Below are some notes to help you with your reading. I have posted two specific options for your reflection below these notes. You can use these or go another direction, but please try to relate the reading concepts to your service experience.
Chapter 4) Moral disagreement –what does he mean by Thick and Thin?
- Thin concepts as placeholders?
- Thicker concepts can be peculiar to particular societies. And the most fundamental level of disagreement occurs when one part to a discussion involves a concept that the other simply doesn’t have. (47) Here we need not to agree but at least to understand.
- Why are cross-cultural conversations about values important?
Chapter 5)The Primacy of practice: Conversation doesn’t start with agreement on principles.
- We can agree about practices while disagreeing about their justification. We can live together because we don’t have to agree on a set of universal values.
- Changing our Minds p.72—
- Reasoning comes in not when we are going on in the usual way, but when we are thinking about change. And when it comes to change, what moves people is often not an argument from a principle, not a long discussion of values, but just a gradually acquired new way of seeing things. (73).
Chapter 6) Imaginary strangers:
- Once we have found enough to share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to enjoy discovering things that we do not yet share. . .
- Yet, we have a natural inclination to define ourselves over and against the different "other". Do we really need to wait for the "War of the World" with an alien enemy or "out group" in order to generate compassion for the other based on our shared human identity (98)? Does this remind you of other readings we have done in class, particularly Butler's Precarious Life?
- Are you finding ways to "make sense of each other" (99) through your service-learning experience?
Ideas for your reflection:
- Appiah writes: “I am a philosopher. I believe in reason. But I have learned in a life of university teaching and research that even the cleverest people are not easily shifted by reason alone—and that can be true even in the most cerebral of realms” (84). [Reminds me of "The Moral Mind" and "The Brain is an Argument.] Thus, he believes that conversation between people is not so much about arriving at shared agreements or to persuade the other. Instead, he sees conversation as “practice” or “deed” that may help us “to live together in peace” more than any abstract principles . “Conversations across boundaries of identity…begin with the sort of imaginative engagement you get when you read a novel or watch a movie or attend to a work of art that speaks from some place other than your own…And I stress the role of the imagination here because the encounters, properly conducted, are valuable in themselves. Conversation doesn’t have to lead to consensus about anything, especially values; it’s enough that it helps people get used to one another. (85)
- Appiah discusses the idea that collective/shared identities gain strength by “othering” or defining themselves over and against an “out-group.” He suggests that one way to deal with this reflex in human nature is that of the cosmopolitan who certainly holds loyalties to certain groups, to family, but also recognizes the commonality of simply being human and “once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to discuss things we do not yet share…We can learn from one another, or we can simply be intrigued by alternative ways of thinking, feeling, and acting” (97). He continues, stating that the objection to the cosmopolitan understanding of shared humanity is that any moral interest we have in strangers can only be abstract, “lacking in warmth and power that comes from shared identity” (98). Yet, he argues, even if they are strangers, the fact of engagement itself, makes them “particular strangers; and the warmth that comes from shared identity will often be available.”
Do you have an example, a story of engagement/conversation from your service experience that illustrates this point?
The idea that resonated most with me came out of chapter 5, The Primacy of Practice, on page 81, “what makes these conflicts so intense is that they are battles over the meaning of the same value”. In other words, many people can have the same idea, but have various perspectives that justify why they have accepted that value. This idea is repeated on page 71 “we can agree about what to do in most cases, without agreeing about why it is right”. Humans have developed a common sense of right and wrong, so as shown in the reading The Moral Mind #1, people can relate to one another because they share similar emotional responses to situation. Appiah points out that we might not all have the same justification for our responses. The author of The Moral Mind indicates that our first response is an emotionally based response and only after can we attempt to support our reaction with logic or reasoning.
ReplyDeleteAt the very end of chapter 5, Appiah says “conversation doesn’t have to lead to consensus about anything, especially not values; it’s enough that it helps people get used to one another” (pg85). One of the topics of this class was the idea of collective responsibility and living together in a Democratic society, Cornel West, and it’s important to know that in order to live with one another, it helps to understand where other people’s values come from. Although we might not always agree with the decisions being made, an understanding in the origin of the idea can assist with the idea of collective responsibility.
In the end we are all responsible for one another and we can all work to improve our lives. Conversations about values and morals may not result in consensus, but they do help people to better relate to one another. For instance on a very simplified level, in my service learning at Canal Alliance, we carry conversation about all sorts of topics in order to help the students practice and use English in the proper context. The conversations may not be all that complicated or they may not come to a clear conclusion, but that doesn’t mean they are not important. The conversations are important because it provides the opportunity to practice English. Same goes for conversations on a larger scale. Although we might not all agree about our values, simply having those conversations are still important because they offer the opportunity to learn and understand.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteFrom Kiefer: Invaluable Insights
ReplyDeleteThe biggest thing that stuck with me after reading chapters 4, 5, and 6 of Cosmopolitanism is when in chapter 6 Appiah discusses how simple exposure to a group of people helps you understand them. That by being in their presence, you can in a sense “get used to” them and gain insight into their culture. This really stuck with me because I completely agree and it directly relates to my service learning experience. I have found ways to “make sense of the other” (p99) through my continued work with the kids at Coleman. When I first started my service, I had tough time relating to the kids. I’m not quite sure if it is because I come from a different culture or because I am just in a totally different generation, but I definitely recognized that these kids are quite different to me when I was their age. The kids at Coleman have such differing needs and have many issues which relate back to society. My first several tutoring sessions were, and I am not going to lie, kind of awkward. I was not expecting to deal with the level of hyperactivity and authority issues that I encountered. As an introvert, I was undoubtedly taken aback. A great example of this I remember is when another tutor asked one of the 3rd grade boys to tie his shoe lace, he retorted saying his shoelace was not untied. The tutor asked him to look at his other shoe, which was completely untied. He saw this and fought with her saying that he does not need to tie his laces, they are ok to be left open, etc. Obviously, the child did not adhere to a strict shoe lace regime and format, the issue was not the shoelace, but the fact that he was being told to tie it. Superficially and initially, one might feel annoyed and frustrated, but the more I work with the kids and the more I see where they come from and the state of society, the more I sympathize with them and realize that it is not their fault. Their behaviours and mannerisms are the product of their home life. Many of the kids have individual issues that are the product of a deteriorating society. I see and am exposed to the kids every Thursday afternoon, I see their parents, listen to their stories. Without my service I would not have that insight that can only be gained through the personal contact with the kids. Honestly, the service has not being easy for me, but what I have gained is invaluable.