Monday, November 14, 2011

Shared world, Shared mirrors, Shared everything

I think Kiefer definitely makes his point in saying that the moral absolute is that there is no universal truth. But after reading his blog, and reading Cosmopolitanism, I can't help but question that reasoning. In chapter 2, Appiah ends by saying, "...without a shared world, what is there to discuss? People often recommend relativism because they think it will lead to tolerance. But if we cannot learn from one another what is right to think and fell and do, then conversation between us will be pointless." (31) The message Appiah is conveying is not saying that we are concretely one or the other. We walk a fine line between moral relativism and universal rule. If we were one, for example, completely relative, we would walk around accepting each other's different ideals no problem. In reality, we do not do this. We question, we doubt, we grow to understand that point of view better.

In the same way, it's nearly impossible to say that we have an underlying universal law. In order for that to happen, we'd "have to agree on the rule book" and accept the fact that there is one. (11) Again, if we look at reality, most of us don't play by the "rules" at all times. In fact, some people would say that rules were made to be broken!

I am brought back to the two mentioned ideas of cosmopolitanism: 1) "the recognition of our responsibility for every human being" (8) and 2) "the recognition that human beings are different and we can learn from each other's differences." (4) Both these ideas, or "strands" (4) encompass the fact that we are neither one nor the other. In every article we have read, we are RARELY either one idea or the other. We are always a mixture because we are always interconnected or intertwined. Whether it be with nature, our fellow brethren, or ourselves.

I think the idea so far could be illustrated as such: in our world full of mirrors, the idea is not to just stand in our own mirror and stare at our reflection and whatever bounces off of it, but to move through the room and stand in each other's mirrors as well, to see what differences and similarities we each face.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.