Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Appiah's Points

In the introduction on page xiii, Appiah is trying to coin a term for his ideas. He comes up with "cosmopolitanism." This to me embodies that everyone as humans are kind of intertwined. I think he zones in to say that we all belong to the same universe and are connected by a single morality even though we come from varying backgrounds and varying ethnicities. On page xv, he defines two strands that intertwine the notion of cosmopolitanism. I find I resonate more with the latter, that "we take seriously the value not just of human life but of particular human lives, which means taking in the practices and beliefs that lend them significance." This was demonstrated in his portrayal of relativism (which i have been completely using and referring to incorrectly). "There are facts and there are values...unlike values, facts--the things that make beliefs true and false--are the natural inhabitants of the world, the things that scientists can study or that we can explore with our own senses...If people in other places have different basic desires from people around here--and so have different values---that's not something we can rationally criticize. No appeal to reason can correct them." Meaning each person is entitled to their own desire. He counters this with his ideas of positivism. That if enough people share the same values, then it is significant enough to consider them truth. I don't know whether or not morality should be objective or subjective. I find I relate more with a relavist point of view particularly because most of the time I don't like to convict to choosing a side or whatever. I have my own opinions and everyone else can have their own. But to some extent I feel like there should be an objective field of morality.

In my service learning, not everyone might agree with the priority of what the kids are learning and how they are learning material but we can all agree that they need help and a better, improved, reinforcement of the schoolwork.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.