Monday, October 31, 2011

Gains - Whitney Myers

The aspect of ‘service’ that I seem to struggle most with is the question of how to determine what actually qualifies as ‘service.’ Say service might be defined simply as any activity that helps others; do occupations like ‘teacher’ or ‘doctor’ count as service? They do not seem to be generally accepted as such, but are of great assistance to many. The main reason that those occupations are unacceptable as service seems to be that they are paid positions. Can a paid position be considered service? What if the pay is low enough? Or if the job is difficult enough? What the teachers at MCCS do seems to qualify as service to me, as does what most teachers do, though they are undoubtedly paid some amount. Does monetary return negate the help that an occupation might offer to society, so that it cannot count as true service? And if so, does any return at all remove an activity’s value as service? I do not believe so, but there does seem to be a prominent disagreement about the correlation between service and gain, even emotional gain.

The authors of On Kindness ask the same questions about kindness, and what might or might not qualify as kindness. They indicate that kindness also suffers argument between those who believe that kindness can be defined simply as any benevolent action, and those who believe that that action must come without personal gain to be valid. “The most long-standing suspicion about kindness is that it is just narcissism in disguise. We are kind because it makes us feel good about ourselves: kindly people are self-approbation junkies” (111). The suspicion that kind actions lose some of their value when the one performing the action might be performing in self-interest is one that the authors of On Kindness find unfounded. Kind actions stand whether they are driven by pure intent to help or not. Indeed, Phillips and Taylor do not support the validity of self-interest itself, let alone its ability to affect kindness. “The notion of self-interest implies that we always know what we want, by knowing what the self is and what its interests are…” (13). It does not seem viable that the conditions for self-interest can be met when it comes to the return gained from kind actions, as that return is largely indefinable, one of the issues that Phillips and Taylor cite in the disassociation between modern society and kindness.

I found another of Phillips’ and Taylor’s reasons for the detachment between our society and kindness especially interesting. They cite envy in this issue. “…Only the self-caring child who enjoys being alive will ‘seek to extend his being and enjoyments’ to others… People think that they envy other people for their success, money, fame, when in fact it is kindness that is most envied, because it is the strongest indicator of people’s well-being, their pleasure in existence” (111). According to the authors of On Kindness, because only one who enjoys life will seek to create joy in other’s lives, that one is in a position to be envied. Envy is not a friendly emotion, and might create animosity toward the kind one. Kindness will not be desirable if it should create such animosity, and Philips and Taylor believe that this is one of the reasons that kindness has become less desirable.

It seems to me that both kindness and service can be valid, as long as they accomplish their purpose, to better people’s lives and to help people find more joy. The authors of On Kindness seem to agree that it does not matter that they might also create emotional return, or even other types of gain, for those that are kind or do service.

Saturday, October 29, 2011

Prompt for: On Kindness

Against Kindness and Modern Kindness

The authors' thesis (you may not agree but try to see this on a societal level, not from your individual perspective) is that, “[m]ost people appear to believe that deep down they (and other people) are mad, bad, and dangerous to know. . . our motives are utterly self-seeking, and that our sympathies are forms of self-protection” (4).

The authors suggest that although many of us live life in “instinctive sympathetic identification with the vulnerabilities and attractions of others. . . but without a language in which to express this, or cultural support for it” (4)

(Again, remember, at times we have to over-generalize in order to be able to examine collective issues, and if we look at the state of our own country in the moment, there may be some evidence that supports these claims.)

One of the reasons, that the authors suggest, for our ambivalence about our instinct for kindness, has to do with making ourselves vulnerabile, weak: “Bearing other people’s vulnerability—which means sharing in it imaginatively and practically . . .––entails being able to bear one’s own” (11). In a sense, what we have in common is our vulnerability (an idea that Judith Butler elaborates in Precarious Life).

Thus, kindness has an internal tension—it brings us pleasure but it also reminds us of all that we fear about ourselves including change. (There is also an interesting discussion about whether kindness requires selflessness). How do you see the role of vulnerability in your service-learning experience? Think about yourself, those you work with etc. As always use the text to support your ideas and specifics from service to illustrate.

Also think about this in relation to and tie in the final chapter, "Modern Kindness" where the authors start by citing Winnicott who wrote about our moral ability to imagine the "thoughts and feelings and hopes of another person" (95). Jonathon Lehrer also described this capacity for empathy and its source in the emotions. The argument is also very much the message that is so well captured in I Am, for those who saw it: "We depend upon others not just for our survival but for our being. The self without sympathetic attachments is either a fiction or a lunatic" (95).

The authors continue to discuss the reasons why this is such a difficult reality for us to face: "Our resistance to kindness is resistance to encountering what kindness means in us, and what we meet in other people by being kind to them" (113).

Of course, our issues with vulnerability and dependence as discussed in the first chapter are a large part of this resistance. So keep thinking about the connections and how you see the implications in your own relation to your service experience (remember to start with yourself, not just about what you see in others).

Thursday, October 27, 2011

I agreed with Butler’s discussion about violence and mourning. I mainly agreed with “Despite our differences in location and history, my guess is that it is possible to appeal to a “we”, for all of us have some notion of what it is to have lost somebody” (20). When 9/11 took place, it was an eye-opener for Americans as they immediately came together as a country. This was also when the security for Americans was at stake and together, Americans tightened the security system on airplanes and in the airports. I can see the same reaction in the kids at County. They develop a sort of “buddy system”, where they can rely on each other. This can be done by either looking more superior amongst each other as a way to show they have a group behind them or in other ways, which are to actually form a bond and friend in this system. While they find it most often hard to make a friend, they more or less have acquaintances to which they associate and talk to for the time being. My experiences at County have been quite interesting. There have been days, where they seem to be friends and other days when they aren’t but most definitely when they have lost someone close or are grieving about something, they come together. Circles is where they can connect on other levels or try to from time to time.

Precarious

"Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence"

First, I had to look up the definition of "precarious." It basically means something is uncertain, taking chances, and possibly not stable. However, I think that is exactly human life, it is not certain, not exactly stable, and chances do have to be made. The second part of the title are embodied very well in the two portions of our reading. Judith Butler illustrates her points using the events of September 11 and the following war. It is funny how America played the victim in a situation where yes, we were clearly victims but certainly not the only ones. September 11 was necessary for the "terrorists." They felt they were pursing a holy deed for the greater good. They saw themselves as martyrs. American felt the need for instant gratification. We are a people who need immediate action and are impatient enough to require instant results too. "Anti intellectual" positions were manifested in this "either you're with us or you're with the terrorists" attitude (2). Hence, we went to war and hurt a lot more people. We retaliated. "It is one matter to suffer violence and quite another to use that fact to ground a framework in which one's injury authorizes limitless aggression" (4). In this case, an eye for an eye made the whole world blind. We made it hell for the innocent Middle Eastern citizens of our own country, aroused fear in ourselves, and hurt the people out there as well. We made everyone suffer. This leads me to the next point I understood: "Let's face it. We're undone by each other. And if we're not, we're missing something" (23). Humans have the capacity to feel pain, each other's pain. That's sort of what makes us human is that we can all suffer. We are able to understand each other's suffering through the experience of our own pain and suffering. And again, that puts people in a very vulnerable place which is why it is so hard to allow ourselves to be undone by someone else.


I have no real relation to this reading and my service without stretching it except for the fact that, it seems that the kids have a harder time rationalizing things. When they horseplay, sometimes it seems so close to getting serious because each kid wants to get the last shove in. (Which is why of course horsplay is not allowed.)

Collective Conditions

What struck me the most about Butler’s writing was its connections with Arendt’s ideas of collective responsibility. Butler made a point about the United States’ collective responsibility in response to the 911 attacks. It had never occurred to me that the past actions of the U.S. could have fueled the terrorist acts in New York. I realize that no politician in their right mind would actually point out that the U.S. may be responsible, but I’m kind of disappointed that I’m just reading about this idea now. The United States is not directly responsible, but we may be indirectly responsible for the conditions that lead those people to drive the planes into the towers and we needed to acknowledge that before we went to war.

Butler’s concept of individual responsibility is similar to Arendt’s concept of guilt, only a single person can be guilty of their crime. However, Butler goes on to say that “we need to situate individual responsibility in light of its collective conditions,” (15) meaning that rather than deeming an individual’s actions as simply “self-generated acts of will or symptoms of individual pathology or evil,” (15) there could be a collective that is responsible for pushing that individual to such extreme measures.

My favorite point Butler makes is that “our responsibility is heightened once we have been subjected to the violence of others…only once we have suffered that violence are we compelled, ethically, to ask how we will respond to violent injury” (16). When America was attacked, we did not respond to this tragedy in a responsible manner. Everyone just wanted to pull out the big guns and show the East who was boss rather than getting to the root of the problem and “[asking] how these conditions came about” (17). I realize that this is probably too idealistic, but it would be a nice change from beating violence with violence.

~C. Standridge-Folsom

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

In Judith Butler’s book, Precarious Life=The Powers of Mourning and Violence, she makes the bold statement “Since the events of September 11, we have seen both a rise of anti-intellectualism and a growing acceptance of censorship within the media.” (pg: 1) Butler then discusses how the media frequently displays a bias one-sided opinion, and how that has affected and somewhat stifled the more “intellectual positions” and viewpoints that some may have. For example, Butler references the war in Iraq as well as the “abusive treatment of prisoners” and how their reasons and justifications for these events have seemed to elude the public’s intellectual attention. Also during that time, “the voicing of critical perspectives against the war has become difficult to do…” According to Butler, this was not only due to the anti-war opinion not being accepted by mainstream media, but there was the added risk of “hystericization and censorship.”
It seems as if our society has become so consumed by trivial events such as Kim Kardashian’s wedding and enthralled by meaningless shows such as Jersey Shore, that we have ignored the important issues at hand. For example, in class yesterday I was surprised to uncover that most of the people in our class (including me) do not consistently watch the news, or retrieve their news from sources such as Yahoo and Google. Because of our neglect, we tend to agree with the most popular opinion available. It seems as if our society (especially our generation) has lost its voice ability to form its own opinion. This attitude could not only prove detrimental to our future, but the future of many generations to come!!!!!!!

What Words Can Do -Whitney Myers

I found Butler’s discussion of the intentional use of political rhetoric by the government and the media to influence the public extremely intriguing. She writes about the use of specific, politically controlled rhetoric to influence domestic perception of events, and about the larger implications of certain rhetoric in distorting human perception of the value of lives. I do not mean to say that all media or all government literature employ a deceptive rhetoric like the one Butler describes, but rather I mean to examine the method by which words can be used to damage public perception of a people or institution.

Butler’s primary example, the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, works to demonstrate the devastating effects political rhetoric can have on the operation of democratic society.

She begins by describing the conditions that invalidated public anti-war sentiment, which she refers to as ‘anti-intellectualist.’ “…Moralistic anti-intellectual trends coupled with a distrust of the Left… has produced a situation in which our very capacity to think about the grounds and causes of the current global conflict is considered impermissible” (Butler, 3). When it is impermissible to disagree with the government, democratic society cannot function, as democracy’s success hinges on the ability of the people to influence government action.

Butler then describes how dissent became impermissible. “The raw public mockery of the peace movement, and the characterization of anti-war demonstrations as anachronistic or nostalgic, work to produce a consensus of public opinion that profoundly marginalizes anti-war sentiment and analysis, putting into question in a very strong way the very value of dissent as part of contemporary U.S. democratic culture” (Butler, 3-4). By creating public hostility toward anti-war sentiment, a view opposing the government, the American public is no longer able to dissent without seeming anti-American and anti-democratic. This is in complete conflict with democratic ideals, but effective in minimizing public refusal to accept the publicized reasoning behind the war.

She finally explains that the United States government retains their appearance of hegemonic standing by dictating a specific vocabulary, both in terms of definition and usage, and therefore limiting the language allowed to express dissent. “The articulation of this hegemony takes place in part through producing a consensus on what certain terms will mean, how they can be used, and what lines of solidarity are implicitly drawn through this use” (Butler, 4). By restricting usage and controlling definition, the government creates a climate in which certain terms will be interpreted as it desires, specifically in order to equate anti-war sentiment and anti-Americanism.

When Butler comes to her discussion of dehumanization, and whom the government and media allow to be portrayed as human, she suggests that rather than controlling for meaning and usage of certain terms, the government and media simply omit all language pertaining to those they seek to dehumanize. “There is less a dehumanizing discourse at work here than a refusal of discourse that produces dehumanization as a result” (Butler, 36). By excluding all mention of tragedy when the victim is considered an enemy, and focusing attention on domestic tragedy at the hands of that enemy, writers can construct a distorted public view of that subject. “If there is a ‘discourse,’ it is a silent and melancholic one in which there have been no lives, and no losses; there has been no common bodily condition. No vulnerability that serves as the basis for an apprehension of our commonality; there has been no sundering of the event” (Butler, 36). The government and media can eliminate the perception of human aspects, such as grief and suffering by refusing to report those aspects, resulting in prejudice against an enemy as inhuman.

The use of words to influence perception of a population is not limited to political objectives, and can manifest additionally in social situations. Many minorities fall victim to rhetoric, even unintentional biased language, which creates stigma and prejudice at every social level, from national politics to school yard bullying. When this dehumanizing rhetoric becomes absorbed into mainstream speech, it can be highly detrimental to the mindset of the targeted group, as well as perception of their human aspects. We must be aware of such rhetoric and work to prevent further absorption of distortive language into our everyday speech.

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Who Counts As Human- Jessica D.

Any person who has experienced loss is human. Suffering loss is an essential aspect that makes up humanity. If suffering from loss can be observed in mother animals toward loss or death of her offspring, how much more so in humans? Butler’s piece revolves around war and politics involved in war. “Loss has made a tenuous “we” of us all” (20). I think Butler tries to convey that no matter the difference among nations regarding race, cultures, religion, and ideology, everyone is tied by our human capacity to experience loss. No matter how much a nation spends on war, military training or man power, it all comes down to the death on both sides. The excuses and reasons people make to justify war and violence can never erase the inevitable result of death and loss, whether the loss is monetary, resource, or most importantly, loved ones. Anger and hate can make people think so low of others to the point where they degrade the hated to “dogs” or “beastly savages.” For example, if a person’s innocent husband is brutally killed in war by enemy forces, the person may likely think, “That killer is a cruel heartless beast. That beast deserves to die.” Because of anger and hatred, people forget that “enemy” is also a human with a heart and soul.

This calls to my mind, the students I tutor at MCC, many of who might have experienced loss of loved ones due to gang-related violence. Violence and hate create divisions among even people of the same race. Many of the kids at MCC might act rude to teachers and seem very self-centered, but beneath that exterior may lie the roots of bitterness due to loss of loved ones or even the loss of being and feeling loved.

Perspectives and Viewpoints

This week we were asked to read the first two chapters of Judith Butler’s Precarious Life. Her writing felt complex and extensive, yet had a multitude of impressive insights woven in throughout the text. The first chapter looks at more holistic perspectives, while the second chapter focuses on the viewpoint of the individual.

The first chapter of Precarious Life opens with Butler discussing anti-intellectualism. It becomes apparent to the reader that this term refers to situations where dissenting opinions, even when expressed in an intelligent manner, are rejected out of hand and associated with “the enemy.” Butler exemplifies this with the Iraq war, as well as with the segmentation of the “East” and “West” (1-2). Further in the text, Butler discusses what she refers to as “First World complacency” (7). She seems to urge Americans to look at events from something akin to a third person or global perspective, as well as the first person or national perspective that is so easy to adopt (7-9).Another topic Butler explores in the first chapter is the line between individual and collective responsibility. She proposes that the individuals behind acts of violence certainly have a level of responsibility, but that external forces ultimately helped condition those individuals to make the choices that they made. The responsibility is essential shared between conditions that led to the act as well as the act itself (15-16).

In Butler’s second chapter, the focus alters significantly. Butler starts out by making the argument that, from a particular individual’s perspective, certain human lives are considered more valuable than others. She even goes as far as to making the distinction between lives that are considered “grievable” and those that are not (20). Butler appears to see grief as an expression of how important a person’s relationships are to him or her. She also believes, sensibly, that a lack of grief is abnormal. Both of these propositions are evidenced in her words: “Let’s face it. We’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something” (23). Later in the chapter, Butler brings the conversation back to viewpoints of individuals by discussing “derealization” (33). Here she suggests that if human lives are never made into real and grievable beings to the individual, then that individual will not see those lives as noteworthy and therefore will not be affected if those lives are affected by violence (33-34).

One of Butler’s earlier points, the contrast between individual and collective responsibility, was brought up just last week when we read some of Arendt’s work. In Arendt’s book Responsibility and Judgement, she gives a definition of sorts for collective responsibility. She writes, “Two conditions have to be present for collective responsibility: I must be held responsible for something I have not done, and the reason for my responsibility must be my membership in a group (a collective) which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve, that is a membership which is utterly unlike a business partnership which I can dissolve at will” (149). These thoughts can be applied fairly well to Butler’s example of the Iraq war in relation to Americans. Americans certainly did not enact terrorism upon themselves, but they are a fairly permanent element of the United States government. Previous actions of the U.S. government, in turn, had undoubtedly created a negative effect on those who would later become terrorists. A much simpler example of individual and collective responsibility could be seen in my service at Coleman Elementary school. I volunteer with the afterschool program designed to help students who are behind in their studies. It is not completely the fault of students that they are in this situation. More likely, a combination of factors at home and in the classroom have contributed to this outcome.

- Christopher Galbick

Awaken to Universal Humanity - Kiefer O'Sullivan

Our world has shrunk; not physically, but mentally. More and more, our global information is filtered and processed by the media, ourselves, and our subconscious. The ways in which we are directed to think gives rise to a trend of, as Butler terms it, anti-intellectualism. Butler exemplifies this by writing how there is a clear lack of questioning about the nature of the war in Iraq, or the “war on terror.” He writes how it seems “that neither the justification nor the cause of the war have been the focus of public intellectual attention” (2). This is due to an almost cold war era like witch hunt that effectively isolates and villainizes any individual that addresses the validity of the war. Post 9/11 America echoes eerily of McCarthyism, with any “unpatriotic” attempt to question America’s dominance or the necessity of force being immediately tossed out as sympathetic to the “evil-doers”. Butler points out that “our own acts of violence do not receive graphic coverage in the press, and so they remain acts that are justified in the same of self-defense, but by a noble cause, namely, the rooting out of terrorism” (6). We are conditioned to think that the war is just, that the enemies are villains, evil to the core, and that their causalities are but ants lost to an overbearing magnifying glass. If only we were allowed to look through the magnifying glass, we would see that the people being blown apart in their very homes are just like us. Thinking about the attitude towards the war in Iraq reminds me of something my grandfather told me when he would tell stories before he passed. He said that after serving in WWII he had a revelation. He would be in his fox hole, clutching the pictures of his wife and kids, being given orders to run across and kill the “evil” nazi across the way. Once he was out of the war though, he realized, that the person across the way that he was being sent to kill was just like he was. He was across the battlelines in his own foxhole clutching his own pictures of his wife and kids. They were two men that could have been best friends under any other circumstances, however, they were taught that all the Nazi soldiers were villainous to the bone and taught to kill indiscriminately among them. Our minds are but sheep to an insidious shepherd. Just like the WWII Nazis my grandfather fought, we are taught to hate and think little of the lives of the people in the Middle East. As Butler writes, “when America commits some act of dehumanization, we castigate ourselves for not aiming better, as if the end goal is to aim right” (6). The war crimes committed in the Middle East, performed in any kind of Western context, would be totally unacceptable; there would be outrage.

Butler raises the question, “What makes for a grievable life? . . . Loss and vulnerability seem to follow from our being socially constituted bodies, attached to others, at risk of losing those attachments,” (20). Are the deaths of thousands of Middle Eastern civilians not worthy of our attention? We all suffer loss in our lives, it is part of being human. We are all vulnerable to harm, and a “Mindfulness of this vulnerability can become the basis of claims for non-military political solutions, just as a denial of this vulnerability . . . can fuel the instruments of war” (29). The “evil doers” are dehumanized and generalized to a whole race of people. People from any kind of Middle Eastern descent are now suffering significant discrimination post 9/11. However, no one is able to disseminate the reasons for why they stereotype these people, they are just conditioned. George Bush famously said, “You’re either with us or against us” in relation to the War on Terror, and this false dichotomy that is being presented is obvious, but yet the prevailing consensus is that yes, you’re either with the heroes or the villains. That is what creates the conditions favourable for a trend of anti-intellectualism. No room is left for analysis, no shades of grey, just black and white. Anyone who takes the time to understand the war from a decentralized viewpoint is branded as some kind of heretic and is ignored by the media, as in the case of Noam Chomsky. If we are to break this cycle of anti-intellectualism, America needs to be “open to narration [from a viewpoint] that decenters us from our supremacy” (18). We need to realize that the people that we spend billions on to kill are people with families and jobs and lives just like us.

Confused responsibility and Collective Grief

One statement that really stuck out to me was her response to her self-asked question, "What social conditions help to form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed?" (16) Meghann interpreted that responsibility arose from the individual based on their environment. Part of me agrees with that, especially with the things I have posted previously commenting on other articles. But the statement that really stuck out to me went a little deeper than that. She says, "We are at once acted upon and acting, and our 'responsibility' lies in the juncture between the two." (16) I thought this was such a great insight that we've been talking about all year!

This statement is so significant because it implies that there is a reciprocal responsibility within each situation - whether it be between man-and-man, man-and-environment, man-and-himself, whatever it is, there is a responsibility we hold to the other, and there is a responsibility that is held for us. To further her idea, Butler evidences a common occurance in our society - violence. She poses the idea that violence stems from response from violent injury because it "may well seem 'justified'". (16) This is true. But then she challenges us, asking if this is the kind of responsibility we want to be holding as we participate in "social transformation" that is "non-violent" and cooperative". (17) I love the idea she brings up about the double standard - about how we WANT to do it the non-violent, peaceful way, but in our own lives we act out violently and defensively, almost the complete opposite of the "guiding ideal". (17)

This ties into another one of her points, "who counts as human?" (20) I believe our negative reactions to negative situations would definitely define us as human, just as the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, and mourning also make us human. Because we have all experienced loss, vulnerability, and grief - whether through a family member dying as Danielle mentioned, or a break up with a boyfriend/girlfriend, or a special pet dying, or a brother/sister going away to college - this ties us together as a race. We are defined and differentiated from other animals and living things on Earth because of our ability to feel intense emotion and our ability to speak out, act out, or try to change it. The connection we automatically have with another when we realize they are experiencing or have experienced the same feelings overtaking us, counts us all as human.

The idea of shared anger, pain, and vulnerability ties back to my work at MCCS. The kids are definitely one of a kind and heavily guarded. But talking to one student has been such a great experience at school. He is very quick to talk about his frustrations and problems with me. I didn't expect to be affected so much by his situations, but I found myself relating to him by thinking about times in my life when I felt just as frustrated and angry. In this way, we have this connectedness and bond that I'm so grateful for. Butler sums up my thoughts very nicely in her last paragraph, "You are what I gain through this disorientation and loss. This is how the human comes into being, again, and again, as that which we have yet to know." (49) Even though I don't know the exact reasons why he and I have such a great bond, that is how the human life works. We all experience the same feelings and the feeling of connectedness it brings us is something that brings us peace.

Covalent Bonding.

“Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something (23). Do you have a significant moment from service that illustrates this?

As I had stated before, I initially thought that I’d be able to walk away from Young Moms unscathed and uninfluenced but I immediately began to empathize with these families and with their experiences. The way I have interpreted this is that we feel that, when there are no dramatic circumstances, which we can live independently of ourselves. We may be able to walk into a situation without being influenced and without being emotionally attached. However, it becomes evident that this is false when we come into direct contact with saddening situations. The most powerful situation is when we have lost a loved one. ‘It is not as if an 'I' exists independently over here and then simply loses a 'you' over there, especially if the attachment to 'you' is part of what composes who 'I' am' (22). When we create a relationship with another person, we become attached and share, in a sense, a part of each other. It’s difficult to describe but I feel that when I establish a relationship with someone, we both sacrifice a part of ourselves that we give to the other. Because of this exchange, we always live with that person and the relationship within us, it is in a sense, a glue that keeps us together. This is why I believe that when we lose a loved one, we feel that part of the relationship with the person come undone, the glue is no longer keeping the person together as a whole. We were so comfortably with being put together so well because of that one piece of the relationship that we don’t realize that it was truly there until the physical person is gone. With regard to my service learning, I feel that I have established a relationship with both the parents and the children and when I discover a devastating moment from one of them, I feel their pain and I became undone in that I empathize with the ‘glue’ of their relationships faltering. We need each other because we are interdependent, our major theme.

I believe that I am on the same page as Butler when I say that ‘..And if we’re not, we’re missing something,’ refers to that piece that is sacrificed when a relationship is established. Actually, instead of a piece, it’s more like a covalent bond; in order to be stable they must BOTH share the piece that they have. They may have other covalent bonds with other people, but when one is in jeopardy or is broken, the entire compound is affected and is no longer the same as it once was. Therefore, if we do not have that covalent bond with others, we are not being equal or stable. If we don’t allow ourselves to make that bond with those around us, we will forever be unstable and incomplete. When we are stable and complete, we are content and become so comfortable that we forget that we needed someone in the first place.

‘The question that preoccupies be in the light of recent global violence is, Who counts as human? Whose lives count as lives? And, finally, What makes for a grievable life?' (20). Because of increasing amount of violence that we have been exposed to in our lifetime, it seems as if we have become desensitized to a point where ‘friendly fire’ and ‘just war’ are truly those things in our minds. This desensitized inhibits our ability to create those covalent bonds with each other and instead feel that we are stable and complete. By doing so, the human life is trivialized because there is no direct contact with those being killed. How could we possibly mourn or grieve a death that we may not even be counted as ‘human’? If that life is ‘ungrievable’ there is no need for the feeling of loss and we are therefore not undone. The desensitizing that violence in the media has done to our society is affecting not only the people but it is affecting the legal system as well. 'The term 'terrorist' is used, for instance, by the Israeli state to describe any and all Palestinian acts of resistance, but none of its own practices of state violence’ (4). The desensitizing is deep enough that we don’t even recognize our own actions as violent but instead highlight what others are doing.

The Chaos of Humanity

Butler asks, “What social conditions help to form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed? . . .” (16) Explore her discussion around these questions.

The argument that these questions pose is that, “our acts are not self-generated, but conditioned” (16). Responsibility is therefore put on the individual and the conditions that the person is in. Butler then ties in her argument of violence into this question. It takes a person’s experience with violence to compel them to take action. According to Butler, “(Only) Once we have suffered violence are we compelled, ethically, to ask how we will respond to violent injury” (16). Take for instance, the women suffrage movement. Because women were subjected to violence, their view of the violence that is occurring in the world today is affected. The same goes for other minorities that have had violent histories. Experiencing violence definitely gives you a different point of view when you hear about violence occurring which is why the use of violence is an unethical way to solve a dispute.

(What really caught my eye in Butler’s argument was the emphasis given by president Bush put on the mentality of “us or them.” If you spoke out against what he was doing you were considered a terrorist yourself. What was down during 9/11 was a terrible thing but responding with just as much violence is not the answer. I found it very appalling as a modern that a mentality even existed. Disagreeing with the government should not automatically make you a terrorist.)

“Who counts as human?” (20). Why are the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, mourning integral to Butler’s thesis? Do I agree that these are universal human experiences that might be a source of moral response?

One of Butler’s main themes is that man is vulnerable and in that vulnerability we must accept things about ourselves. When a person experiences a loss, he or she will feel like, “we have lost some ties by which we are constituted” (22) because of that we feel like, “we don’t know who we are or what to do” (22). In a way, loss leaves us to open to vulnerability and in that place we question who we are. Personally, I agree with this concept. It is important to accept how truly vulnerable we are and accept that loss and grief is an integral part of life. In my previous question, I quoted Butler saying that in order to understand violence you must undergo violence yourself. The same can be applied to grief. In order to be able to support a grieving person and support them you must have experienced grief yourself. Grief and loss add to our knowledge and experience of life and in turn shape what we think is morally sound or not. Without the experience of loss, you will not fully grasp the hollow emptiness that a person is feeling when they have lost someone. In short, I do agree that loss, vulnerability, etc. are a source of moral responses because they shape the way a person thinks and reacts to everyday life.

“Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something (23).” Do you have a significant moment from service that illustrates this?

My understanding of the quote is that humanity in itself is chaos and we do have a self-destructive nature. If we were all operating together peacefully something is wrong. If we all agreed to everything then we would be a brain washed society that doesn’t have the ability to think. This can be shown in both of my service projects. One kid I worked with at County Community (I will not state his name) told me when I was tutoring him that he thought I would automatically think he was an awful person because of where he is. Of course, I quickly replied with a no because I believe that just because you are in County doesn’t make you a bad person. He then proceeded to tell me that he wants to strive to do better and he knows that what he did to get into County was bad but he has a hard time doing what is instructed because he doesn’t want to be told what to do. To link this with the previous quote, he is the perfect example of human nature and its need to be against. We all have been in situations where we wanted to skip an assignment a teacher wants us to do or defy an authority but in order to survive we have learned to obey. The kids at county community are products of not wanting to work in the system. That is not only in the county community kids but in all of us. What makes us different from the county community kids is we have learned to keep the feelings of defiance controlled.

Saturday, October 22, 2011

Prompt: Text/Service Reflection: Precarious Life

Use the following points to help you "pull the thread" of Butler's ideas--please make sure that you find a connection to service and that you include other quotes from the reading.

Make sure to notice where Butler identifies issues and presents alternative formulations, often in the form of questions, sometimes as very clear statements.


The rise of anti-intellectualism—what does Butler mean by this/how does she illustrate this phenomenon/ what are the implications?

Terminology and framing of events: why is it crucial to think/critique the ways in information (through language/narratives/images etc) that we receive about violence: “the frame works both to preclude certain kinds of questions [and] historical inquiries, and to function as a moral justification for retaliation” (4). Find examples of the dangers and the alternatives that Butler suggests.


Find other places in the text to unpack what Butler mean when she asks, “Can we find another meaning, and another possibility, for the decentering of the first-person narrative within the global framework?” (7).



Butler asks, “What social conditions help to form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed? . . .” (16) Explore her discussion around these questions.


“Who counts as human?” (20). Why are the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, mourning integral to Butler’s thesis? Do we agree that these are universal human experiences that might be a source of moral response?


“Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something (23). Do you have a significant moment from service that illustrates this?

Significance of the discussion of identity/autonomy/the body (24-38). Tie back to other points. This leads into important discussion of vulnerability—how does she then tie this back into the previous points she has built?


Dehumanization of the Other 32-49. Crucial points here and she weaves in all the other points.


“We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). Think about this in relation to the thesis Butler has built and, if possible, in relation to your service-learning experience.

Do you see echoes of Arendt in any of Butler’s points? Where? There are also many points about vulnerability that remind me of the reading from On Kindness. Also, think back to Deo and the violence and loss he experienced, does his story illustrate some of Butler's ideas as well? What about the Cornell piece on the "Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society" and the necessary struggles and asking of hard questions. . .? (Finding common themes, that are also illuminated through your service experience, will help you formulate your final paper.)

Thursday, October 20, 2011

Responsibility and Judgement

How do you interpret "collective responsibility" and "collective guilt" as expressed by Arendt?

I find I agree and disagree with Arendt in terms of her presented views. "There is no such thing as being or feeling guilty without oneself actively participating in them" (147). I know that working in retail, I feel guilty when a kid wants something and his or her parents say no and the kid feels bad. I am a mere spectator in the situation but I guess in a way I am feeling some kind of collective guilt. In regards to collective responsibility, I was taught earlier on that indifference=consent, it is sort of a civic duty not to be ignorant, and nonparticipation is often irresponsible. Although I find connections to these views to the real world I always hated being grouped into a collective. I felt as though my responsibilities belong to me and that they are my own, just like any guilt I would have should be from my own actions. But that is the interesting thing about collective responsibility, with it "I must be held responsible for something I have not done" (149). However, I do not feel guilty for the actions of my ancestors. I find myself very capable of drawing the line and embracing subjectiveness. If I were a descendant of Hitler himself, I do not think I would feel guilty unless put in a weird special circumstance. For instance, if my best friend was a descendant of a family extremely persecuted during Nazi reign.

I do feel responsibility to help those at Coleman though I don't know that it is necessary collective responsibility. I do feel guilty when there is a homework or problem they need help with and I cannot recall that far back and cannot help them right away. It's not really something I did wrong or a wrong done against them but it is a weird feeling.

Do you think that the absence of thinking lead to evil?

In the following chapter, Arendt proposes the idea that if the Nazi soldiers knew what they were doing, thought about their actions, perhaps they would not have committed the things that they did. She realizes thay in asking such a question, other questions arise "What is thinking? What is evil?" (161). Thinking to me is basically putting time into predicting the outcomes of a certain decision, of actions, of the near and far future. Thinking might be drawing on past experiences to help make new choices. Thinking is a fundamental in making decisions. Evil to me, is a strict interpretation of possible sins that could be committed. Lying is evil, killing is evil, sinning and not feeling sorry about it is pretty evil. (This isn't necessarily what I think, I'm just using a strict interpretation of "evil.") One of my favorite quotes is "The road to hell is paved with good intentions." I feel like, this is true a lot, especially for children. Sometimes they think they are doing a good deed, being "thoughtful" and in turn, they are actually doing something "bad." For instance, the kids at Coleman are given snacks at the start of the day. Due to the budget cuts they are only allowed one snack and one juice, no seconds. One child tried to steal about six or seven other kids' snacks. (This kid is one of the sweetest kids that never get in trouble.) Anyway, when asked why he would go into other people's things and take snacks, he told us that his younger sister, who wasn't a part of the program because she was too young, did not get a snack and he wanted to share with her. Their family had been a little tight on money and sometimes they would go hungry. Stealing snacks from other kids was the wrong thing to do, but this "wrong" this "evil" was not thoughtless at all. He actually put a lot of thought into his "evil." So I disagree with the implied conclusion that "Nobody does evil voluntarily." but agree that "Everybody wants to do good." Arendt thinks that "the sad truth of the matter is that most evil is done by people who never made up their mind to be either good or bad" and perhaps this might be the case statistic wise. But I know a lot of people who want to do good and want to think they are good but come off as...bad sometimes, or even a lot of times (180).