Wednesday, November 30, 2011

from Noelle

The ideas illustrated in Appiah's final chapters go hand in hand with the points made by Suk Cha in "Toward Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World," especially the first two points. Suk Cha states that humanity cannot use fear of difference as an excuse for violence and conflict because our societies share too much in common with each other. We are all connected in many unique ways, even if we stem from different backgrounds and cultures. Appiah purports this same idea in his "Cosmopolitanism." He writes that one connection we all share with each other "...is the connection not through identity but despite difference" (135). He uses the example that all human beings can respond to art, even if the art is not our own art or art from our specific culture. Despite the differences of humanity, the commonalities which all humans share; such as the urge for love, compassion, and family create much stronger bonds. Suk Cha's second point includes "...We have obligations though, as we never need have if we choose to believe that we are not responsible for decisions we make and the actions we take. Our obligations include examining the nature of societies in terms of their differences and similarities and in terms of how they change upon interaction" (6). Appiah illustrates this point in his writings; in fact he believes that all humans have obligations to each other. He is not saying that we should treat all strangers with the same love and care that we would treat a close friend or relative; "...our obligation is not to carry the whole burden alone. Each of us should do our fair share; but we cannot be required to do more" (164). We have the obligation to treat each other with dignity and respect, and to do our part in benefiting the lives of those less fortunate than us. But we are only expected to do what we can, no more and no less.

In everyday language, contamination is perceived as a negative thing, however Appiah does not see cosmopolitan contamination as such. People feel as if their identities are being threatened by globalization and the meshing of different cultures. Many do not like the changes which are resulting from the ever expanding world. Appiah writes, "In the era of globalization...people make pockets of homogeneity. Are these pockets of homogeneity less distinctive than they were a century ago? Well, yes, but mostly in good ways. More of them have access to medicines that work. More of them have access to clean drinking water. More of them have schools " (103). It is true that the world is changing, and along with it, the cultures of the people who live in this world. There is a difference in preserving cultural artifacts and cultures. Cultural artifacts can be saved, restored, and used to tell the story of the particular culture it originates from. Cultures themselves, however, are susceptible to the changing times and the people who embrace them.

In order to understand counter-cosmopolitans, we must be able to fully define cosmopolitans. Cosmopolitans embrace the belief that there are countless values to live by, and no one person can live by them all. This is why they hope and expect that these values will be embodied by the different people and societies around the world. Cosmopolitans also understand that their knowledge is not bullet-proof; but constantly subject to change. On the other hand, counter-cosmopolitans believe that there is one right way for everyone to live. "For counter-cosmopolitans, then, universalism issues in uniformity. The cosmopolitan may be happy to abide by the Golden Rule about doing unto others...But cosmopolitans care if those others don't want to be done unto as I would be done unto" (145). Counter-cosmopolitans, on the other hand, tend to embrace their own ideology and do what they themselves believe the correct action is, regardless of the beliefs held by those they are helping. Counter-cosmopolitans are part of all different cultures across the world, including fundamentalist Christians in the West and fundamentalist Muslims in the Middle East. MCCS consists of a mix of students from various cultures and backgrounds. They are more likely to hold a counter-cosmopolitan mindset, simply because they are usually set in their views and are least likely to be open to other ways of thought. This is because most of them have grown up in harsh environments, and the only way survived is by living by their own rules. It would not make sense to open up to different ways of viewing things because these students relate uncertainty and fear to what they do not know.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.