect these ideas. If we are interdependent, is it selfish to be kind? And if we are interdependent, is it possible to be selfless? Maybe you can connect to your ideas above about your service experience.

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Sorry I am late...I did not have web access while away. I was amazed by the findings of the study by Antonio Damasio, when patients with orbitofrontel cortex damage lose most of their emotional lives, yet their reasoning and logical abilities remain in tact. When this occurs they basically become non-functional. One would think that they would be able to navigate most situations cooly and calmly( see Spock from the "Star Trek" series) yet they lack the ability to make simple decisions. Throughout my life I have been told that I am very emotional. For years my brother and sisters called me a cry baby. In my adult life I have used my humor as a tool to navigate the business world and to help build relationships with my co-workers. But I have never tied(consciously anyway) my emotions to the way I might make a decision considering different choices to make. I have always felt that I made rational decisions based on facts and plausible outcomes that would result in the most beneficial outcome. In retrospect it is emotion or desire that drives what we do and the need to accomplish a task or goal. During my working life I have also witnessed co-workers who have blown themselves up, led themselves to be fired because they were unable to control their emotions and just do there jobs. Granted in the corporate world there are many injustices and much unfairness and remaining unemotional to a certain extant helps to just maintain your job and tow the company line. Yet my emotion has helped me remain competitive and keep giving my all to try and reach ver increasing company targets. "reason and emotion must both work together to create intelligent behavior, but emotion does most of the work" We sure do need both. I just always assumed it was the reason that ruled the day.

Friday, February 19, 2010

The Psychology of Compassion

Interesting op-ed. . . last night I watched the documentary about Nick Kristoff called Reporter. They talk about his methods in which he pays a lot of attention to how to best get the attention of the world--by telling individual stories which don't cause the kind of psychic numbing that people get when they are confronted by the numbers and data related to genocide, poverty, and other social horrors.

from Katherine

‘Reading “Living by a Love Ethic” made me think why in the twenty-first century is Love still so complicated, since it is so desired universally by every man woman and child. Yet many members in Americas have embraced fear as a motive to discard love, and replace it with material things and have designed their lives to be about them selves. Lady Ga Ga’s lyrics in her song “Vanity” define the tone of a budding society that is in need of “VALUES LIVING BY A LOVE ETHIC.”

Vanity

Popular and glamorous, we love ourselves no one else

Touch me, touch me baby but don’t get to attached, this is a brink affair

Look at me

Look at me

Marrriane Williamson states in chapter six from “VALUES LIVING BY A LOVE ETHIC.” Society’s collective fear of love must be faced if we are to claim to a love ethic can inspire us and give us the courage to make necessary changes.” I think apathy has silenced the nation and then leads me to question does a collective society embrace love. Since there is no such thing as a perfect love has it been overrated into some obscure myth that is no longer attainable. Love is work, love ethics is work, and love has both the qualities of being beautiful and ugly. This particular sentence of Marianne Williamson resonates within me “ When we choose to love, we choose to move against fear- against alienation and separation. The choice to love is a choice to connect--to find ourselves in the other. “

Why aren’t global leaders engaging in a dialogue with members of society to collective imagining a world that consciously recognizes the value of loving thy neighbor?

Jackie De Shannon’s song “What The World Needs Now” hit the charts in May of 1965. Teenagers, people in their mid twenties, thirties, and on up loved this song and it inspired you to smile when you heard it. This song should be re-adapted and sung by a popular artist today and convey this message globally

What the world needs now,

Is love, sweet love?

It's the only thing that there's just too little of.

What the world needs now,

Is love, sweet love,

No, not just for some but for everyone.

The January earthquake in Haiti earthquake, engaged people collectively, who in turn immediately formed into groups from every segment of society, rich, poor, middleclass, religious non-religious to address the overwhelming issues, devastation, and magnitude of problems effecting the people and families of the Haitians. This demonstrated the worth of other human beings welfare and was defined not by individuation but by actions that defined community within communities to organize, raise immediate funds, medical supplies, transportation of volunteers, and expediting it as quick as humanly possible. Every action we take those values another human beings worth moves us in the direction of love ethics.

Beautiful thing happen everyday and inspires one to believe in humanity.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Why do we do terrible things? Don't we know better?

I was very touched by all of the readings, the way they all connected to one another and the way that they are all analyzing human behavior in order to try and figure out how we can live more harmoniously. I have done some things in my life that I am very ashamed and guilty about, I have manifested the evil that Needleman talks about in Why Can't We Be Good? The harm that I caused to myself and to other people is something I will never forget. The only way I have been able to overcome my guilt, is to confide in a loved one, to talk to someone else. From my experiences with acting "badly", or against my moral code, I have learned so much about what is important to me. Needleman notes that human companionship, listening to other people, listening to our intuitions and continuing to try and understand human nature are some of the hope that we have in becoming good. Listening to those moments of humanity that we all experience, his examples; the mutual compassionate love, all embracing grief and sorrow, awesome instant response to life threatening danger etc. These moments, although fleeting, are those moments that everyone can relate to as human beings.
The Divided Self was a fascinating read. I was reminded of the work I did in the course: Philosophy of Human Nature; digging into all of the ways that we are interconnected to others. Our idea of individuality as an illusion. I see community like a banyan tree, as it grows the tree lowers its branches to the ground where it takes root and gives the illusion of being its own tree, but in actuality is thoroughly connected in the network of the entire banyan tree. So it is with our lives, as we construct houses and fences that separate us from our neighbors, and community. We fail to see that we all need one another.


Reading the Divided Self, provided me with a new perspective on my own body as well. The idea of having a separate "gut brain" explained so much to me! As well as the reintroduction of the idea that what we resists persists. We tend to generate our own negative and positive as we project outwardly what is happening in our own bodies. This appears to be because we are not as individual as we appear. We are interdependent upon others for our own survival. We lean on others to perform tasks that we are unable or unwilling to do ourselves. This indisputable reality is reflected through our economic system.


In Why Can’t we be Good, they describe the “Original Sin” of ignorance, and I have to agree. To go about our days purchasing goods that we know are derived of the labors of children or indentured servants, or at the exploitation of poor developing countries is a sin. And to not address these issues openly and honestly is the greatest sin! When the almighty dollar trumps human dignity and life, we should question it.
Imagine a world existing without the counter balance of organizations like the Red Cross, or Unicef, or Doctors without Borders. The world would be a frightening place! We create our own Hell and Heaven within our own minds and thus in the world around us. The interplay of all our realities colliding and commingling creates a friction that we encounter as energy. We have control over some of this within our minds, and we can use our minds to communicate our shared life experiences with others in an attempt at harmony. This is how we get music and art, or great literature. This shared experience we all have helps to bring out the better side of our humanity. When we get caught up in the material, the money, the cars, the stuff that fill our homes and clutters our conscience, we lose that goodness and are more apt to turn a blind eye to the injustices, and inhuman capabilities of our fellow men. We all have a responsibility to one another, friend, relative, and stranger alike. In other words, we need to step above simply recycling our cans and bottles, and take the time to know what we are doing, and what we purchase, are both good for us inside and good for humanity at large.


The Elephant and the Rider

In the Happiness Hypothesis, the author describes a theory that was developed over time. That theory was to think of the mind and self as an elephant and a rider. The elephant is our base emotional responses and feelings. The rider is our rational mind. We struggle with these two forces inside of us constantly. The rational mind sees what is best, but we often are controlled by the elephant - which leads us the opposite way.

The author's theory is a metaphor for human nature - the several different aspects of ourselves that must be reconciled in order for us to truly become a full person. This struggle never truly ends, and it - in many ways - is what truly defines us. Logic verse emotion, rational verse feeling body verse mind - these are the constant battles within us.

This may be all well and good for a person with a scientific view of the world, but I believe that it leaves out a critical part of the equation: the spiritual. There is no mention of a force outside of ourselves that can, in any way, influence us. This, I feel, is essential to the struggle. After all, if there is no outside force creating situations, then there is no need for either the elephant or the rider. Also, if there is no spirituality, there is no way to short cercuit the entire process and allow us to see outside of ourselves from time to time.

However, my thoughts and opinions are not of importance here. What is important is the author's views - which seem to be this: We have a rational way of thinking, we have emotions. These come into conflict - the only way that we can progress through life is by allowing this conflict, recognizing it for what it is, finding a way to harmonize the two dissident sides, and grow. Marvellous.
I really enjoyed The Divided Self. I really liked the scientific aspect, including split-brained patients, and the expansion of the human brain. I enjoy any theory as to why we think the way we do and how things such as a tumor can rapidly change the way a person acts, talks, and thinks. The thought of driving to the airport being automatic is so obvious, and I have never given much thought to the fact that driving, daydreaming, blinking, breathing, etc. are all so automatic and require no thought at all to execute, and controlled processing is limited. The older I get, the more time I take to make decisions and I find myself mentally walking through scenarios before I can act. I guess there really is no substitute for experience.
In Why Can't We Be Good, I am fascinated with the concept of evil without and the evil within. I also have never considered that the feeling of guilt is founded on the premises that one could have acted differently, while remorse is the state of one's being that has been revealed. I do not think, at least for me, that I can have guilt without remorse. In saying that, they tend to be blurred into one emotion. I can not help to wonder if there is a "good" element that exist is mankind, somekind of moral guideline. I would guess that it is organized religion. In instances where religion is absent, traditions that even include canabalism are present. I believe that religion offers a moral guideline, eventhough it is also the root cause of many atrocities.
What stood out for me was the following quote from The Divided Self: "Human thinking depends on metaphor (p.3)." This I believe is true if one has examples of thinking about life experiences then it is much easier to understand. But just like times change metaphors changed as well. Now a metaphor has to be about things we use today, such as cars, computer, or other technology. At the same time one should be able to relate to the metaphor. For example if a person has limited interaction with animals but has more interaction with technology then a metaphor with an animal may not be as useful or as related to him or her a good metaphor would be one that involves technology.

The question that Jacob Needleman of "Why Can't We Be Good?" may well be linked to Freud. The ego , superego and id may have something to do with the actions we make. Many of the things do are not always good one because sometimes one of these take over the others. Sometimes our desires are not always good ones or are meant to do good but we do them anyways; that is when the id is possibly taking over the ego and superego.

from Cathy. . .

The Divided Self was really interesting to me. I love the metaphor of the elephant and its rider to represent, the automatic vs. conscious/rational parts of the brain. I could especially relate to the discussion in the section titled “First Division: Mind vs. Body” for its specific examples of how our bodies represent an automatic response to what is going on (IBS, “gut feelings and intuitions” (6)) because for me, gut feelings and intuition factor in very heavily in how I respond to the world. I learned to listen to my gut feelings the hard way. There was a situation back in the 1980s when I lived in the Bronx, NY, and I did not listen to my gut, and consciously considered the possibility that someone was stalking/following me on a subway ride. I rationalized the concern away even when after I disembarked he followed me into my neighborhood and then into the lobby of my apartment building. I STILL tried to tamp down my gut feeling that I was being followed by rationalizing that it’s a big city with lots of people, and even though I’ve never seen this guy on my usual subway commute—stop imagining things and move along! Well, he was following me, and he tried to push himself in the door behind me when I unlocked my apartment door. Luckily he did not succeed and I was able to fight him off and push him back out and lock my door. That was a HUGE lesson for me to listen to my gut feelings! My instincts were absolutely correct in that event. After that I started listening to my elephant!
In Values: Living by a Love Ethic, I was struck by the unfortunate truth of the following quote: “As a culture we are obsessed with the notion of safety. Yet we do not question why we live in states of extreme anxiety and dread. Fear is the primary force upholding structures of domination. It promotes the desire for separation, the desire not to be known. When we are taught that safety lies always with sameness, then difference, of any kind, will appear as a threat. When we choose to love we choose to move against fear—against alienation and separation. The choice to love is a choice to connect—to find ourselves in the other” (93). How this relates to me is that I tend to speak out and question authority or my colleagues when my gut starts telling me it is concerned (or “fears”) some result. I see that others have similar fears because they’ll comment in private but are too afraid to speak their minds because they disagree about an approach to a problem. My rationale for overcoming my fear and speaking out could be out of love. Love for the reputation of a group I have committed to be a part of. My rationale is, I would rather have some position we take be fully challenged from within, so that we can prepare for similar criticism from outside. Better from within than without is my motto. If you anticipate a problem, you can often do things to better explain a position in a way that helps others understand why you have decided to take a certain approach and accept it more easily—even if they’re not crazy about the idea.
Unfortunately I haven’t finished reading Why Can’t We Be Good, but from what I’ve read so far, I am very interested in the discussion of guilt and remorse (page 101?). I hope to complete reading before class tonight because I am not clear about where this idea is going. Looking forward to the discussion!

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Living by Love Ethic is a wonderful piece of writing. However, it felt a little unrealistic. If everyone on the earth was a good person who treated others how they wanted to be treated there would be no war, violence or any other negative things. This is just not true as far as I'm concerned. I think that treating all people well is a very difficult thing to do and many people want to take the easy way out. Don't get me wrong, I believe in treating everyone equally and I wish the world was more loving. It's just not reality. However, there were two quotes that I felt were very powerful. The first is from Wendell Berry who wrote, "They know that work ought to be necessary; it ought to be good;it ought to be satisfying and gratifying to the people who do it; and genuinely useful and pleasing to the people for whom it is done"(pg 100) Ideally this is true, I just wish it was a reality. Just think how great it would be if everyone had a positive attitude and wanted to help their fellow man. The other quote states: "When we let our light shine, we draw to us and are drawn to other bearers of light"(101). My belief is that if you if you treat people well, than you will only get something positive in return. In other words, if you smile at someone they will smile back. The golden rule!
In The Divided Self the author talks about how people who can focus do better in life. I found this to be very interesting because it makes sense to me. When I'm really interested in something I tend to have a much higher chance to succeed than if I have little interest in the subject. This success usually gives you confidence and more of a chance to improve. Most people tend to avoid things that they are not interested in and their level of success will suffer. One example that I can think of is in the sporting world. People who are great athletes feel confident in their ability, while people who struggle have less confidence. This sense of confidence will help you improve your abilities. That is why it is important to be exposed to all kinds of things at an early age.

Another thing that I found to be very interesting was this idea that the things that are shocking are the things we remember. In the section where he speaks of mental intrusion, the author explains that the more we try to forget something the more we think of it. People usually do not obsess about pleasant things, we usually remember the negative. This rings true in my life.

The Two Goods Made Me Ponder

Something I found particularly impressive in the reading was the two different forms of what being “good” is. How there is the intellectual good and the actual good that one can feel in their bones. I have never really given that side of goodness much thought, and to be honest never even realized it even existed. Now that it brought to my attention, and I have to say I wholeheartedly agree with it too, that the best kind of goodness, is the goodness that is felt because it feels so genuine. It’s funny like I know I do good things all the time, however that genuine “good” feeling/action is really rare.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Prompt for week of Feb 15th

Read the chapter, "The Divided Self" (Haidt, The Happiness Hypothesis). Read the chapter, " Values: Living by A Love Ethic” " (hooks, All About Love) and/or the selection from Needleman's Why Can't We Be Good. These readings are not long or difficult, so I hope you read all three.

Haidt writes about the dualities present in our humanness that influence our thinking, our actions, and our capacity for moral being. He also really deconstructs the mind/body split that traditional philosophers have usually reinforced--Needleman also speaks to this, the power of embodiment . Haidt also writes about the role of the emotions in our rational thinking and hooks plays this out a lot more in her chapter in her thoughts about love as a source for community building and openness to the reality of others. You can use these connections between the readings and unpack them further and/or see what other connections you make. Extra credit for working with all three readings!

Saturday, February 6, 2010

reflection

Hearing how Paulo Freir described leaders really spoke to me. Daily life and influences are what makes someone unique, and how people decide to use their energy is what separates leaders from followers. Having the courage to stand up for something that you believe in can be extremely difficult. If a task seems too daunting, starting is almost impossible. In order to achieve or accomplish something, one must take the first step, and that is hard. Leaders are born from the momentum that is gained when you choose a side, and feel strongly enough to stand up for your position.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

One concept that I have grappled with in our readings relates directly to the pervading themes of theory and practice and one’s individual moral calling. In particular, it is that which Myles Horton refers to in We Make the Road by Walking when speaking of “being neutral” vs. “choosing a side” in a cause. It is a difficult concept for me because in the way Horton explains it, “neutrality has nothing to do with anything but agreeing with what is and what will always be” (102). Yet, for me personally, I have seen neutrality as an important learning place before accepting ideas and choosing sides wholeheartedly. At the same time, however, I think I may understand where Horton is coming from and I feel I can find agreement.

In part, this is tough because Horton is speaking from the standpoint of an educator. Yet, what he says, at least at first, seems to go against what I have recently learned in my education with the Humanities. That is, the practice of taking concepts inch by inch, and only accepting those pieces that, through careful scrutiny, prove to be consistently true and beneficial. To me, this has everything to do with not choosing the wrong side. It has everything to do with being critical. It is all about a steadfast nonconformity with that which does not work.

On another level, I see how Horton is also speaking from the standpoint of an experienced social activist. Through this perspective, I can see how the status of “neutrality” and conceptual criticism change immensely. As Horton says, “You need to know why you take sides; you should be able to justify it,” and when it comes to human rights, this becomes much easier to do and the process of deliberation becomes much less important (102).

On these matters of conceptual criticism and one’s involvement in a cause, it was Paulo Freire that really broke it down for me. He said that “the question is not just to make the criticism but to interpret the dreams of the people… [O]ne is much more of a translator of the aspirations and dreams of the people, instead of being the creator of the dreams” (111,112). Hence, it is not about trying to create your own right answer and worrying about being on the right side. Once you understand the dreams of the people, neutrality is useless, the criticism is much less important, and action for those dreams is crucial.

Response and thoughts

The charismatic leader needs to know that finally he was not created by God." p.111

There's an old story (perhaps it is now a Myth) about a Roman general that returned victorious from a great battle. Cezar assigned a slave to ride in the chariot with this general as he triumphantly paraded through the streets of Rome. The slave was required to whisper in the ear of the general "You are only mortal, you are not a God" as the crowds cheered wildly for him. I believe that it is too easy to slip into believing the words of others, especially when they are positive words. But the same holds true for society as a whole. We when are told that problems are too big to overcome - or that they will take a lot of work - we often shy away from the problem in persuit of something else instead of simply making a beginning. For if we make a beginning, perhaps others will see and want to help as well. But even if we fail, we can still have the experience - one which will give us more lessons about things that we can't even imagine yet.

Here were my thoughts on the questions posed in the sylabus. They also tie in with the beginning of our selected reading by Myles Horton and Paulo Freire:

“Without practice there is no knowledge.”
- We Make the Road by Walking: Myles Horton and Paulo Freire
I know what a Unicorn looks like – even though I have never had the experience of meeting one in real life. I know how fission works, although I will never be able to actually see it happen (for it is too small and happens too fast for me to be able to witness with my own eyes). But in other ways – love, tolerance, mechanical skills – I cannot know these things until I have experienced them. Love is a fine thought, a nice idea – and that is all it will be until it is experienced. Then it is discovered that it is an amazing and wonderful (sometimes overpowering) experience that changes lives. If Plato’s Socrates is right, then without love inside of the individual, it is impossible to expect love from society. As such, political justice and knowledge must come from the experience had by the individuals – which makes up the collective knowledge.
And yet, we all know what a Unicorn is. Is it possible for us to have certain ideas that are outside of our own experience? Where do these ideas come from? Why are you, me, and others able to envision such a creature? Through education – we have been taught what it is. Someone else has given us the theory that is necessary for us to begin. We change through the teachings of others. However, if it is simply given to us, such knowledge becomes cheapened – we must struggle for it or it has little meaning. As such, we learned what a Unicorn was for a purpose (more than likely one that we can no longer recall) and that knowledge did not stick. However, the Unicorn concept did – because we had to struggle for it.
So then, all change comes from struggle. We had to struggle to wrap our heads around the idea of a Unicorn – and as such it took on meaning. We took action. And action is what is required if we are to change ourselves in other ways – ways that allow us to become better people. For we must become better people if we are to attempt to make the world a better place. Good intentions are all well and good, but they have no purpose or way of implementation if we have not had the experience of changing ourselves and gaining in the skills necessary to affect others and the world as a whole.
So we initially struggled to imagine what the unicorn is. We learned how, through struggle, to bring into existence in our minds something that has yet to be. We practiced for the most important task which will happen later – to imagine ourselves as better persons. For if we cannot imagine what a unicorn looks like, how can we ever hope to imagine how we can be better? We must take the lessons learned from theory into practice. Through this practice we have learned the path. And now, having had the practice needed, we can, indeed, make ourselves into the ones that we want to be, and all because we once learned how to imagine a Unicorn.
I feel that the struggle during the Civil Rights Era paved a huge road in the methods of non-violent social action. As time has passed, however, it seems that the general public has grown complacent, and has just accepted their lot in life. There is very little resistance to the fact that corporations have taken over our media sources. And those who control the message, control the moment. Both Paul Loeb and Myles Horton allude to this in the readings. As I read over the words, I couldn't help but think about how there has been such a deterioration in the quality of news and information we receive the last few years. The level of critical thinking and inquiry in grade schools has been degraded and entertainment has replaced genuine news as television and radio stations compete for the shrinking pool of corporate profits in a slowing economy.


It is important to look at history, and the lessons it offers. Those in the service of social justice can take these stories and lessons from the past to develop better strategies and more accurate results the same way that companies hire consultants and experts to help tem run a more efficient business. The difference is that the goal of social justice is to ensure that all people are taken care of, and companies want to ensure their share holders are taken care of. For this reason I love Myles Horton’s analogy of the critic and the gardener. We do need to approach challenges in the same manner. By being too focused on a symptom like homelessness, and not seeing the big picture, a person can spin their wheels and put a lot of energy into trying to fix the problem without making progress. What Horton proposes is a school of strategy, and lessons from history in ways to change entire systems rather than the outlying symptoms.


When Paolo Freire and Myles Horton talk about the role of teachers it reminded me of a math teacher I had in high school who wrote a big “0” on the board and said it was the answer to ending teen pregnancies. We all looked at each other like he was crazy. He later explained that it symbolized a wedding ring. Clearly teachers play an important role in the process of changing. They are right to state that you cannot change men’s hearts, but you can change systems.


Reading all of these stories gets me feeling charged again. I feel more energized by my ideas, and it is so important that we look at language as the first frontier. It would seem... Those When Loeb stated, "The host's description--The story's standard rendition--stripped the Montgomery Boycott of all its content," it occurred to me that all event in the news are similarly portrayed. Ideas that the media wants minimized will be characterized as an isolated event or a solo endeavor. Things that are meant to carry a heavier weight or greater importance are portrayed in monumental terms. How the media frames the world influences how we understand the world. Propaganda is just the most obvious way information is distorted. The mainstream media is just a watered down version of the same thing. I recognize my own biases, but also understand the important role language, media, and education play in everyone’s lives.

Leadership

What struck me the most was the way a leader or chrismatic leader was discribed by Paulo Freir in the We Make the Road by Walking reading. On page 111 though 112 Paulo describes how the leader is shaped by the people and the people are shaped by the leader.
"The charismatic leader needs to know that finally he was not created by God." p.111
With that quote I understand what Paulo is meaning. A leader is created by God but the actions and feelings inside him or her were created by the people around him or her. With this being done the leader expresses not only what he or she believes is right but what others do as well. Just like MLK and Rosa Parks, they were created or shaped by the people. They saw a cause that was affecting not only them but a big group of people. They were not only doing something that would benifit them but they saw how it would benifit all. That is what a great leader is, a person who thinks for the good of society and/or the community.
I have to say what really stuck out the most to me out of all the reading is the importance it is to take action. For me personally, it struck a chord simply because, I'm one of those people who is always too shy or afraid to jump in simply because I'm worried about doing something wrong and what not. I think that tends to be one of the reasons for many people when it comes to getting involved. It's either they do not know where to begin or they are hesitant about jumping into something because they don't want to screw something up. Which I think partially ties in (along with other things) with this whole ideal that society has come up for activists; that they don't screw up or anything and it just paralyzes a lot of people into not wanting to take that risk. On the other hand, if people do want to take that risk there seems to be that expectation that the change will be instant and not gradual, which is a fantasy.

from Cathy. . .

Cathy Manovi’s Post for the Blog:
I too was struck by King's observations about the incremental, cummulative efforts of many unsung heroes of social change. For example on page 289 King describes Rosa Parks's predecessor, who the NAACP decided would not be a successful poster child to bring forth a legal action on her behalf because of her status as an unmarried pregnant woman. He also brought out in the open that Parks did not make a spur of the moment decision to act, but rather that she had been "part of an existing movement for change" (289). I agree with the statement that the "humble and frustrating work that Parks and others undertook earlier on" (289) is what really spurs change over time. Things need to build otherwise singular indiviudal acts may be seen as an anomoly. His overall point that it is a myth that social change heroes are born overnight. Rather, incremental experiences and small actions make a difference and build up to something significant that catches the attention of the masses. It takes a lot of courage to act or speak out. I can be outspoken in group settings and personal interactions and have learned over time that you can get a lot of flak from your opposition or cheers from those who share your view or concern but are--for whatever reason--intimidated or hesitate to speak. One of the things that gives me the push to do so is when I see that others experience the same things I do, and I hear complaints on a one-to-one basis, but do not see anyone talking about it with the people who have the ability to actually do something about it. Usually that means people in authority positions. I believe really strongly in the importance of raising questions and making suggestions in such situations--openly at times, and sometimes quietly behind the scenes, but always with people who can effect change. Depending on how you go about it (e.g., rather than an outright attack on a position, to question it because that allows people to start thinking about it and to gain awareness about their own feelings about it. That is way less controversial than an outright statement of right or wrong). When the buzz gets going and more people start talking, then others may feel empowered and the time may be more ripe for talking about "so what can we do to change this and will we?" The other thing about this week's readings that struck a chord with me was Horton and Freire's discussion about neutrality and how it is an excuse to either hide your position (perhaps this is because people are afraid of the personal consequences when they know they're in the company of people influential to their well being, who oppose their position), or an outright excuse not to change the status quo. I have had many experiences where I get frustrated with superiors who, unlike me as a person in a position to handle and execute on and trouble shoot on behalf of others, would rather let things remain as they are because "we've always done it this way" or because it would take so much effort to blaze a new path. Sometimes things like that require collaboration and consensus building and it's not easy. This is a law and order approach over a social justice (or change for the good of all) approach, and can be disappointing, frustrating, outrageous, etc., depending on the topic of concern.
Finally, getting back to speaking up in public/group settings, Paulo Friere's spoke about the importance of charismatic vs. humble leadership and not just making criticism but also suggesting alternatives. He wrote about the importance of "interpreting the dreams of the people who are making the leader turn charismatic" (112). That, I think, is really important to inspire people to get involved in change efforts. Myles Horton also spoke of the importance of humility in some leaders and how they often are more able to reach people who shut themselves off to the "radicals." ( see p. 112) I grew up liberal, but the longer I've lived and the more often I've stuck my neck out and spoke out about things, the more I've learned that humility, and questioning and suggesting and asking for the thoughts of others, is often much more powerful and effective, because a more diverse group is willing to listen and start thinking, and hopefully acting. Jesus was big on getting people to think. He was fond of speaking in parables and that method forced people to think rather than just obey more of the same old pronouncements of law and order.

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

I also found a very powerful quote in The Real Rosa Parks piece. "The myth of Parks as lone activist reinforces a notion that anyone who takes a committed public stand, or at least an effective one, has to be a larger-than-life figure--someone with more time,energy,courage,vision or knowledge than any normal person could ever possess." (pg 290) This quote inspires me to be involved in my community and makes feel like I'm making a difference. I am significant!
The main theme that was similar in all of our readings is that being involved and taking action is the only way for us to move forward. Basically anyone can say that they are humanitarians, it's the action that is most important. For example, on page 102, Myles says, "I wasn't interested in being good, I was interested in being good for something." Being good and doing what's right can be two different things entirely. In the Letter from Birmingham Jail by MLK, he makes a statement about this difference. "the Negro's great stumbling block in the stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen's Counciler or the KKK, but the white moderate who is more devoted to "order" than to justice." (282) To make change people have to take a chance, they must do what is right no matter the consequence. Of course people don't always do this because they are afraid of the repercussions of their actions. Overall, we must have a feeling at the end of the day that our actions have made positive changes. "The first and most enduring measure of success is what we see in the mirror at the end of each day."
The theme/question that struck a chord for me was “where to start” and how to grow through this process in the most, for lack of a better term, objective and positive way. Paulo states “The educator must know in favor of whom and in favor of what he or she wants. That means to know against whom and against what we are working for as educators.” Myself included, I think we all have very strong opinions about the issues and injustices we see around us. Yet it is important to not only dig deep within ourselves to clarify why we have these beliefs and opinions to begin with, but to seek out from where, when and why these issues have arisen, to gain fundamental knowledge of the root causes that lead to these injustices. Myles speaks directly to that point, “I learned from Marxism about analysis and about the practical use of the whole business of conflict, how you deal with the dichotomies or seeming dichotomies (interesting that he uses the term “seeming dichotomies’). I started trying to learn about society so I could make a moral judgment, a rational judgment.” As I participate in this class and become involved in community service I want to discover the underlying causes, the true issues at hand so that I can be as effective as possible and so that my efforts do not go off track. Flexibility in our thinking is also crucial, for it will surely change as we live through this experience as will our very selves. Paulo states “today’s knowledge about something is not necessarily the same tomorrow. Knowledge is changed to the extent that reality also moves and changes. Then theory also does the same.” I believe one of the biggest hurdles we face as a society, concerning any issue, is that we build a theory/judgment and then refuse to let it evolve or change in any way moving forward, even though the surrounding circumstances my be changing. This conversation between Paulo and Myles is a great one as we all start our journey.