In Hannah Arendt’s book, entitled Responsibility and Judgment, She first begins by distinguishing between collective responsibility and guilt by making the powerful statement “Guilt, unlike responsibility, always singles out; it is strictly personal.” I completely agree with her. I believe that everyone has different emotional blueprints. Therefore, in a certain situation, everyone expresses varying amount of guilt (even if you are not directly involved in the situation). However taking responsibility for ones actions is completely independent of guilt and depends heavily upon one’s involvement in the situation. For example, Hannah Arendt uses the example of a team of professional swimmers letting a person drown. She then goes deeper by drawing a distinction between our responsibilities and morals “What I am driving at here is a sharper dividing line between collective responsibility, on one side, and moral and/or legal (personal) guilt . . . “ I do agree with the authors position that a lot of our morals come from our religious origins and backgrounds. I also believe that one’s religious views should not act as the main source for one’s values and morals.
The author then goes on to make the point that our “Nonparticipation in the political affairs of the world has always been open to the reproach of irresponsibility of shirking one’s duties to the world we share with one another and the community we belong to.” When applied to community service, this quote is dead on. It seems as if a bad habit has developed. Everyone plays an important role in the community they live in. I feel as if people are neglecting the roles in they play in their community and not getting involved in the political issues they face with. This not only affects that individual, but also the individuals around them. According to the author, the health of a community would be a collective responsibility. The author states it beautifully saying “we live our lives not by ourselves but among our fellow men,” and attitude that I hope many of us adopt as we go though out our community service experience this year.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.