Our world has shrunk; not physically, but mentally. More and more, our global information is filtered and processed by the media, ourselves, and our subconscious. The ways in which we are directed to think gives rise to a trend of, as Butler terms it, anti-intellectualism. Butler exemplifies this by writing how there is a clear lack of questioning about the nature of the war in Iraq, or the “war on terror.” He writes how it seems “that neither the justification nor the cause of the war have been the focus of public intellectual attention” (2). This is due to an almost cold war era like witch hunt that effectively isolates and villainizes any individual that addresses the validity of the war. Post 9/11 America echoes eerily of McCarthyism, with any “unpatriotic” attempt to question America’s dominance or the necessity of force being immediately tossed out as sympathetic to the “evil-doers”. Butler points out that “our own acts of violence do not receive graphic coverage in the press, and so they remain acts that are justified in the same of self-defense, but by a noble cause, namely, the rooting out of terrorism” (6). We are conditioned to think that the war is just, that the enemies are villains, evil to the core, and that their causalities are but ants lost to an overbearing magnifying glass. If only we were allowed to look through the magnifying glass, we would see that the people being blown apart in their very homes are just like us. Thinking about the attitude towards the war in Iraq reminds me of something my grandfather told me when he would tell stories before he passed. He said that after serving in WWII he had a revelation. He would be in his fox hole, clutching the pictures of his wife and kids, being given orders to run across and kill the “evil” nazi across the way. Once he was out of the war though, he realized, that the person across the way that he was being sent to kill was just like he was. He was across the battlelines in his own foxhole clutching his own pictures of his wife and kids. They were two men that could have been best friends under any other circumstances, however, they were taught that all the Nazi soldiers were villainous to the bone and taught to kill indiscriminately among them. Our minds are but sheep to an insidious shepherd. Just like the WWII Nazis my grandfather fought, we are taught to hate and think little of the lives of the people in the Middle East. As Butler writes, “when America commits some act of dehumanization, we castigate ourselves for not aiming better, as if the end goal is to aim right” (6). The war crimes committed in the Middle East, performed in any kind of Western context, would be totally unacceptable; there would be outrage.
Butler raises the question, “What makes for a grievable life? . . . Loss and vulnerability seem to follow from our being socially constituted bodies, attached to others, at risk of losing those attachments,” (20). Are the deaths of thousands of Middle Eastern civilians not worthy of our attention? We all suffer loss in our lives, it is part of being human. We are all vulnerable to harm, and a “Mindfulness of this vulnerability can become the basis of claims for non-military political solutions, just as a denial of this vulnerability . . . can fuel the instruments of war” (29). The “evil doers” are dehumanized and generalized to a whole race of people. People from any kind of Middle Eastern descent are now suffering significant discrimination post 9/11. However, no one is able to disseminate the reasons for why they stereotype these people, they are just conditioned. George Bush famously said, “You’re either with us or against us” in relation to the War on Terror, and this false dichotomy that is being presented is obvious, but yet the prevailing consensus is that yes, you’re either with the heroes or the villains. That is what creates the conditions favourable for a trend of anti-intellectualism. No room is left for analysis, no shades of grey, just black and white. Anyone who takes the time to understand the war from a decentralized viewpoint is branded as some kind of heretic and is ignored by the media, as in the case of Noam Chomsky. If we are to break this cycle of anti-intellectualism, America needs to be “open to narration [from a viewpoint] that decenters us from our supremacy” (18). We need to realize that the people that we spend billions on to kill are people with families and jobs and lives just like us.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.