How does Arendt define collective responsibility and the conditions that must be present to define it as such?
Arendt defines collective responsibility as an individual’s responsibility for an action that that individual has not committed, caused by that individual’s association with a larger group that “no voluntary act of [theirs] can dissolve, that is, a membership which is utterly unlike a business partnership which [they] can dissolve at will” (Arendt, 149). She draws a sharp contrast between collective responsibility and guilt. An individual collectively responsible for one action might not necessarily be guilty of that action; they may simply be responsible by association. However, an individual in a group who is guilty of an action, meaning that they have actually committed that action, creates collective responsibility for that action in the rest of the group. She says that the context in which collective responsibility is relevant is that of politics, rather than that of legality or morality.
Legal and moral standard have one very important thing in common – they always relate to the person and what the person has done; if the person happens to be involved in a common undertaking as in the case of organized crime, what is to be judged is still this very person, the degree of his participation, his specific role, and so on, and not the group (Arendt, 148).
Arendt emphasizes that guilt is not collective in the case of individual action, meaning that while law does not prosecute collective responsibility, it does prosecute guilt. Whether one belongs to a collective and commits a crime is of no consequence. Other members of the group are not guilty of that person’s crime. They may be collectively responsible for that crime, but they are not guilty. Equally, one person cannot cite the collective in defense of their individual actions, as they alone can be held guilty of their own actions.
For example, the class I was in this week at Marin County Community School (MCCS) was particularly rowdy. One student continuously disrupted the class, drawing a few other students into unruly behavior. Finally, a campus supervisor came to take the group of uncooperative students out of class, calling the originator of the trouble and a couple of the others to the door. The instigating student went immediately, but the others protested, naming that student as the cause of their own misconduct. The rest of the students looked uncomfortable. In this case, the rest of the class was collectively responsible for the disruption. The instigating student was definitely guilty of disruption, and the students citing that student as guilty of their own disruption were individually guilty, though they protested.
How does Arendt differentiate knowing from thinking? Why is this significant?
Arendt differentiates knowing from thinking by differentiating intellect and reason, intellect being the desire for and the possession of verifiable information, and reason being the urge to deliberate and understand (163). This is significant because Arendt draws a connection between the ability or inability to think and evil. She says that knowledge of right and wrong are a result of thinking, and if thinking as present in everyone, then everyone should be expected to understand right and wrong (“…The faculty of thinking, as distinguished from the thirst for knowledge, must be ascribed to everybody; it cannot be a privilege of the few” (166)), but that thinking cannot lead to unquestionable rules, so our conception of right and wrong cannot be definite (“…We cannot expect any moral propositions or commandments, no final code of conduct from the thinking activity, least of all a new and now allegedly final definition of what is good and what is evil” (167)). In the situation above, this might be interpreted as meaning that each of the students can be expected to know the difference between good behavior and bad behavior, and know that when they commit bad behaviors, it puts them in the wrong, but that we cannot truly know what wrong is because we cannot judge their behaviors based solely on our own thinking.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.