People seem to hold the logical idea that there is safety in groups. In order to create a stable group, the group identity can be established in competition with those considered “outsiders.” Appiah’s cosmopolitan perspective of this issue is that people must learn to depend on ties to humanity in addition to the smaller groups to which they may hold allegiance. Issues occur when “…we care only about people with whom we share an identity- national, familial, religious, or the like” (98). People create groups based on sub-identities, and lose sight of their more substantial identity as human beings. In order to achieve this larger loyalty, humans must find common ground on which to join.
As an option in finding a common base for human interaction, Appiah describes the “thin” moral concepts that seem to permeate humanity, despite cultural differences. “Thin concepts seem to be universal; we aren’t the only people who have the concepts of right and wrong, good and bad; every society, it seems, has terms that correspond to these thin concepts” (47). These thin concepts might provide commonality useful in communication between people of different groups. In finding joint values between groups, the “other” can begin to be seen as human. “The problem of cross-cultural communication can seem immensely difficult in theory, when we are trying to imagine making sense of a stranger in the abstract. But the great lesson of anthropology is that when the stranger is no longer imaginary, but real and present, sharing a human social life,… you can make sense of each other in the end” (99). Once a stranger’s life can be viewed as human, like one’s own, it creates common ground and opportunity for communication. Once this communication can be established, conversation between groups can take place.
Appiah’s discussion of the human tendency to create a sense of group identity by designating an “other” is interesting, especially in light of the many collective identities that one person might feel themselves to be part of. They might consider themselves to be part of an ethnic group, or a socio-economic group, or a regional/geographical group, or even a smaller social group, like a gang. A group like a gang uses the concept of the “other” to create group definition, but the process of creating strength this way can cause violence, as can ethnic conflict or geographical conflict. Appiah’s position allows people to maintain their ties to many groups, as long as the overarching loyalty to humanity is present to prevent violent conflicts. Sub-groups seem to play a large part in the social interactions at MCCS, and, similarly to humanity as a whole, MCCS might benefit from unification under one extensive identity.
Another option to counter the group-forming aspect of human nature might be to find an “other” against which to create solidarity in the human race as a whole. As possibilities, I nominate the zombie population, or, alternatively, the inevitable Borg invading force.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.