Tuesday, November 15, 2011

What I meant to say... -Whitney Myers

The following is the explanation of the reading that I had hoped to communicate during the discussion today, but which didn’t really come out through my feverish haze…

This reading was a bit complicated, for a number of reasons. One, the large number of references and allusions to historical and philosophical entities, and the frequent ‘latinization’ of various expressions can appear quite intimidating and confusing. Apart from these issues, which can’t really be helped, it is also a bit difficult to determine the continuous thread Appiah intended to achieve through the first three chapters. This thread is what I had hoped to clarify.

First, Appiah is writing a book about Cosmopolitanism, a philosophy he hopes will help humans to live more effectively together in the modern world. Within Cosmopolitanism, he describes two strands. “One is the idea that we have obligations to others, obligations that stretch beyond those to whom we are related by the ties of kith and kind, or even the more formal ties of a shared citizenship. The other is that we take seriously the value not just of human life but of particular human lives, which means taking an interest in the practices and beliefs that lend them significance. People are different, the cosmopolitan knows, and there is much to learn from our differences” (xv). Though Cosmopolitanism recognizes and respects the differences between people and cultures, Appiah makes a point of indicating that it is not the same as relativism.

Second, in order to point out the differences between relativism and Cosmopolitanism, and why Cosmopolitanism is more effective for our modern world, Appiah describes the dangers of relativism. To illustrate the differences between relativism and Cosmopolitanism, Appiah introduces the image of the ‘shattered mirror’, in which there are many shards, each reflecting one view, but unable to reflect the whole.

The shattered mirror image can be used to illustrate both the relativist point of view and the non-relativist point of view that Appiah prefers. In a relativist point of view, there are many mirrors, each representing a different culture’s values. Even if all cultures agree about how the world is, they may all have different ideas about how the world ought to be, which, from a relativist point of view, are all perfectly legitimate. “…Even if we agree on all the facts, what’s morally appropriate for me to do from my point of view is different from what’s morally appropriate for you to do from your point of view…Perhaps, when it comes to morality there is no singular truth. In that case there’s no one shattered mirror; there are lots of mirrors, lots of moral truths, and we can at best agree to differ” (11). While this sounds as if it would be a wonderfully tolerant philosophy to live by, it can also lead to dangerous indifference to violence and suffering. “…The modern doctrines of relativism – the approach that cultural anthropologists often subscribe to – go beyond the old skeptical traditions. A lingering suspicion that a lot of what we take to be right and wrong is simply a matter of local custom has hardened, in the modern age, into a scientific certainty that talk of objective moral ‘truths’ is just a conceptual error” (17). Relativism has the potential to allow horrible practices to go uncontested, because those practices are accepted within a culture, and relativism dictates that what we see as our morals do not give us the right to dictate what others should see as right and wrong.

Third, in order to further distinguish between Cosmopolitanism and relativism, Appiah describes, and then indicates the flaws in, the concepts underlying relativism. The philosophy upon which the distinction relativism makes between facts and values is positivism. The purpose of Appiah’s discussion of positivism is to make clear the differences between his conception of values as opposed to the conception of values upon which positivism, and by extension, relativism, is based. “What people do, Positivism holds, is driven by two fundamentally different kinds of psychological states. Beliefs – the first kind – are supposed to reflect how the world is. Desires, by contrast, reflect how we’d like it to be… So beliefs can be true or false, reasonable or unreasonable. Desires, on the other hand, are satisfied or unsatisfied” (18). A relativist value corresponds to a positivist desire. Appiah points out, in opposing positivism, that the positivist concept of belief depends on evidence to prove that beliefs are true or reasonable (or are facts). However, “there are lots of facts that one can’t point to and lots of beliefs that we don’t have evidence for (if that means evidence from experience, from seeing, hearing, tasting, smelling, touching)” (23). If positivism is a flawed philosophy, then relativism, which is based on positivism, is also flawed.

Fourth, Appiah would like to communicate that, though there might be only one true reality, which we all look at from our own point of view, and we might acknowledge many views in addition to our own, we cannot expect to understand every point of view in the world. In chapter three, Appiah seeks to communicate the difference in preparedness cultures might face in being asked to accept the single mirror of Cosmopolitanism. Some cultures might have systems of belief so different from ours, that we will have trouble understanding their rational. This does not mean, however, that their culture is based in a different mirror all together. Facts may be understood as universal, which can provide a framework for understanding values as more universal, but this does not mean that there is a universal understanding of what we consider facts. We have our worldview, but “in the end…, with facts as with values, nothing guarantees that we will be able to persuade everyone else of our view” (44). Nevertheless, it is important to remember that our view is only one shard of the larger mirror, and “you will find parts of the truth (along with much error) everywhere and the whole truth nowhere. The deepest mistake… is to think that your little shard of mirror can reflect the whole” (8).

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.