My first reaction was, “What in the world?! Siblings fornicating and heartless psychopaths?!” My initial reaction was disgust and pity. The story of the psychopath challenged the justification of his imprisonment because his moral judgment was impaired by biological aspects. In the story of the siblings was justified in that the benefits heavily outweighed the negatives. . The psychopath and the siblings felt no regret. They felt that it was alright for them. But why do we still feel that it’s not right? That’s why the idea of many “truths” and moral relativism bothers me. The standard becomes oneself. But then why was the psychopath jailed? If truth depends on the person, why was the judge who sentenced him entitled to determine his guilt or innocence? Then who sets the moral standards? The lawmakers?
I find that in both case scenarios, pleasure and self-gain was the standard of “right.” However I agree with the excerpt from The Moral Mind, “Doing the right thing means thinking about everybody else” (175).
The Brain is an Argument states, “It feels good to be certain. Confidence is comforting (210). Again, the idea of emotion-driven judgment is dangerous because emotions are fleeting and change. So to set the standards of morality on emotions would be unstable and unwise.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.