Tuesday, October 11, 2011

More arguments, more peace?

Jonah Lewer's How We Decide is such an interesting piece of writing! These two chapters definitely say something about why we think the way we think, why we respond the way we do, and what is our driving force.

In both chapters I found emotions to be an underlying red thread that tied us to our cognitive thinking. In the chapter, The Moral Mind, I thought it was a really interesting situation with the brother and sister who have sex, use protection, and become closely bonded from that. My first thought, and even now, I can't help to think that this is gross! But why? They were practicing safe sex, it didn't drive them apart, and biologically, if they wanted to keep their genes passed on, that's how you would do it. But still, I feel everything inside my body telling me that this is wrong.

It all comes down to emotions. In this situation, everything seems normal, EXCEPT the sibling relationship. This one detail changes everything. Tying it into his next chapter, The Brain Is An Argument, the insula of the brain, which is attuned to bad feelings, is in overdrive because of this one statement and because of it's strong emotion, overpowers the NAcc (controlling positive feelings). The prefrontal cortex (which deals with sorting out the feelings of both these parts of the brain, as well as the others) can only come to the conclusion that this is a bad situtation.

This drives me to ask another question, why is it bad for siblings to fornicate? Is it just based on the fact that genetic mutations are more likely to arise, or is it something else? It just makes me wonder what was the driving force behind the ill-conceived thoughts on this issue, and whether it was rational or not.

Going further into The Brain Is An Argument, I found it really interesting that we actually do not assimilate uncomfortable information into our brains. (205) In reality, everything points to a type of filtering system, where we already have the answer and we use logic to find evidence to support it. In that way, we purposely chose to be ignorant. (207) This really hits me because the kids I work with a MCCS have this kind of mindset. Even in myself and in my peers, I can see this process occurring. We think we have the answers, we think we have it all figured out, but really we are just lulling ourselves into a false sense of security because we want to shut up the argument in our heads. Although I think it is an innate need to strive for peace, in our environment and within ourselves, I also think that the kids of MCCS do the things they do because they feel the can control the peace in themselves, even if their environment appears chaotic.

Still, I don't know them well enough yet to come to that conclusion, but from the interactions I have had, I can only guess that.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.