Monday, October 3, 2011

Catalytic Empathy - J. Kiefer O'Sullivan

To me, Canada’s biggest motivation seems to be empathy. It is made apparent in the text that Canada lives a secure life. He has a wife and a child and is able to take care of them quite well. However, that does not stop him from feeling the pain of poverty. Not only does he want to improve the lives of the people in Harlem, but he also he also feels their struggle. In the last page of chapter 1, Canada is quoted, “’When I go home tonight to my own kid, whose life is pretty much secure’, Canada said, ‘it’s not going to make me sleep well knowing there are kids and families out there that don’t feel secure. They are just terrified that their child is not going to make it, and they think this is another opportunity that slipped by.” By having empathy for the people of Harlem, and all struggling youth, it takes the intellectual, sociological issue, and turns it into a personal one. In the eyes of Canada, all the children of Harlem, those left behind, those that are the victims of crime, etc, could be his child. To him, society’s failures are “personal failures”. From reading the text, that is what I derived as Canada’s motivation. I also believe that empathy is one of the greatest motivations you can have toward doing good in this world. The people who can empathize, the people who can see from another’s perspective, those are the ones who do the most good in the world. The people that realize that the only difference between them and someone who is poverty stricken, is a tiny shard of luck, randomly assigned in the universal lottery.

In chapter 2, several theories are laid out as to the solution to poverty, and what poor people need in order to survive. I think one of the biggest problem is that that word, “survive”, is used far too much. It should not matter what the poor of society need to survive, it should matter that they get what the rest of society already has so that they can prosper. Some people think they need moral guidelines and rules, while others think they need financial support. I think that poverty is a multi-faceted problem that requires a multi-faceted solution. I think they should be able to receive all of the above. Financial handouts are not enough, they just build dependence. Just moral support isn’t enough, as I feel it would breed resentment, for how are poor people to be blamed for what society deems bad behavior, if they do not have the basic commodities which we deem normal for society? As Canada is cited as saying, “It was almost primal, we were literally just trying to keep our children alive.” Who are we to judge the people in that society, when in most of our daily lives survival is ensured and requires not even a passing thought?

Unfortunately, most people lack empathy, and this is what leads to racism, classism, and discrimination. If more people were like Canada, the world would be a totally different place.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.