In the first chapter of Cosmopolitanism, Appiah discusses the way in which we view and deal with opposing moralities around the world. Is there just one morality, a universal from which all of humanity can be compared? Or is all morality relative, are right and wrong entirely subjective notions? The author cites this as a source of major trouble, presenting cosmopolitanism as a way to deal with these troubles in comparing values. In the introduction, the author defines cosmopolites as people who “regard all the peoples of the earth as so many branches of a single family, and the universe as a state, of which they, with innumerable other rational beings, are citizens, promoting together under the general laws of nature the perfection of the whole, while each in his own fashion is busy about his own well being” (xv). This ‘ideal’ as he calls it is one of the closest things to a moral absolute that I have ever come across, paradoxically, because it suggests that the universal truth is that there is no universal truth, that we are all parts of a whole and are responsible and care about only that part of the whole as we see as ours. I am reminded of the poem the author cites, written by Burton, that goes “All faith is false, all faith is true / Truth is the shattered mirror strown / In myriad bits; while each believes / his little bit the whole to own” (5). This reading got me reflecting about how there can be no definitive universal right or wrong. Humans are psycho-social biological beings. Yes, we all have essentially the same DNA and therefore the same kind of body and brain, simply speaking. However, to me, even as a biologist, that is no reason to lay foundation for universal truth. Right and wrong are abstract terms, products of the human mind, relative to whoever is thinking about them. There can be such a wide variety of human experiences, an enormous pool of endless personalities and viewpoints that can created from a single human life. Given that the concepts of right and wrong are subjective products of the individual experience, I do not think there is a way to effectively mark off one human’s opinions as the comparison point for the rest of humanity to come. Life is a hall of mirrors, truths are reflected in truths, and everything that you see and know is a reflection of everything else. The biggest mistake, as Appiah puts it, is to think your “mirror can reflect the whole” (8).
Monday, November 14, 2011
Life is a Hall of Mirrors - J. Kiefer O'Sullivan
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.