I found the first few chapters of Cosmopolitanism incredibly difficult to decipher. It seemed as if as soon as I got a grasp of what he was trying to say, he’d go off in a different direction that was completely different from what I thought I understood. With that being said, I actually believe a moderate form of relativism is a good thing. How can there be one absolute truth when there are so many cultures out there that experience the world differently? “Because there are so many human possibilities worth exploring, we neither expect nor desire that every person or every society should converge on a single mode of life” (xv).
We no longer live in a small community where what we experience is the only thing we are aware of. We are now global citizens, which mean rather than just looking out for those in our community, we have to be responsible for fellow citizens of the world. Cosmopolitanism respects other people’s differences and values. In fact, variations of culture are encouraged. Being a cosmopolite means “You will find parts of the truth (along with much error) everywhere and the whole truth nowhere”(8).
Relativism is good to the extent of tolerating other people’s beliefs and values, but one must also question those values. It is important to exchange ideas about right and wrong. Curiosity can bring understanding rather than fear of the unknown. It broadens our minds. There is no exact way to determine if one culture’s values are better than another’s. A huge diversity of values is a reflection of our moral nature as human beings. We all have morals, but they are different based on our culture. Tolerance is good in many, if not most, situations. But we can’t be completely relative because it is also a moral obligation to pay attention to, question, and not tolerate the larger issues such as oppression, neglect, and murder. This goes back to the idea of collective responsibility.
I also think it is good to share wisdom across cultures as long as traditions are still kept. I know that this can be difficult and the author describes instances where this could be frowned upon, but I think every culture has something valuable to contribute to another. For example, I think that it was wonderful that the researcher taught the women of a village how to purify their water by incorporating the village’s beliefs. It was a contribution to their society without harming their traditions and culture.
C.Standridge-Folsom
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.