The first theme that I would like to focus on is the two strands of cosmopolitanism. According to Appiah, “[There is]one idea that we have obligations to others, obligations that stretch beyond those to whom we are related by the ties of kith and kind, or even ties of citizenship. The other is that we take seriously the value of human lives” (XV). I do not personally do not know much about cosmopolitanism so this was an interesting concept to me. To help further my understanding of these concepts they were used in the first chapter, where the work of Sir Richard Francis Burton is further analyzed. A man of many languages, Burton was both a cosmopolitan and an anti-cosmopolitan. Burton believed in the difference of beliefs in man and made statements such as, “All faith is false, all Faith is true; Truth is the shattered mirror strewn” (5). He was seen as a, “Catholic among Catholics” (6) which furthers the fact that Burton supported a difference in belief. What gets me is that he recognized the difference in man but he did nothing to prevent the suffering of his fellow man (anti-cosmopolitanism). If Burton understood man enough to recognize the difference then why didn’t he show compassion to his fellows?
A theme I found very important in chapter two was the two different psychological states of a person and their effect on their decisions. There is, “beliefs [that] are supposed to reflect the way the world is [and] desires reflect how we’d like it to be” (18). It is important to recognize the two different states of a person because you can then understand how they see the world. Desires should not be criticized because they are in fact just a vision of what they want but it is beliefs that get the action done. The author uses his value of kindness as an example. He believes that kindness is important but he desires that others believe the importance of kindness as well. The author then brings up the possibility that there are shared basic desires which aligns with the previous strand of cosmopolitanism that there is a universal whole. I believe with Appiah when he states this and can link this with the previous reading On Kindness. In On Kindness, kindness was argued to be something that brings us joy and we are born with. I believe that everyone is born kind and the experiences in their life shape their future decisions.
The third chapter was the most interesting for me to read because it brought up the argument that, “there will always be more than one possible reasonable account of the facts” (40). Upon reading this statement, I thought of the psychology world and how if an experiment doesn’t have an argument against it then it is not usable. This made me realize all of the opposing factors we are exposed to in everyday life. For example, the democratic and republican parties are clearly opposite of each other and we are swayed typically to go either direction but if there wasn’t a democratic to oppose a republican or vice versa then it would not be a democracy. If we all agreed on everything then there would be no free thinking or free speech. A real life example that Appiah used was the difference of sickness when looked at from a medical perspective and a Ghanaian perspective. According to the Ghanaian people, when a family member or friend falls ill it is because of witchcraft by someone close to them. A medical professional would not think that the ill was experiencing witchcraft but suffering from a viral infection. These two opposing views are important to keep in mind because for a medical professional to treat Ghanaian patient he or she must keep in mind the mindset of the patient. Without the cultural reference, then the cultural barrier will act as a block for the medical professional to communicate and the patient to get treated.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.