Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Appiah states that “[they] each have a pattern of life that they are used to; and neighbors who are, by and large, used to them…” (71). This relates to my service experience as I have noticed that these students are grown up in a certain way, influenced by media, friends and family, that they live life in only one way. Through this one experience, they experience much more. By this I mean that, their attitude towards one person in their life is carried through to the rest. If they are used to swearing at home to express their emotions and not getting in trouble, they are most likely going to swear in school to express their emotions and hopefully, not get in trouble. Also by this I mean that, if they grew up being tough, that one experience that made them tough will make them tough and ready for any other situation. It’s like siblings almost. If one sibling hurts another, then the other sibling will retaliate. And later when that sibling is in danger, he knows what to do from experience of retaliating before. In other instances, when the teachers ask the students to write for a bit, they immediately jump back and start to curse. This is in contrast to the fact that when the students are allowed to speak out, they tend to lower their cursing. Their skills are held in their speech as they have been taught, like any other being, to use their voice, hence being “street-smart”. This leads me into looking into conversations. Appiah states that “I don’t say that we can’t change minds, but the reason we exchange in our conversations will seldom do much to persuade others who do not share our fundamental evaluative judgments already” (72). In other words, he says that conversations are in part to persuade people to think differently about an issue. Appiah later states that “…a good deal of what we intuitively take to be right….is what we are used to…” (72). This again connects back to the fact that how a person lives their life is the only way they know how to live their life. What humans learn from living their life is what they translate into words to converse and perhaps persuade others with. However, this way of life can be changed if one has a reason for the change. For example, I listen to the students conversing about their activities outside of class and sometimes talk to them about those activities. One of the students was telling me, during the “My Hero” project, that she babysits her niece. She mentioned that prior to babysitting her niece, she would always be either smoking or drinking or etc but when she is around the newborn baby, she doesn’t engage in these activities. This shows that with reason, changes can be made but regardless of these temporary changes, the way of life this student is used to will exist. While this shows the students values set, Appiah’s response is that “conversation doesn’t…lead to…values; it’s enough that it helps people get used to one another” (85). In other words, Appiah says that through conversing people learn about one another and how to handle each person in a situation. This, to me, is a mature concept. At County, I noticed that the students like to irritate one another, a sort of childish thing to do. When you know something is going to get someone angry, you continue to do it until the other person cracks. This has gotten some students in a lot of trouble. I agree with Appiah that conversation does lead to a way of knowing how man should live with one another but at the same time, I do believe that it does show a set of values and morals just as long as man follows them.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.