Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Cosmopolitanism Continued

This week’s reading consisted of three additional chapters from Kwame Anthony Appiah’s Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers. Chapters four, five, and six take a closer look at disagreements, justifications, and the organization of people into groups.

The fourth chapter of Cosmopolitanism opens with Appiah introducing moral discussions as a form of conversation across cultures (46). He goes on to define “thin” and “thick” concepts, where thin concepts are broad notions that tend to be universal while thicker concepts are more specific ideas that tend to have ties to a particular culture (46-47). Appiah uses taboos as an example of a local value, while noting that this thick concept does not interfere with people’s recognition of thinner and more universal concepts (56). Later in the chapter, the Golden Rule is brought up as a representative case of how the same value can have more than one interpretation (62). Appiah also uses the death penalty to show that the same value can be weighted differently (65). He sums up the chapter by indicating that people can disagree about three things: what values should be applied to a situation, how those values should be interpreted, and what significance those values should be given (66).

In the fifth chapter, Appiah starts out by looking at situations where people have different justifications but end up with the same result. He argues that people can readily live together and agree with most results without using the same reasoning (71). Appiah continues along this line of thought, proposing that most of the time people’s choices are based on experiences and intuition. The only time people use reasoning is when changing their normal habits, and even that is less about arguing values and more about seeing things from a different perspective (72-73). One of the examples Appiah uses to support these claims is with females wanting to have more specialized careers such as being doctors and lawyers. He argues that if the disagreement was about logic, the women’s movement could have happened very quickly. Instead, the movement was a long process of changing people’s perspectives on female roles (76-77).

The first part of Appiah’s sixth chapter is spent introducing and then explaining one of the customs in Ghana. Appiah uses this to lead into questioning how universal human characteristics are (94). His ultimate point in this vein of reasoning is that people’s ability to connect is not necessarily limited to what values they share. He notes that normally two individuals get to know each other because they share a number of the same values, but then end up enjoying the discovery of values they did not previously share (97). Appiah’s final thought references cosmopolitan opponents who argue that for a group to be made there must be another set of people left out. His rebuttal for this is that any given individual is going to fit in with a variety of different groups. This implies both that no individual will be left out from everything and that the groups lead to everyone being interconnected.

I think some of Appiah’s ideas, particular in chapter six, can be applied to my experiences with students at Coleman Elementary. In some ways, I can be seen as part of a culture separate from the children. The children share a similar age and have been growing up together for a number of years, while I share a closer attachment with the “Dominican tutor” culture. Nonetheless, during the last time I served at Coleman I ended up playing soccer with several of the students. During the game, we were able to better learn each other’s names and personalities. Our mutual love of soccer essentially allowed us to get to know each other better and expand our connections beyond the value of soccer itself.

- Christopher Galbick

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.