In chapters two and three of Cosmopolitanism, by Kwame Appiah, the topics of relativism and absolutism were discussed. Appiah described how both have their pros and cons and how cosmopolitanism is somewhat in the middle. I found Appiah’s arguments on relativism versus absolutism and cosmopolitanism interesting, but I disagree with him on some of his points on relativism.
If focusing on relativism and absolutism alone (not cosmopolitanism), would it be possible to say that one should apply absolutism to their own values and beliefs, but relativism when comparing one’s values and beliefs to another’s? For instance, when a person is to look at their beliefs, values, and desires than they would automatically feel that those were right (unless morally wrong in which case the person may try to talk themselves into different feelings). This absolutism would give a person the confidence to act and trust in what they believe. However, the problem comes when one compares or judges the actions of another against their beliefs. At the end of his discussion about relativism, Appiah states, “If relativism about ethics and morality were true, then, at the end of many discussions, we would each have to end up saying, 'From where I stand, I am right. From where you stand, you are right.' And there would be nothing further to say." (31). The problem, he seems to be saying, is that intellectual conversation would not occur if all people utilized relativism. In Camille’s post, she discusses how we don’t just simply accept other people’s beliefs, “We question, we doubt, we grow to understand that point of view better.” (Shared Worlds, Shared Mirrors, Shared Everything). I definitely agree with her idea, but I don’t think that it disproves relativism. When one states, “From where I stand, I am right. From where you stand, you are right,” they are not throwing away their own beliefs, they are merely accepting that the other person believes in something else. This acceptance may pressure the two to discuss their views in order to come to a greater understanding of how they are similar and different.
Whether absolute or relativistic, I think that the true problem is that many important conversations instantly become arguments about whose idea is correct, rather than a conversation to exchange beliefs and come to a greater understanding of one another.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.