Tuesday, November 29, 2011

The Final Chapters

I enjoy Appiah on the chapter on cosmopolitan contamination. Although humans tend to indulge in other cultures...they do not always necessarily buy into them. On page 110 there was a mini story about a man named Sipho and how his culture differs from that of the Western culture and that he does not have to embrace this culture proving "cultural consumers are not dupes." Even with commonality with others people can still retain their own ways. On page 111 "talk of cultural imperialism structuring the consciousness of those in the periphery treats Sipho and people like him as tabulae rasae on which global capitalism's moving finger writes its message, leaving behind another homogenized consumer as it moves on. It is deeply condescending. And it isn't true." But he also finds what he calls the golden rule of cosmopolitanism in contamination: "Homo sum: human nil a me alienum puto. I am human: nothing human is alien to me." Suk Cha writes "It is difficult to find some sort of cultural exchange with another." People like Sipho who do not necessarily embrace the ways of Western culture are still exposed and practice some form of cultural exchange. "People in each place make their own uses of the most famous global commodities" (113). I mean I know he was talking about marketing but I feel like people do exchange cultures even if it is an economic thing. I feel like having a diverse multicultural food court in a mall counts even. Anyway my point is that people are connected by their commonality in being human and that's how they can peacefully exist in this world although their cultures might differ, it shapes a rounder world.

In terms of counter-cosmpolitanism Appiah states "For the counter-cosmopolitanisms, then, universalism issues in uniformity. The cosmopolitanism may be happy to abide by the Golden Rule about doing onto others (putting aside, for the moment, the conceptual problems of "universalizability" I discussed earlier). But cosmopolitans care if those others don't want to be done unto as I would be done unto to" (145). My interpretation here of what Appiah is saying is that for counter-cosmpolitanism is that you maintain the same attitude towards everyone with uniformity. However, cosmopolitanisms understand that you want and how you want to be treated may not be the same for others. --I find I can apply this to my service. I would have to be a cosmopolitanism. In a situation where I am growing and blind to what is in the future. However, the kids do not necessarily want to be helped. And not all of them need help or need someone looking over their shoulder. Some kids need more attention than others and I think it is good that some kids do not want to be help. I can think of one girl who hates the attention and hates the help because she motivates herself and challenges herself to succeed on her own. Even if she is considered somewhat below par, considering the circumstances that she comes from a family who does not speak english, she is an impressive student. And in a situation where one might think she needs help, she might be better off on her own and I think this shapes who she will become. (She does get help every now and then and that's why she is in the program.)

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.