Wednesday, November 16, 2011

First Look: Cosmopolitanism

For this week, we were asked to start exploring Kwame Anthony Appiah’s Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers. As one might infer from the title, the introduction and first three chapters familiarize the reader with Appiah’s concept of cosmopolitans and then attempts to make meaningful connections between these ideas and the world at large.

Appiah starts out his book by providing a broad look at cosmopolitanism, which includes frequent historical references. Early in the introduction he notes that the literal meaning of cosmopolitanism is someone who is a “citizen of the cosmos” (xiv). He elaborates on the term, eventually dividing the concept into two main areas: the idea that humans have a responsibility for each other at a universal level, and that there is value in the differences between individuals (xv). He ends the introduction by suggesting that there are some values that exist at the local levels and others that simply are universal (xxi).

In chapter one of Cosmopolitanism, Appiah takes a close look at the life of Sir Richard Francis Burton. Burton was an adventurer of the Victorian era who, among other things, spent a considerable amount of his life involved with a wide variety of cultures. Appiah notes Burton’s easy acceptance of cultures was very much in accord with cosmopolitarian way of thinking, but that his view of humanity was frequency on the other side of the spectrum (5-7). Appiah ends the chapter with an example involving Muslims and Catholics, questioning whether or not there is a single truth when it comes to morality (8-11).

For his second chapter, Appiah echoes a though of John Maynard Keynes that modern relativism is essentially the same as an old philosophy he nicknames “Positivism” (17). He explains the philosophy as where humans’ behavior is driven by two main states: beliefs that reflect the reality of the world and desires that reflect a person’s ideas on how the world should be (18). Appiah spends most of the remainder of the chapter highlighting the logical limitations involved with Positivism, including that desires are essentially derived from certain beliefs. Since values, within the Positivism school of thought, are basically complex desires there is no way to criticize the values of others (19-22).

In the fourth chapter, Appiah becomes less abstract in his thinking process. The chapter centers around a belief of spirits and witchcraft that is common in Ghana (35). Appiah includes a well known story about a missionary that was only able to convince the local people to stop feeding their babies dirty water by relating the cleaning process to spirits, rather than a more scientific explanation. Appiah uses this exemplar to demonstrate that a person’s beliefs and life experiences determine what new information appears reasonable for them (37-39). The fourth chapter is concluded with the idea that, even if there are absolute truths for reality (the Positive viewpoint), there is no reason to suppose humans can conclusively agree to what those absolute truths are (44).

- Christopher Galbick

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.