What struck me the most about Butler’s writing was its connections with Arendt’s ideas of collective responsibility. Butler made a point about the United States’ collective responsibility in response to the 911 attacks. It had never occurred to me that the past actions of the U.S. could have fueled the terrorist acts in New York. I realize that no politician in their right mind would actually point out that the U.S. may be responsible, but I’m kind of disappointed that I’m just reading about this idea now. The United States is not directly responsible, but we may be indirectly responsible for the conditions that lead those people to drive the planes into the towers and we needed to acknowledge that before we went to war.
Butler’s concept of individual responsibility is similar to Arendt’s concept of guilt, only a single person can be guilty of their crime. However, Butler goes on to say that “we need to situate individual responsibility in light of its collective conditions,” (15) meaning that rather than deeming an individual’s actions as simply “self-generated acts of will or symptoms of individual pathology or evil,” (15) there could be a collective that is responsible for pushing that individual to such extreme measures.
My favorite point Butler makes is that “our responsibility is heightened once we have been subjected to the violence of others…only once we have suffered that violence are we compelled, ethically, to ask how we will respond to violent injury” (16). When America was attacked, we did not respond to this tragedy in a responsible manner. Everyone just wanted to pull out the big guns and show the East who was boss rather than getting to the root of the problem and “[asking] how these conditions came about” (17). I realize that this is probably too idealistic, but it would be a nice change from beating violence with violence.
~C. Standridge-Folsom
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.